We had TWO cake tastings before the wedding: one to choose the cake itself and another to select…read morethe filling. We met with Diana and shared our vision, along with a ChatGPT-generated image for inspiration. They truly went above and beyond our expectations! Not only did the cake look amazing, but it was also absolutely delicious! We also had another cake made as we were celebrating two different birthdays, and that cake didn't disappoint either ! Great experience !

My 1st time trying this bakery boy I'm glad I stopped in. They make the roll similar to Peter…read moreLugers with Salt & Rye which was delicious. Then they had mini apple turnovers which was delicious Definitely want to swing back again

Highly recommend Princess Bakery! I learned about Princess Bakery because I scored a TGTG bag by…read moreluck! After trying their delicious cakes + pastries, this is now my go to bakery. It's in the shopping center with Marshall's right off Hicksville Road. I went in on a Sunday night right before closing & the girls working there were so kind. There were so many choices to chose from! I ended up picking the chocolate mousse cake for my dad's cancer survival anniversary and my dad loved it! Great customer service & delicious cakes + goodies!

I went here the day before I needed a birthday cake and they made it exactly how I wanted in such a…read moreshort time. They also thanked me for the business when I picked up the cake. I got a red velvet heart cake for my golden birthday and it was so delicious and moist. Also very reasonably priced!

OMG! Freshly baked dog treats!!! After a big lunch, we…read morewalked over to Baker's Trading Sweets co for dessert. This place reminds me of the small town mom and pop bakery you see in the movies. Cookies and muffins are baked in small batches similar to what you would find at a food fair. My biggest surprise was the freshly baked dog treats!!! My puppies will be super happy when I get home.

The cupcake didnt last to make the photo... it was so fresh and heavenly homemade. The cookie…read moredecorations were so pretty for orders and she had some available. Also, great to go coffee selection!

Only open once a week and because of that there's usually a limited selection. Whoever is giving…read morethis less than 4 stars is probably just annoyed they got there and all the good stuff was gone. Best butter cream cakes you'll ever have.

I'm glad I don't live around here for two solid reasons.... (1) I'd gain my weight in baked goods,…read moreno doubt about it.... sooooo amazingly good; and (2) I'd be REALLY upset about Connemarra only being open one day per week. However, since I'm not from around here, it was with pure delight and joy that my daughter introduced me to this place. Just walking into their storefront, the lovely sweet fragrance of freshly baked items was ever so apparent. While they are quite a small bakery and bake in very small batches, what they produce is so delicious, I told my daughter and son-in-law this place turns out the BEST bakery items... and when I said best, I meant BEST IN THE COUNTRY. That's pretty high praise, I'd say. IN THE COUNTRY. Supposedly, this is an Amish bakery. An Amish bakery in the heart of Wantagh, Long Island, NY. I'm not sure what makes it Amish, and I didn't bother to ask the ladies who were there on the Saturday I went, but whatever that means, I loved what I ate. I bought one of their Amish sugar cookies, which was a very soft sugar cookie, almost cake-like in texture, but still very much a cookie, which then had a layer of perfectly prepared vanilla buttercream, and then a drizzle of chocolate ganache. This normally would not be something I'd buy or eat, but when I saw it in the display case, it was callin' my name, and I'm soooooooo glad it did. It was spectacular. Soft, fragrant, buttery, creamy, sweet but not overly, with just a hint of salt. Perfection. I also bought a pint of their banana cream pudding. Again, a tout from my son-in-law (we tend to like the same kinds of foods), and it was AMAAAAAZING. Yes, in my opinion, it easily surpasses Magnolia Bakery's claim to the best banana pudding. I ate the entire amount by myself. EASILY. What flavor !!!!!!!! I also bought some little lemon cake/cookie, a Lemon Blossom, I believe... not really sure how to describe it, but it had a lovely lemon flavor, and I ate it in one bite. Lastly, I bought a lemon blueberry scone, and that was excellent, too. They had a number of cupcake flavors that all looked great, but I don't typically buy cupcakes. There were a few other bakery items that I also didn't buy, but I can assure you that when I return to NY to visit family, I will request a return visit here. This was an amazing bakery with superlative baked items that are NOT to be missed !! YUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM !!

The staff are very friendly and great with my kids when I bring them in. Kids love the rainbow…read morecookies. Got a few mini cakes for a random party and they were very rich but delicious. Iced coffee is super over priced at $6-7 so avoid the cold brew. Tonight had the rainbow cookie cake. It was pricey for a tiny cake but SO DELICIOUS. TREAT YO SELF. Rainbow cookies as a crust surround a delicious light strawberry cream filled vanilla cake. So moist. So delicious. Fudge covered top.

I loved this bakery! It was very clean and the pastries are so beautiful. It smells like heaven…read more I got the almond croissant- I wish I got some for later too. So delicious. The staff is very friendly and patient as well. I would definitely recommend this bakery.

Ok so as of now I only stopped in here for something sweet to bring to my buddies house. So I…read moregrabbed a dozen cupcakes, picked out by the wonderful girl working here. I wasn't too picky but I seen her choices and she did a fair share of chocolate and vanilla type cupcakes so i was happy (I'm a huge vanilla fan). So I go hard for desserts, like super picky on my sweets because I love them so much. Welp.....these cupcakes.... blew my tastebuds away!!!!! Moist, cakey, sweet base with a delicious frosting not only on top but in the centers on these classic cup beauties. The icing was skillfully placed on all the different designs and truly gave me a reason to be happy I stopped in here. They were a huge hit, my friends (being from the area) asked where I got them and I had to rave. They do personal cakes with beautiful designs, have a great Instagram that shows it all off and they do all types of treats. I am excited to be able to keep their number in mind to now order something special from them one day. Thanks NY Cupcakery for crushing the cupcake game. I can't wait to stop in and grab some more sweet treats next time I go by my friends.

My husband and I got tons of wonderful compliments on our wedding in NYC on January 18, but the…read moreones we heard most often were always about our cake. How beautiful it was, decked out in snowflakes and sparkle and jewel-toned florals, but mostly about how absolutely freaking delicious it was. One friend told me it was the best wedding cake she'd EVER had. And that was all thanks to Joseph at NY Cupcakery! He made every step in the process incredibly easy and efficient, which is exactly what a stressed-out bride needs. Our stunning, decadent cake was the result of one brief phone call and a few text exchanges because Joseph knew exactly what to do when we told him what we wanted. He's a consummate professional and a true artist, and I wish I could eat my wedding cake literally every day. (My husband and his sweet tooth agree.) Do yourself a favor and get your cupcakes, cakes and other treats from NY Cupcakery and nowhere else, literally ever. Thanks, Joseph!

I wanted to come leave them a review simply for how delicious their crumb cake cookies are. We were…read moregifted a tin for the holidays, and they are amazing. Now that I look through their pictures and menu, I know I'll have to make a visit to try more. The crumb cake cookies, though. So good.

The original crumb cake was great for my mother in laws birthday party. The chocolate one was ok…read morebut a tad dry. Would definitely order again.

5 stars isn't enough! The owner went above and beyond to hand create a custom reese's cake for my…read moreboyfriends birthday! She was the only one out of 5 places that said she would assist... and let me tell you... there was ZERO disappointment!! We will be back! Thank you again for making the best cake ever!

We had the opportunity of tasting your delicious cake today. One of our friends from your…read moreneighborhood brought this cake over last night. Oh boy.....It was a babka cake that hooked up with a crumb cake the flavor is perfect. Of course a little more chocolate in the center and top would have complement this cake. Definitely recommend everyone try this cake.