That lady that works in there is the goat she knows my order bagels are so good customer service top on li best bagels in Suffolk county

This place is awful. The lady behind the counter was very rude and was asking for tip. The lady also refused to write my order down. If I owned this place I would be embarrassed . read more

This place SUCKS! The lady who takes the order doesn't listen. The cook doesn't listen. So you wind up with an order you are ALLERGIC to!! Simple sausage, egg and cheese on roll. No ketchup ( I'm ALLERGIC) salt or pepper. Result: KETCHUP salt and pepper on it. I tried calling for 20 minutes when I got home and discovered their mistake. They left me on hold. Wound up THROWING AWAY a $10.00 sandwich!! BTW: why the heck are you still charging such a high price??? Egg prices went down! Rude and BAD BUSINESS PRACTICE NEVER RETURNING! Would love to give NO STARS! read more

They dont listen to requests. I asked for light ketchup and had to wipe my sandwich down with two napkins from a swimming pool of ketchup. It seems like they give light amount of cream cheese automatically. They have delicious bagels though and they have amazing cookies made by local bakers which is great and delicious. read more

$9.45 for 2 eggs turkey and cheese on a bagel...20$ for 2 egg sandwiches.. this place is greedy. 1 slice of cheese and Maybe 3 slices of turkey! Been coming here for 10+ years and won't be back read more

The staff is caring. Great drink choices haha, hashbrowns are amazing oh em gee, nice and good prices i dont know why people are complaining shoutout to ricky :))) Try the egg everything bagel toasted with butter best combo !! read more

I really believe this is the best bagel / deli on Long Island. The prices are right and the staff are all friendly. Gotta love the CEO Ming read more

Omelette was a little expensive for the amount but it was good none the less . Also had to remind them I ordered a bagel .

Nice staff, very accommodating but it takes a long time to get your sandwich. It was Sunday afternoon, they ran out of some items and offered to substitute different items but the panini still came out wrong, it wasn't even pressed or made hot, head scratcher? My wrap was fine and had sufficient meat for the price. Be careful, there is more than one bagel place on Wellwood Avenue and it confuses lots of people, even us since we had a gift card and oops it was for the other store. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Mary Mapleton a bagel June 2022 - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Ordered on a delivery app. Got a sandwich on a hero. They adjusted to price after I ordered because I asked for Lettuce and tomato on the sandwich. They charged me $3 for those changes. I then got a call telling me they are out of heros so there could make it on a roll instead. I said that's fine, and will they be adjusting the price accordingly? They told me they can't do that. I then told them about how they just modified my price before adding on charges, they said they can't do that still... I already bit my tongue on the $3 for freakin tomato and lettuce, now they are stiffing me for the whole damn sandwich. I am a big deli sandwich fan, I have had a lot of them. Even worked at 2 different delis at points in my life. I have never been charged extra for lettuce and tomato especially for that much of a charge. This is bad business and I most likely won't be ordering from here again. Oh and the kicker is the had the Gaul to call me back a second time because they didn't have the drink I ordered either. Figures read more

Woman at the register was rude and extremely inattentive. I asked for a LIGHTLY toasted bagel. it came out burnt... Also got a BEC and she didn't even ask if i wanted ketchup, salt etc. So i received it without anything. This is really disappointing. read more

I read the mediocre reviews but still ended up eating breakfast here. Toasted everything bagel was very good. Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. I came here early on a Saturday morning and there was no line to order. As I was eating, I noticed that the line got really long, and people started complaining because they were waiting for half an hour. I'm glad I got there when I did. Coffee was good too. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Great spot for a quick and fresh traditional Long Island egg sandwich. The coffee is good and strong, bagels are OK but not my favorite tbh. The service is quick and friendly with plenty of seating for while you wait for your order, or to enjoy there. read more

Mediocre bagels. I ordered an everything with cream cheese, which had a more than enough for me. I also ordered an everything toasted with butter. Took longer than it should have , just for the girl to come from the kitchen and say "I apologize for the wait, I had to "manually" toast the bagel". I didn't really question it but at the same time wondered and even said to my daughter... "manually toast the bagel? What does that even mean??" Just to get home and see what she meant was throwing it on a grill? This bagel was NOT toasted!! See pic. My daughter said it tasted burnt. I would have rather the girl say she wasn't able to toast it and I could have done it myself at home! read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - "Manually" toasted bagel with butter - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

