Best boneless wings ever. Regular wings are good too. Haven't ventured out of wings yet but the pizza and burger always look delicious !

Nice little sports bar that really takes 'errors' seriously. No offense likes a dropped ball and no bartender a broken glass. This place has a strong defense: martini's served in stainless steel. I like a strong defense and this place is on their game. Two points for Casey! read more

Casey's Pub - Stainless Steel martini glass is a great defense! - American Near Me - Holliston, Massachusetts

See all

I have come here a few times and the service and food just isn't good. The food is never consistent my sandwich always comes with different things on it when I order it. Fries are cold! The worst part is out waitress never gave us plates, so we used a take out box that they had and cut it in half for my daughters to eat on. When the waitress came she said oh we used to have plates up here but I don't know where they went. That was it! She never got us plates or apologized or anything. Seriously no plates! How do you expect us to eat when we ordered a bunch of apps and a pizza. Never going back! Waste of money. read more

After walking 4 miles on the rail trail this feels like paradise. Fabulous beer selection! 1st had Pipeworks Lizard King very thirst quenching. After the fresh tasting chili with multi colored nacho chips had the awesome Toppling Goliath Golden Nugget. Toppling is an old favorite, and this beer is a new favorite. Last time here was New Year's Eve for the railtrail festival, and Michelle was our waitress then, came back today because Michelle is the best waitress - thank you ! read more

Casey's Pub - American Near Me - Holliston, Massachusetts

I feel bad having to write this review during this time we are in. But, today I ordered a Greek salad w/grilled chicken on the side today. It was not during a peak time/busy. So the reason for it looking the way it did was uncalled for. The salad (lettuce) was wilted, and wet. The tomatoes were old and mushy. The grilled chicken, was not even grilled and was full of pepper. For being 3:00 pm I would of thought, the salad would be fresh. Having to pay $14.25.... very disappointed! read more

Our party booked the entire second floor of Casey's this past Sunday. Unfortunately, the owner did not notify the staff that we were coming. While I appreciate the difficulty of this situation, the bartender had a wicked attitude and made us feel extremely unwelcome. We overheard her (several different times) badmouthing our party to other customers. She also served her regulars immediately while making anyone from our party wait up to 30+ minutes for service. The breakdown in communication was not our fault, and we felt that the treatment we received was uncalled for. read more

I ate at Casey's this afternoon. The bartender was very nice but I almost walked right out the door after sitting at the bar for 5 minutes since she was watching the View with the volume turned up like a Who concert. She turned it down to a little so I could at least stand to be there. Now on to the food. I ordered the chicken parm. It came in a skillet with elbow noodles. Oh, I also ordered a Coke. They served me something fizzy and dark but it was by no means Coke. The "marinara" sauce was obviously made from left over chili. So it was elbow noodles, which is completely inappropriate for this application, covered in bad chili with a piece of fried boneless chicken on top. The food was completely unseasoned. Mine was probably the third meal to come out of the kitchen today and somehow it was cold. This meal was so incredibly off the mark that I could only surmise that the cook was completely unfamiliar with chicken parmigiana. It was like having a steak cooked by a vegan. Also the place did not smell great. read more

I'll start with the waitress. From the start our waitress was kind of rude. The website advertised 50 cents wings dine in only and we were rudely told they don't do that anymore. So ok whatever worlds greatest wings I'll try a beer and some wings but the wings were so over fried like the Chinese chicken wings from the place I only order from Because I'm drunk and they are the only place open at 2 AM. The only decent thing was the beer was cold and only 3 bucks a draft. Extremely disappointed their sign on the outside was such a fraud "worlds greatest wings since 2004". read more

Horrible!!! The place is dirty, the customer service is terrible and very rude with attitude. The manager/owner is an a***hole! How does he keep any customers or the place running being like that? Second, the food orders are never right each time I've ordered from there.. And to be honest it isn't even that good. Wendy's has better food. I'll never return or order from there again. Word of advice.. Stay Clear Away from here. read more

they can never make the food right and the staff is terrible. The board of health should probably pay a visit in my opinion.

