Just check your pizza before you leave the restaurant. I really love this place, the pizza is delicious, but they make our order wrong almost every single time we place an order. We get a large pizza with 3 toppings: pep, sausage, mozzarella, and every time it is missing a meat. We repeat the order and make sure they say it back...It's happened the last 4 times in a row and several times before that. We are going to take a break from Anna's JB read more

First time visitors went on recommendation of friends. We purchased 'theworks' pizza and were modestly satisfied. Below average amount of toppings and DRY amount of sauce. The dough was great but overall the pizza left us wanting. We may try again but, for now, the search for amazing pizza continues! read more

How have I never left a review for my dear ANNAS PIZZA?! Notice how any of the bad reviews have nothing to do with the actual pizza what you see is what you get and I like it... pizza that's good affordable and yes, you have to pay cash for it- cool, SOLD! Try the little cinnamon buns. They run out a lot, but they are great. Will return again and again for Cache only pizza in a restaurant that doesn't have a/c in the summer. This is a realllll pizza joint! Try the take home dinners if u want to skip cooking dinner! read more

Anna's hits the spot! When we went, there were 8-10 different pizzas you could order by the slice. But I'd recommend branching out to the stromboli! Different filling options, and boy will it fill you up. The staff is super friendly and makes you feel at home. read more

See all

Great pizza and sandwiches Not a fancy Italian place, but perfect for a quick bite at lunch or take home dinner to the favorite place read more

Hands down the absolute best pizza, sauce, meatballs and entrees as far as Italian food goes in Jensen beach and Stuart. Cannot recommend enough. Might be hard to get through on the phone to put in your order but keep trying, or just go in to see the iconic Anna manning her station in the kitchen. read more

Ordered take-out. It was ready on time, friendly atmosphere. MCSOs stopped in and were friendly with staff. I take that as a good sign. Large pepperoni only $22 and it's big for a large. Crust and cheese were good, could've used a bit more sauce. I might order extra sauce and well done next time but it was not undercooked by any means. Cash only, I will order from here again. read more

Beat chicken parm around! Everything is always delicious, had the family meal with chicken parm and thin spaghetti with sauce. I also picked up a fruit pastry that was next to the register that was AMAZING! read more

Hands down best pizza on treasure coast!! Authentic, Italian family owned for years. "Real" cheese, not processed, sauce is delicious, crust is not too thick and not too thin. Toppings are always super fresh! read more

Seriously what business in todays day and age still doesn't accept debit/ credit cards???? They dont even have an ATM inside. Makes u wonder.... Are they trying to cheat on paying taxes read more

I've driven by Anna's Pizza for many years but didn't try it till now. SCW and I stopped in for some slices to go. Of note during Covid "masks required" on the door as well as "cash only". One was adhered to by staff, one was not. Obviously "cash only" was more important. Ok fine. The employees regardless of the mask issue were pleasantish. No real menu, stacks of pizza with handwritten prices for some based on the number of ingredients. But you really don't know what the price is of anything you buy. We got slices of cheese and margarita pizza. Both huge, warmed in the oven and put in a box. You can add spices and such pictured. Great pizza smells in the car home. Looked forward to the pizza. Tried the cheese first after de greasing. Meh, compared to most I've had quite average. Sauce was the highlight. Nothing special there. We didn't eat both slices. The margarita pizza slices were odd. Basically a cheese pizza with tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella seemingly placed on top afterwards. Mozzarella was rubbery, basil was good. Literally a cheese pizza with the tomato and mozzarella with basil as an addition. Quite odd. I don't like giving bad reviews, much less to a local place. But I guess there's a reason I've not stopped here for years before. The employees are great. The pizza not my thing. read more

Original Anna's Pizza - a counter with spices and condiments - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Excellent pizza! Great crust on Sicilian and regular. Pleasant worker's. Pricing were really inexpensive for slice, soda and garlic knot special. $8.00 Will definitely be coming back read more

Something has changed with the pizza. Premade dough? Not as good as it once was. Sad.

Even now, years later, nothing's changed (thank God). Same old sign out front, same checkered tablecloths, and somehow--miraculously--the same exact taste. It hits you like a time machine with every bite. If you grew up around here, you know this place isn't just a pizza joint--it's part of your DNA. read more

I love Annas pizza. The portions are huge. The pizza is delicious here! The sauce is great, and this location certainly does it best. I've noticed a trend in the reviews that those who order seem to have a less positive experience than those who go in person and eat inside. I have always gotten it and eaten it there, so I've never really seen whether their delivery is as good as just going in person. Obviously, pizza is going to be better freshly heated up, anyhow! I've been eating here for years and will always love to come back for a slice. For best results, show up and order inside instead of getting it delivered read more

Food was delicious , fresh and very enjoyable. Service was excellent. Every one was very helpful and answered all my questions.

Very good quality Italian food well prepared. Pizza is also very good with a lot of choices.