We picked up a half dozen assorted bagels (everything, egg everything, cinnamon raisin, and sesame) and a half pound of lox spread. The bagels were just alright - decent flavor but flat, tough, and hard to chew. The texture improved after popping them in the toaster, but they still gave our jaw muscles a workout. The spread was yummy, and we appreciated how the girl at the counter threw in some extra slices of lox for us. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - a bagel sandwich and dip - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Bought a plain bagel this morning - got it home & opened the bag and found this nasty inedible gross mess. The side of the bagel is torn and the bottom is black. You should feel ashamed you gave this to someone to eat, it looks like someone dropped it on the floor. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Dirty Torn bagel - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

When you order a bacon and cheese, apparently you have to be specific that you want more than one egg and they never put the cheese. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Becsk - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

I have gone to this place a couple times, as they have pretty good bagels. That being said, I will never be returning. While I was waiting for my food (already ordered and paid) I watched roaches crawl across the floor in front of me in the main dining area. As I looked around, I noticed how filthy this place is. I did not have the heart to say anything about it, as it was not the fault of the girl at the register, so I just took my food and left and promptly threw it away. It is a shame that they have gone down hill. My advice would be to consume their food at your own risk. read more

Bagels are good, sandwiches are full. HOWEVER why is it that the young women (sisters) NEVER, EVER say "THANK YOU"??!?!? Most sour looking women behind the any counter that I've ever seen. I'm tired of being the one who says "thanks". Hey I'm the customer, I'm paying your salary, etc. I've stopped leaving tips because...why should I? And why do I have to remind them that I get a side (chips, salad) with my sandwich order? Barely two stars....one for each sister! read more

This is their "Extra Cream Cheese"! I HATE Cheap people! I never complain about their prices or the fact that they ALWAYS Charge a credit card fee whether it's $10 or $100! The problem is there's no consistency! One employee makes this Garbage and another with make a Real New York Bagel Store Poppy Seed with Extra Cream Cheese. Most NY Bagel stores would consider this "Light on the Cream Cheese!" They don't even offer a side salad with the deli sandwiches anymore! I once ordered an egg sandwich on a croissant, instead or telling me they don't bake croissants, they took the prepackaged croissant they sell next to the chips and candy(the nasty ones the bodegas sell), and made my sandwich with that. It tasted nothing like a croissant, just fake butter and the plastic wrapper it was sitting in for weeks. There's always egg shells in the last few bites of your egg sandwich. I have yet to get a soft "Fresh Backed Bagel" from them after going here for 11 years! I only come back because my kids request them, but I'm going to bring them to a real Bagel Shop tomorrow to show them the difference! Enough is enough. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - This is their "Extra Cream Cheese"! Definitely NOT a NY Bagel Shop! - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

I wish I can give 0 starts, this place sucks now. I'm a daily customer Monday - Friday and I'm just tired of getting to work and seeing the crap they put together. I don't know what happened to this place, but this is the last time they see my face in there. I will not be going back to this place. I hope someone new comes In and can run the place the right way. Also they never answer the phone, like get it together it's 2022 read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - This is what they call a "Western Omelet Breakfast", my 6 year old son would have made this better. Nothing is cooked but the eggs. - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Bagels are great! Wide variety of cream cheese. Attentive staff (just be clear on add-on/off of their specialty menu). Tables to eat and read the paper/text messages. Lunch menu offers what you would expect...a sandwich of your choice. Lousy coffee, though. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Bagels - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

The best deli in the area and the staff are the best to , all fresh only takes few min to have my breakfast ready love this place ,

As a recent transplant from NYC I love my bagels. In NYC We're spoiled because we have an abundance of them available to us. Even the "bad" places are better than most others. Imagine my surprise when the place literally down the block from me has the best bagels I've ever had. Trust me when I say Lindenhurst bagels is the best bagel place ever. They make the absolute best bagel anywhere. They are my go to before every Jets game (4-0 so far) and that just adds to why they'll be my place forever!! Seriously folks, come here. The staff is awesome, the bagels are ridiculous and the're right here in wonderful Lindenhurst. You're welcome. :) read more

Yummy bagels that I can tell are freshly made. Got a great "chew" to them. Loving the French toast bagels with cream cheese.

