Took the ole lady in for her birthday overall we had a wonderful night Let's start with the good; * Unique experience with boat ride and rustic appeal * The overall atmosphere of the bar and restaurant was very authentic * The property was beautiful * Service with Robert was outstanding. He was extremely knowledgeable about the history of the restaurant and menu Less good; * I think there's room for improvement with the menu, it is a bit outdated and it can be updated to a more modern take without losing its authenticity * Food was fresh but may have be under seasoned * Over time the food has not changed but the prices have for sure "been adjusted for inflation" * No sugar coatin' it was pricey We will be back to see Robert when the piggy bank fills back up read more

This is an experience, it is not just a quick easy dinner. Dirst make reservations! You take a boat to and from the island that takes less than 5 minutes. The restaurant is rich in history (look at website for details). Caps is very rustic with original wood,photos from the many years its been around and has a cool slant to the floor with the structure leaning. The food was delicious. It is pricey but I assume the costs also cover the boat going to and from. I really enjoyed the experience. I also would come with some patience as some of the wait staff is a little older. Our waiter was super sweet but did get confused a few times on who had what ect. Overall it was a unique experience. I would take someone who loves history, old florida style restaurants and fresh seafood. read more

See all

Food, Ambiance, the environment with a history going back to the 1920's ! Key Features Historic & Unique: Opened in 1928, it was a speakeasy and gambling den, attracting figures like Al Capone, JFK, and Winston Churchill. Waterfront Access: Reached by a complimentary water taxi from a mainland dock, adding to the experience. Cuisine: Focuses on fresh seafood (dolphin, snapper, lobster, stone crab) and other options like steaks and chicken, with many dishes prepared in various styles (broiled, blackened, etc.). O.M.G. Kayla and the team rocked my mom's 77th birthday dinner and what a chance at a unique experience for a woman who has it all !!!! read more

Cap's Place Island Restaurant - Here is my mom on this special 77th outing ! - Seafood Near Me - Lighthouse Point, Florida

Cool spot! We took a little "ferry" across to the restaurant which made it super special. The ladies had the Hearts of Palm salad and Crabcakes and they loved them! I had the bacon wrapped scallops which were OK. Service was great and the atmosphere was excellent! read more

Cap's Place Island Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Lighthouse Point, Florida

Very pricey (63 for rib eye) 43 for scallops Ok. The review. We got a ferry ride to the restaurant. It's a very old restaurant (old. Weathered, worn, got character) We got a crab cake (25) pricey but really tasty Hubby got rib eye (what can I say, you don't get steak at a seafood place). Overdone but still good. No we didn't send it back, we asked for medium, it was well done. I got scallops. They were big, sweet, tasty in a lovely scampi. Veggies were green beans (boring), we both got cheesy mashed potatoes (meh) Please note, the more expensive the menu, the pickier I am. The bread they served was piping hot, fresh, delicious The bartender is awesome!!! read more

See all

Even though I had this place bookmarked for years, I never visited when I lived in Broward. I decided to make reservations here for our 10th wedding anniversary, since we were in town for a birthday party. I even received a voicemail and text message from Caps the day of. Our reservation was at 9pm and the voicemail had requested we be at the dock at 8:45pm. Howe, when I called back, she requested I be at the dock by 8:30pm. We decided to take an Uber to the dock since it was our first time visiting. Luckily, there was another couple who joined us at the dock who have visited Caps previously. There was a young kid who docked his boat at the dock, which was confusing but the Caps boat came shortly after and chased that other boat away. We were greeted by the captain and welcomed aboard. I wish the ride was longer but still nice anyway. Fun fact, after residing in Florida for 15 years, this was my first boat ride in the state! Since we arrived early, we decided to head to the bar first. We had no idea it was separate from the restaurant. I am glad we went though because it was awesome! Talk about stepping into history! Luckily there were only 4 patrons-2 at the bar and 2 at a table. The bartender greeted us and offered us drinks. I ordered an extra dirty martini and hubs ordered a beer. We made our way to the restaurant close to our reservation. The host greeted us, led us to a table, and wished us a happy anniversary. Our server soon after greeted us. Even though we had our drinks still from the bar, we ordered a bottle of wine. That was quickly brought over & served to us. We then attempted to place our order and when hubs ordered chicken (he does not eat seafood), we were informed they ran out. We were very sad and the only item hubs was interested in was the hearts of palm salad. I ordered the crab cakes entree with the loaded mashed potatoes and vegetables. We also ordered a house salad with extra dressing. The food arrived quickly and everything tasted good. The crab cakes came highly recommended by the woman we were on the boat with and I'm glad I took her word. They were super filling though and I barely got through it. The mashed potatoes were good but I think I was expecting something insane with the description of loaded lol. The Palm salad was good but holy crap-it was $20! We ordered a slice of key lime pie for dessert because my sugar was dropping and it was really good. Our server even delivered it to us with a little candle for our anniversary! That was really sweet. Overall a fun experience and we are hoping to visit again when we are in SoFL again. read more

