I have absolutely fallen in love with this gem of a restaurant! We celebrated our anniversary dinner here, and the food was truly amazing. January sounded like a slower season for them, which showed since we were the only diners that evening. Honestly, it made the experience even more special. The waiter, who was also the bartender, was incredible. Unfortunately, we did not catch his name, but he was working on January 10th and did a fantastic job. He was attentive, welcoming, and genuinely great at what he does. On to the food. We started with the fresh baked bread and Brussels sprouts. I never thought Brussels sprouts could steal the show, but these were packed with flavor and absolutely delicious. I ordered the linguine, and my boyfriend had the filet with crab and hollandaise sauce. Both dishes were outstanding and truly next level. The vibe of the restaurant was perfect. Very chic and sophisticated, which felt ideal for celebrating an anniversary. We actually loved that it was quiet because it felt like all the attention was on us. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Quite nice old fashioned indoor design. Good for a date night Short rib's quite decent amount but a bit dry. Has a nice char flavor. Goes well with the mashed potatoes but wish it has some sauce. Also should've ordered some side veggies. Quite a lot of meat without veggie Orange crème brûlée is a great idea, however, the orange flavor is quite artificial and overly sweet. Could've been an amazing dessert if used real orange zest/puree read more

See all

Since my last review I've been back here maybe two or three times, and I even understand it got a new owner at some point since then, but Carruthers is just not for me..... Even if the owner is new, I will go as far as suspecting the same Chef is still there because the handwriting on the food never changed: inconsistent as in my first review. Today I had the crab cakes appetizer, which was overseasoned and had no crab taste. The pork shank was better although served only luke warm and a little too dry (more sauce or au just would have been nice). I will still give max points to the bartender; the black Manhattan was as good as the first time. They have some kind of dishwasher in the bar area that makes a diesel engine noise vibrating the ground you sit on.... making the dining experience similar to sitting in the middle of a construction zone. Service started out fine but then faded out a bit; a good thing they don't add an automatic service charge to the check like some places in Seattle. read more

Carruthers - Rye Manhattan - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

See all

We had reservations for Mother's Day brunch and were disappointed when got there and found that it was buffet only! We were not told so when we made the reservations. The service was terrible. No one asked if we wanted coffee or drinks. I had to wave down a server to get my water glass refilled, and for the check. There were several empty tables so why we were ignored is a mystery. Very disappointing read more

Hubby and I went for one of their special 5 course menu night. Ambiance was great (wonderful historic building), as was the food (beautiful AND delicious) and hospitality (warm, good timing between courses. 5/5 read more

See all

One of the best meals I've had. Great service. Nice atmosphere. The brussels and drinks are fantastic as well! read more

Carruthers - Osso Buco - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

Amazing food and drinks and a great! We enjoyed a wonderful Happy Hour (3-6pm). Staff were very attentive.

Last year, hubby and I fell in love with the Caesar Salad topped with sous vide chicken (OMG so good). Visited last night and something changed. Thinking it was a change in Chef. The salads were WAY overdressed. There were thick slices of Parmesan clumped in the dressing rather than super fine shavings as before. The chicken was no longer tender. We also had the fish and chips which had little flavor. The finesse is sadly missing. The server was friendly and attentive. The interior is cool and vintage except for the addition of the weird mannequins in flapper attire, looming over diners' heads. They were added after ownership changed. read more

Wow!!! I've eaten at Carruthers many times. The cocktails are the very definition of craft and the menu is thoughtful . However last night and this morning...they have outdone themselves. My husband and I arrived and sat at the bar as we usually do. The bartender Joey met us with our usual old-fashion cocktail starters. Last night special was a whole lobster which came with asparagus and mashed potatoes. I ordered the lobster and my husband ordered the ribeye from the menu. Per usual the cocktails were amazing but the flavor and the execution on the ribeye was top-tier. The Brussel sprouts which came with the ribeye were stellar. Seasoned to perfection. After dinner we had Cadillac margs for dessert and again, crafted to perfection. This morning, we decided to try brunch out for the first time and holy hell. This place should be much busier than what it is for brunch. It is absolutely fantastic. The honey, maple pancakes and the hollandaise on the Benedict's were absolutely fantastic. It was warm and cozy with a candle burning in the background, which set the mood. Thank you so much for a wonderful dinner experience both times!! Oh I almost forgot, the breakfast potatoes were of a new style for me and they were amazing. I hope they never change the preparation of those. read more

