No bread service? (Tonight or forever, not sure). The menu and intent of Center Cut has changed, so reset your expectations if you haven't been in a while. What was previously a surprisingly elegant dining space with exquisite steaks and specialty items in an Indiana casino, is temporarily their main restaurant. Service still excels and the food is tasty. I ate the crab cakes (appetizer) as an entrée and couldn't finish. The texture was perfect and the taste was very good. My dining companion had the filet accompanied by the asparagus and said it was fantastic! In addition to a few steaks--there is a chicken entree, sandwiches and other lighter meals on the menu. The bar is full service although they were out of the Tom Gore Chardonnay tonight. read more

Center Cut - Oscar - style lump crab meat and barnaise sauce. Good taste, great texture and seasoned just right! - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

See all

We went to Center Cut last night for dinner. My birthday is on Valentine's Day so there's never a table to be had and it's always so crowded so we decided to celebrate early. It was a Friday night and we were about 15 minutes early for our reservation. We were greeted at the door of the restaurant as soon as we walked in. We were immediately ushered to our table. Our waiter was at the table a few minutes later to introduce himself and see if we wanted anything to drink. I ordered the Second Circle martini and the hubby got an iced tea. Our excellent waiter was Patrick. The Second Circle martini is Woodford Reserve bourbon, Ruby port, maple syrup, and Bitters. The martini was good with the overriding flavors being the port and maple syrup. Really did not taste the Woodford but I liked it. Someone brought a bread service to the table and poured water. Patrick took our order for starters when he brought the drinks back. We ordered the steak tartare and the chicken livers. I have had the chicken livers here before and already knew that I liked them. The chicken livers are served on a bed of frisee lettuce, sweet red onions, and aged balsamic vinegar. This perfectly complements the crispy on the outside and tender on the inside chicken livers. The hubby liked the steak tartare better. The steak tartare was made with black garlic, egg yolk jam, shiso, a bone marrow cracker, and togarashi. Both were tasty ways to start our meal. Patrick took our order for dinner when he brought out our starters. The hubby ordered the 14 oz New York strip and a loaded baked potato. I ordered the lobster bisque and coho salmon. In addition I ordered another martini, the vanilla espresso martini. Patrick brought my lobster bisque out shortly after that. This was very tasty and reminiscent my favorite lobster bisque. The only thing I would change would be to make it a little bit thicker but it had excellent flavor it had a little bit of pernod cream and a few bites of lobster. Our dinner was brought to the table and he set the baked potato in between us because it was huge any thought we might want to share it! The hubby ordered his steak medium rare and it was cooked perfectly and he said it had great flavor. My coho salmon was cooked perfectly as well and I had never eaten wheat berries and they were slightly crunchy giving the dish some texture. We both really enjoyed our main dishes with no complaints. To top off the night I ordered coffee with cream and creme brulee. He brought my coffee to the table in a stainless steel pitcher and he brought a pitcher of cream and he had also taken the extra step to warm up my coffee cup. This was awesome! I love my coffee to be very hot and this was perfect. A little bit later he brought the creme brulee in the hubby and I shared it the burnt sugar on top was nice and crusty and we had to crack through it just like you should. We had a very enjoyable meal and will definitely be going back. I would suggest asking for Patrick on your trip in as he did an excellent job. read more

See all

I eat here at least once a month and I come back for the food, but also the staff! They're so friendly and always remember my favorites! It is located inside of the casino and you must be 21 to enter! My insider rec: sit at the bar with Kyle. Their bar drinks are also some of my favorite around. Such good quality and made perfectly. He makes my favorite espresso martini! My order every time I come in: shrimp cocktail, Caesar salad (their onion soup is great too!), filet, the balsamic sprouts as a side, and then I switch up the other side. Loaded baked potato, mashed, or lobster Mac (not as good as their old menu's lobster Mac but still good!). Also don't sleep on their daily specials. They're always good!! For dessert fry their new buttery toffee cake! read more

Center Cut - Millers farm chicken (old menu), Lobster Mac & Cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

See all

Located within Indiana Grand Casino, this steakhouse has delicious lamb chops and filet mignon with all the sides you could ever want! The food, expectedly, did take about 30-45 minutes to come to the table which our awesome waitress warned us about when ordering the medium rare lamb chops (average cooking time she said)! Our experience was awesome and albeit on the pricier end, we'll definitely find a reason to be back for more. read more