I've only been here for egg sandwiches so far. They are really great spot for breakfast. I will come back here whenever I'm in town read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Came here to get food, the sandwich (look at photo) is sort of ok. The sandwich is a normal hero split in to 2. The first part of the hero started to taste good but on the way to the end of the first piece to to start of the 2nd piece, the chicken looks not fresh, it was warm but looked like it was over cooked. Never seen a chicken that was cooked turned a brownish color. Bacon looked dehydration and the sandwich had no flavor. At least the fries I order was fresh and tasted better. I am giving this place 3 stars as it's my first time visiting there. The location looks pretty nice, almost made me think I am in a restaurant that had a bakery. I don't understand how a dink, sandwich and fries came out to ~$17 but not going to complain about price just the quality of my sandwich. I will comeback and try again (but getting a different sandwich ) then my judgment will be clear. read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

The quality of food, the service and how attentive is the staff. I stop by occasionally and it never disappoints. We order mostly bagels for the office and occasionally sandwiches. Everything is delicious. read more

This place is hit or miss. I've had the best breakfast sandwich there and other times where idk who is cooking but they chose the wrong career path. I can't comprehend how you can both burn and undercook a food at the same time lol. Lastly either their lemonade or ice is bad but be careful. I hope they step up their food safety on our behalf read more

I n placed a order received it in 1/2 hour. They messed up on my order said it would be redelivered in 20 minutes. Two hours have gone by no redelivered. Tried calling over 10 times no answer on phone. Is this the way they do business. I will never ever order from them again!!!! read more

Don't eat here! Bagels and Baileys is right down the road and their food is way better! I ordered via Uber eats Easter morning, the cream cheese had a rancid sour and overly cheesy aftertaste whereas cream cheese is usually somewhat sweet. The owner would rather accuse me of lying than reimburse me for an $8 meal. He said if it were their fault then they would have taken care of me. Not sure how their food tasting wrong could possibly be my fault. I used to manage a restaurant and this is not the way to treat customers. The meal went in the trash and my stomach started to feel funny when I decided to call them. What a mistake, if I knew they'd make me feel so stupid for calling then I would've saved myself the time and aggravation. Clearly their business can't afford to make things right with a customer who threw their food in the trash. If you don't enjoy your meal here, you better suck it up because this establishment couldn't care less. In fact, they'll be condescending, rude and tell you there's something wrong with your taste buds. read more

Lindenhurst bagels and deli are the best ever the employees are extremely kind and courteous. When they take your order it's done within two or three minutes I'm never disappointed in any sandwich I get any make my coffee in the morning or tea and it's perfect it's just the way I like it the amount of cream that they put in and sugar I would never go to another bagel shop Lindenhurst bagels are always going to the Best for me and my Family. read more

Great go-to spot for all your food needs. Bagels are fresh and lunch options are awesome. Love it!

Bagels are solid. My go-to's are egg everything and French toast. Egg sandwiches are good. The bagels are soft and fluffy and so yummy. They really do a great job with the bagels. Service is normally very quick and friendly. They forgot the lox on my bagel one time, which was annoying, since lox is expensive. But it was only one time. I'm not going to penalize a place for forgetting one item one time. They have been great otherwise. I haven't tried many of the sandwiches, but this is right near my apartment and walking there is super convenient. read more

Being mid-afternoon, I was expecting my buttered bagel to not be super fresh... But it was!! Awesome!! :-) There were many delicious looking cream cheeses to choose from, as well as hot and cold lunch specials and cold cuts. The place was very clean and the staff was very welcoming and quick to help me. The bagel was very good. I would definitely return here to try something more intricate on another visit. read more

Second trip to Lindenhurst Bagel, still not disappointed. The bagels are still amazing here. There was a bit of a line this morning but the staff behind the counter really hustled and moved everyone along. I just spotted Oreo Cream Cheese, now that sounds interesting! Never seen that one before. They also have a deal where you can txt in your order. I may try that one next time. Thumbs are still pointing up from me. read more

I ate here several times last week and my stomach was bothering me all last week. I came here yesterday and bought two sandwiches. I ate one last night and got a terrible stomach ache, had the other one just now and had to run to the bathroom. I've got a pretty strong stomach too and all I had was a ham sandwich- nothing difficult to digest. I think this place is dirty. I won't be going back and I'm pretty grossed out. read more

By far the best deli in lindenhurst. This is a great tasting deli. With a bunch of delightful smelling pastries, bagels, salads coffees and much more. The best part is the costumer service is fast friendly and alright on point. I must say also the awesome happy Spanish man who delivers your food is so sweet and makes your day If you know what's good for you get your food there read more

Lindenhurst Bagels and Deli - Blueberry muffins !!! - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Much improved. I stopped going here about 2 years ago. Stopped in over the weekend, because I didn't feel like going to N Lindenhurst to get bagels. Wow, what an improvement, the bagels were nice and fresh. I'll be back for sure read more

Very dirty place. Food have no taste. I brought friends and family for breakfast. I was so embarrassed, Shame on me. This bagke place should be closed by the health department. Sorry but it's TRUE. read more