See all

The first word that comes to mind is WOW!! From the boat ride over to the food and our AMAZING waitress Melissa. She made our dinner experience incredible. Thank you for our little treat to take home. read more

Cap's Place Island Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Lighthouse Point, Florida

Food was overpriced for what was offered. Very disappointing food. No ambiance any more. Service was just so so and all in all a big disappointment. Ate there for years. No more read more

You have to take a quick boat ride to the restaurant. Arrive 20min before your reservation. Restaurant is old Florida style. Good for date night. read more

If you want to check the box that you came to Cap's Place for its history, etc. that's fine. Know that the Bar is poorly stocked. The hostess/owner is a surly elderly woman with a horrible personality. The food is overpriced... So much so that things that they would normally have on their menu are not showing. You have to ask and then they just make up a price. The crabcakes are great, but everything is way overpriced. Take a chance and go once, you'll never go back. This used to be a great spot. It's tired, and as I said, overpriced and under quality. read more

cap's is an extremely unique experience with amazing food. you have to take a 5-minute ferry to get to the actual restaurant and once you're there, you are immersed in a historic building with a lot of old decor. the staff is all super friendly, and the food was incredible! the crab cakes were my favorite! the scallops, calamari, and caprese salad were also very good. the key lime pie was delicious, the perfect balance of sweet and sour. i would highly recommend cap's!! read more

See all

This place is cool and has so much history. You have to go. Make sure to get the tour at the end. Melissa was our server. She is great and made it so much better. The food is good. I would suggest the crab cakes. read more

See all

Wow! That sums up my experience. Taking the boat over to this rich historical location was the ultimate dining enhancement of the day. Loved the food - one of the best ribeye I have ever had. Fabulous! The atmosphere is not comparable to any other feeling of nostalgia, history, and great dining experience. Dan was my server and he was excellent. Great job by all. A must stop if you're hungry for great food and a little history. read more

See all

The delightful experience starts when you park and get on the dock for a ferry to this restaurant. A short ferry ride and you get to choose between the bar building or the restaurant building. read more

Cap's Place Island Restaurant - Boardwalk to bar and restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Lighthouse Point, Florida

There's a nasty old lady in the front that scurries anyone away that is early. She may be the owner, but what a un-delightful person. However, Melissa was a fabulous server. She made up for the lack or personality the owner had. read more

The ferry needs to be refurbished. Captain was great! Water was leaking inside not a deluge but the cover needs to be replaced. Our server Melissa was great and she made excellent Martini's! We had Calamari with various sauces. My Escargot was good however it needed more garlic. Warm delicious bread and butter. We ordered the seafood platter however the Scallops were not prepared properly, they were fried and Scallops should have a beautiful sheen when prepared properly. Expensive entree's but not prepared with any seasoning or flair. Very boring presentation on our seafood platter,French Fries were soft not crispy. Needs to be updated. read more

See all

Great place to eat!! Went here to watch the LHP boat parade and it was a great time! The fried snapper was excellent!!! I wish they included the entire thing from head to tail though. The sauce that came with it was so delicious and made the entire dish. Mashed sweet potato's were indeed sweet ! The boat driver recommended the crab cakes and they did not disappoint. Filet was also very tasty ! overall a very enjoyable experience and a Lighthouse Point Staple! read more

