I know this is the first thing I say in this review but cash only!!!!! the service. It's always great. The staff to speak. Spanish is Beyond attentive. This time we got a croissant egg and cheese and a bacon egg and cheese on a roll. Three sandwiches and a coffee, a total of $27. read more

Bethpage Bagels - Menu - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

Delicious and fresh bagels everytime I stop in. Staff is super friendly ! This is a cash only bagel place read more

Bethpage Bagels - Best bagels - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

A family member brought a bag full of bagels from here over for a gathering. Since it was a variety, I tried the cinnamon raisin bagel, everything egg bagel, and onion bagel. They were all pretty large in size and were extremely soft and pillowy. The flavors were more on the mild side but went well with some cream cheese and jam. I would definitely visit to get some more bagels whenever I am in the area. read more

Cash only. Excellent. Good people. Affordable. Enjoy. Bagels are excellent so are her side salads.

I highly recommend this bagel shop. Their bagels are amazing and customer service was great. We ordered a dozen of different bagels and all were so tasty and airy. The bagels were still fresh and soft the next day. I will definitely come back to support their business. read more

Limited selection. No iced coffee. No rainbow bagels. Splenda is hidden behind the counter so you have to ask for it. Cash only. Ordered a bagel toasted (didn't seem fresh) with butter. They put so much butter on it soaked through the paper bag. Plain bagel is no better than a frozen Lender's. read more

My hometown bagel shop. SO DELICIOUS! EVERY TIME! Staff is so friendly and takes care of every customer. Such a cute little bagel shop on the corner. read more

Moved to Bethpage in 2020 and finally got to go here. VERY delicious!! Honestly one of the best bagels I ever had. They are so fluffy and light!!! The staff were sooo friendly and even helped us make a better decision for our order based off what we were trying to get. It was a better deal and got more food for it too!!! Cute little spot to stand your days or to grab a quick sandwich. Cash only ! read more

I had fried eggs a couple times I was not happy with fried eggs being runny!! I now beef sandwich in Bethpage Long Island!! Yesterday morning was my third time in this kind of restaurant read more

Cash only was a bummer. I went in for the first time as I was looking for a new bagel place. It was super clean and the bagels looked fantastic. I ordered, handed them my card and BAM... "We only take cash". I did not have cash. I was looking forward to these but sadly I went elsewhere. read more

don't come here if you plan on ordering more than one thing - lack of language comprehension will result in disgusting wrong order. ordered a breakfast sandwich and a cold cut sandwich, dumbass put mayo on my breakfast sandwich. disgusting read more

Having an oil change across the street and in need of coffee and a place to wait. Saturday morning - steady line but not out the door like other places - makes me hesitate for a second. Ordered a dark sesame flagel with scallion cream cheese. Hoping, since I limit carbs that it's going to be worth the splurge. The flagel was excellent - crispy seedy crust and soft and chewy inside. Really good flavor. Cream cheese fresh but could have used a heavier dose of scallion. Coffee also fresh and reminiscent of my teen days working in gourmet delis - a good uncomplicated cup of joe. read more

Bethpage Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Bagels tasted great and fresh. Service was kind. The place itself smelled great and gives you that hometown feel.

Excellent bagel shop! I stop here once in a while on my way to work and I am never disappointed. The bagels are crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and have great flavor. The woman who is always there (not sure of her name) is so sweet. read more

The best!!!! Amazing bagels and sandwhiches, coffee is always hot. You get served with a smile!!! read more

Bethpage Bagels - Great selection - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

I'm not big on bagels but I don't know why the bagel I had from this place was just perfect, the butter just melted inside of it probably cause it just came out the oven, the other sandwich I order was on a Bialy and it was freshly made as well, just simple good food. Service was good too, very friendly staff. read more

Bethpage Bagels - Pastries - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

Very good NY bagels. Good prices and excellent quality. Staff was friendly too. !!!! read more

This Bagel spot is an amazing place. The Bagels are crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. Amazing flavors and texture all the time.

