Bacon egg tomato on a roll is my go to! Comes with an option of tea or juice. I go for the tea as they have plenty of options. I haven't tried anything else, but I have overheard lots of people ordering extensive breakfast items consistently so eventually I'll venture out. read more

See all

Great ! New owners doing an awesome job ! Place is very clean . Food is amazing lots of selection.

I've been buying my heroes from the shop for over 40 years. My favorite is the Dagwood. Which most people miss read and call the Dogwood. I love it with Island dressing. They put plenty of meat on it and the lettuce is nicely shredded and tomato nice and thin, but still a lot of it so you get that flavor. My favorite is how soft the bread is. I've had lots of great salads from here. I love their coleslaw. But my fave is their German potato salad. And the potato salad was good just a little bit more mayo than I'm used to. I feel their pricing is really good and the value is great. The owner John does lots for the community and I appreciate that their times when I dream about my favorite hero and can't wait to have another read more

New owners turned this place around. Food is great! Excellent sandwiches and now they have fresh smoothies!

Just ran up to get a 1/2 pd of ham,could not believe they didn't sell bread or hot dog or hamburger rolls.What's that all about????

I will never go back to NB Deli again. Today was the last time. I ordered 2 egg sandwiches both w/ over easy eggs. The eggs were cooked well done the sausage had a weird flavor. The roll and the bagel were both stale 1 or 2 days old, and the OJ that you get with the sandwich was disguising like it was sour. This place really went down hill. Stay away! read more

I love this deli...everything from the coolers to the beverage dispensers!The staff is super helpful and attentive.I am always beyond pleased with their Boars Head cold cuts and freshly made salads.This morning I purchased a ham/egg/cheese,it was made exactly as ordered(I do not eat eggs,lol my Sweetheart does daily!) a roast beef provolone lettuce tomato oregano thin sliced onion on a roll(rb was super rare just like I wished) and a small cuke salad!Stop in get a bite to eat and deff say hi to VERONICA she is #1!!! read more

North Babylon Deli - Exactly as ordered,roast beef super rare..oregano...oil and vinegar...provolone..tomato(vine ripe look!!) THANK Veronica!!!] - Delis Near Me - North Babylon, New York

good sandwiches comes w OJ .... a bit over priced They're so busy, call/ text ahead !! Sometimes they load it up & sometimes it feels super thin read more

See all

Food and service excellentpresentation was beautiful. and sandwiches Salads are delicious read more

So I had a very weird experience here. Well a weird experience for a deli that serves egg sandwiches and it goes against every practice of every deli I've ever went to. I ordered an egg and cheese on a roll and when they rang me up they charged me for a sandwich that was eggs, cheese and MEAT.... I asked the guy behind the counter "you guys charge people for meat even if they don't get it?" His response to me was "Yea would you like for me to put the meat on?"......... What deli doesn't have an option for an Egg and cheese without meat as a menu option? read more

Amazing turkey BLTs and great service! Everyone is super nice and my order was filled quickly! I drive a little farther to go to this deli because their prices are lower than the ones near me and for the awesome people that work here! They also have a good drink selection :) read more

Great Italian Hero and the BEST potato salad ever!!!! I've never had to wait. Definitely my go to.

The service has been horrible. The counter service is needs help. I will not be going back. There's Wally's bagels and uncle Giuseppe's. Get it together. The red haired girl at counter don't need to hear about your boyfriend. No one cares read more

If you like run down establishments, mediocre food, high prices, and terrible service, visit North Babylon Deli.

I often pick up an egg sandwich or a few when I feel like it. It's an egg cheese bacon/sausage on a roll for like $4.75. Comes with a small OJ, which I recommend. Only ever ordered anything else once and there was a commotion apparently going on. One sandwich was perfect, one was not right. Averaged out to being good. Will give another change in the future. It's a good, Long Island deli. If you want something from one of them and are around there, give it a shot. read more

One star is for convenience. In two years I've yet to get the correct egg sandwich. Not once. I'm not ordering a crazy sandwich - scrambled, cheese, well done bacon, s/p ketchup. That shouldn't be too much to ask, should it? We get fried in stead of scrambled every single time, limp bacon (every time) and rarely get s/p/k. Prices are a bit higher, but supporting community commerce is important. I only wish the owners and staff understood the need to cater to the community that supports them - care enough to get a sandwich right, people! The specialty sandwiches are very inconsistent - what you get and how it tastes depends on who makes it, so counter staff isn't trained on the "signature" sandwiches Disappointing they don't care more about the community that supports them. read more

Expensive, amateur food. There is one lady that licks her fingers before writing down your order, then proceeds to grab a glove and make your sandwich. Nice and hygienic. They should make her their in house expert, specializing in beef tongue. This way the lick is appropriate and the saliva is part of the " secret sauce "... No stars. read more