See all

Great spot for dinner and history. Originally a speak easy where liquor was brought in by boat. This dinner spot was visited by numerous presidents and celebrities. Entey is by boat! Fun night. The waitstaff is great and well versed in the history. They r happy to tell diners about the history read more

Caps is still a phenomenal seafood restaurant. It's been around for almost 100 years! I've been going since 1978. All the fish is fresh and perfectly prepared. Highly recommend the crab cakes, dolphin, all the fish really, hearts of palm salad and key lime pie. Atmosphere is authentic old Florida. You even get a little boat ride. Highly recommend. read more

Went to Cap's tonight for the first time in 35 years and was a little hesitant due to recent reviews saying it's gone downhill. Well, those reviews are just wrong. We stopped at the bar for a cosmo and an old fashioned before heading into the restaurant. Our server, Benita, was an absolute gem. So attentive and friendly and gave us a ton of great trivia about the place. We started with calamari and escargot - both to die for. I had the crab cakes (amazing) with a wonderful side of mashed sweet potatoes. So good. My husband got a giant piece of mahi mahi that was the best I've ever tasted. I really wanted key lime pie but we were too stuffed in a good way. I'm so glad we gave Cap's a chance because we will definitely be back! read more

See all

A true gem! And so much history all around you. The seafood so delicious! The Calamari and the Maryland Style Crab Cake are a Must! Ask to sit in Bonita (waitress) section. She is so welcoming and truly made our experience that much more memorable. What a beautiful dinner my husband and I had. read more

See all

Amazing food and atmosphere! The fact that you have to get there by boat it's an adventure on its own... super recommend it!

Cap's was recommended to us by a local who told us about this unique restaurant. First, you are shuttled to the island restaurant by a water taxi. Captain Joey was adept at driving that thing! Second, this place was obviously very old as there was not one straight wall outside. It was like being in a nautical fun-house. Third, our waitress Melissa was warm and funny. She was like a floor show all in herself. And fourth, the food was outstanding. We had a killer crab cake and escargot to start; my wife had scrimp scampi over pasta and I had a fried red snapper which was perfectly done. The place was hoping on a Friday night and without reservations, we waited almost an hour. Understandable but the hostess was anything but hospitable! She was short with us and jumped on us as we went back inside to be out of the wind that 'it's not even 10 minutes'! Yikes, I was paying to eat there, she could have been nicer. The bartender wasn't very friendly either, neither the hostess or the bartender eked out even the smallest of smiles. It was busy but if it's too busy for them or they were too old, maybe get more help. Regardless of that, the kitchen serves the food quickly and Melissa was attentive and funny; and the food spoke for itself! Give it a try for yourself. Well worth the grouchy staff... read more

See all

Family visiting from northeast and ther 50 th anniversary coming so wifey and I decided to take them out for dinner gave them a choice and the boat ride was the deciding vote! Big mistake! Food was sub par ! Except the crab cake a handful of delicious Jumbo Lump delicious! I spent my life in the restaurant business as an owner and also a distributor sales manager for the largest company in the business so my perspective is based on knowledge of food and preparation but I digress... uber expensive 3rd tier seafood in a classic rundown cabin. Service was spot on drinks were good but 65 buck for four well drinks. I'm here for four months and dine out 70% of the time so many great choices but the friggin boat ride which is five minutes was the deciding factor! on the reservation we mentioned the anniversary with no metion from host or waiter! no big thing ! shit food other than crab cake and pie! shit food $$$$$ read more

I like the mysterious location, the short ride in the boat, the cocktails. I was not thrilled with the food. I'll give them another try

Wow! Is all I can say. A true surprise. Overall we give the restaurant four stars. The seafood is well prepared. This is not red lobster where everything seems overcooked. So, I can understand some of the negative comments. I would recommend this place for a treat, a special place to bring out of town guest and etc. Basic ambiance not fancy but the area/location is beautiful and special all by itself. If you make reservations get to the ferry 30 minutes early it runs every 10 minutes between the restaurant and the dock. Stop at the bar and get a well made drink' read more

