Literally stumbled upon this hidden gem while strolling through Brooklyn one morning. Decided to stop and have a quick brunch, which might end up being the best decision I've made this year! Every dish was tasty, balanced, and left me longing for more. The ambiance was quite relaxed for weekend brunch, and the friendly service made me feel at home in the neighborhood. My favorite dish was the classic Spaghetti Pomodoro, and the Crispy Brussel Sprouts might be the best I've had, ever. Needless to say, I will definitely soon be back to one of my new favorite Italian spots in NYC! read more

See all

Went here with friends for their anniversary- delish. Drinks were tasty (had the spaghetti spritz, which came with olives). Garlic twists were yummy with a good balance of olive oil, crispy bread and garlic. The eggplant parm was in a cheesy velvety tomato sauce. I had the chicken Milanese - nicely crispy. Got a side of spaghetti with sauce which was tasty. The tiramisu was so light and creamy. The cannoli was nicely mild in sweetness with lovely ricotta and a crispy shell. Loved the firework brought out with complementary sorbet for my friends. Overall a great choice. read more

Great little gem in carrol gardens. Great service by the hostess, waitress and manager. The plates were delicious. Some elevated traditional ones and some new unique ones what a great neighborhood place to go to if you're from here or traveling to. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Overall great experience and good food. - salad was great - olives great - rice balls: amazing - pasta great - cannoli (would pass) I look forward to going back!! read more

I cannot rave enough about how AMAZING the meal was here. 10/10 for the service, 10/10 for the ambiance & most def 10/10 for the delicious food. I made a reservation here for 4 adults & the staff was more than accommodating towards our friends' baby and my fur baby. I'm so glad my friend & his wife had Cafe Spaghetti on their list - it definitely worth the trek from Queens! From beginning to end, the food was on point. We ordered the meatballs, the rice balls, the burrata & the calamari. Every bite was legit super tasty. The burrata was smooth, creamy & voluptuous. The calamari was fried perfection yet meaty. The meatballs were generously doused in sauce. And all the pastas were done well al dente. The chefs at Cafe Spaghetti were absolutely not afraid to sauce it up. Everything was SO on point. Make sure to make room for the desserts too. The tiramisu and hazelnut gelato def deserve a chef's kiss. And I have to give a shout out to the staff. They were absolutely amazing with the baby and our fur bebz. The staff was super warm and they looked happy just to be present. Thank you for making our night! read more

I only learned about this restaurant because a visiting friend from out of town insisted on coming here. The restaurant, located on the outer reaches of Cobble Hill, is deceptively large - they have built a solarium like structure out in the back which is pretty cool. The menu is southern Italian standards like pasta vongole, arancini, eggplant parm, and tiramisu. Our group had all of these, plus a ricotta crostini with truffled honey and nice fennel and arugula salad. Food was above average - all very tasty and good portions. The hazelnut gelato was out of this world, maybe it was the wine but it made an impression on me. Speaking of which, the drinks were good - I had the negroni and a glass of verdicchio. It was a perfect casual dinner. Service was excellent - Joey was a joy and all around lovely server. Definitely one to add to the rotation. You wont be disappointed. read more

See all

A very cute Italian neighborhood spot in Carroll Gardens that serves great pasta dishes. Their whole restaurant is narrow, but goes back pretty far. Their back area is fully enclosed and heated right now, so it's pretty much the same as sitting inside. I can imagine it's even better in the summer when they open it up! We started with 3 apps and then 3 pastas + dessert for 4 people and it was enough food since its pretty much all carbs - Caesar salad: I thought this was just ok, and would probably try the arugula salad next time - Cacio e pepe rice balls: This was highly recommended by a friend, but maybe I'm just not into rice balls or don't appreciate the hype. They were perfectly crisp and cheesy, but it's just exactly what it is lol a fried ball of rice. - Ricotta toast: pleasantly surprised with this! Many different flavors : it's a little bit sweet from the honey and a nice surprise with the truffle. also loved the crunch on top - Fusili: my fave pasta of the night! a classic bolognese sauce - Penne with crab: this one had more cajun flavors in my opinion. There was a decent amount of shredded crab, but I wasn't that into the taste. Also has a slight kick to it - Fettuccini with shrimp: really enjoyed this one as well! it was their special that night, and the pasta and shrimp were cooked perfectly - Tiramisu: highly recommend saving room for the tiramisu! It's more on the creamy side and kinda plops on the plate, melting down but it's not soggy. I can see why this would be a popular spot if you live in the neighborhood, but it's a bit far for us to travel to. I'd come back if others wanted to try though ! There were a few other things on the menu we didn't get read more

