The pizza, especially "Grandma's", is always delicious!! The service is great, including the fabulous waitress, Marianne, & Wayne at the bar who pours a fantastic cold draft beer. We highly recommend bringing a big appetite & enjoying an awesome pizza at Carmelas!! read more

Website is Terrible can't change orders They don't answer their phones Tried different numbers Gong show They apologized they were closed ‼ website needs work read more

We're locals, and a few years ago this was our absolute favorite pizza. Then something changed and it just wasn't the same, so we stopped coming. I am *sooooo* thankful we decided to come back tonight and give it another try! We ordered our favorite--the Grandma pizza--along with an order of garlic knots, and everything was amazing. It's officially back to being our favorite pizza on the Treasure Coast! And trust me, we're pizza snobs, so that says a lot From the crust, to the cheese, to the sauce (the sauce is *the best*), it was all 5-star perfection! Thank you Carmelas! Xoxo P.s I should've taken photos when the food first came out, but we were so hungry we had to eat first. read more

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

Lunch today took a friend from church close by st Mary's . Service by Laura was excellent you can tell she is a happy people person and loves her job! Food always consistent fresh and hot . Wish I had room for desert! read more

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Recently ordered a pizza from here when I was in Stuart. It came out perfect and really enjoyed how it was made and all the ingredients were top shelf fresh. Would definitely order again from here. read more

just got a margarita pizza tonight. it was poor, no cheese, little tomato, too much crust. I used to rave about this pizza, not any more.

Great food! Great service from nice folks. Very comfortable experience with nice atmosphere.

Service was lackluster. we waited an hour for our dinner. There was no ambiance. They stuck us in a back room with no windows and weird paintings on the walls. The food was abysmal!!! They brought out our entrees with garlic rolls that were so burnt that they were black. I could have used them for hockey pucks. The fact that our waitress even brought them out was unreal. My husband's chicken marsala was doing the breast stroke with his side of broccoli it was so soupy! our leftovers went into the garbage. As soon as we got home. Not doing this restaurant again. Shame on them! read more

Everything was great ,food ,service atmosphere. We would definitely recommend and go back ..five stars if you ask me.,

Their Grandma Annabella pizza is wonderful. Delivery is only $7. Well worth it on a busy evening!

excellent food and top notch service great wine list and the best garlic rolls!! keeps us coming back!!! read more

I'm sure the safest bet is to just order pizza from here. Anything else may be a mistake. Not only did they get one of my orders wrong (gave me chicken parm hero when I asked for plain chicken cutlet) but there was actually hair from a pig left in my meal of pork osso bucco. My fault for ordering that at a pizza place I guess. For the price, I would have hoped they'd leave the hair out. Waste of money read more

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza - Pork Shank Osso Buco - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

Strange policy of only making a small personal cheese pie if you eat in. So I sat down and ordered it, but they brought me a regular size pizza pie anyway? I didn't make a big stink and still gave the waiter 25% tip, but it was annoying enough to write this review! read more

What a true Italian restaurant. Service and staff was absolutely superb! Food is absolutely delicious. You can't go wrong with anything on their menu. It's all amazingly delicious. Ambiance fits the menu. If we ever come back to Florida we will bring our family who lives here in Florida. read more

See all

Great spot. Staff is friendly but professional. Food is delicious. Atmosphere is perfect. See Wayne at the bar! Maryanne, Stevie, Pat, et. al. read more

It was my birthday dinner, and I'd been to the same old Italian restaurants in the area but wanted something new. Carmela's is not really new to me...but I kind of forgot about it. It's been probably 4 years since my last visit, but I used to go there all the time. The pizza is phenomenal...they are known widely for their Grandma pizza, which is a thin crust Sicilian pie...very large and extremely delicious. I had one with eggplant last night, and it was fantastic. I don't quite know what kind of mozzarella they use, but it sure beats any other pizza joint--it has a fresh and creamy taste that you just don't find elsewhere. The same can be said for the pasta dish I had (I know...just how much carb-loading can one person do--but it was my birthday!) I ordered the Shrimp Angelica, a great dish of rotini, artichokes, red peppers, mushrooms, and shrimp--all in a very light cream sauce. No heavy, gluey Alfredo sauce here, I don't know where they're getting their dairy products, but keep it up! The difference in taste is quite noticeable between the mozzarella on the pizza and the cream in the pasta sauce. Maybe there's a dairy cow out back, I don't know. What I do know is it's a great small place with an excellent menu. It fills up quickly, so either get there early or you might have to wait. Prices are very reasonable, and it's a warm atmosphere. The only reason for 4 stars, not 5, is that the rotini was a tad over cooked. Al dente works best in pasta dishes. Try it...you'll like it. read more

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza - Shrimp Angelica - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Closest to New York Pizza you're ever gonna have anywhere in Florida as far as I'm concerned. Garlic knots are outstanding, the atmosphere everything about it! read more

The food and service is good here. They have a wide range of pizza and other dishes that are tasty and well seasoned. A nice place for lunch or dinner. read more

Not a bad place to stop for some Italian themed entrees and pizza. My wife and I enjoyed the dining room, it was pleasant and comfortable. Ordered a sausage and peppers hero and a grandma pizza. All in all it tasted fine. One thing you need to understand when you go here, younger folks are your servers. Very younger folks, not that it's a bad thing, it is a bit different but I cannot say they hadn't done a good job! read more

Service was amazing, you were in and out quickly. It wasn't too loud inside, but I don't recommend the lasagna, it tasted bland.