I wish I could give -stars for this review Working in the neighborhood and visited this deli bought a hot plate of turkey mashed potatoes and vegetables. The portion of turkey was about the size of a kids meal and got about 2 tablespoons of mashed potatoes and vegetables. The turkey was dry , Like cardboard dry they put absolutely no gravy on it . The mashed potatoes were the only good part . Them when we were leaving the employee didn't give me a fork or knife . 3 sandwiches and one plate with turkey just under $40 id say a bit overpriced for mediocre at best food read more

The best deli!!! Love the sandwiches, the best potato ,macaroni salad. Can't forget the amazing German potato salad!!! Hope this place will always be there read more

We have been going to this deli for over 20 years for sandwiches. Recently, I ordered a sandwich and when we got to the beach, realized that they had given us the wrong sandwich. Unfortunately it had mayo on it so neither myself or my husband could eat it! I returned the next day and explained the mix-up, fully expecting that the sandwich I was ordering would be on the house, since the birds ate the last one. I was simply told "sorry, I'll make sure to get it right this time"! Guess what, last time I go to North Babylon Deli!! The new owners just aren't the same. read more

Would come here a lot but service is getting worse and the prices are outrageous. $30 bucks for a turkey sandwich and ham/salami sandwich? No thanks... I'll find somewhere else read more

Good food. We stopped on our way out of town. my boyfriend really misses authentic NY delis and this fit the bill. clean and nice, joking staff. We both got The Godfather, which was delish. read more

Love this deli not just because it's nearby but because it's a true LI deli and everything here is delicious and fresh. Great heros and sandwiches and truly the best macaroni and potato salad ever. read more

Sandwiches are over priced. $9 for a turkey hero and $6.00 for a roll: Then they stuff the sandwich with about a whole pound of meat. That's too much if u ask me. I'd rather go to Brooklyn and get a $3.50 hero. They just taste better. Even subway is cheaper and u can get whatever I want on it. The people who work there are nice tho. read more

Waited 15 minutes and still wasn't helped. One woman was making food while others were in the back singing and dancing. Will never return to this store even if the food was free. They must be making tons of money if they can ignore customers at their leisure. read more

Salads went downhill not the same deli it used to be also clerks let you wait too long

I have been going to this deli for over 30 years. The new ownership over the past few years has finally made me swear to never go back. I've given chance after chance for them to get orders correct only to find the wrong sandwich, condiment or cheese almost every time. They took away Equal as a sweetener because it's more expensive by a few cents, they raised their limits for credit card purchases. Today was the last straw. Calling for delivery because my son had a 102 fever and couldn't go out they let me know they can't take credit cards over the phone. The person taking the order was rude and I asked to speak with the manager. I was put on hold and was never picked up again. Thankfully I called the BABYLON Village Deli who happily delivered much better food at a better price! North Babylon Deli deserves to lose the customers it doesn't value. read more

Turkey & cheese on a roll with lettuce and mayo (no tomato), $8.50, does that seem right? I pay less in Manhattan. The sandwich was good enough but I just think it's way too pricey. read more

The North Babylon deli is awesome. They have great food and service. They have been around as long as I remember and I'm 44 yrs old. Now that John from Mangia pizza owns it it's even better. Can't go wrong with this Deli read more

We order from here almost every day. They are the fastest when it comes to delivery and always so nice. Sandwiches and soup are always fresh and delicious! read more

One of my favorite things about traveling to NY is getting a breakfast sandwich at the deli and grabbing a Dagwood for the drive home. It's a shame there isn't a place remotely like this in the D.C. area. read more

I frequent this deli often and the food is good but the girl that works there , Alexa, is the best reason. She is quick and friendly and makes the best sandwiches! read more

Ordered my first sandwich today. Very clean deli. Lots of variety and the sandwich was delicious. So close by. I'll be back.

I very rarely post a negative review but living in North Babylon for many many years, North Babylon Deli has lost all its neighborhood charm and appeal. Never can you get a hero that is made the same by different servers. There is no meat on the sandwich. This place is looking to make more profits by ripping people off. I can walk in there and stand on line for 10 min and never see anyone at the register counter. Not good business practice. Always out of something. Overpriced and annoying. It used to be called the "GUCCI DELI" under the old owner. Expensive but always good food and lots of meat on the sandwiches. Now I call it the " WORST DELI". Some of the workers are fine and helpful. Others are a waste. This family will drive further to get good service at a reasonable cost rather than overpay for lousy food with a hit or miss service. read more

So rude. I went there this morning to order a bagel and it took over 10 mins because it was well over 5 mins before anyone who worked there even acknowledged that i was standing there.They walked right by like they dont even see you. The food is so overpriced. They charge $1.75 for a roll with butter. You can go to the supermarket and buy 10 rolls for $2. They charge extra for lettuce and tomato. Will not be returning! read more