See all

What an amazing date night this experience turned out to be. We wanted to do something fun so we went gambling. We we saw this restaurant then got on the reservation list as they were busy. We decided we wanted to have drinks when we went to the drink area the bartender brought us a dinner menu. We were able to eat there right by the piano. Multiple martinis were delicious and smooth. I highly recommend a date night here read more

Since moving from indy to Shelby County we are always looking for a good place to eat. we were wanting a steak so we went to Center Cut. it is located inside Indian Grand Casino. We have been to Sullivan's in Indy and loved it. But the price was high and the portion small. Center Cut the price was basically the same but the portions were huge. The steak was perfect the potato was the size of a child's head, and the lobster mac is to die for. we got seated early, the food came to us quickly. Everybody was very attentive. There was a small problem with the table next to us so it took longer for my waitress to get me my boxes and check out then it did to take to get our food to us. I will be going back and I definitely recommend this place read more

Center Cut - My great meal. - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

See all

Nine of our family planned the trip to Indiana Grand, in Shelbyville, IN, around dinner at Center Cut. We'd never dined here before and everyone was looking forward to our new dining experience. Along with the possiblity of hitting a large jackpot which one of the group did. We made reservations for 6:00 p.m. on a Thursday evening allowing everyone a few hours of gambling before dinner. At 6:00 we entered the restaurant and was promptly seated in the very back of the restaurant where the larger group tables were located. The room was very quiet, comfortable and felt like our own private dining room. As we walked through the restaurant a bar sits in the middle with small, intimate tables throughout. A large wall of wine greets you as you enter with the large, glass Center Cut sign. The service was phenomenal from the moment we sat down to the very last minute in the restaurant. From the hostess, our servers, and the Manager went above and beyond to make our dinner an exceptional experience. Service, food and atmosphere was truly a five star experience for all nine of us. The cocktails, wine and beverages arrived timely. The wine drinkers were very happy with their selections and my husband thoroughly enjoy his 3 Woodford Reserve over the one large ice cube ball. Nice and chilled without the ice melting quickly and diluting the bourbon. Each of us had a variety of appetizers. The large shrimp appetizers had a nice presentation and so fresh with an excellent spicy cocktail sauce. Not St. Elmo spicy but delicious without the nasal burn. The thick Lobster Bisque was served with a dollop of sour cream and had a generous amount of lobster and loaded with flavor. The salads were crisp and fresh and everyone loved the assortment of fresh, warm bread and dinner rolls. The flavored butters were a miss for a couple people but that was the only minute issue all evening and, of course was a personal preference. Our dinners consisted of Lobsters, Ribeyes, Pork Chops, 10 oz. Filets, and Salmon. Everthing was extraordinary, prepared perfectly with beautiful presentations. All the sides are noted as shareable and can easily be shared between 2 or 3 people. The baked potatoes were HUGE, very tender and topped as requested from butter to loaded. The Lobster Mac n' Cheese was filled with large chunks of lobster, 3 types of cheeses with a thin layer of bread crumbs and lightly baked. Excellent!! And it reheated well the next day. Dessert was a struggle for all of us but several spoons appeared to help the situation. The Creme Brulee was the hit of the desserts with a close second to the Chocolate Torte. An excellent Steakhouse and we all agreed the quality and service was worth the price paid. We look forward to dining at Center Cut again on a future trip. read more

Honestly, wow. This place not only looks really great, very sexy, but had incredible food. Seriously. I really wasn't expecting much but their chef is amazing. The ambiance outs top notch. There's a piano player and a wall of wine to the right, a beautiful bar in the center and initiate seating all around. The menu is pretty reasonable for a steak house and many typical steakhouse items. We started with the shrimp cocktail which came out as 4 enormous prawns. And honestly, their cocktail sauce is just as good as st Elmo without the crazy burn. Nick had the filet which he rated an 8 out of 10. I had a bite and would absolutely order it for myself sometime. We had the Brussel sprouts and mashed potatoes for a side. The potatoes were great but the Brussel sprouts were amazing. They have a great bacon flavor. I ordered the goat cheese crab fondue appetizer. Omg it's amazing. We were warned it wad big so I decided that would be my entree. Now I also have a great snack for later. The service was great too. The lady bartender has worked here since the place opened and was wonderful to chat with. I'm sorry I don't remember her name but ill definitely be back and I hope you see her again! read more