I grew up in Holliston but never went to casey until recently, went a cpl weeks ago on a Saturday with my mom and the waitress was awesome, service was great and we loved the food. So, went back yesterday with her and my brother Same great waitress and the place was packed for a party. Unfortunately there was a major issue with the bathrooms.( I may of told the owner or a random customer lol not sure ) Which wasn't as bad as the RUDE bartender! We got up and moved to a different table, to give our booth to a dad with 3 small children This bartender starts to clean off the table for them than stops and states we can not sit at the new table, she has to clean the table. Okay so we move AGAIN Than she proceeds to reprimand us that she has to sweep the exact spot we were standing in Needless to say we left ! read more

Decent food one waitress is terrible had the audacity to tell us we don't tip well enough and we need to tip better or not come (mind you we're leaving 4-5 dollars on a 17 dollar bill almost 25 percent) and we also go there multiple times a week on our lunch break for work will not return on fridays .. Updated from 2 to 4 stars. Food is amazing there always has been. Besides the shotty service the owners (Mozie and John) are really nice people. A lot of the bartenders/waitress' are amazing Megan is the best! Andrew is a great bartender to. The bartender who thinks she's too good to be a waitress still works there i just don't go on her days! Other then that I would give this place 5 stars any day of the week' the wings are amazing! Deep fried steak and cheese is something amazing and different! I love this place read more

I've only had takeout but the place looks fun. Had the wings and fries. The fries were crisp and salty, just how they should be. The wings were good - meaty, crisp and cooked well. I'm from Buffalo and these wings are some of the best I've had outside of western NY. My only complaint is that the hot sauce isn't authentic. It's kind of spicy and a little sweet. They definitely didn't use Frank's hot sauce which is the traditional sauce used in Buffalo. I'll get over it because most wings around here don't even come close to real wings. I'll definitely go back to Casey's. read more

This review is for take out only. We had a great experience with takeout. The bone in wings were great. Just the right amount of heat for someone who cant handle really hot! The sweet potato fries were surprisingly excellent. The buffalo chicken calzone was good. Will definitely get take out again. read more

Imagine your boss swinging a chair around, then grinding on it and acting out a strip tease while Journey blasts on the jukebox. Now imagine this scene with your boss as a slightly insane story-telling hippie camp counselor and you'll have it just about right... This is my memory of Casey's. Yes they have an attractive interior with a small town pub atmosphere, but what you will take home with you is the spicy aftertaste of hot wings and bud light mixed with the stench of failure. Believe me, after a handful of marriage proposals from decrepit drunken townies, you too will vow to never go out drinking in the suburbs again. read more

Joined the MFS in Holiston for a year. Was looking for a local place to grab a drink and food after spending time on the range. As my drive up to the range is about 40 minutes this would be a great place to unwind. We expect to go to the range a few times a month. Joined last week and already have gone 4 times. Our first run by the place was on Friday night and the place was full. So we passed it up. We went again on Tuesday and stopped in. We sat on a high table and the chairs felt like they would collapse beneath us. We waited 5 minutes watching the servers chit chat and pass us by. When we were approached we were informed that they are cash only and the ATM was out of $$. Well that was a deal breaker. After reading some of the horrible reviews, on yelp, I won't be back. We found nice places in the area that gladly took our orders. My advice? Try it... but be prepared to be unhappy. read more

Wednesday & Sunday Bartender, Jay is the BEST bartender. She absolutely knows what shes doing. Best drinks and Music playlist on Wednesdays, you will not be disappointed!! If I could give her 100 stars, I would-- SHE IS A STAR!! read more

This is the kind of bar that people from your high school who never made it anywhere go to drink. It's not good, but it's not the worst either. It says they're open until midnight on yelp, but I've been there before where last call was at 10pm. If you're not a regular or a townie you might wait a while to be served if it's busy because the bartenders will just ignore you. If you're stuck in Holliston for whatever reason and don't have the means to transport yourself to Milford/Framingham/Worcester/Boston I guess this place is ok as a last resort. Definitely not worth traveling to. read more

Went here with the family one Saturday afternoon. It wasn't busy and our service was good. The interior is full of stuff to look at which satisfied my 3 yr old. We ordered a few apps and a salad and a kids burger. The Good: The rugrat killed all the fries and some of the burger. Also gave a thumbs up to the chocolate milk. The bride and I truly enjoyed the boneless Garlic Parmesan - they were cooked just right and has a very tasty flavor. Boneless may be the way to go here (see below) The wedge salad was a hit - crisp and fresh and big enough for us to share along with the other stuff. Not So Good: The chili was bland and boring and a little too tomatoey - just not the right flavor. The buffalo wings were not good. I don't know if it was the expectations that they raised with the "greatest wings on earth" statement but what I received was not close. The wings I had were dry and could have used more sauce - the buffalo sauce was just ok not great. I'm not sure if they were smoked too long or what but they were just disappointing all around. If in the area again we'd give it another shot read more