I would recommend this bagel store to anyone. They are always fresh. They are not heavy and starchy. Friendly service and the only thing is cash only. Otherwise enjoy. read more

The bagels are very light and when I visit I pick up some breakfast sandwiches, when I eat in, i have coffee not bad. Its owned by a nice young asian couple and They keep the place nice and clean and also have a good staff . read more

Bethpage Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

My first time trying these bagels. Ordered an everything with cream cheese. Not the best bagel I've ever tasted, but it was ok. It was fresh but was softer and less dense that what I think a great bagel should be. It did have a nice chew but could have used a bit more crunch. The store itself is well kept and clean, but a bit dated and is need of a face lift. Seems like an Asian husband and wife run the place and they were both very friendly. I'm a firm believer in supporting the local "little guy" operations.........and for this reason, I will return. read more

If you are looking for a classic, fresh tasting bagel, this is a good place to visit. I just ordered a poppy bagel with cream cheese, and really enjoyed the fact that it had a perfect consistency to it, and was very fresh tasting. The service was very quick too, I was in and out within 2 minutes. I will say that if you are looking for a unique bagel flavor, this may not be the place for you. There aren't too many options outside of your standard bagel flavors. But I still enjoyed the one I ordered! read more

Ordered from here for some bagels. Bagels Were fresh and flavorful. Would recommend for a cheap on the go bite

The food is fresh and tasty, the staff are friendly and the menu is a good balance of products. Highly recommended

Bagels were fresh, delicious, only complaint, I believe it's cash only. I do recommend

I'm not a fan. Their menu is limited compared to some of the other local bagel stores (e.g., I asked for spinach and feta on a bagel, and they didn't have spinach or feta). They also got my order wrong and the bagels were just okay. I also hate when I ask for a bagel out of the oven and they give me one that's room temperature. The problem is that the good places around the area have ridiculously long lines. The bagel situation around here is challenging. read more

Very friendly service, nice staff. Clean shop. My fav place to go in the area. I've gotten an egg bagel for breakfast and it tastes fresh and delicious. Price is reasonable and fair. read more

I live and work in the area for many years and have gone there for there tuna on a bialy or chicken salad. I ENJOY IT VERY MUCH ..they do not ad bread to the salads. For 8 dollars you can get a sandwich ice tea potato salad, Snapple.. I recommend..and the staff are so nice... I AM FROM NEY YORK NOT CALIFORNIA read more

GO TO THIS PLACE IF YOU WANT A COMPLETELY WRONG ORDER. I swear the lady that served me must have thought it was opposite day. I ordered a toasted baily with extra bacon and a little cream cheese, I received a non-toasted baily with extra cream cheese and a little bacon. I asked for a wrap with egg whites and turkey, she asked If I wanted peppers and onions for some reason, which I said no. I received a wrap with egg whites and peppers...what? On top of getting the wrong food, I had to wait over 40 minutes to receive it, since apparently somebody got fired/walked out midway through making my order. I am surprised this place is still even open. I would not recommend this place to anybody...ever! read more

My favorite place. Always fresh bagels and friendly staff. Make sure you have cash. No credit cards.

Delicious local bagels. My go to when im in the area. The bagels are Fresh and Chewy, the way a ny bagel is meant to be. I had a plain bagel with cream cheese and jelly. Simple, but perfectly done. The workers are also very nice. read more

I have been going to this bagel place forever. The current owners have been there for some time now. They are super nice as are all the workers there. Their bagels are nice and fluffy which is what I prefer my bagels to me. They make their bagels on site which means the bagel may be nice and warm when it is given to you. There are some tables inside to sit and eat but those are usually filled up with cute elderly people who always come here to read the paper and eat some of their delicious bagels. There coffee is self serve which is my favorite. I like to make my own coffee and adjust the sweetness as needed. As long as this bagel place continues to stay open, I will continue to go. read more

Try the super egg bagel! the egg sandwiches are great and the staff is really friendly, i love this place

The egg sandwiches are always on point. Coffee is decent. Staff is very friendly. I haven't been in this place in over a year and the lady remembered me and said how have u been it's been a long time. When i work in the area this is the place i go. read more

A bare bones deli counter & bagel stash, this place gets its regulars who come to sit & chat over bagels. And those bagels are quite good. Other details leave me wondering how this place has survived: the cluelessness of the manager, the less-than-basic self-serve coffee/tea setup, the vacant customer service, styrofoam cups, no restroom, overflowing trash can... but if looking for a good bagel, I'd stop by again. Keep your expectations low, enjoy the fundamentals, and all will be well. read more

The place itself is a little run down, but the people that work here are amazingly nice & welcoming!

Solid bagel place, quick and inexpensive but only problems are there is very little seating and the plates barely fit a sandwich on them.

The bagels are really good here. Have to try a super egg bagel. I get them all the time. Soooo good. The prices are fair and the people are really nice read more

Their food and service were awesome! Bagels are fresh, they use real eggs and everything was great! The service was exceptional. We were a large party of almost 15 people with a bunch of kids (under the age of 3) and they were patient, organized and very friendly! read more

Been going here for years. Definitely a hidden gem. Favorite bagel place around, and I've been to more bagel places than I can count. Staff is so friendly, and they remember you and will always make you feel welcome. Treated like family there. Many bagel places are over priced and mediocre these days, but have never been disappointed here. Will go here forever!! read more