My mom and I made reservations here for an outdoor girls' dinner. I had seen videos of the patio space at Cafe Mulberry and it seemed like the perfect setting for the lovely summer evening. We arrived at 6pm at which point the restaurant was pretty empty but by the time we left at 7:40pm it was completely packed. This cute little restaurant is in the very busy Mulberry Street (hence the name), and serves a French menu. There is a dimly lit, intimate, simple, yet elegant indoor dining room that is perfect for a date, and then there is patio seating in an open courtyard in the back, which is perfect for outdoor dining-- it feels bright and open, yet private enough out of the public eye from the crowds walking on Mulberry. Our waitress was super pleasant and helped make the dinner go very smoothly. She was very attentive of our needs without being overbearing. I tried their Garden Lemonade which was refreshing and tasted more of cucumber water than anything else. It was not sweet at all (in a good way!) I wish it had been more lemon forward though but good nonetheless. For food we shared what I think was really the absolute perfect meal here:
- tuna tartare: they bring this out unmixed and mix it up for you tableside. It was fun to see how few ingredients go into it and that makes the dish feel almost homemade. The flavors were perfectly tangy, citrusy, bright. Perfect light app to share between two people. I appreciated that it came with both little lettuce cups and crostini. Not the most mind blowing tartare I've had but was pretty good. Would order again!
- shrimp cocktail: 4 jumbo prawns with this super delicious cocktail sauce that did not skimp on the horseradish. While this was very good, I don't know if the portion size justifies the price. Would skip next time.
- green salad: the only salad they offer for dinner so most tables had ordered this. Super fresh mix of butter lettuce with several herbs like dill and parsley, very lightly dressed so that the flavors of the produce really came through. Simplicity in all its beauty! It was perfect.
- poulet roti: this dish was actually mind-blowing. The portion was more generous than I imagined. The chicken was so tender, it fell off the bone. Also, the skin was crispy and flavorful. The chicken came over the most delicious mashed potatoes I've had at a restaurant, that were covered in chicken jus. The umami flavors, with the fat of the chicken, and the creamy mashed potatoes were absolutely dreamy. If you get one thing, get this! Shared between two and it was perfect!
- coquillettes aux champignons: we also shared this dish which is basically an elevated Mac and cheese with
mushrooms, chives, and truffles. They use Comte cheese so it has a perfectly nutty, sweet undertone. This came au gratin with a crispy layer of cheese on top of the pasta shells that was perfect. The pasta could have been a bit more al dente. Loved the mushroom and pasta combo! Very satisfying,
- roasted carrots with marcona almonds: we got this as our last side and it was also delicious. The carrots were roasted perfectly with the right amount of caramelization, paired with the salty and nutty Marcona almonds. Chef's kiss. Really nice side dish!
- dessert: we were initially pretty full so skipped ordering dessert. However, the staff was really nice and brought out some complimentary gelato for my mom's birthday with a candle! The vanilla flavor was rich (it was probably more of a French vanilla with an egg base), and it was soo creamy. Perfect for a summer afternoon! The gelato tasted very fresh and homemade! We enjoyed it a lot and I forgot to take pics of it.
Overall, super cute ambiance, great service, and strong culinary work. While there are some dishes I would skip next time, I would come back for their chicken alone. The staff is very warm and welcoming, and the patio is such a nice vibe. I will certainly be coming back to have more lunches or dinners here this year, especially try their dining room as well because that was super cute! read more