Service was slow and often forgot items we asked for. Fish sandwich was a bit bland, but the appetizer and spaghetti my friend ordered were superb. Would love to try again. I'd like to sit outside next time to enjoy the outdoor space. read more

Have now been here several times. Lunchtime and dinnertime. Busy and not busy. The atmosphere is always inviting and friendly. The food is delicious! We have enjoyed homemade meatballs & sauce! The chicken strips are breaded in house as well! All very tasty! We have sat in their family section. Very attentive and knowledgable staff! We also have sat at the bar with I believe Ashley the bartender! She is also top notch and makes drinks that not only taste good they are pretty to look at! Prices are great with good portions! read more

Came here last night for dessert with my parents there's a mixup my wife and I had already eaten. Sure was busy I like that so I got the cheesecake for dessert. Oh my gosh, it was so good. read more

Cappy's Northside Restaurants - I had the haddock dinner. Delicious - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

Food sucked, service, sweet server but slow, loud the guests and the staff were so loud. First and last visit. Kind of embarrassing I chose the place. read more

good food and cold beer. liked the tarter sauce and fries were crisp and well seasoned. everyone enjoyed their meal

Reasonable pricing, great food, family friendly atmosphere. Not much more to say. Get the broccoli salad and the sausage sandwich.

We have been going there frequently. Good food nice atmosphere, great staff. We always have a good time.

The don't remember dates but food bar both times. First. Time tried the Italian sub. It was a burned piece of ham some melted cheese & a bit of lettuce & tomato. On the side was a brown unappetizing looking sauce. Didn't much of it. Tried spaghetti next time. Obviously from a can or jar. Mostly tasteless. Sad because former owners made excellent sauce read more

Came here for my wife's birthday. Kinda slow for a Saturday night just after 5:30. Got seated right away. Our server was not long behind our seating and we had appetizers of their cheese stuffed ravioli with marinara sauce. The were delicious but the star of the show was their marinara sauce. So flavorful I could buy a gal. Of it if I could. Then we ordered their perch dinner with broccoli salad and baked potato and the chicken with shrimp.and fries. Both dinners were delicious and juicy. Plenty to take home also. We didn't have any room for dessert. You have to go here if you want good food and drinks. read more

See all

Prices are unbelievably reasonable. Wait staff was excellent. Don't be fooled by exterior or the location. Had the steak burger and the meat was the best I've had in a while. French fries were delicious double fried. Take the time to check it out. read more

Food and atmosphere changed not for the better with the sale of the restaurant. At their other restaurant I was called a liar. They told me I ordered shrimp and I don't eat shrimp. To defend myself I'm happily banned from Cappy's and Kaos!!!! Merle was nicer All my peeps stay away as well read more

Man oh man, I really hate to have to leave this update. I was hopeful the new owners would continue to hold the same standards as the old ones, but it just doesn't appear that way. Quality and consistency seem to be taking a steady nosedive. Tonight was the last straw. I ordered take out to enjoy my favorite meal from here. I always get a side of their red pasta sauce for my fries....am I am disgusted. I first noticed my fries tasted like fish....which NEVER happened with the old owners. Next, I noticed chunks in the sauce... and not little ones. BIG, nasty chunks. I pulled them out....it was meat of some sort .... which was almost enough to make me physically sick because I DO NOT eat red meat. I have no idea how it got there or how old it was. I threw away my meal. The bun was burned anyway and the chicken didn't taste very good. What a shame to see what's happened to Cappy's. I truly hope they can get their act together. This used to be one of my favorite places to come. read more

Cappy's Northside Restaurants - Meat that was pulled from my pasta sauce. - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

So, I work down the street from this place and I go by here to go home. I see that it's packed all the time. So I'm like hmmmm can't be bad. Decided to go on a Friday night. You know the usual it's fairly busy. All but a few tables were full. We were told to sit anywhere you like. Which is great of the tables were cleaned off... had to sit at a dirty table. Ok no big deal. Sat there for about 5 mins, finally the waitress cleaned the table off. Came back about 5 mins later to get a drink order. Five mins later got our drinks, ordered an appetizer, the hand breaded mozzarella sticks. They were terrible. They were over done and the cheese fell out of the breading. It was not good at all. Need to work on those. We ordered the lake perch dinner and broiled chopped steak with salad and baked potato and fries with the fish. The fish was soggy, full of small bones. The fries were cold. The "chopped" steak was a burger covered in over cooked onions with mushrooms that were not cooked much. It was cold. The baked potato was so cold that the butter would not melt on it. I'm not sure what the allure is, but we won't be back. Service was fair. Food terrible. Ambiance hmmmm old drunks. Thanks but no thanks read more

