Captree Gourmet Deli

They had fresh turkey and other daily specials. The rye bread super fresh. They make their own…read morehoney mustard which was delicious. Very nice man at counter. I will try again. Normally priced deli sandwich.

Decent deli, a 3 1/2 to 4 star, a good place for an egg sandwich or decent and respectable deli…read moresandwich. I had turkey sandwich with L&T on wheat bread. Portion was quite large and reasonable priced. Sandwich comes with a small mac, potato, or cole slaw. Counter people were professional and friendly. I will come back and i will recommend. Just keep in mind this is a good solid standard reasonably priced deli sandwich. This is not an over the top, high priced sandwich spot with named speciality sandwiches coating $15 and more. My large sized sandwich with salad and gatoade was $12 out the door. Thats hard to beat today.

Rotti chicken..it was good.

Smells good in here...

See all

Gemelli Fine Foods

3.8(79 reviews)

1.4 mi

Gemelli Market on Main Street in Babylon NY has a variety of things including ground chicken and…read moreturkey for sale. They also to my surprise, sell Beef Tallow and item to check out if you have not used. There are a small variety of packaged breads and a few bread rolls located near the register. The sweet young lady behind the counter was helpful. As I'd had an appointment in the area, on a somewhat warm day and she kept the meat in the fridge until I got back. I made a meatloaf with the meats and it was delicious. A place to stop by when in the area.

Gemelli the Restaurant which is down the block is slated to become a Whisky Down location in Fall…read more2026. Could Gemelli the store be packing their bags too? The store has no life inside, it's depressing. The shelves have minimal products which are overpriced. The grab and go dinners only had 2 choices available, so sad. Store made frozen pasta is available. Fresh meat is available, looked good but expensive. Salted cod was $21 a pound, why? There's a full array of salads in the front showcase which showed some promise but too expensive. No other customers in the store and it was lunch time. The quiche we bought had plenty of cheese and tasted good heated up despite the bottom crust being underbaked. I think that Uncle Giuseppe's sucked away business from Gemelli which used to be the only high end Italian market around.

Front case January 2026

Pork chop

See all

Summerwind Deli

3.9(59 reviews)

1.0 mi

I was in the area two weeks back.. had a window of time and needed to eat. Slipped into this place…read moreas we were driving by.... 4 adults / 4 kids... I was hoping to feed these kids quickly before their hunger turned into madness This place was absolutely killer! Awesome staff that ran us through the menu pointing out what was popular and then made the best sandwiches. Super stoked and super fresh and tasty!! If i lived in the area this would be a regular spot.. And they have these little crumble cookies by the register that are just insane.. dont get a bag, get several.

This place is amazing!! I was in town on business, and came across this special place. I got the…read morebullet chicken based off a recommendation from a local guy in line and an Italian Hero to go and bring back home. I asked if they could pack the Italian hero for a flight home and they gladly accommodated. This place is amazing, definitely on my list of if I ever come back!!

Roast Beef Sandwich

Roll cut by ray charles

See all

North Babylon Deli

3.1(35 reviews)

1.5 mi

I've been buying my heroes from the shop for over 40 years. My favorite is the Dagwood. Which most…read morepeople miss read and call the Dogwood. I love it with Island dressing. They put plenty of meat on it and the lettuce is nicely shredded and tomato nice and thin, but still a lot of it so you get that flavor. My favorite is how soft the bread is. I've had lots of great salads from here. I love their coleslaw. But my fave is their German potato salad. And the potato salad was good just a little bit more mayo than I'm used to. I feel their pricing is really good and the value is great. The owner John does lots for the community and I appreciate that their times when I dream about my favorite hero and can't wait to have another

Bacon egg tomato on a roll is my go to! Comes with an option of tea or juice. I go for the tea as…read morethey have plenty of options. I haven't tried anything else, but I have overheard lots of people ordering extensive breakfast items consistently so eventually I'll venture out.

See all

Breakfast menu

Golden Orange Deli

4.2(14 reviews)

1.3 mi

Great service Friendly staff…read more Delicious food They pack their trays, they're not cheap!

Great people working behind the counter. A family owned place. It's a deli, a few grocery shelves,…read morea BEC spot, a steam table for lunch and dinner with typical Latin and Caribbean dishes or even a grilled cheese sandwich. Steamed table food is good but you need to be careful with your selections some food look like yesterday's food reheated. Menu changes based on the day of the week. Portions are generous. Prices are fair but there are no postings stating the price or the menu.