Carruthers - Sausage Benedict. Biscuit and gravy side. Side of bacon, and honey maple pancakes with a berry compote!! - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

I'd like to start by saying that they're trying. Maybe a little too hard. Big sign hanging outside saying under new management or ownership or something like that so I don't know if this all is new or what. The building itself is beautiful. The food and drink just ok. I appreciated the allergy information on the menu - - saves me from having to ask a million questions - - but I feel like they are trying to be fancy. The staff were very nice but a little too much. We had hoped to enjoy a romantic, relaxing anniversary dinner but someone was always coming over to clear dishes - - like while I'm still eating. read more

See all

We sat at the bar for drinks and a bite. Service was good and the ambiance/décor was lovely. Our cocktails were solid, including a very nice espresso martini. Sadly, our one food dish was terrible. We ordered the Thai chicken wings, which were not Thai at all but instead were plain fried chicken served with three uninspired dipping sauces. This wouldn't be the worst thing in the world but unfortunately it was some of the blandest fried chicken I've ever had. Would come back, but only for a swanky cocktail and nothing more. read more

Dining this visit was good but not like more memorable past visits. I have removed stars from my initial review because Carruthers has slipped over the last couple years that we have been dining here. I called 6 weeks ago to make a reservation for our 49th anniversary and when we arrived, there was no record of my reservation. That is the second time we have experienced this oversight since they no longer accept Open Table reservations. I strongly suggest they fix their customer service glitches as it does affect their future business. This was a very slow Thursday night so it was no problem getting seated immediately 6:00PM at a cozy corner window table. Our waiter, Zack was friendly and attentive. We both started with drinks and fresh side salads, My black Manhattan cocktail was perfect and her fluted champagne over the top. I ordered the Cioppino and to be honest, It was filled with seafood but lackluster in taste and have enjoyed better here in the past. One of the shellfish hadn't opened and It wasn't served hot or with the zesty flavor I expect from this traditional dish. The tiny toasted bread pieces which I always have used to sop up the leftover broth, were more like small croutons and not at all suitable to be anything more than a garnish. For dessert, we ordered the decadent chocolate cake with a cream filling, much like memories of childhood Hostess cupcakes that may have been on the shelf for a while. Very dry without ice cream. After this disappointing experience, I am unsure if we will return to Carruthers as there are many other good dining options on the North coast. read more

Carruthers - Window table with a beautiful view of the Liberty Theatre! - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

Chowder was bland for me with a few chunks of crab but had a decent amount of bay shrimp, and clams. My friend loved the chowder though. Crab cakes were small and a bit too salty for me. Strawberry spicy margarita was good. Service was attentive and quick. Felt like I was in an old luxury restaurant so classy but not fully upscale modern like in the bigger cities. read more

Carruthers - Chowder and crab cakes - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

See all

Presentation and feel was nice.... Service was good too! Unfortunately, the meal was not done correctly. If you like eggs Benedict, go elsewhere. My friend had the steak and I guess he enjoyed that; however, I had a different experience with their smoked salmon eggs Benedict. Normally I go traditional but that would have been a let down too based on the lack of flavor from the hollandaise sauce and the eggs that were incorrectly cooked..... I've never had a messed up poached egg until today but it was terrible. They nuked the crap out of it.... Tasted like it was cooked in a microwave and the smoked salmon tasted like I was eating wood chips..... it was just an unfortunate meal on my trip out of town. Would I go here again? lol I'd go to where I first started that was packed. There was a reason.... And it's the same reason why this place had plenty of room.... Again, I think they're off to a good start with the service and setting but they need to find someone able to deliver eggs Benedict if they're going to make it a "go to" as it seems to take up 25% of their menu..... read more

Carruthers - Smoked salmon eggs Benedict - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

Great ambiance - you walk in and feel like you're stepping into the roaring 20's, complete with a full flapper outfit on display. The service was friendly and attentive without hovering. We came for lunch on a Sunday during off-season and both had salads - the housemate Caesar is delicious! Good cocktails and strong coffee. We will definitely come by for dinner sometime soon! read more

Stopped by hoping to have an enjoyable dinner. Was a bit confused by the ambience with the mannequins and multicolored up lighting. The staff were friendly and somewhat efficient. Decided to give the shrimp cocktail try...which was a big no. The shrimp was lukewarm and was served with a salsa, the two did not pair together well. Crab cakes were the only highlight of our meal, as our entrees were not much to write home about. Our food did not taste fresh. I hope that this restaurant in the future finds better way to prepare their food. Also extremely overpriced. read more

