2/4/26 update: I guess many people don't know the difference between a wood fired/Neapolitan vs like tavern style and NY. Google is your friend, people. We have smart phones but no one really uses its features. Calogero's uses Neapolitan style which is soft and chewy. It's not supposed to be cracker thin and crispy. We ordered arancini, salsiccia e rapini pizza, and prosciutto & fig pizza. We got a couple mini cannoli's. It was from a promotion on their social media page. -arancini 5 - these are the best ones I've had. We got meat instead of cheese. They are crunchy and filled with meat and risotto. They are a good size for $5 each. -salsiccia e rapini 5 - this one has a little bit of a kick but it's great. It has Italian fennel sausage, mozzarella, broccoli rabe, pecorino, and basil. -prosciutto & fig 5 - this was a good combination with prosciutto, fig confit, and shaved parm. read more

See all

Are you craving REAL NY style pizza? Well look no further this is the real deal. I grew up in NY with 3 pizza parlors within walking distance under the 'A' train el. They were all owned by Italian immigrants. If you appreciate a crust that's both crisp and foldable than you will love this pizza. Perfect balance of sauce and cheese. I saw a reviewer gave it one star, and they gave Lou Malnati's deep dish 5 stars. They obviously don't get and maybe never had NY pizza. Pastries are also made fresh daily. I had a Bombolino filled with pastry cream. Chocolate and berry were also available the day I went as well as beautiful Cornetto with pistachio cream. I also get the arugula salad, simply dressed with tomatoes and shaved Parmesan. It's my favorite pizza after moving here in 2020 and searching for REAL NY PIZZA read more

Calogero's - Bombolino with pastry cream - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

See all

We came here on a Wednesday. Nobody was dining in. The place is not big, with only 4 tables. Most people would just order takeout. You ordered at the counter, and they will bring the food to the table. We ordered the chicken pesto pizza, orecchiette pasta, cannoli, Nutella bomboloni, and Italian sodas. My boyfriend also bought a pistachio panettone, which we haven't tried yet. The pizza was amazing! The pizza is thin, crispy, and has a chewy crust. The pasta was good, but I asked them not to add any chili pepper to it. The cannoli is crunchy and big. I like all the food there. The staff were friendly and nice. I would definitely go back to try the other items on the menu. read more

See all

We had the fungi and pepperoni pizza! Was delicious! Not heavy handed with a pizza sauce so you can taste the pizzas' toppings. We also ordered arancini and garlic knots. Soooo good! It's a small place, not alot of bells and whistles as far as ambiance but the owner was so nice! We will definitely go again! You should too ~ read more

Oh my gosh - this place is amazing! We had pasta dishes and the garlic knots. It was right up there with the best Italian I've ever had! Highly recommend! read more

Superb service and excellent food. Front of house is always so attentive to customers dining in.

Delicious pizza with fresh ingredients and great flavor combinations! We tried the mushroom, prosciutto and arugula, and one with artichoke and all were delicious! The crust had a nice chew and eat pizza has a ton of flavor! Will definitely come back to try more! read more

Calogero's - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

Recently, came across this place here and thought will give this a try looking at good reviews. It was a pickup order and we ordered a Sicilian Bianca Pizza, Rigatoni Alla vodka, Aglio e Olio and Nutella Calzone. The rigatoni alla vodka was decent but the rest of the items weren't good. The calzone was burnt , the aglio e olio had no seasonings and tasted like boiled noodles. The pizza was very chewy and dry. Overall, a very disappointing meal. Couldn't take proper pictures as it was a pick up order and we were too hungry to wait and click pictures. read more

Wife and I found this gem for lunch today. ABSOLUTELY the BEST pizza we've ever had outside of Italy!!! This is going to be our new fav spot, can't wait to try the whole menu. read more

Calogero's - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

See all

The pizza was burnt and yet still a little cold. The sauce was very sweet, which was nice for us, but not everyone's thing. The rainbow cookies were excellent and I would recommend them read more

This pizza place is in the same shopping center as Naperville Fresh and, even though I shop fresh all the time, I've never been here. I'm glad I tried it first my birthday dinner. We ordered 3 different pizzas and an aricini ball. All was very fresh and nicely seasoned. I will be back to try their orange cannoli - I didn't get one because I had birthday cake at home. Only downfall was the lack of dining room. Only 3 tables and I've only seats 2 people. We ended up taking the food home due to this limited seating. Still worth it. read more

Amazing food Fast service Friendly staff Will definitely be returning with the entire family read more

They are the best neighborhood pizza shop nearby. The regular pizzas are great, while they also have 16 inches larger ones for bigger parties read more

The arugula salad is delicious and very well priced for the portion. The pepperoni and margherita pizzas were so yummy, too!