Yucca and plaintain

Rice with black beans

See all

Ribs and tamale

Jessen's Delicatessen

3.7(102 reviews)

2.3 mi

We have always found the sandwiches here to be of good quality . The macaroni salad, cole slaw…read moreand potato salad are very flavorful and taste homemade . The Italian catering sandwich was filled with plenty of cold cuts. Minus One star for the woman answering the phone for catering , impossible to deal with . Someone needs to tell her yes , they will make a hero without tomatoes .

This is a very good deli with some nice people working behind the counter that makes some delicious…read moresandwiches,hot food and salads but my favorite is their homemade carrot cake, absolutely the best around and I also had their split pea soup that was hot and savory.so if you're in the area give them a try I don't think you will be disappointed.

Inside 9-25-2026

See all

Inside 9-25-2026

The Delica Sea

4.0(20 reviews)

1.8 mi

New favorite spot! Service is great with attention to detail. I ordered a bagel with ham and cheese…read more(no egg) & was asked if I wanted it like a breakfast sandy or lunch sandwich-I really appreciated. Classic BEC. Nice hot coffee. A place to sit and enjoy or easy for take-out.

I went in there for a hot dog and wow so tasty. taco Tuesday ain't too bad either…read more Perfect breakfast also u should stop over there

Valentines day brunch board

See all

Grandpa J's Bagel and Deli

3.8(33 reviews)

2.3 mi

I had it for the first time this past weekend and it was so good. I usually to go Jessen's but this…read moreone is better. It was about 8-9 when my husband and I got there and it was decently busy. The staff was nice and on top of everything. It's a small place but definitely, but they have a few tables so you can sit on the inside. We both got everything bagels but I got mine with halva cream cheese and my husband got his toasted with plain cream cheese. I got a hungry man, which was so good. The bread was so soft. My husband got an egg sandwich on a roll. His looked good as well. For two sandwiches, bagels with cream cheese, and two drinks it came out to about $33. I will definitely be coming back here to get more food.

If I could give it more than five stars I would! Everything…read moreabout this deli is great. Great food, great service, it's clean and everyone is so friendly. Their bagels are soft and fresh, egg sandwiches are perfect and they have great combos. The potato and chicken salads are both next level and I highly recommend.

J's # 2 Box... Yummy!

See all

Small coffee

Southdown Marketplace

3.5(16 reviews)

1.0 mi

This store is great for comparison shopping--especially when it comes to specialty items I…read moreregularly buy. The shaved Parmesan cheese (the only kind I buy) is significantly cheaper here. For example, a 7 oz. bag of Satori Shaved Parmesan costs just $4.99, compared to $6.99 at Stop & Shop and $6.59 at Target. Their fresh, uncooked chicken burgers are a great value too. I paid $6.79 for two generously sized patties made with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, cilantro, and salt. Their seasoned, uncooked chicken cutlets are also competitively priced and great for quick meals. Even the individual Kaiser rolls are a deal--just $0.50 each, compared to around $1.00 elsewhere. (Note: they're not baked in-house.) If you're looking to stretch your grocery budget without sacrificing quality, this place is definitely worth a stop!

Loved it when it first opened.....mold issue with raviolis....prepared wraps very heavily salted…read more Will not buy again

I wanted everything! 8-17-2025

See all

Sandwich

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tori L.

10 years ago

People do not go to Captree deli the older woman with sour look on her face wearing clothes meant for a thin 18 yr old is a sloppy saggy mess with A dirty mouth. Id advise you don't get food from someone/place that has no respect for you or the food you have to put in YOUR mouth. Lets all band together to get this woman trashed out just like her mouth and food. I brought the food back because it was burnt and thrown together with carelessness and when I asked her for my money back she said that the sandwich was fine. Meanwhile the sandwich was missing the lettuce, the tomatoes were falling out some were squished, the meat was burnt and the bread was Burnt, also crumbling pieces that turned into soggy bits of crap. The paper that wrapped it was wet and re wrapped in a sec sheet folded up like a paper bag not like a sandwich. It was sloppy. would you guys eat it? No I don't think so. so do me a favor folks instead of getting reamed out by a nasty New York deli WORKER/owner, whatever, who lacks proper customer service and food handling skills let's not go to Captree deli west islip and waste nine dollars on a sandwich that isn't even edible with an eye sore and nasty attitude behind the counter. read more

Junior R.