I've brought my son here twice now. It's one of the better places we've been in a while. Each time, we've gotten the boneless wings - we've tried buffalo (awesome!), the honey mustard (typical) and BBQ (also very good). The other appetizers are, for the most part, very generous and very good. I recommend the spinach/artichoke dip - it's big, very thick and covered in cheese, then baked. It's outstanding. Most chain places microwave this app and it drives me nuts. Pluses: It's decently priced, really tasty food and very friendly servers. Minuses: You can't see any TV from about one third of their dining area, and their bathrooms could use a re-vamp. But overall, a fun place to take your older kids for some great food and watching a game! read more

Great atmosphere! We love the beer selection, pizza, and the staff is amazing! Definitely a must visit pub!

It's a pub, next to the tracks and it is named after Casey at Bat written by Thayer who lived in the area and although the story was published while he lived in Cali it is assumed by most locals that the Mudville 9 was born just down the tracks and hence---Casey's Most have cried "foul" to Casey's food and I did not find that the case. I found the food better then average and the sides were'nt bad either. It beats an Applebees or Friday's any day of the week and the service was on the friendly side. The fact that they were out of "native corn" when every roadside stand has it available in Sept was a bit perplexing and even though service was not spot on I felt relaxed and comfy enough to just enjoy the meal. It wasn't at all busy when we visited and the people I were with were about as local as one could get so they knew just about all the workers and patrons. I liked the atmosphere and to catch some quick grub found this place to do the trick. read more

I've been coming here for about 2 years and I don't have any complaints. Obviously as a newcomer I felt like a bit of an outsider, as with any new bar/pub, but in my time coming here I've grown to know the staff. They are wonderful people that definitely get busy at times but do their best to serve each and every patron with respect and service in a timely fashion. I've always had great service with a smile! Their food has gotten even better with the new kitchen staff! I definitely recommend coming to get a good beer or good food! You won't be disappointed! read more

Tried several times going there a couple of years ago. I see by the reviews they are still suffering from THE slowest service imaginable. Also wobbly tables and chairs. One time, we had ordered the wings but decided not to eat them after one of us visited the ladies room - there was NO evidence of soap or soap dispenser so we asked the waitress if there was a separate restroom for the employees and when she said no, we got too scared to eat the wings we had ordered. Plus, we would have had to eat them with our hands as well but we weren't able to wash them! Ugh. Also overcharged our credit card once by a lot (40%!) - had rung up someone else's bill onto our card and it took super pushiness on our part, for 1/2 hour, to get them to process the refund. Nice location - what a shame. It seems like the owners are purposely trying to keep it down. read more

I thought I would try this place again after a couple of years avoiding it-I should have stayed away. The entryway was so run down and dirty I had to look in the window to see if it was still in business. It was lunch with only three patrons when I arrived, I still waited 25 minutes for a sandwich that was HORRIBLE. The place is unappealing inside, a desperate attempt to be a sports bar, the menu is limited, the service poor and the food worse still. I very, very seldom write reviews that is how bad this place is. Go elsewhere! read more

First time at Casey's after moving to the area and we were beyond pleased. Awesome fun atmosphere with music, friendly staff. Quick attentive service with great food. We had the wings which were excellent and excited to try other things off the expansive menu. This will be our new go to spot! read more

New menu pizza and wings are great. Andrew the bartender on Saturday night is great. Great local spot

A highly-rated wings place severely hampered by the lack of waitstaff. We were "fortunate" enough to get one round of drinks in. After being ignored for 30 minutes, just to try and order another beer and some wings, we gave up and went elsewhere. You might get better service if you sat at the bar. Nearby tables were in the same boat. read more

Service was very slow!! Waited close to an hour for a API and fries, we had it bagged to go as we were running late.

Casey's Pub is a hidden gem. It's very homey with a relaxed atmosphere and great food. The owner is outstanding with a great personality and makes everyone feel so welcome. This is the place you don't want to miss out on. read more

Beer selection is improving. It's a great neighborhood place but not worth a special trip.