Center Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Hate the menu change & service this time, won't be back. Enjoyed a nice dinner in September w/ our bartender Tara who was nice, checked in on us when we got our meal & had great recommendations. Kyle sucked, avoided us both times, as he did today, but checked in on everyone around us. Both times the manager did ask how everything was which I appreciate. I do like the live music, today was a violinist. Also this is a smoking restaurant. Odd in a Steakhouse, but I'm in Shelbyville. Now Caesars has taken over so maybe things will change here in July. Today we got Kyle's wife Brandy who was just as rude, snappy & ready to have us gone. No reason cause we are good tippers & not difficult. She never brought the dessert tray after saying someone else had it & never acknowledged it after we asked for the check. By that time, we were ready to be gone. Will not be back so her problem is solved. She had no recommendations on food & told me the pictures I showed her from September were 'a long time.' Hmmm cause she said the menu changed two weeks ago, guess that's a long time. The customer next to me is a regular & said the menu sucks & keeps getting worse cause chefs don't want to take other chef's menu, instead make up their own new menu. No specials were presented or descriptions as her husband Kyle explained to the guys next to us. The ribeye & roasted Cauliflower were good so will give the star to the Chef. Nothing worthwhile on the menu besides the steak. Why change a great menu such as the Scallops, Sea Bass & the Coffee Rubbed NY Strip or even the Tartare? Thankfully I didn't leave those recommendations cause they're gone now. read more

Our table of 7 had a great time at Center Cut! We were all about the seafood entrees. The Chilean Sea Bass got high marks, as well as the salmon. Be aware that it is ala carte, so all side dishes are an extra charge. The complimentary bread and butter plate features a variety of fine breads and three unique butters, which were warm and delicious. The lobster bisque was tasty, but could have been thicker and creamier. The arugula pear salad had a tangy dressing and lots of pine nuts. The ambiance is very nice and upscale, with a bar area you can dine at, and there are loads of tables, nicely set with linens. This restaurant is located inside the casino. You have to walk through the casino, so be prepared for smoky air when you enter. But the restaurant is smoke free. You can valet park for $3.00, or self park for free. Our waiter, Damien, was prompt and professional. Our water glasses were continuously filled and our silverware replaced. Give Center Cut a try, the steaks are awesome, too! read more

Very good atmosphere. I felt like the family style sides were enough for three people. Our server Kyle was fabulous. He provided multiple wine selections based on our food choices. I got a ribeye steak that was cooked to perfection. It's worth going to this restaurant even if you don't want to go to the casino in my opinion. I would put their menu up against any high-end steak restaurant in Indianapolis. Absolutely a diamond in the rough. read more

See all

We visited last night 6/4/22 and ordered wine, crab cakes, side salads, 2 filets, and 1 ribeye. The filets came out as small medallion hockey pucks. We ordered our temperature medium and medium rare and the steaks came out well done. No big deal, try again, however, it took them 40 minutes to get our new steaks out. Should have been maybe 3-5 minutes per side. We ended up taking it home at this point we were unhappy and nobody cared to ask how our evening was. Just gave us our bill. Stay away. This place is not a steak house. read more

This was our first meal here and we were very pleased with our experience. We began with some cocktails and the bar can seriously make a drink! We ordered a cheese fondue appetizer (minus crab) and a tuna tartare. Both appetizers were excellent. The cheese was extra creamy and the bread that accompanied it was perfect for the cheese. The tuna was incredibly fresh and very filling. We were already getting quite full, so we split the pork chop with a side of mashed potatoes and garlic broccoli. We were given a slice of chocolate cake for dessert and we were able to take it home with the rest of our leftovers. One really nice feature is that they will hold your food in the cooler while you go into the casino, and you can pick it up anytime before the restaurant closes for the night! read more

See all

I am a return customer. I asked my husband to take me here for my birthday dinner.We were here pre-Covid & the food & service was outstanding.Not able to report the same thing post-Covid.We had a reservation.Upon our arrival, we were seated in a booth near the bar the exact same location year prior.I quickly scanned the restaurant,there were not many people dining so I was quite surprised that it took 20 minutes before our drink order was taken.Another 10min to get them. Followed by 30 minutes of waiting for appetizers.We sat for an hour.I chose not to eat for hours in anticipation of the dinner meal. Good news:The food was excellent. I suggest you eat a snack if your really hungry. Always hoping for quality service every time but this was a huge disappointment read more