Amazing food and Neapolitan pizza done to perfection! We've been here a few times and it's always been delicious. A great spot for dine in and super convenient for pick up/to go. Definitely add this place to your pizza go-to's. read more

Calogeros catered my sisters wedding and let me tell you, not only were they super responsive and on time, the pizza was a hit! The food was great and the service was phenomenal. I will definitely have them cater again! read more

Great New York style pizza, Woodford and crispy. Their combinations of flavors are spot on.

OMG!!! This place is amazing!!! It has been so difficult for us to find a good Italian restaurant in the area..this ticked all the boxes! It's a small place with maybe 4 tables inside. You order at the counter and you can see them making the pizza which is pretty cool. The pizza is literally the best!!! We got the Pepperoni and inhaled it in minutes. We also got the penne alla vodka pasta...so good! We got the Cannoli for dessert- it was soo light and flavorful! Amazing! read more

See all

We had to stop in and try this place out because it was recommended by my favorite pizza man, whose opinion I hold in high esteem. The pizza here is very good. The flavor is legit and the portions on the menu are excellent. We had the pepperoni (with hot honey) and the carciofe (artichoke hearts and garlic on white pizza). I wish I could find artichoke hearts in more places. And it's real thin crust wood fired pizza. The people were really nice. Seems like a family run business. There is not much seating, but they come right out and wipe them down quick. And the Sicilian flag logo on the wall matched the Sicilian lemon and orange sodas. The Nutella calzone (with strawberries and bananas and powdered sugar) is unique and delicious. (Was enough for dessert for 4.) Although the filling could be dispersed more evenly. The restaurant business is tough, especially in the first year. I hope they stick around. read more

Calogero's - Pepperoni and hot honey pie, and carciofe pie. - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

Service was great, you order at the front and they'll bring your food to the table. Everyone was friendly and helpful. We got the burrata salad, the arugula was nice and peppery, the burrata was good, but not as creamy as I prefer but would definitely order again. Maybe ordering some prosciutto on top. We got the mushroom pizza, crust was perfect and mushrooms were nicely done and flavorful. An authentic wood fired pizza, one of the best in north Plainfield/Naperville area. The winner of the evening was the vodka pasta, the sauce was creamy and cheesy. Was so good we wanted to lick the plate. They have a strong carry out business as well. Find this hidden gem and have some great Italian food. read more

The Sicilian Style pizza is light and delicious. Amazingly kind people and fresh every time! If you like sweets, the Sicilian Donuts, the banana and strawberry calzone and the cannoli are out of this world. This has been a weekly take out for my family since "finding" this great establishment over the summer. read more

I'd like to give this place 10 stars!! Everything I've ordered here has been nothing short of amazing !! This place is a little gem !! Great job read more

Calogero's - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

See all

Great Sicilian restaurant with great people. Best of all was the panettone. Best in world! Never had better. It was well worth driving out of my way to have real homemade panettone for the holiday . Thanks! read more

Went there after returning from Italy in October and wanting some authentic Italian pizza. It was fantastic! My friend had the Burrata salad and pepperoni pizza..I had the fileti pizza. Everything was fresh and the pizza was cooked perfect. We sat at a table and they brought our food out.. the inside is small, but very cute, with Italian decor. Love all the old pictures on the wall. I ordered spaghetti Aglio e olio to bring home and a Nutella Bombolino to go but ended up having the dessert there while we sat and talked. It was delicious! Will go back again!!! read more

If there was only a way to leave 100 stars! By far - the best dough I've ever tried! BY FAR! Service - quick and excellent! We had a pickup order and got a few doughnuts. ya'll, you gotta try this! Margarita, Mortadella and Sicilian pizza is what we got! No words to describe how good this place is! read more

I recently tried Calagero's Pizza, and it was absolutely phenomenal! Every bite felt like a masterpiece, bursting with authentic taste that reminded me why I love pizza so much. It's clear they put a lot of care into their recipes, and the results speak for themselves--pure deliciousness! That said, I was disappointed to notice an unexpected "LOCAL fee" added to the bill. While I understand businesses may have certain costs to cover, this type of surcharge feels unnecessary and detracts from an otherwise amazing experience. I'd recommend rolling such fees into the menu prices to avoid surprising customers. Overall, Calagero's serves some true pizza but the billing practice just seems shady to me, it's a matter of principal, might or might not ever come back. Pizza is truly 5 stars but the fees are - 2 for me. read more