Quite mediocre. Consider saving some money and going to papa johns, or literally anywhere else. Chicken parm tasted microwaved. Grannies pizza was definitely not made by a grannie who cares. read more

The food was very good and the service was excellent. The 4% charge for using a credit card was a bit excessive compared to other places in Stuart that charge 3%. Look around because there are still many places that do not charge their customers for using a debit or credit card. We were not told of the fee up front. The booths were very small. read more

Florida has no shortage of bad pizza and this place is one. Service was good is all I can say. It's not worth the calories.

Absolutely love this place. The only reason I did not give it five stars is it's very dark. We are older people and it's hard to see. We had a pizza and an antipasto. Both were excellent a beer and a glass of Pinot Grigio accompanied our meal. We sat at a hightop. The weight staff were attentive, and the price was reasonable. read more

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza - This is the antipasto we had - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

I love Carmela's! Sometimes the chicken pizza tastes a little dry but I love the overall taste. My last two orders have been a large pizza half chicken half pepperoni. I love the taste of the cheese and that it always tastes fresh. It can get pricey though. But the ordering process has always been simple for me, just calling and then picking up and always in a timely manner. The garlic knots are a nice touch. Very filling! read more

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza - Large pizza half chicken half pepperoni and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Always a great experience with Wayne! Mussel meal can't be beat Of course there is the Grandmother's pizza read more

So this review is only for a takeout pizza but oh my gosh was that take out pizza incredible!! Whenever we're in my boyfriend's hometown, we usually try to go to places he remembers loving as a kid and we finally got around to a pizza night! He mentioned Carmela's first but we didn't pull up that menu at first because he was worried things were going to be really expensive. After all other near by places were over priced or had bad reviews we finally dug into the Carmela's menu and WOW! Such reasonable prices for huge pizzas! We were sold! We ordered a Neapolitan Pizza with Italian sausage on one half, and four garlic knots! The pizza was $13 and an additional $1.25 for the sausage and the knots were only 25¢ each! We placed our order online and it said the food would be ready in 40 minutes. We arrived to Carmela's around 8:15 and were a little surprised at how empty the place was. Our food was ready and we asked for some Parmesan and crush red pepper to go. The staff was super quick to help us get what we needed! Everyone thanked us for our order and they were all so kind. Again WOW this pizza was so so good. Huge slices, lots of toppings, the sauce was tangy and sweet at the same time, the crust was cooked perfectly, even the bottom of the pizza was nice and crispy! But those knots *insert drooling emoji here* SO GOOD! If I could go back in time I would've paid another $1.25 for sausage on both sides to the pie and I would've ordered 10 more knots, not even joking! If you're looking for a great pizza that's reasonably priced, this is your place! I will definitely be trying to Grandma Pizza next time! Keep up the great flavors Carmela's! read more

See all

Best pizza in Stuart. Always good I ordered for a birthday party and it was easy and the food was perfect

I'm originally from New York this is some of the best pizza in south Florida in the treasure coast area

The pizza was great. The service was great. Our party had a good experience at this restaurant would definitely go back.

We had dinner here the other night. Our salads were nicely sized and fresh. The pizza was delicious. Our waitress was amazing and the rest of the staff stopped by to make sure we were taken care of. The dining area was small but there was plenty of room for the tables and booths they had. We will be back. read more

Toppings we chose for our pizza were pepperoni, bell pepper, onion and goat cheese. This thing was huge too. The service is exceptional here too. read more

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza - Sicilian pizza, it maybe the best I've ever eaten. - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Carmela's has the best pizza I've ever had outside of Naples Italy. True, thin crusted NY style pizza with a fresh tasting sauce and just the right amount of pizza and toppings. We started our meal with the chicken wings which are delicious and crispy. Our pizza was the Neapolitan style and too big for the two of us to finish. The beer was nice and cold. It was a very simple, unplanned meal out but we are glad we went. I have found my go to for pizza when in Stuart. read more

Carmela's was a good restaurant a few years ago, but boy how the food has gone downhill. The service was terrible and the food was just as bad. I will not be dining there again. read more

Long time local eatery, brings NY Italian cooking. Pizza and meals are great. Also has a wine bar where you can eat in addition to dining room. read more

Great spot! Picked up on our way in from Orlando! White pizza was awesome, and got 2 others! Fantastic and delicious! Thanks

Ordered the Grandma pizza tonight which has been our go-to for the past year however it was SO SALTY tonight. We couldn't even eat it. Very disappointing as we've always enjoyed this pizza. Maybe new pizza cook ? read more

One word- AMAZING everything we tried was on point Meatball appetizer Caesar salad with fried calamari Osso bucco Beer And expresso!!! My new fave Italian place!!!! Loved siting by the bar and the Italian music playing in the background. I felt like I was having dinner In Epcots Italy ! read more

Great pizza an a little story behind this lovely restaurant; Me and my sister in law would go here every Tuesday for a sister day have our pizza and a couple glasses of wine. We would talk for hours love this place read more

Great food and a cozy wine bar. Perfect spot for a relaxing meal, with live music on some nights.