Pizza and chili oil are great, good cocktails, nice wine selection. Service was pretty good too. Could you use a better beer selection. read more

Great pizza, pasta, service and the owners both had smiles on as they mingled with the crowd. This place is authentic in so many ways and is the perfect mix of nice but not too nice. Service was great and that was a concern based on other reviews so when it was great that was refreshing. Food was equally good. read more

If you think this little gem is just a pizza joint you'd be mistaken. Of course the pizza is excellent but so are the pastas and pork belly. Yummy! read more

This place saved the Lakeshore for me. I've been waiting for a great restaurant to open down here for 10 years, and now hopefully the rest will follow. Fresh, light, pasta, some of the best seafood I've ever had...excellent pizza, good beer on tap, all served in a comfortable, contemporary atmosphere (with proper lighting) Can't reccomend Cellar Door enough! read more

We came in on a Thursday night and the restaurant has a lovely intimate ambience. We ordered the appetizer of the day which were white fish cake croquettes that were amazing. Following that we had the pasta with pesto and long roasted lamb that was one if the best dishes I have had in a long time as far as pasta dishes go. Along with that we ordered the four seasons pizza. Cool concept but toppings are better when they are mixed . read more

The first time we went to this restaurant we had just returned from a trip to Italy, where as we know, the pizza is as good as it gets. We thought it was a bit risky to order pizza and be disappointed but instead we were delighted by how delicious it was. The crust was crisp, the toppings fresh and tasty and the size was generous. We have been there several times since and always look forward to the next. read more

SOS... Soggy, Overpriced, and Salty It's the only pizza doggie bag I've ever thrown out in 30 years. Maybe it was just a bad night, There's a much better place just to the west. read more

The food was very good but the service not so much. Since we like to support local establishments we decided to try the Cellar Door based on some decent reviews. I have to say they need some more experienced servers/hosts . Although the restaurant was only 3/4 full on a Saturday night the atmosphere could be described as sort of laid back scrambly. Very disorganized floor staff. We waited about 15 minutes before anyone even looked at us. As soon as they did we were seated at a half set table. Our server was decent- fairly attentive and quick as opposed to the others we saw. Our food came quickly and it was really quite good. Arugula beet salad was simple yet amazing. Will get it again. The pizza had a super thin crust and it was superbly put together. It was better than anything offered in the area- including FBI and Even Dino's . The gnocchi would have been excellent with more (some) sauce and without the roasted sweet potatoes that were basically chewy pieces of blech..... The homemade bread which came halfway through the meal was also very good but too late. I will go back because the food makes up for the poor service plus maybe they will have new floor staff next time. read more

This place is real deal. The pizza is fantastic. The food is a bit pricey, but the food is so good u don't feel ripped off. We need a lot more restaurants that look, and taste like this one. The services was great as well go here. U won't be disappointed. read more

Really yummy! I had the beet and arugala salad, and the "pepperoni, pepperoni, pepperoni" pizza. Both were great! I give it 4-stars because they are not open for lunch! Hopefully some day that changes. read more

My wife and I came here for our 1 year anniversary last night. We showed up for our reservations and we were pleasantly greeted with a "Happy Anniversary" from the staff. Pizza is great, ambiance and decor were modern rustic. Would go back for the pizza. read more

Great service and excellent pasta! Can't wait to go back and try the pizza! Nice to have a super local restaurant! read more

Food is amazing! Friendly, attentive, caring staff! True home experience! I have tried many, many pizza places in Toronto. This is by far my favourite one. I'm not sure how they do their crust, but it is just like pizza I ate in Rome. Thank you for bringing such an outstanding experience to this area of town read more

Atmosphere is great. Good service. Love the pizza variety there. Have dined in and take out. Not a fan of the pastas selection. Tried a couple and all werent to my liking. read more

Wonderful meal, from the beet salad appetizer to my lamb gnocchi. The smooth red wine was the perfect compliment to the meal, especially when I can just walk home. And an attentive server is always a bonus, as there was a group of us and we just loved it. read more

A great addition to New Toronto. I've been here a few times now and the food & service has always been exceptional. I highly recommend you try it out. read more

Great little gem of a spot, hands down the best and most authentic Italian food in all of Etobicoke. Pizza is fresh and hot straight from the oven, highly recommended read more

So I've been here twice and the first time we went the food was amazing but unfortunately the second time around we were very unimpressed. The food took over an hour to arrive, we had all ordered oven made pizzas. Understandably the restaurant was very busy but really the wait was too long for any pizzeria. Then to top it off there was a piece of hair wedged into the toppings of my pizza, when I told the waiter he took it away then within 2 minutes brought it back to me again asking me to point out the hair... it was as if he didn't really believe me. Through out the service he wasn't particularly friendly, quite cold to be honest so that comment didn't really help either. Thankfully he brought a new pizza to me pretty quickly, and the pizza was cooked deliciously apart from being slightly burnt around the edges. It's just a shame that the service isn't spectacular, the wait is far too long and there was a piece of hair in it too... read more

This place is great. Pizza is the best, authentic and delicious. Ambiance is casual yet nicely decorated. Staff very friendly and helpful, and service was speedy! read more

Had a great dinner here last night. The caprese salad with burrata was fresh and the cheese was so creamy. The grilled octopus was my favourite, tender with the perfect amount of char and a flavourful romesco sauce. The wood oven pizza has a great crust, crispy and light. The gnocchi was fluffy with a rich mushroom sauce. Service was friendly and attentive. A great environment and place to sit eat and relax! read more