The wait was worth it! This Friday night was hopping. Arrived at six with party of five. Cappy's is seeking a bartender, so self-checkin was the norm. We had a decent wait for a table but the food was great. The salmon special was particularly tasty. As was the lobster steak combo special. Blue gill, 8 piece grilled shrimp and a lovely salad with grilled chicken breast were enjoyed by our party. Gin & tonics and Moscow mules were just the ticket on this hot Friday in late June. Service was fantastic even though they were very busy and only two servers on duty. We closed the place down. Wonderful evening. read more

updated. Always good. Always consistent. Good prices, friendly service. Casual setting, perfect place for a group or just a couple. One of our local favorites. read more

Cappy's Northside Restaurants - Haddock dinner - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

The place was awesome! Sat by a few regulars who were cheerful which always makes the experience. Got good suggestions on what to order. I wanted to try the whole menu, but I settled for a burger (and a grape snow cone? Who sang it?) Anyhow, the burger was great, service even better. A great hole in the wall if you will. Hit this place up! We left a Notre dame game and ended up here based on reviews. 5 stars read more

The Perch fish were excellent, though a bit pricey the atmosphere was good! Will visit again next time we're in Elkhart again.

Food was super fresh and tasty. Bartender/waitress was hilarious, we had so much for a quick stop lunch. Who knew?! read more

Food was quick! Waitress was friendly. Would visit again! Plenty of selection on the menu and specials.

Family! Homestyle cooking. Come early gets busy fast . Great service with a smile.Food is tasty and good quality. read more

Cappy's Northside Restaurants - Perch and bluegill dinner with pasta side ! - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Great food, great service, a piece of Elkhart history. My favorite item: House salad with creamy garlic dressing, fried raviolis, meatball sandwich. Hint: you can buy a few loaves of their bread. Take home and bake at 400 for 14 minutes. Life changing. read more

Great place for lunch. Good old diner with great food and great service to match. I'll be back for sure!

Hey, check this place out. First time I had been at this restaurant/bar in abut 10 years. Always a great spot over the years that maintains Elkhart (and original Cappelletti owner's) history even when it--after long, long runs over the years--changes hands. We came for a mid-afternoon lunch right before a Notre Dame game was to start. Pre-game is good there too. Would loved to have stayed if my 90-year-old lunch date (not a Fighting Irish fan for no particular reason, except being contrary to regional ways [some others love Michigan]) would have suggested it. I loved the draft beer selection and the food. Have to say, no city, and I mean no city, does Italian sauce (outside Chicago) like Elkhart, Indiana, Italians. Cappy's has good sauce, like the Cappelettis, but difficult to match in Phoenix (except I have the family recipes and I'm not telling) where I reside. Bravo, Cappy's. Get the sausage sandwich. Get the fresh salad. Next time in town, I'm trying the fish. read more

See all

service sucked food mediocre been driving by there for years decided to stop to have dinner, our first visit became our last! read more

I just had THE BEST spaghetti and meatballs here at Cappy's! I had heard their food was good but I had no idea how good their food really is. The service was amazing as well. I really enjoyed the vibe there as well. I am already looking forward to returning there. read more

First time visiting the Elkhart stalwart and it won't be the last! Everyone in our table of 6 enjoyed their food, blue gill, burgers and spaghetti. The service was over the top! The place has a good, welcoming vibe. read more

Wonderful people that always provide great service. We appreciate enjoying a good food for lunch.

Nice hometown meal for an out-of-towner. Service was great. Spaghetti and meatballs were delicious and felt like home.