See all

At one point a long time ago this restaurant received awards and many accolades. It is known for its history being from the 1920s. Although it has charm and some nice views of the intercoastal it needs to have the menu updated as its heavy, tired and rather bland. The shrimp on the seafood platter were over cooked and dry dry. I can now say I've been to Cap's place by boat but will not be in a hurry to return. read more

Absolutely, stunningly awful. It started with the "hostess," who was incredibly rude. The table next to us called her "scary." The drinks were expensive-$14 for a glass of wine (whole bottle in the grocery store is $12). The menu has very little variety. One crab cake was $25. We had to ask for roumalaide sauce, which was served in a plastic to go cup. Crab cake was small and tasteless. Three of ordered the seafood platter for $40-ish dollars, and everything was completely overcooked--very rubbery and tasteless. If you wanted a side salad-$14.50-no joke. Our bill for 4 with an appetizer-one person doesn't drink-was $320 pre-tip. Morton's prices with Denny's quality food. We were so excited to go here and wanted to love it, but it was truly awful. read more

Fun place to go to by boat and their crab cakes really are epic. It's a bit pricey but the service was excellent and everyone in our party raved about the food. We loved the escargot and the mashed potatoes were exceptional. Great place for a family dinner. read more

We made reservations for Valentines Day at Cap's Place at my request. I have wanted to return here for several years as I came many years ago and loved it! I remembered most of the history behind this 100 year old establishment, once a speak easy and casino, especially that surrounding prohibition with much more information located online. It was hard to find parking on Valentine's Day at the off sight location where a small boat picks you up. We had to wait for a second boat because of the many arriving Valentine customers like ourselves! It was just as I remembered, old and rustic but well maintained. We were seated immediately at a table in a back room with a view of the intercostal on one side and small Lake Placid on the other. We enjoyed the sunset view and were greeted by our server LJ who explained everything in detail. All the other dining rooms looked filled. We started with their specialty Hearts of Palm salad and i ordered a sautéd whole split yellowtail snapper with mashed sweet potatoes. My boyfriend ordered the crab cakes and steak fries. Both came with a vegetable of the day. Our salad and hot rolls came out first. The food is made fresh to order so it took a little while to arrive. We were both very happy with our meals. The home made key line pie sounded good but we were too full. After dinner, we stopped at a small building where the bar and bathrooms were located and got to see more of the history and memorabilia all over the walls. We boarded our little boat back to the parking lot happy and satisfied having enjoyed a romantic delicious valentine's dinner. We will return on a less crowded day! read more

See all

The boat ride was nice, something different The food was small portions but, very good and tasty The service was good The VERY NEGATIVE The prices ..... we were charged $7 MORE per plate on our bill than listed on the menu . When we brought the discrepancy up to the waiter it was ignored and nothing was done about it....SO KEEP A MENU AT THE TABLE...that was not so cool!! read more

This place has me torn. It's the kind of place that the ambiance and history make it what it is. Otherwise, it's just ok. The parking lot is located at the yacht club and you take a very quick boat ride (3 min or so) over to the bar and restaurant. We were seated at our reservation time and ordered drinks. Server was dry humor but kind and started off very attentive. We had the heart of Palm salad and calamari as appetizers. Heart of Palm salad was good- unique- but not over the top outstanding. It needed salt (an easy tweak table side). The calamari was very good, fresh and clean oil was used. My son devoured it. We all had fish entrees - broiled- w varying sides. My son had their pasta and loved it. The service took a big dip when our waiter was assigned a huge table about half way through our meal. There was also a woman having a medical issue and they had to relocate our table. They handled it discreetly, but I was a little shocked they didn't offer us a drink or free appetizer to compensate for us having to move rooms mid meal and the distractions occurred. (Happy to report- She was ok!) Our entrees took a very long time and getting the waiter's attention after moving rooms and the large party arrival was almost impossible. We got key lime pie to go and it was very very tart. Didn't get packed w whip cream but that would have helped cut the tart and we saw it served w whip when on plates at the restaurant. A three star is absolutely fair. Cool place, prices are very high for the portions and service was hot and cold. I would go back but I would probably stick to the bar. read more

See all

Dinner here with a friend. We shared a hearts of palm salad and both ordered crab cakes. Everything was excellent. Server Benita took good care of us. We will be back soon. read more