See all

The energy was like going to your nonna's house. Beautifully decorated, quaint restaurant with big personality staff. I immediately felt at home upon going. My partner has been following this place for a while and glad we could get reservations here. They also had the back patio open even in the cool weather (not sure if it's heated.) The menu is simple and no frills which I greatly appreciate. The food is rustic, perfect serving sizes and let the ingredients speak for themselves. Had the ricotta pancakes. Owww weeee! They were fluffy, not overly sweet and the toppings complimented it well. I was in full brunch mood.I had the baked egg and bloody mary, they were superb. Ended my meal with tiramisu. They put their foot in it! It was perfect. Overall the price was very fair considering location. Run to Cafe Spaghetti you'll be glad you did. read more

See all

I rarely make it down to this narrow strip of land between Cobble Hill and Red Hook, but I'm glad I had a chance to try this new much-heralded, if cheekily named, bastion of Brooklynized Italian cooking, offered in beautiful quaint environs. We shared the spiadini, cacio e pepe arancini, a Caesar salad, the eggplant Parmesan, and cavatelli with squash. The tangy yet cheesy and perfectly soft spiadini was definitely my favorite dish of the evening, followed by the creamy cavatelli dish. The cacio e pepe was a bit too mild for my taste. The aperitivo bianco was an excellent cocktail. read more

Cafe Spaghetti - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We sat outside( private party inside) It's clean, well lit. We never felt abandoned. Our server was very attentive. Made some suggestions and was able to accommodate an Allium allergy We started our brunch with several appetizers. Rice balls, burrata cremosa, prosciutto, cherry tomatoes, grill ciabatta, all so flavorful, plentiful The romaine Caesar with fried egg , and the breakfast spaghetti ( a first for us and so delicious) was a huge hit. The portions were just right. A man would come by and ask how we were, if we needed anything. Now we see why this Cafe is so popular. The service and food is flawless! read more

See all

Tried the Bolognese, Butternut Squash Pasta and Milanese at Cafe Spaghetti. The Butternut Squash Pasta stole the spotlight, but the others were good too. Service was good... nothing memorable which is a good thing. They really pack people into the space which actually gives a nice homey feel. read more

See all

While it looks small on the inside, when you walk in you'll be surprised to see how large and open their back patio is. Rice balls were amazing!! Definitely recommend! We were a party of 4 and the order comes with 3 rice balls, but our waiter let us know we can add an additional for a small upcharge. I personally ordered the NY strip which was seasoned really well - wasn't expecting too much since this restaurant is pasta-focused but I'd order it again! read more

See all

There's a lot of hype and great write ups about this place so had to get there. If you can't walk there then parking is a huge issue. It's extremely extremely small but way back there's an enclosed outdoor much larger area. We got there when they reopened for the dinner shift. It was totally freezing. There's heaters but everyone was sitting in their coats including me. Since it's an outdoor area, the tables and chairs are on pebbles Appetizers - Spedini which is like a fancy grilled cheese with a red sauce. Nothing to write home about. I would have preferred the bread crunchy. It was soft - Ricotta Crostini - in general I always love this but again was disappointing because it wasn't crunchy - on a soft crostini. Pasta - we shared Orecchiette which was amazing. Broccoli rabe and sausage. Mains- Eggplant parm. Delicious. Great sauce. Nice portion Chicken Franchese - good and lemony. Chicken was a drop tough Best part of my meal - decaf coffee was delicious and tiramisu - one of the best I've ever tasted. read more