So sad to hear that Cappy's is for sale! Has been one of my favorite places for over 50 years. Like the atmosphere with the pictures of the original owners. Food has always been A+, most recently the chili cheese dog with tater tots!!!! OK, lately the service has been a bit slow but consider how busy the place is and usually Kelly is serving the whole dining room and doing a fantastic job! I can only hope someone will buy Cappy's and treat it with the friendly, family asmosphere it has provided all these years. The Andersons deserve a rest after all their hard blood, sweat and tears. Pat Barber (water with lime) :-) read more

Went with my family and it felt...old. Not run down, but walking a fine line before it feels like it's going out of business. I wouldn't say the food was bad, but it wasn't great either. Just neutral. It feels like one of those places the old folks go to in order to stay away from the crowds and it's one of the "old school" hangouts. As in, you probably need to be over 70 to feel like you belong. read more

Excellent bar food! Fresh cold brew, friendly efficient staff! We're new to the area, We'll be back often read more

Old school restaurant in Elkhart serving classic fish fry and other comfort foods. Appetizers are tasty, the meatballs, garlic bread and fried pickles are winners. Sandwiches are satisfying. Generous drink pours. read more

The food is always delicious at Cappy's. I took out of town friends there and they liked everything too. The waitstaff are friendly and efficient. We liked the old fashioned atmosphere too. I would highly recommend visiting Cappy's! read more

Excellent service, amazing food, very reasonably priced, jalapeno ketchup so good and you can purchase a bottle or two at cost. Kelly waited on us and is family to original owner. Great gem. read more

First time here, last time too! I have never had such a rude waitress! We met some friends there who like to eat there and agreed, that was the worst service ever and that they have never had that problem there before. She said "sit where ever", so we did, then she said "That's not prepared you have to move over here". So we moved to a table for 6 because we all realized a table for 4 was NO ROOM for us and the food. Then the same waitress said "Are you having 6 people tonight?" We said "No, just wanted a bigger table for more room", to which she replied "Oh, well I hope we don't need the table for a group of 6. Thursday is our busy night." [It was NOT busy! and it NEVER got busy! - This IS during Covid pandemic]. Then they kind of threw the menus on the table in front of us instead of nicely placing them on the table. I almost asked her if we should just leave and take our hard-earned money somewhere else to eat, but I didn't, because I didn't choose the place and didn't want to hurt my friend's feelings! Food was sub-par. I had the special which was a Mastaciolli pasta which wasn't bad but needed more flavor. I forgot to ask for the meatballs at an additional cost. The pasta WAS HOT! It was baked in the oven on the skillet that the pasta was then served in, which I really like as a general rule for hot food. The bread was a bit tough. We opted for no dessert due to the rude service. I ordered mozzarella sticks which were bland as the breading was not seasoned at all. Same with the ravioli bite which my friend shared with me. My husband had smelt (fish) and it also said the food was sub par. Dishes were mostly $9-$10 each and not worth anything above that! The restaurant itself is "cheaply decorated" and nothing fancy to look at. The parking is all in the back, so you have to walk by the kitchen to get to the dining room OR you have to walk around the building to get to the front door. I didn't bother with the bathrooms and waited to get home. The cleanliness is also in question since the food quality is low and service was horrendous. My own family doesn't treat me that rude and disrespectfully! She was nice at the end when she delivered the food and the bill, expecting a tip I'm sure. read more

Geez...I'm over this place. Fine for a beer after work. Dinner is a whole other story. We waited OVER and hour and a half for our food on a Thursday night. We arrived at 6:00 and put our name in. Waited 30 minutes to be seated...ordered two apps... Still waited ridiculous amount of time for average food. Our party is 4 people. Figure it out, Cappy's!! Waiting nearly 2 hours for 3 sandwiches and a salad is shameful. These folks own Pete's Tavern at Simonton Lake as well. Spotty service and average bar food should be expected unfortunately. read more

What a great place. The spaghetti and Italian sausage was over the top, bread to die for.

So much great food! Between all of us we tried handmade mozzarella sticks, fried pickles with in house dips, burgers, fish, pork tenderloin, salads with in house made dressings , Italian sub, pasta and of course beer. The owners were gracious, talked to us and checked in frequently. Sweetest waitress ever. Cappys is an Elkhart tradition, you are missing out if you don't frequent Cappy's Northside Tavern read more

Very disappointed. Have been going there since Linda & Merl open it several years ago. Have been back 2x's since the vid. Food has been Terrible! Pretty sure it came directly from Gordon's! Had a $15.00 piece of Walleye. It was about 1 in. wide x 4 in long... cold and watery! Ordered a 2nd Bourbon to wash it down and was charged $26,00 for TWO DRINKS! $10 PER DRINK & $3 PER DRINK FOR ICE! Sorry... happy to give my support BUT there's a lot of restaurants in town that wouldn't charge me $3.00 just for ice in my drink! read more

our to go to place. friendly staff and owners always talks with us. Food is wonderful. Homemade white chicken chili is the best. always welcoming and warm family atmosphere. read more