I really like this place. I like it more than Crumbl Cookies are pricey for sure but thats okay. As previous Yelpers said, the Banana Pudding Cookie is all that. FRFR. Ambiance is typical for a cookie shop, its kind of stripped to basics. read more

Service was fantastic! The bakeshop was nice, clean & welcoming. The young lady who helped me mentioned she had more cookies baking if I'd like to wait. All of the cookies I bought were fresh & delicious!! My favorite is the banana pudding cookie. I highly recommend the Butter Pecan Bakeshop & I can't wait to take these cookies to my next function! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Nice, sturdy box. - Bakeries Near Me - Vallejo, California

See all

Got a 12-pack of cookies, in separate boxes to gift half of them to someone else. The display case was well stocked with lots of unique and tantalizing flavors on a Saturday afternoon, nut free options on the left, others to the right. We appreciated receiving immediate service, as we were the only customers there. With so many flavors to choose from, our cookie selections included the brown butter pecan (most popular according to the worker), oatmeal raisin pecan, walnut brownie, chocolate butter pecan, rocky road, mint cookies & cream, birthday cake, and my fave, the dark chocolate walnut. They also offered other unique flavors like banana toffee, carrot cake, and strawberry lemonade pound cake. Unfortunately, no peanut butter flavor available. The cookies were inconsistent in size and a little pricey, but the taste was pretty good, with a soft and chewy texture I really enjoyed. Staff was friendly and helpful as well, which made for a positive experience overall. read more

See all

I can't stop thinking about the banana pudding cookie. The staff at Butter Pecan's Vallejo outpost were kind and explained all the cookies to us, since it was our first time visiting. I'm curious about many of their flavors but I think it will be hard for me to get past the banana pudding cooking. It's that good, friends! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - The banana pudding cookie stole the show for me! - Bakeries Near Me - Vallejo, California

I love that Vallejo also has a Butter Pecan Bakeshop location! They are honestly the best cookies in the Bay Area and taste way better and more flavorful than Crumbl! Just like any other Butter Pecan location I've been to, they provide quick and friendly service. The young lady helping us out was very friendly and knowledgeable of the menu. Excellent customer service! I went just before they closed, so some flavors were sold out, unfortunately. But all of the cookies that remained, that I ordered, still tasted great. They all had the softer interior which most of us love. 5 out of 5 stars. read more

See all

They're right off Sonoma Blvd ! Like any bake shop you got the goods and you got the favorites . By far my Favorites were the Birthday Cake Cookie and the Salted Dark Chocolate Chip Cookie. The staff were very friendly and gave insightful recommendations. And they were very patient with my sister that was very indecisive. Definitely should try them out if you're on the hunt for a sweet treat just make sure you have the milk on standby . read more

See all

That's a lie sir! I've been to this location and the door was locked and the open sign was off. Nice try! Get your security cameras fixed, because the timer is clearly off. We stood outside and tried that door a couple of times. Anybody inside seeing us trying to get in would have seen us. Another slacking business in Vallejo. You don't have to worry about us coming back! Zero stars for you lying about the whole situation! read more

This newly opened branch is located at a small not busy plaza in Vallejo, with plenty of parking. Same interior as the other branches. Good customer service. I love their butter pecan and the banana pudding cookie is the best! They are fancy and more expensive in my opinion but they are worth trying. They are also good when gifted to family or friends. read more

See all

This wonderful cookie shop was recommended to me and my husband by our son. We had the opportunity of stopping by the shop today. I got the Brown Butter Pecan and my husband got the Dark Chocolate Walnut. Both delicious. Moist and not overly sweet. Crumbl who? The staff was so courteous. I will be back, there are other flavors I can't wait to try. Thanks for choosing Vallejo. Update: Went back again today and decided to purchase the 1/2 dozen. Purchasing a couple of cookies worked the first time but after tasting them 1/2 dozen was the way to go. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Flavors: Brown Butter Pecan, Dark Chocolate with Sea Salt, Oatmeal Raisin Pecan and Dark Chocolate Chip Walnuts - Bakeries Near Me - Vallejo, California