Finally tried Carruthers for breakfast and it did not disappoint. One of, if not THE best breakfast's we've had in Astoria in years! Service was outstanding and the food all tasted scratch made. The ambiance is upscale but prices are on par with most of the other breakfast spots in town. I had the Praire Starter and the wife had the Traditional Eggs Benedict and we would both order them again. Hopefully they keep serving breakfast because Astoria definitely needs more breakfast options. read more

See all

The all new Carruthers !! Joey provided exceptional service and drinks that exceeded our expectations. His focus on quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect of his business. We will definitely return to Joey at Carruthers for future special occasions. An incredible experience! read more

See all

Very poor food quality, service quality poor. Overall quality need to improve for me to come back

I have wanted to dine at this restaurant for years. Finally, we had the opportunity, but I am sad to report that it was somewhat of a let down. The ambiance and service were delightful. The food was not. We started with wine and a cocktail. Both were just fine. Where we messed up, was ordering food. For an appetizer, we ordered "stuffed mushrooms". While the mushrooms were warm, they were not stuffed, nor thoroughly cooked. Like so not cooked that the mushrooms were legitimately firm and crisp, and the parmesan sprinked on top did not melt. No sauce to dip the crusty darn things in either. I later realized, I've had these breaded mushrooms from somewhere before. Yes, they come in bulk from the US Chef store as frozen breaded, not stuffed mushrooms. As a meal, I ordered the crab. It was ok. The potatoes and coleslaw that came with the crab were not ok. The potatoes were so overcooked and dry that I chose to leave them in the bowl they came in. Next, we need to talk about the coleslaw. It was plain shredded cabbage. No dressing. Just a heap of raw shredded cabbage from a bag, dropped on a plate. I'd recommend just going in for drinks at their beautiful bar and lovely servers. Eat somewhere else until they sort out the kitchen. read more

Highly recommended for your Astoria trip. One of the nicer restaurants in town and has excellent brunch and dinner items. The service is always top notch and it never feels too busy here. read more

We were delighted to discover this downtown gem. The restaurant is classic, spacious and comfortable. The food was so fresh and delicious. We both had a Caesar salad - my husband had his with smoked salmon that was moist, slightly sweet and tender. He got the entree size and could barely finish it. I had the half size and a fantastic shrimp cocktail with a gazpacho-like sauce. Very good wine list too. We shared a bourbon chocolate cake that had a ganache , whipped cream filling and was so rich we took half of it home. Great service as well. Highly recommended. read more

Carruthers - Dessert decadence! - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

We are from the Seattle area and visit often - this is one of my favorite restaurants. Amazing cocktails - I love that they make bespoke cocktails when asked (try a lavender lemon drop!) and their cocktail and appetizer menu is wonderful. The food has always been delicious and we have tried most of the menu. Terrific service and love the vintage vibes. They also have a kids menu! read more

See all

It was my 31st birthday and my fiancé and I were ready to propose right after we ate dinner so it was very special. I love the old-school vibes. We got to sit right next to the window. We ordered for our appetizer; clams and they were really good in the garlic sauce. I could not stop eating it. I wish there was more although it is a bit pricey it's totally worth it. They weren't too busy since it was a Saturday afternoon. There was some sort of festival going on so it was hard to find parking, but that's typical in the city. They treated us super good. I highly recommend. read more

Carruthers - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

See all

Came in with my husband for our anniversary. Special occasion or not I didn't expect any special service or anything but there were barely any people in the whole place and we were completely ignored most of our visit. Never got a refill on my soda but my husband was offered another beer? I get it soda refills don't run up a tab but I am 8 months pregnant and a soda refill sounded great. The lobster and crab risotto was just bad. My husband liked his fish and chips but literally spit out his coleslaw, and I swear we are no food snobs. I wish I was warned about the food and service here as we would have loved to have had dinner somewhere else. read more

This restaurant is convenient for an early Sunday dinner. We have a great waiter who always waits on us. Service is very good. Drinks are improved. Food is good enough to bring us back every Sunday we are in town. In my opinion there has been considerable improvement. We will continue to have our Sunday dinner there. read more