See all

- delicious spaghetti pomodoro Doesn't need meatballs Tasted al dente - spicy crab was perfectly sauced Came recommended by several staff members - tasty mussels I enjoyed the bread and the sauce - meatballs are thick - Brussels sprouts have pepperoni Brussels sprouts portion is small - great drinks Mezcalita was perfect - very spacious Great for large parties Soft pop music soundtrack leaves enough space for conversation - laid back and unpretentious environment I wore scrubs and I was NOT the most dressed down person in the restaurant - 1 bathroom - awesome tiramisu - I did notice that I finished my food before my drink Usually it's the other way around By the end of the entree, I still wasn't finished with my first drink Made me think how infrequently that happens read more

What Cafe Spaghetti lacks in terms of a creative name, it more than makes up for in terms of its menu. It pulls off a neighborhood vibe, while still feeling very much like a fancy Italian restaurant. We tried the burrata appetizer, which comes with prosciutto, tomatoes, and focaccia. The burrata was smooth and creamy, and the bread was toasted perfectly to go with everything else on the plate (though it got pretty oily from sitting in the dish). Everything tasted really fresh. For mains, we tried the orecchiette and another ragu pasta dish (not pictured). Both were well prepared and tasted fantastic. The menu is straightforward, with a few tempting options for each course. I always appreciate restaurants that do a few dishes well, instead of overloading with mediocre options. The space is a little cramped, especially inside. But there's outdoor seating for when it's nice out! And with most mains coming in under $30, this place delivers a great meal at a reasonable price. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Cafe Spaghetti - Orecchiette - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Recommend reservations at least 1-2 weeks ahead of time. We got seated by the bar which had its perks and great service, but would love to see the backyard patio next time. Fast paced but still cozy. Absolutely must not miss the Ricotta crostini with truffle honey and rosemary and hazelnut was yum. The truffle oil and rosemary takes it over the edge. One large piece made a good size appetizer for 2. Then I also had the spaghetti pomodoro, basic but executed well and still tasty. You can taste the love in the marinara. Also got the cavatelli with zucchini which was also decent but it was very plain. Tasted like butter pasta and fried zucchini. Small cocktail menu but done well, got the gin and orange? drink which was so smooth and paired well with everything else. Affogato was pretty good, esp the cappuccino but I'd probably get the tiramisu instead next time read more

See all

Sal Napoli, formerly of Bar Primi, just opened his own restaurant, another great Italian spot, this time in Brooklyn. So obviously get the spaghetti, but there are so many other great pastas and starters to try. Don't miss the Carciofi Fritti ($15) to start, and definitely get the Fusilli Grosso ($21) also. I'll definitely be back to try the rest of the menu. The backyard space is amazing, perfect for kids if you come around opening time. read more

See all

Stopped here on a Friday night thinking we had a reservation (later finding out we made one for the week after) but they were so accommodating and nice!! We were sat in the outdoor area that was so cosy. The service was great and very attentive and everything was so friendly. We ordered the Caesar salad, spaghetti alle vongole and bolognese. All the dishes were great and you can tell it was homemade. There was a lot of flavor to the Caesar salad, ricotta was a nice touch to the bolognese, and the sauce of the vongole was perfect. I will be recommending this place to friends and family!! read more

We had reservations at 5pm on a Sat. We ate inside which was tight but still a nice experience. Service was very good. My husband and I both had Amaro colada cocktails which were nicely made and delicious. We started with the spiedini alla Romana which is like a grilled cheese with sauce. It was really good but very filling so beware. :) I had the eggplant parm which was very good - came out super hot and was also a generous portion. I could only eat half. It was pretty salty (and I like my food salty). I am speculating that they may need to rinse the eggplant better after salting to remove the moisture. My husband had the spaghetti pomodoro and he ate the whole thing. It's pretty basic but done well. We had hazelnut gelato for dessert. It was a nice experience and I would go back. read more