Super delicious!! The service is amazing also! Honestly not what I expected from a restaurant at a small casino but I was very surprised & highly satisfied! I had the strawberry lemon drop martini, filet and lobster mac-n-cheese! Yummy & I can't wait to go back!! read more

Center Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Im sad the lack of servers were part of the cause of spending $$$ on a meal that took 2 courses to took 2 1/2 hrs to have. For that money we have received wait staff that have been educated on how to serve. And the food was not good at all. Steak was tough. Sorry wont be back. read more

Okay I'm a steak snob having had worked at Ruth Chris for awhile. This place beats Ruth Chris with ease! Great service (they didn't have gingerale so the bartender 'Kyle' made some), and perfectly executed food. The prices really are great for the quality and portion too! Warm, comfortable, cozy atmosphere. I'm coming back here every time I'm in town. read more

Center Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

I had the filet mignon Oscar style, rack of lamb, and lobster macaroni and cheese. Amazing food. Amazing atmosphere. We sat next to the pianist and felt like we were somewhere in Vegas. Nope. Just a diamond in the rough of Shelbyville, Indiana. I've been here twice now. It's probably my favorite place to sit down and eat at this point. read more

Center Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

This steakhouse was a surprising find inside the casino. Service was good as was the meal. I had the spinach salad and Cabernet steak. Love the salad and the steak was cooked just right and very tender. We will return. read more

Center Cut - Spinach salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Quality doesn't match price point. Service is less than stellar. I am aware that places are short staffed like crazy right now so we are understanding. However, if y'all just chillin while my drink is empty or even just waiting for water that's a fail read more

The food okay. You can seriously get food passion here. There always bleach right next to the food witch can kill anyone. The staff are sometimes friendly. They sometimes pick up food off the floor and give it to customers. read more

The wife and I were there last year for Valentine's Day excellent dinner. we are returning again this year for a Valentine's Day dinner. it may become a new tradition. The food is excellent the wait staff is excellent a little pricey but well worth the money. Make sure you have reservations read more

Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. Was expensive but you get what you pay for. Steak was cooked perfectly, the gigantic shrimp cocktail and sauce was amazing, and the 3 sides, mushrooms, green beans, and mac and cheese were simply the best. One of my favorite steakhouses to eat at. Makes going to gamble more of a treat when you can also eat food this well prepared. And the service was amazing, my drink was never empty as the server made certain I was well taken care of. See my photos of this wonderful food. read more

See all

Excellent shrimp cocktail. Excellent bone in ribeye. Great sociable bartender and good stiff drinks. Everything you would expect at a fine steakhouse and they fully met expectation. I would have loved to try their lobster bisque but next time. Great place. read more

Center Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

I loved the steak here! Falls in line with Morton's or st.Elmo but without the price tag! Awesome atmosphere,very attentive staff! Can't wait to go back! read more

I recently had a very satisfactory experience at this establishment. I had the filet mignon which was good. Not the best I've had but I wasn't disappointed. My girlfriend also had the same steak. For a side she had a big ole bowl of brussel sprouts. We all know what this make you do, at know fault of the restaurant of course. Do yourself a favor and grab some mints on your way out. They were just delightful. read more

The best steaks I've ever had! That's right Indy, you have nothing on this place! Staff is extremely nice!

This is one of my favorite steakhouses. I have had good experiences and great experiences. I've been here many times so the couple "good" ones didn't bring the scale down to 4 stars. The service has usually been extraordinary. There were a couple hiccups on both the service and food but overall it's a great place to enjoy an upscale steak. Can't be perfect. If you're on a tight budget and don't want to go this deep in your pockets, I would recommend the OTB in the casino. Good deal for great food. read more

I would like to also take this opportunity to thank you Eric Kichler and his staff for a wonderful dining experience last night. Our server Tammy was gracious, helpful and very engaging in personality. She is truly an asset to Center Cut. As well, Jorge was so humble and friendly. Kind. The food was by far, the best we have had (and we've dined there many times). Cooked to perfection and served timely. I honestly don't know where a better prepared steak and overall dining experience could be found elsewhere, no matter the cost. This was reminiscent of 5 Star Las Vegas. Lastly, please know that the pianist, Ken .. made the ambiance of this experience unequalled to anything I've ever had the pleasure of enjoying. What brilliant talent. Mr. Kichler is the quintessential manager for Center Cut and he and his staff are to be commended for their preeminence for setting the bar for customer satisfaction on all levels. Alexandra Eads read more