I have tried these cookies here several times and I am not a huge fan. They're overpriced and greasy. The owners are never anywhere to be found. They never answer and I feel like they're not really trying to be a part of the community. The front counter girl was nice- so there is my 2 stars. read more

I came back for a second time within the same week after tasting their cookies through a Yelp event! This time I stopped by around 5:30pm on a Friday. Some cookies were sold out for the time being. They had more going in the back. You can always ask the employee if they have more of a flavor in the back or what's the wait time for them. (For one flavor I overheard them say it would be 40 minutes.) When I arrived there were two people in line before me. Another 2-3 groups came in after me. They are busy! This time I chose a 6 box assortment to gift to a new neighbor and another two cookies in a paper bag for myself. The boxes have a sticker seal so it's perfect for gifting! Grab a flyer with pics as a guide! Tip. The little flyer they have with pics and lists of flavors has a coupon for 1 free cookie on the back! For myself I got the cookies and cream and the brownie cookie. It was just as delicious as I remembered earlier in the week! Points for consistency! I love how big these cookies are and how they are soft on the inside without being underbaked/raw. Butter Pecan will likely be my new go to for bringing baked goods into work for occasions like potlucks or birthdays celebrations! read more

I am a huge cookie fanatic. When I was on the ferry and overheard someone talking about a new cookie shop in Vallejo, I had to stop by and try it out for myself. First, I saw the sign: best cookies in the bay. I thought wait wait wait, that's a bold claim. It was empty when I opened the door. I walked in and saw a row of cookies in front of me - just like how I like them, nice and well done on the edges and looked soft in the center. I had to order a dozen (which is a bit odd that they don't offer a bakers dozen - that would be wonderful). When I turned around there was a whole line behind me! I thought either this place was overhyped or it's the real deal. When I got home, I immediately opened the box with my mom and started taste testing every single cookie. And it was better than I expected. Excited to support this business and this location. read more

Excellent delicious cookies Friendly staff. Clean cookie shop. Wish there place served coffee too. read more

See all

This place was busy for arriving close to 6pm. Much to my surprise the cookies were fresh! The workers appeared a bit overwhelmed with the line of people and at one point there was only one person working in the storefront. I granted them some grace as I'm sure everything is still getting sorted out! Just be prepared to wait a little for a sweet treat as with the amount of dispensaries this town has, they're going to be kept busy! read more

The butter pecan cookie and tea cake cookie are my absolute faves... reminds me of being down south...YUM! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Tea Cake cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Vallejo, California

Always a great experience at butter pecan bakeshop. The service is always impeccable. The cookies are very tasty. I got 12 brown butter pecan cookies. The price is a little steep at about $39 for a dozen, but the cookies definitely taste very good. It is a nice treat and even though they are not the softest, a little time in the microwave brings them back to life! read more

See all

Amazing cookies! The perfect crunchy and chewy outer crust and moist and chewy inner cookie. Excellent customer service. I would love to come back again to try their other flavors. My favorite so far is their original butter pecan cookie. read more

See all

This place is cutesy and tje flavors they serve are yummy. I think these taste way bettet than crumbl. This feels like they were baked at someone's house. I just don't like the location of the place though, semi sketchy area. read more

So I just went through there two days ago get a half doesn't cookies 23.95 is the total my favorite hands down is always the brown butter pecan the signature cookie sometimes they are out if you go in the afternoon but on this day they were in stock fresh and hot thank you. You always going to get my business. My belly& thighs don't like it however my husband and my kids do so I'll be back. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Vallejo, California

Great cookies and friendly staff. It's small inside but you just walk in and order your cookies at the counter, check out, get your cookies. There is no seating inside. You have to get the classic butter pecan and my personal favorite the banana pudding cookie. Great for gifting or just a sweet treat for yourself. read more

I'm so happy the have a location in Vallejo now. As soon as you walk in you are greeted. The cookies are so chewy, warm and delicious. I literally can't stop eating 'em. It was also clean inside. I will be back. Cashier today is so nice and kind. read more