Overall rating: 4.7 I just happened upon this place when I was in the neighborhood waiting to meet up with a friend. I had only a beer at the bar. But during that small amount of time, the hostess, bartender and staff were so friendly! It was much needed because I was having a rough day. I definitely want to come back and try the pasta if I'm ever in the area. Recommend giving it a try. read more

Cafe Spaghetti - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I thought this place was slightly overrated. I gave it a 4 for the overall experience but the pasta dish I came for was underwhelming and closer to a 3.5. For starters, the meatballs and ricotta crostini were great and definitely worth getting. I really enjoyed the truffle honey on the crostini. We also had the arugula insalata which was very salty to the point of being inedible. I had the crab pasta for the main dish. It was creamy and had a ton of crab. The pasta itself was good but the sauce lacked flavor. We sat outside and the temperature was perfect, but our main waitress seemed to forget about us on a few occasions. Overall the serving staff was good, bringing water constantly and cleaning the table between appetizers and mains. However, at one point a few of us finished our wine glasses and had to ask another member of the wait staff to bring our bottle back to the table. Same thing happened with the check at the end. I imagine this was just due to the restaurant being packed on a Saturday as they were kind about it. read more

Fantasy local spot pushing out great pastas. I believe the pasta is made in house. The dishes were all great and full of flavor. The best part if the meal was the tiramisu. It was light creamy and fluffy. read more

See all

The food was absolutely delicious. They really pack in the place though. I felt cramped and while the server was attentive, we definitely felt rushed. But everyone was very nice from start to finish. And all of the dishes were tasty. read more

See all

This place is so great!! First our server Brendan was super helpful and friendly, took the time to go through the whole menu with us and answer all of our questions and advise on things to order. The olive oil martini was so amazing, I'm on a huge martini kick and this one was truly excellent. Had a few apps and 4 pastas everything was excellent and would have again. The fusilli bolognese was my surprise hit, it was not my fav dish on paper but once I got it wow blew me away. The backyard was also really nice and has a covering so all seasons. read more

Cafe Spaghetti - Olive oil martini - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came here with a group of friends. We had a reservation and were seated in the patio which was perfect on a 70s day. For appetizers, we shared the rice balls, the romaine Caesar salad, truffle ricotta crostini, and the spiedini allá romana. My ha route item was the rice balls. For the pasta course, we shared the spaghetti pomodoro, the tubetti Al limone, the penne, and the cavatelli. The penne was unanimous favorite. Deep umami and rich flavor from Maine lump crab. Very seafood forward. Undoubtedly, the most flavorful item. We also shared the eggplant parmigiana. Large tray which was super comfy and savory. Staff was very attentive. They were very busy on a Sunday night and it seemed a reservation was needed. read more

Food was good, portions aren't that big , good enough for one person . Service is decent. Would go back again .

I hate to write a lackluster review for a place that is clearly being embraced as a neighborhood spot with charm. It is that, for sure: a nice spot for locals to have a meal they could have cooked at home had they felt like putting in more than the minimum. Basic dried pasta with sausage and broccoli rabe (according to our waitress, there isn't a single dish made with housemade pasta here, which is surprising for a place called Cafe Spaghetti). A steak you asked for medium rare but the chef hammered and cooked well done, neglecting to trim the gristle sufficiently so it was all a bit too chewy (it was also strangely served stuffed on a tiny plate that made it impossible to cut without most of the food flying off of the plate). A pretty sad spaghetti with clams...bland sauce, nothing particularly interesting about it. The eggplant parmesan was a highlight. The spiedini was something new to me and we liked it - a mozzarella grilled cheese topped with a super lemony tomato basil sauce. The tiramisu was very good as well and we liked the ricotta crostini. But the rest was just...fine. It wasn't priced for fine. It wasn't hyped for fine. And frankly, I want my restaurant experiences to be more than what I can easily do at home with 15 minutes and the right ingredients on hand. I want them to try a little harder. I want them to put a few dishes on a menu that surprise me and take too much work to make at home. Make a sauce or two that I don't see elsewhere. Put some effort into making the key ingredients that one expects in at least one dish at a destination Italian restaurant. And for heaven's sake, don't hammer a steak to oblivion when the patron asks for medium rare. Feel like something basic and homey? I can see the appeal. Many of the other places with truly epic Italian food are just too hard to get into. But I think for even good home cooking, you can do better and they can too. read more