The best ribeye I have ever had. Excellent customer service, fabulous advent garde ambiance and appropriate pricing. I visited Carruthers while on a road trip for my birthday with a friend. We looked on Yelp for dinner recommendations and found this place. Quiet on a weekday December night, we loved everything we had. The items we had were: 1. Crostini. 2. Ribeye - came with mashed potatoes; fresh cauliflower, carrots and bell pepper; and a to die for bourbon sauce. Best steak ever. 3. Moroccan curry - My friend didn't say a word as he inhaled this dish. Rice, chickpeas, raisins, celery, garlic, cilantro and lemon in a tasty coconut milk sauce. 4. Chocolate hazelnut cheesecake - With caramel sauce. Divine. Great service by our host/server. Clean bathroom. Gorgeous dining area. Definitely coming back when in town again. read more

See all

They must pick and choose the reviews that they publish on here. Two and a half years ago I left a scathing review that apparently they didn't like. I don't see it anymore. I'm not sure that it ever made it on here. Didn't go back for over 2 and a half years. We've always had a wonderful time at the bar but not with the waitress the ONE time we had a reservation in the dining room. We have been back to the bar since, a few months ago. Enjoyed it. Don't know if we can try the dining experience at a table again. It was humiliating. Never an apology. read more

Carruthers is located in an historic, high-ceiling building, which is definitely worth a visit. Our party of four stopped in for drinks and were impressed by the quality and creativity. Hands down the best cocktails I have ever had at a bar/restaurant. Excellent service and relaxing ambiance with great background music. We highly recommend. read more

Someone does not know how to pouch an egg. Bad food, poor chef. Does not know what good food is. Hollandaise sauce is butter, egg yoke and bit of lemon juice. How can you screw that up? No buttery taste, no lemon just very tasteless. Uggg stay clear. read more

I enjoyed a meal here after a six hour drive, with colleagues I have not seen in over two years. The atmosphere was inviting and warm, and this was a perfect place to start catching up after a long time of social distancing. I started with a plate of steamer clams, which were served in a larger bowl with three toasted slices of crostini, with a lemon wedge, in flavorful broth. The crostini was rather tough even after dipping in broth so next time I may ask for just the bread, sans toasting. The broth was delicious to the point where I made sure to finish some off with a spoon after the clams and crostini were gone. For entrée, I enjoyed the half Caesar salad with steak medallions and the beef was cooked to perfection, salad well seasoned, and even had three longer pieces of anchovies on it. The crème brûlée was the perfect dessert to finish off a meal here and the brûléed crust was so delightful to break. I was pleasantly surprised to see the small micro grains of actual vanilla line the dish below the vanilla custard, I can't remember last time I saw that. Wishing there was a garnish or something to make this staple's gentle flavor stand out more, like a spear of mint or Thai basil, or a berry. read more

See all

What a great lunch experience we had at Carruthers! We were on the road to Seattle to have our last meal while on vacation. We stumbled upon some great Yelp reviews and thought we would give it a try! I'm so glad we did and Thrilled they had room for us at the bar. Kaitlin was our hostess and bartender/sever extraordinaire! She made us feel right at home and guided us through the menu with excellent suggestions. We shared the Avocado Fried Rice with added shrimp and the Bistec Bruschetta and both were so delicious and flavorful. We even had a scrumptious creme brûlée desert which was a perfect ending to a great meal. Kudos to the chef and Kaitlin for a great meal to end our vacation! The food here is definitely next level. read more

See all

Terrible! Their soup of the day, French Onion, arrived cold and with no cheese. We sent it back. A minute later it arrived warmish. The cheese, I was told, was at the bottom of the bowl. It was nothing more than a few bits of shredded cheese that were attempting to clump together in what tasted like a beef bouillon broth. It was inedible. My pain course was a vegetarian pasta. It arrived kinda warm. Like the noodles and sauce had perhaps been introduced to flame for maybe 15 seconds. Its bowl remained cold, the cheese did not melt. Again, inedible. The place was not busy, so there was no excuse for the shoddy cooking. I will never go back. read more