Food is has great flavor !!! And huge portions Don't sleep on this place my new spot !!! read more

Amazing traditional pizza. Cash only but "Wow" worth it! Haven't had anything like this since I was in NYC. A real treat and Anna is a blast. read more

Original Anna's Pizza - Personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Loved it. Delicious food and incredibly nice and professional staff. You can tell they take pride in their food. Also they passed the unwritten rule of the pizza business. Cash Only = The Real Deal. read more

100years agoANNA and family came here from Long Island and has cooked the same since when she came she made a new rep I get food from at least once a wk fantastic I have my fav but try everything till u find yours u will never be unhappy and she gives u plenty call your friendsbut not to many I hope God is good and she's here for another 100 yrs I ate her place on LONG ISLAND back when read more

This has now surprised me 2x! The square pizza with fresh mozzarella and extra basil is amazing! I think it's called Grandma's Pizza. Slightly spiced and the crust is wonderful! Then I tried the angel hair with chicken Marsala otherwise know has Julianna something. I don't use this expression very often, but OMG. Don't pass this one up!! And, you can't leave a review without a strong shoutout to the amazing and vivacious woman who runs the front. Truly adds to the experience! Thank you! read more

Best pizza around, just as good as New Jersey and New York, maybe better. Lovely sraff

I crave Anna's Pizza every time I make the trip back to my hometown. The slices are behemoth in size and flavor. It's one of the most authentic slices of pizza you'll ever have in your life. ***Pro Tip: Order the Grandma and/or the Sicilian*** The inside houses two tables and a few seats at a cramped counter. Expect to order take out. Also, it's worth noting that it's kept uncomfortably warm inside. It's Florida, splurge on the A/C. I'm going to save the final star (for now) for customer service. Often times, I've struggled with the accuracy of my order. Besides that, expect to unzip those jeans because you'll be stuffed after an Anna's slice. Look out for specials during the week, too. Until next time! read more

Original Anna's Pizza - Delicious Grandma slices - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

Great food, some of the best in the area! Staff is great, friendly. CASH ONLY I haven't even tried some of the other items b/c the pizza is that good! read more

Food is Amazing, Pizza Beal Parm it's a very nice place for takeout and some sitting if you eat there. Family Run & Mom is always there over seeing the cooking. I highly Recommend you visit this place read more

I am from NY I discovered this place in 2020 after my brother-in-law who lives near Anna's told me about the place I was amazed with the melt in your mouth Chicken Parm and the Eggplant. The marinara is sweet and delicious the zepolles to die for Garlic knots huge! read more

How do you run a business on cash only something fishy going on here and $12 for 2 single slices of pizza thats gotta be a joke

I travel to Jensen Beach for business and a friend highly recommended anything Italian from this quaint little place. This is my 4th time ordering pick up from the Original Anna's Pizza. The Fried Eggplant, Onions and Mushrooms is my favorite pizza and Anna's did not disappoint. The red sauce is excellent, both on the pizza and with the side of meatballs. Bring Cash. They don't accept credit cards. read more

The pizza was delicious but there was METAL in it! And no, it was not foil. The metal was very hard and sharp! I'm not sure how this could have possibly happened but thank GOD it wasn't swallowed. Very disappointing. read more

Original Anna's Pizza - Sharp metal in the pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

I have been a long time customer of this establishment and I feel besides Anna's stellar food she has employees like Alex who is friendly has a smile on his face and makes you feel appreciated. Tonight I accidentally ordered from the palm city location when I went in here this lady was yelling an order to the staff and turned to another customer and said "I don't know if she is stupid or deaf" to belittle your coworkers while other customers are in the store to make yourself feel empowered is toxic. And honestly I don't think someone that is spending their Golden years working as a counter person at a rinky dink pizza shop has the right to call anyone stupid! This is not the first time I have been in their when she is there the last time she was talking crap about customers as they walked out the door. She needs to take it down a notch! But for now I picked up in palm city and the young lady was friendly the food was exemplary and they take credit cards . What's a 15 minute drive read more

Man what happened? I went with a friend.. Two different friends two different times within the past few months. I'm not sure why both times I had to ask for cleaning supplies to clean the grease of the tables. One time the food was good..yea.. The pizza. Can't go wrong. The next time the baked ziti that wasn't baked enough. It was SOUPziti. I couldn't continue trying to act like I'm liking it so I talked to them.. Showed them and they replaced the meal. NOT very happily tho. I didn't do it!! read more

This place is a little hole in the wall that makes some of the best pizza around. Bring cash only!

Fabulous! Great takeout Italian:) When you walk in and everyone in the kitchen are speaking Italian you know it will be great! And it is .... read more

Very good pizza! The pizzas are large, their pieces huge. Also liked the garlic knots.

Anna's is a staple in our family. We have never had a bad experience. My husband has an addiction to her pizza, eggplant stacks, and zucchini stacks. Now all of my children have the same addiction and have to eat Anna's food whenever they are in town. We just love the food there, including the chicken parm, eggplant rollatini, and Strombolis. read more

Good little spot where you can pick up a slice (2 large Costco size pizza slices) for five bucks. They have the pizza already cooked and then just reheat in the oven (a few min) and it tastes great. You can also buy calzone type food and whole pizzas. The meat lovers pizza slice was good read more

Anna has been in this area for years. Prices are reasonable, the food is delicious, authentic, Italian. They also have great cannoli. These are some of the best pies in Jensen read more

Anna's Pizza has the best pizza I have ever tasted. The environment is friendly and family oriented. The prices are beyond reasonable and the service is great. read more

I have been coming to Anna's in Jensen Beach for years. This place has the best pizza in the Stuart area. I felt inclined to post a review after trying a nearby New Haven style pizza place. That place had so many 5 star reviews we had to try it. We were so disappointed with it, so I looked up Anna's and I couldn't believe there weren't hundreds of 5 star reviews. If you know good NY style pizza then you will not be disappointed here. Very similar to your quintessential NY pizzeria, they have multiple style pies and you can choose a slice from any of them. Or order an entire pie of whatever you want. They always have zeppole's available and their white pie is made exactly as it should, ricotta, mozzarella and garlic. Seems like some of the negative reviews have to do with their cash only policy and small dining area (two booths and a couple of stools at a counter). There is a location in Palm City but the food is not as good (but still better than the New Haven style place). However Palm City accepts credit cards and has better seating availability. Perfect scenario would be for Anna and her kitchen crew to come to Palm City and teach/retrain the Palm City crew. read more