The bus boy dropped a glass next to the table I was sitting on, the glass flew on my table and on my sisters clothing. They replaced the sandwich but did not replace the pasta dish that was 20$ that my nephew took 1bite of. I didn't want to say anything in front of my family because they are over friendly to wait staff even and would probably apologize. I sent a message on Instagram to the restaurant explaining that the bus boy dropped a glass next to my table and it flew all over our table and our food that was not finished. They said they would Venmo me for the dish but they did not. Going out to eat in general is just a nightmare. Always something that goes wrong. Just an annoying experience in my opinion. Glass flying on the food and didn't get it replaced, of course my family tipped. I wouldn't have tipped anything. In some instances people don't need to be tipped and this was one of them but my family is just too nice. I paid the entire bill, 400$ and a side of glass and food that had to be thrown out. Hate going out to eat. read more

To start - the bolognese at Cafe Spaghetti is the best I've ever had. And the other food is also excellent! We had the Caesar (slightly overdressed but delicious), the rice balls, and the Brussels sprouts (unclear if there was still any nutritional value under the pepperoni and dressing but wow were they good) followed by the bolognese (incredible!) and tubuletti (good, but not great). We had a round of cocktails and none stood out. This is clearly a neighborhood spot but it's also worth a trip for the bolognese and Brussels sprouts. read more

See all

Food was very good. Staff attentive and helpful. And the bartender made me my own signature drink and it was delicious pasta was great read more

Cafe Spaghetti - baked clams, garlic butter, lemon - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The pasta noodles themselves were the shining star at @cafespaghetti in my opinion. The chewy texture was obviously handmade and just stood out so much. Loved it! The food was delicious in a down to earth style. Felt like a restaurant that you would find in Italy. People were super nice and friendly as well! read more

Cafe Spaghetti - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I had cafe spaghetti on my list for a while now but unfortunately the experience left me feeling disappointed. I loved the food and the decor, and the service was attentive. however what completely ruined the experience was the atmosphere. I dined on a Saturday night on the back patio and it was infiltrated by families with little kids who made it feel like I was dining in a zoo- kids screaming and crying, throwing their utensils, even climbing all over the moped as if they were at Chuck E. Cheese. I guess since this restaurant is in a more family friendly neighborhood of Brooklyn, the parents feel entitled to use this restaurant like their child's personal playground. its unfortunate that the parents are too selfish and stupid to disciple their own children and ruined the experience for other adult diners like myself. read more

Love Cafe Spaghetti! Food is so good. My favorite is the bolognese pasta, I regularly find myself craving it. I like how this place provides an elevated dining experience that is still down to earth and cozy. I've enjoyed their appetizers too, their salads are fresh and well dressed. I always find myself coming back to that bolognese though! read more

Awesome patio space with cool sunroof that opens and wide windows. Stepping into the space for brunch is immediately cheerful. Solid brunch menu and we loved our cocktails and coffee too. Ricotta toast was notably good. Great service too. Definitely recommend read more

The first time my daughter and I visited Cafe Spaghetti, the backyard garden area was open, but had no roof. Since then, they have built a roof and added air conditioning, which makes the backyard much more comfortable, if not a bit more noisy . Be that as it may, it assures the availability of the area rain or shine. The other thing is the staff remains friendly and knowledgeable, The big news is the food remains the star of the experience and, while we probably ordered too much of it, the quality of the ingredients and the expert preparation are unmatched. I say that because the name, Cafe Spaghetti is still rather unpretentious. I'm guessing that since one doesn't expect that much, the experience is what creates a strong word of mouth and a clientele that loves this excellent restaurant. We were so happy that the food is still as wonderful as the first time we came. We ordered a few of the same items to compare them, and yes, our first experience wasn't a charm! We ordered the meatballs and rice balls, both delicious. The watermelon salad with toasted pistachios and pesto was " to die for" and a can of a cold, locally brewed beer was a great accompaniment to the crab pasta I ordered. We also had the cannoli which must have been made right after we ordered it because the crispness of the shell was in stark contrast to the creaminess of the filling. I felt afterwards that I'd like to live down the block so I could come several times and keep sampling their menu, I can almost guarantee that if you enjoy Italian food done perfectly, you too will award Cafe Spaghetti with 5 stars. Their bathroom was even great-beautifully appointed with Dion and the Belmonts rocking on the speakers. I left thinking of what I might try next time! read more