Not realizing that very little places are open in Astoria over then holidays, we were glad to find Carruthers open for our Christmas Eve dinner. I'm vegan, but wife is not, so it's always great to find a place that has options for both of us. My wife had the Ribeye with garlic mash potatoes, roasted winter veggies and a butternut puree. She ordered the ribeye medium and when she received it, the steak was more mid-rare instead. She loved it though, even rarer than she prefers it was very good and had almost no unrendered fat. I ate the Chickpea Masala with Jasmine rice. I was surprised at how sweet the dish was, that's not my usual cup of tea. It was an amazing dish though! The chickpeas were perfectly cooked, slightly toothy but not mush. The flavors danced between mostly savory with some sweet notes that played on my tongue. The rice was a little dry for my preference but in all a worthy dish. For dessert my wife tried the peach creme brule that she adored and I had a vegan hazelnut cheesecake. The cheesecake was a little grainy, but that happens with cashew based cheeses so I wasn't complaining. This was a fantastic last date night before we moved out of the area! read more

See all

Not much was open round town because it was off season so we were excited to see their menu online included vegan options. Unfortunately the menu was old so there were no vegan options on the menu anymore but the server spoke with the chef and they created a vegan dish just for us. It was yummy and the drinks were amazing. Great service and a classic old school restaurant feel. read more

First off, the cooks were incredible. Our food was probably the best we had in Astoria. Our rating is for how we were treated. It was mine and my finance's anniversary, and after a long day of walking around in the sun (what a rare 80 degree day!) we settled on coming here for a small relaxed dinner because the food reviews were so great. Our wait staff experience was just off. The restaurant was empty, and we were immediately asked if we had a reservation. We were sat quickly, but the couple behind us was treated much nicer. The host gave them what he called "the best seat in the house!" immediately took their drink order and made their drinks, while we waited for around 10-15 minutes (there were 3 tables in the restaurant that were full) for anyone to come talk to us. The rest of the evening just felt off, and although our food was really great, our interactions made us feel uncomfortable and unwelcome, and it pretty much stole the evening. It's not fun to wonder if people are treating you different for how you look, or are dressed, or perceived age or income bracket-- but that's how it felt. We smiled, were polite, and didn't do anything we could think of to warrant such odd behaviors. For context, we're two regular 30 year olds with tattoos who were dressed casually. We were just hoping for a calm and delicious end to a really great day, and we're sorry we only got 50% of what we wanted here. read more

Dinner was so disappointing. Luke warm french onion soup with Costco Parm in bottom of bowl. Brussels sprouts good. Pasta, barely warm. Rib eye acceptible bit potatoes and veggies almost cold. The poor waitress couldnt handle our comments. Got a manager who was nice and discounted our tab but that wasnt our goal. They need the feed back to survive. We need them to survive. It was great 3 or more years ago. Such a sad disappointing birthday dinner. The restaurant itself is beautiful and clean. Has an elegant feel. Im so disappointed in our meal. The bartender, main guy tried to make it right. Thank you to him. We just went back to our hotel and pondered WTF? read more

Great service, good food and friendly people. The steak is very delicious and the salmon is very fresh. It read more

Carruthers - Bar area - New American Near Me - Astoria, Oregon

If you're visiting Carruthers and you see it's busy, I suggest you keep looking. While the ambiance and menu are both appealing, it seems the aim is greater than the execution. Our roasted Brussels sprouts dish was an intriguing blend of sweet and savory but was so disappointingly overcooked it could have been spread on toast. Similarly the beautiful cod filet was so heavily browned it was crunchy! Where crunch was desired and advertised, the "crispy skin" duck breast was instead gelatinous. All the flavors were nice but in every case the kitchen wasn't quite up to the task. Perhaps on a less busy night the quality control will be better. The wait staff were all pleasant but almost comically inefficient. Our mains were brought to the table while our empty appetizer dishes were still there waiting to be cleared. There were just too many times when a visit for clearing the table or refreshing drinks would have been welcomed. All in all it was a case of "close but no cigar". Your fortune might be better on a less busy night. read more

TOTALLY NEW FOLKS!!! After closing this summer I was so pleased to see it re-open...and can I just say...WOW WOW WOW! The food is exceptionally good! We ordered appetizers and I tried the mussels and what a wonderful surprise! EXCELLENT. Then we ordered the Shrimp Pasta...again a HUGE winner. It was smooth as silk, shrimp was cooked perfectly. I couldn't finish it and reheated it the next day (basically bc I couldn't wait to eat it again). We ordered the chocolate cake for dessert..again absolutely amazing. Hubby ordered the cheesecake which was just soo good! The restaurant appearance is changing as well. A throwback to the history of the building built back in 1923...just great fun, great service and great food!! Headed back this next weekend for more! read more