29 days ago

'Wandered into Captree Gourmet Deli after striking out next door, and wow, I'm glad I did. I ordered the Hungry Man and it was the closest thing to a perfect sandwich I've had. Prices are in line with the area, but here I felt like I actually got what I paid for. Compared to other spots where the quality's slipped or the order's off, Captree just delivers: solid service, excellent sandwich, new go-to spot.' read more

Joe B.

12 years ago

Wide variety of unique sandwiches and heros. Very friendly staff. I've had party heros catered more then once. Heros are delicious, guests and I are never disappointed! read more

Lynn M.

8 years ago

Best salads around. Excellent deli for catering orders. I cater all of my parties from this deli. Food is always on time and delicious.

Captree Gourmet Deli - delis - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Captree Gourmet Deli also viewed

Seaqua Delicatessen and Caterers

3.2

(71 reviews)

Good food and salads here. Chopped salads have a lot of variety of add ons and were fresh and…read moredelicious every time I've ordered them

Their breakfast sandwiches are terrific but I ordered lunch and two sandwiches were 38 dollars and…read morenot good. Roast beef was tough, dry and overcooked. Portions were very small and the rolls were stale. Salads are delicious and fresh. Totally disappointing overall

Leggios Deli

4.3

(79 reviews)

Well, the first thing you want to say is good morning! There…read morewas a very pleasant breakfast Experience Always with a smile I'm lucky I took a picture this time. It's exactly how I wanted it..

If you've lived in the area, you know that we've always gone to Leggios…read more Been going for over 50 years. New owners, who have cleaned up the front of the store but maintained the integrity of the famous Italian hot or sweet classic sub , right down to the same wonderful bread.

Babylon Village Delicatessen

3.6

(14 reviews)

First Class Bagels

3.1

(133 reviews)

These bagels are always delicious and fresh !! Yes they're big but very tasty and worthy of…read morewhatever your topping is going to be ! The people are always nice and caring to customers and the line moves fairly quickly unless a dodo gets up there and really doesn't know wth they want !!! Wish there was steerage line for those who want a million things on their sandwiches etc and coffee bc sometimes u just wanna run in and grab dozen but there's a wait bc they're making orders for dine in . Pastries on point as well delicious turnovers and danish !!!! It's. Go to every weekend for sure and they freeze really well !!!

My absolute favorite bagel spot on Long Island! They have the best bacon egg and cheese's and I'm…read moreobsessed with their French toast bagel with the chocolate cream cheese! So yummy

Exit 42

3.3

(41 reviews)

My food was absolutely delicious! My friend recommended this place to me, and I finally came. They…read moregave me a HUGE portion, which I couldnt finish (and I normally do). I was very pleased with my food. They did take a little longer than expected to make my food. It looked like only two people were working in the kitchen. So, next time I'll definitely order ahead of time. They do have a few seating tables that you can have a quick bite at. This place is huge, on the other side it has a deli section. I can't wait to try everything. All the food that I received (in the photo) was only $7.00! Definitely try this place! They do take card as well.

Whenever we're in town this is where we usually stop for breakfast and sandwiches. This spot has…read moreturkey bacon & Beef bacon. Food always on point. Large selection of sandwiches Hot or Cold. This is a take out place.

Northside Delicatessen & Gourmet Catering

3.3

(68 reviews)

Food is always spot on! I've been coming here for years and the service has never disappointed…read more . Can't wait for the next time in in the area to stop in!

A deli that calls this an Italian sandwich? Come on! Barely any meats, 1 slice of cheese and bread…read morethat feels like it's been sitting. So disappointed with the sandwich. My wife also got a hero and it was the vegetarian hero which barely came with anything as well. I know which deli not to go to in the future. Be warned

Larkfield Plaza Delicatessen

4.3

(16 reviews)

Very friendly staff, the egg sandwiches we got where very good, everything cooked perfectread more

Just a really solid LI deli! Exceptional BEC sandwiches as well as lunch sandwiches. Rolls and…read moredeli meats are always fresh. Great family that owns and operates.

The Millennium Diner

3.1

(174 reviews)

Best Burger I ever had in my life. I knew after first bite!…read moreI've had a lot of burgers in my life. I'm 72 now and hands down that was the best.

The diner is spotless, and very nice inside, clean and well decorated…read more I had a delicious bacon, lettuce and tomato club with excellent potato salad (some of the best I have had in a very long time. Lisa had the Greek Chicken soup and loved it. We splurged and had a wonderful blueberry cobler. The service was excellent and the host very friendly.

Lake Ave Deli

3.1

(33 reviews)