Actually enjoyed our experience here! We put our names down and waited for about 45 minutes to be seat which wasn't too bad of a wait. When our table was ready, it was a high top table. The hostess informed us that if a regular table opened up she can provide it for us. She also closed the front door because she saw that I was cold. Very accommodating! Luckily a table opened up and we switched. Have to say that everything we ordered was phenomenal! Everything was fresh and had so much flavor. Definitely will return and make reservations prior! read more

See all

Cafe Spaghetti is either new or severely underrated. We came here the weekend after thanksgiving, and many places were still closed - we had tried to go to another southern/pasta fusion place a couple blocks away. We saw that Cafe Spaghetti had good reviews and wanted to stick to an Italian/pasta theme and decided to come here. Honestly, Cafe Spaghetti's name is hiding something. You would think that it's some Brooklyn diner that specializes in Spaghetti and Meatballs - very wrong. Walked in and saw that it looked quite upscale and charming. The front is small - could fit about 3-4 small tables. However our server just kept guiding us deeper and deeper into the restaurant. We were seated in their covered and heated backyard. Food was exceptional - my entire party got the Fusili - which had a creamy burrata. Simple and rich flavors + textures, when combined with additional Parmesan and the hot pepper flakes they give. We also shared some meatballs as an appetizer - juicy and it stayed intact when bitten into. This is definitely a local hidden gem, since when we went it was jam-packed. Will definitely come back again. read more

Cafe Spaghetti - Fussili - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Delicious food, great coffee and dog friendly outdoors seating. What more do you need? Also, the hazelnut gelato is a must. read more

Cafe Spaghetti - Home Made Beef Tortellini, Vodka Sauce and Basil - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

1. If you come here, you must eat in the garden, or it's not worth it. When you walk through the restaurant and step out the back door, you are moving from the streets of BK to the streets of Napoli; you will feel transformed! 2. Chef Sal is an absolute angel and has created a beautiful, family-oriented establishment. His ode to his grandmother's sauce and his father's tiramisu warms the heart. The service is attentive and friendly. 3. I felt that the antipasti were the real hits. We ordered the ricotta crostini, the meatballs, and the rice balls- all must orders. 4. For pasta, we chose the spaghetti pomodoro, the fusilli, and the orecchiette. My favorite was actually the namesake dish- simple, garlic forward, delicious. Come here for a lovely vibe, a good time, and a solid meal! read more

See all

The had me at the name! Local spot with accolades & a lovely backyard brought us to Carroll Gardens. Neighborhood spot & essentially small plates, the menu is classic & innovative at the same time but very limited on veggies. We snagged a backyard seat by reservation but I'm guessing there's a lot of walk in's as there was an annoying crush at the door at 5PM. Ate: Crostini with ricotta Watermelon & tomato salad with ricotta salada Branzino Oreganata Orecchiette with sausage & broccoli rabe Total: $101 with tip My expectations were high and flavors did not disappoint. Branzino with butter beans was the best interpretation of oregonata I ever had. The pasta: my boyfriends pasta was Uber tasty but only one or two pastas on menu are homemade. That was surprising. While the salad was super tasty, given its tomato season the tomatoes did not stand out as seasonal. The crostini was yummy but I didn't get the pedestrian bread service, when we requested bread we didn't get dipping no oil. I'm guessing if you're more of a carb Harb and get the homemade pasta you will be more satisfied dining here. read more

See all