It's been several years since our last visit. The boat ride from the parking lot to the "island" was OK but the captain didn't speak or tell us the story of Cap's Place like before. The greetings by the hostess and server were friendly and made us feel welcome. Our server, Benita, did a nice job being informative about the menu, being talkative, and being efficient. We enjoyed the popover rolls and she brought a second basket. The food came very quickly and was good. Our party enjoyed the yellowtail snapper, crab cakes, and fried shrimp. Too full for desert. We were back on the boat in about 70 minutes. read more

My daughter took me to Cap's for my birthday I love Crab Cakes.. she said they have the best crabcakes anywhere. I must agree they were amazing. The hearts of palm salad $18 ish was however, very underwhelming sliced hearts of palm mayonnaise and paprika... I definitely could've passed. Our waiter tall gentleman dry since humor was great. Don't remember his name think it started with a J Jerry or Jim The ferry driver said three words coming and going "watch your step" Did not offer a hand tho to help you in or out.. also disappointing. So in short go to Cap's for the Crab cakes everything else is a Crapshoot. read more

Ok here we go .... The Boatride to restaurant was pleasant, driver very short and curt - no manners - scenery very nice . My party and I walked to the restaurant- it is very rustic - lots of history but place smells like an old cabin . I had the unfortunate of being acknowledged by a miserable woman -older blonde - who was absolutely the rudest person I've met in the hospitality industry - come to find out -it was the owner- Tilly . Tilly was no help and did not make any of us feel comfortable. The other employees always expressed " it's just her way" - well , her way doesn't work . If had been alone I would have walked out . Luckily , She was not waiting on us just tortured everyone that walked in . Dan , our waiter , was ok - appeared to be impatient even though he indicated he had been there 20 years . There was another " helper" named Annette , a woman who is a snowbird and going back to NY for the summer was absolutely lovely . The food , very expensive. Our starters , Hearts of Palm Salad , $24 - too much mayonnaise and lacked salt . The Crabcake was fantastic. My entree , along with 3 other of my guests, was Snapper - excelled flavor just overcooked it was accompanied by delicious mashed potatoes. My other guests satisfied with their selections but we all agreed OVERALL we would not return .This is a So FL staple but once is enough . read more

We we enjoyed the experience in lighthouse point! We recommend giving them a try and keeping your expectations low. Service is great. The service overall leaves you wondering why you paid $75pp to have a subpar experience from a general ambiance and how the front and bar treat you. We had 6 of us for dinner. Arrive early to have a drink at the bar and the 5 minute boat ride. Tip the boat Captain. There are cats and you are not allowed to pet them. Lots of rules here. Posted everywhere. We went to the bar and she had us put the chairs and tables back. Interesting place. The history is worth the visit. The food is exceptional. Not fancy. Paper placemats. 1970's furnishing. Banita- wait staff is remarkable. Recommend at least once. read more

See all

Very very nice staff Have to take a boat ride to get you there supplied by them. Great views, then everything goes down hill. Food is horrible, served cold and over cooked . Service doesn't exist never check to see if ur happy or not . This place should have closed a long time ago over priced hole in the wall. read more

The nicest part of the restaurant is being able to catch a ride on the boat to the location. Food was extremely bland pasta was dry and for $45 dollar dish you better blow my mind. Escargot was yummy. Our mash potato was under seasoned food over all was disappointing especially for the cost. Servicer was missing most of the time table next to us got annoyed he had disappeared for such a long time. When they ordered, they just put an in full order to avoid delaying any effort.. the historic restaurant has seen better days just has loyal clients, there is many other better locations to eat in lighthouse point. read more

See all

I have never been treated so poorly. The captain of the boat was not only rude, but he grabbed my arm in anger because one of our guests stepped on the boat before he was ready, even though he gave zero directions. The hostess was so rude to not only us, but to other parties. She seemed to be happy to be rude. We went to the bar before dinner and the bartender was also rude. We literally thought maybe we were on Candid Camera or someone was playing some kind of joke. It did not seem real. The food was good, but our night was ruined. We were so anxious. This is the only negative review I have ever left in my life. That is how bad it was! read more