We love this restaurant for a nice date night or a quick dinner with our toddler. The staff is lovely and accommodating, and the pizza is really great. We are lucky to have such a great, family friendly restaurant near us! read more

My service/ server was amazing. Very accommodating and prompt. My pasta was a tad salty, but so delicous. You could taste how fresh eveything was. Highly recommended for a date or any occasion. Thanks to the Staff and Chefs at Cellar Door! read more

Excellent pizza, great service! A very popular restaurant (read: loud in there during peak hours) that feels a lot like a downtown Toronto resto :) read more

I love handmade pasta and this definitely satisfied my craving for it. Good quality ingredients and delicious plates. The pastas are very simple but the flavours are perfect. Everything is handmade they day of and the bread to start (house made foccacia) was sweet and tasty and different than any bread I've had at a restaurant before; very authentic. We shared the octopus starter which is the best I have had. The flavours again were lovely and the texture of the octopus was amazing, the chefs definitely know how to cook it properly. For entrees we had the spinach tagliatelle which was very simple and tasty and also the pasta e fagioli with rabbit, I loved it. It was light; not a heavy dish; and the texture of the pasta was great. I can't say anything bad about our meal. Wine pairing and our server were also excellent. Inside is very nice, classy yet cozy and a comfortable atmosphere. Looking forward to returning for more pasta and also to try the pizza!!! read more

Live in Mimico and a friend mentioned I should try out the Pizza. It was delicious and the staff was friendly. I have ordered takeout a few times since and will definitely go back soon. Recommend the RHCP pizza and tagliatelle. read more

Nice room, (if a bit noisy); nice staff. Pizzas are good, and a good value - you could share one, with some wine, and come out quite happy. Had pasta dish with lamb. Only okay; kind of bland. Nice place, but not one I would rave over. But it was full, so they must be doing something right. read more

I took my husband here for a birthday dinner. It's one of the best meals we've ever had! I had the beef carpaccio appetizer and spinach pappardelle pasta for my main. He had the Caprese salad appetizer and pizza special. The pasta and pizza dough are made fresh in-house. All meals were well balanced. The food really was outstanding. The service was prompt and friendly. Our server was very knowledgable. We can't wait to go back! read more

My favourite neighbourhood place for dinner....great atmosphere and amazing food, wood oven pizza, pasta and mains are all fantastic!

I have been here a number of times now. As usual the food was excellent. I had the fired artichoke, my wife had octopus. Both were excellent. The last time I came I ordered the octopus which was good but the portion was very small. The one last night was much better and nicer presentation. So I am not sure if it is change in the dish, different chef or just a different night, but keep it from last night!! Our server was very good, but service was a little slow. The restaurant was quite busy for a Wednesday but not packed. They could have used more than one server or a bartender, as it seemed our server was also making drinks for the entire restaurant. The pizzas are amazing! I find the pasta dishes a little on the small side. It certainly won't stop me from returning ..... but .... food for thought .... for Cellar Door management. read more

Very good authentic Italian restaurant. Homemade pasta is fantastic and pizza is clasic woodfired with fresh ingregients. Reasonably priced and some great creative items on the menu. I've been twice, first time service was lacking, second time it was great! hopefully this is the new norm. This place is a great new hidden gem with an extremely talented chef. read more

It was alright.. I went here for a birthday celebration based on the reviews. Pizza was good but their actual entrées need work. Both the white fish and gnocchi were over cooked. 3-4 fold markup on the wines which is disappointing. read more

First time, no reservations on a Thurs night, Great pizza, fabulous gnochi. Nice wait staff though we were abandoned a couple of times as he had a large table of about 16. Would have been nice if the wait staff who were not as busy had pitched in. Aside from that we will definitely be back. read more

Best wood oven pizza in town :-) The octopus salad is great as well and the staff is very friendly. Try the homemade pasta too!

Wine prices atrocious! A bottle of Tawse Gamay Noir at the LCBO is $17.95- at Cellar, it was a coll $50!!! Only americano coffee (not regular), the pizzas so so and the tuna salad had way too much dressing to eat. read more

Food is very good. The pizzas in particular are amazing and that huge italian wood-fired oven at the back is a thing of beauty. I've had pizza at libretto and QMP and would take cellar door's margherita over those two places' any day. Decor could use some updating...it's overly stark and lacks warmth. Sound really bounces off the walls too. read more

This place is a gem in south Etobicoke! We love it here, and eat here often. Their homemade pasta and pizza dough is spectacular! Next to my Italian Nonna, this place makes my favourite Italian food! Eat here! read more

I went with my wife and 2 other couples. Had read a really positive blogto review and it's fairly close to us so thought we would try it. First impression was good - our server (Zack) was fun and personable. We went on a Saturday night and had a 6:30 PM reservation. When we got there, it was crowded and the atmosphere was nice. The decor in the restaurant including all the local photography is a nice touch. Overall, the food was good. More hits than misses. The octopus appetizer had good grill taste and the scallop special was nice. The pizzas were decent. The pasta was definitely the best part! My wife had the braised pork shoulder pappardelle and it was delicious and a huge portion. I had the pasta special - a rapini pesto with homemade Italian sausage. It was delicious too but I wish my portion was as big as the pappardelle. The not so great part of the meal was the end. It literally took us over an hour after we finished to pay and leave. They were so slow coming to finish us up and give us our bill. I think they were short staffed or something. And then they only had 2 working credit card machine. Anyway, it wasn't s great way to end. I'll try it again but hope the service is better. read more