The craft beer rotation is incredible and honestly the last spot I would expect it. There has been some selections on tap that I simply don't understand how they got their hands on (most recently Goliath's King Sue?!) For great craft beer and excellent wings this is your spot. read more

This bar has the potential to be cool, and it looked to me as if would have been...they even had Newcastle on tap...always a good sign...but then I tried to order...apparently they only serve people who live in Massachusetts! No out of state ID's allowed! Boo! read more

Tried to go here once with my husband. Walked in and waited to be seated since we didn't see a sign, and figured it was the polite thing to do. After about 5 minutes, we sat ourselves as the waitresses seemed to be ignoring us. 15-20 minutes sitting at the table and watching 3 different waitresses walk by us, completely ignoring us, even when we tried to get their attention, we just ended up leaving. Never had such horrible service in my life. Didn't even get as far as getting talked to so can't even review the food or beer. read more

I LIKE Casey's. I want to LOVE Casey's, but there are just some little things preventing it from going down like that. My last time there (Friday evening, 11/21), I was meeting friends but was the first one there so I ordered a beer at the bar while I waited. I got a Shiner Oktoberfest, very good, very tasty. While waiting for it, I saw a tap handle for Slumbrew's Porter Square Porter, and thought to myself, "That's next". After joining my friends and finishing my beer, I ordered the porter. The waitress brought me a light amber colored beer which was without a doubt not a porter. When I asked her about, she said that was the Slumbrew they had on tap. I told her I saw the PSP tap handle behind the bar, but she insisted that was their current Slumbrew offering. I asked her which Slumbrew it was, and she simply shrugged, looked confused, and walked away. Thankfully I grabbed another server (a younger guy) and asked him what Slumbrew they had on tap. "The Porter Square Porter, it's a chocolate porter... [holding up my beer] ...which is clearly not what you have. I'll be right back with that." He got me my desired beer, and set the other server straight. However, this is not the only time this has happened. I go here often with coworkers since it is affordable and near our workplace. We want to love it ! The wings are fantastic and the other food is very good! Unfortunately, it's service slipups like the above that make it a once-every-four-weeks spot instead of an every-single-Friday spot. read more

I was frequent patron here from 2011-2012. Great service, great beer, great food and the atmosphere was second to none. Its awful now. My friends and I have since found other places to meet in the area. The food is cold all the time, it takes FOREVER to get a beer, and the food simply tastes BAD. Casey's has all the potential in the world, but its not being realized. Its seems as though no one cares what goes on here. Its in need a of bar rescue. I didn't let just one experience influence my thoughts of Casey's. I went 5-8 times and had an equally awful experience. I used to love it here. Too bad to have to bail on Casey's. Save yourself time and money and go somewhere else read more

Was driving by and gave it a try. Ordered burgers, and wings. Wings were good, burgers tasted funny like either the meat wasn't that good or they were homemade patties and just didn't like the taste. I was just ok. read more

My wife and I went in for what we hoped would be a middle of the week dinner. We gave been here once before and it was OK so we tried again. Upon entering the place was busy not packed and a end booth opened up so I asked if it could be cleaned and it went down hill from their.. First off we seamed to bother her a but got seated looked at menus and I ordered a bottle of beer and a glass well she brought the beer no glass and a attitude. ..ugh So I ordered a stake sandwich with fried onions she said they don't do that, my wife ordered wings and we asked to start off with the special greek salad.... Well twenty minutes later I managed to catch the server and asked if the sale was coming out she said "I don't know" walked away and went behind the bar to BS with the bar tender.. ugh Looked at my wife took five bucks out of my pocket put it on the table for the beer as I don't steal and said let's go. . We walked out went to Shaws picked up chicken went home and sat on our deck and said their off the list.. If your looking for a neighborhood bar to get your drunk on Casey's is for you. read more

We typically only order take out form Casey's. The kitchen and food is great. They can be busy some nights but are really good about giving you an accurate time that your food will ready. Their wings and burgers are some of the best in the area read more

Went there with wife for a couple of appetizers. Ordered chicken fingers and order of nachos. The fingers were ok but started life in a box, frozen not fresh. The nachos came out with clumps of frozen onion and the cheese was not even melted. The salsa was in a little cup and that was also icy and frozen. Sent them back and the waitress came over and said " are those better" to which I replies " if you mean cooked - yes". Wait staff is a little ruff. Ok for a beer but food is not really that impressive read more