We had the sausage pizza and split a salad and it was excellent. East coast style pizza was the right size for 2 hungry people. We also purchased a fresh, out of the oven sourdough bread that they sliced for us. Wonderful Sicilian restsurant. Will definitely come back when in neighborhood. read more

On the 15th/ Wednesday I was enjoying my last day with my daughter on her visit and we stopped by next door for some bubble tea, that place didn't have food so I came in here. I was greeted by a gorgeous man with some colored eyes (hello eye candy). I ordered a pizza and took it next door to eat and was blown away! This is some real authentic Italian pizza. I originally only intended to have one slice and my daughter wasn't going to eat, but we ended up eating the whole pizza in that sitting, lol. I'm so glad we stumbled on this place because this will be my go to pizza place now. The art on the wall was really cool also. This pizza is made fresh so I did understand when he said they didn't have single slices but if there was a way to maybe just pick the the top selling pizza to have available in single slices? I live by myself and would be more inclined to go more often if I could get a smaller size. And it would be nice also to have mozzarella sticks or some small side options. But again amazing pizza!! Thank you. read more

See all

OMG. What a great addition to this relative pizza desert of the Chicago suburbs! Real deal Neapolitan, beautiful sourdough crust, super hot oven, great ingredients, expert chef. With a little NYC attitude and the wisdom of Calabria. What more can you ask for? And real canolis with actual pistachio. Best you can have outside of Napoli itself. Clearly a family business with a commitment to the right way according to the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana. Can't wait to try every pie. Only thing more I could ask for is a nice corner slice from a square Sicilian pie...my favorite in NY. Get yourselves over to Calogero's immediately! read more

Sal has a passion for bread-making. Probably the best sourdough round I have had in the country and that includes the countless sourdough bread makers in SF. Pannatone was on-point. Pizzas are fantastic. The Sicilian roots come through ! Bravo! read more

Pizza crust was not crispy on the bottom but edges were fine. Traditional toppings cheese and sausage were ok. White pizza was better. Not going back when Chicago offers so many other good options. We were visiting from out of town but grew up in Chicago. One of the things we look forward to. read more

The food was outstanding. We ordered the fungi pizza and vodka sauce pasta. The pizza was great but the paste was some of the best I've ever tasted. Very fresh and flavorful. read more

See all

Delicious and authentic italian style pizza. Wish I'd found this place sooner! Best pizza I've had in this area. read more

Calogero's - Marg pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

This is quite possibly the best pizza in Naperville. My wife thinks it's better than the new place in Downtown Naperville, Mia something? Go and pick it up and get it home quick though. read more

They have the best sourdough bread in town, it's so fresh and delicious! Their pizza is very good too, and everything on the menu looks delicious. It's a small business, and it's better to support than a chain! read more

The Pontone has changed it used to be the best now it's terrible and small as a cupcake for 40 bucks. It's insane.

My husband & I came across a video of Calogero's on YouTube a couple of months ago and we had to come try out their pizza! Drove about 45 mins and it was 100% worth it! We tried their pizza, vodka pasta, arancini and garlic knots! Everything was 10/10. Owner was super friendly and made it a very personable experience even with my crazy kids running around! Also Coming from a Sicilian family loved all the decor! Will definitely be back along with some more of the family! read more

This is for delivery service only. Please, please, please do not get delivery here. I could tell if it was served in the restaurant it would have been very good. You can always tell by the crust. But delivered this was lower than room temperature - ice cold. I doubt they deliver or use a service that delivers with insulated carriers. I was a bit put off by the overdone burntness of the garlic knots but another photo of them here looks the same, so I guess that's normal. read more

Excellent pizzas! Great char and fresh ingredients. Service was friendly and you can't beat the speed of a super hot oven read more

Calogero's - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

See all

This is an amazing little pizza place! We love pizza and are always looking for the next best place--well, we found it. The owner is a super-friendly guy and the quality of the pizza is outstanding. We tried the Salsiccia, garlic knots, and a cannoli. The garlic knots were unbelievable- the dough was amazing and had the right blend of oil and garlic. I could have made a meal out of them. The pizza was equally impressive- the right balance of quality ingredients. It even tasted good the next day when we reheated it. Cannolis had pistachios on one end and chocolate chips on the other--perfection. You can tell that they care about their food and we will definitely be back. read more