One of the best steaks I've had was served here. Outstanding service and food!! Prices were just right for the delicious dinner we had. I have recommended people to eat the filet. Perfect amount of seasoning and just a tad bit of a crisp bite on the outside and soft and warm (melt in your mouth) on the inside! read more

To sum it up - - you get a lot for your money at this restaurant. We went a couple of weeks ago with some friends. We made a reservation for 8:00 pm, but could have easily just walked in as there were only a couple of other tables seated. We kicked off with a round of cocktails - all getting something different. All the drinks were served quickly and with a great assortment of garnishes. The food was great! I started with the wedge salad which I really enjoyed. It was 3 smaller wedges of salad which made it perfect for sharing with my husband. I had an 8 oz filet and it was so tender I could truly use my butter knife. The garlic/parmesan butter topper made it extra indulgent and the butter running over into the yukon gold potatoes made them extra yummy as well. The filet was much better than an 8 oz filet I recently had The Capital Grille/Indy. My husband enjoyed his bone-in rib eye immensely also. Our friends enjoyed their steaks and crab legs immensely also. They had a decent wine list, but unfortunately they were out of the first two bottles we attempted to order. The manager handled it very well though and came to our table with a similar bottle and offered it free of charge. We enjoyed the wine so much we ordered a second bottle (we had a hired driver for the night, so why not!). The server seemed a little green, but still offered great service. This is truly a little gem of a place that offers a great steak meal at a good price. Once you are inside the restaurant you don't remember that you are in a casino in the middle of nowhere Indiana. read more

Usually yelp is on point, but im surprised this place isnt a solid 5-stars! absolutely amazing in every way! and for the price??? no way, Long horn pushed me to them, and I'll never go back there and I'm thankful for it!!! If you have any doubts, go there, if you complain, theres other issues in your life that need to be addressed, not this place.... read more

We were here a year ago and it was one of the best steaks we had ever had . . . Unfortunately, a lot can change in a year. The "special" was a 90 day aged New York strip that had a distinct Dinty Moore flavor to it and was tough and grisly. The coffee dusted strip was also tough and the coffee didn't have a chance of covering up the old canned roast beef flavor. To be fair the bread and scallops we had as an appetizer were great, but the beef short rib was also dry and underwhelming. I think they are cutting corners on the quality of their beef and hoping an unsophisticated clientele won't notice. read more

My husband and I went here after playing in the casino. The food was good but the service was even better. Our server Tammy asked us how everything was and after my husband expressed his disappointment with the truffle fries, she removed them from the bill without being asked. We thought this was exemplary service. We both had ribeyes which were cooked great. Overall great experience! read more

Great atmosphere and attentive staff. It was a busy Friday night, so it took 25 mins for our food to come, but once it came we were pleasantly surprised. Steak was perfection! read more

Great food, good service, and friendly service. This place knows how to cook a great stake.

Not just a meal, when coming to Center Cut Steakhouse. Beyond your imagination with the delightful tastes. Not only steaks here but chicken,fish, and other seafoods also. The fact Shelbyville Indiana has this hidden gem, is beautiful for the city. The servers here, become your most well dressed, informed and people that one looks for in service. The palet on the tounge really gets its best possible tastes from Center Cut. Given a 5 star only because it is what is offered on here, when really this restaurant deserves the amount of stars on the American Flag. Delighful dining experience and remarkable decor. The Piano player adds a nice touch also whenever men want to impress their wives. This is a must-go-eat steakhouse. read more

See all

For the price you are better off going to Longhorn. The steak is very over-seasoned and I believe it is because they aren't using the best cuts of meat. The restaurant is a-la-cart so expect to pay a little more and stay away from the salads because they are not worth the price. Their shrimp and grits is actually pretty good so I would recommend it as an appetizer. read more

Great food and wine selection. Manager helped wife and I decide on perfect wine based on our mood! Steaks came out over cooked but apparently just got the wrong order and our med rare steaks were delivered shortly after. Butter served on salt block was a nice treat! read more