See all

I went to get my free birthday cookie and to purchase some for the family. The staff were quick and efficient and the store was clean and neat. The cookies were delicious (like always!) read more

I love their cookies. They are the best cookies anywhere. Try them and you won't be disappointed! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Sign - Bakeries Near Me - Vallejo, California

See all

Smelled delicious inside! Lots of cookie flavors and employees were very helpful. Small space but I think it works since you just pick the cookies you like and go. Cookies were so good!! read more

Great server who had already tried the cookies and recommended good cookies. Got a flyer so next time I can get a free cookie. read more

See all

Love these cookies. They are very moist, soft and delicious.. I have been to this one in Vallejo, Fairfield and Pleasant Hill

Cookies amazing! Service is great, line moves pretty quick when people know what they want. Place is clean, parking easy. Basically pay and go enjoy your cookies outside. read more

1 Star for the neat and cleanliness of the store. But $30 for 8 "just ok" cookies. We won't be back. read more

We really enjoyed our cookies, my hubby and I were in town visiting, and found this place on Yelp, looking for a sweet treat. We stopped in right before closingand the cookies were cold, but we waited and went home and warmed them for 10 seconds and thoroughly enjoyed. Very nice buttery taste, a little sweet, but that's the point, right? We tried the original butter pecan, German chocolate, sweet potato, and dark chocolate with sea salt. Once warm, they were devoured. LOL. So note to the store, invest in a warmer, don't ever sell your cookies refrigerator temp, they will not make for a repeat customer! read more

I was never into cookies (more of a cake and brownie person) and every trendy cookie place that had lines down the block was so meh to me.... Then, I tried Butter Pecan Bakeshop and I guess I'm now a cookie person? Thee best cookies I've ever had in my life. The banana pudding and southern banana pudding cookies are my favorites. read more

Usually cookies are very good. I think I came too early and got yesterday's cookies. Not fresh at all

"Best Cookies in the Bay!" I promise that quote isn't exaggerated one bit. Went in to try the monthly specials; sweet potato and German chocolate and neither disappointed. Soft & flavorful. You can always tell and taste the freshness in every bite. As usual greeted by the staff with a warm welcome, the ambiance is always so clean and calm. Go get some of grandmas cookies!! read more

Omg this is what I'm talking about! This made me think of when my bro would take me to mall and get cookies and I don't mean Mrs Fields. I was a tad nervous to try because crumbles cookies are disgusting! Once I took a bite I was in heaven and to texted my friends so they can try! The girl was helpful and made sure we tried each kind. We got the box of 12. It's small inside, but cute. Will try Fairfield's store next. read more

Always loved butter pecan cookies but this location needs a little work. I've never been told before that there was a maximum number of a certain cookie I could buy. I was told that he can only give me max 2 of the brown butter pecan cookies. I was unsure on why he even gave me a max when there was plenty. Was he too lazy to bake more? Keep it mind I came around 12:30 in the afternoon. If you're going to limit your customers to how many of a certain cookie they can get please make it known somewhere. Thought it was rude of him to only tell me I can buy 2 of that flavor cookie when I was buying an assortment of 18 cookies and he only allowed me 2 of that flavor. read more

Tried the butter pecan namesake and it was great! That's all I have to say about that.

The Banana Pudding Cookie should be illegal. I'm so mad they are so close to my house. I'm embarrassed to say we have gone back 2 days in a row. The first day we got a variety and all of the cookies were good but the Banana Pudding Cookie is life changing. Like- bury me in it. I came back today just to get 6 more. The taste, texture, everything is perfection . I'm mad that I love them so much. They taste like Banana Fosters and a cookie had a baby. I'm gonna need bigger pants I fear. I'm a very picky eater especially when it comes to baked goods. It takes a lot to impress me. You can call me impressed! read more

OMG! Brandon and Monica just helped me out to the best cookies I've ever had in my entire life! Thank you so much! The bakeries' parking lot is a little weird to drive into, but well worth going into in Vallejo. You can see the whole kitchen is nice and clean, and, OMG! Amazing cookies! read more

Best cookies I've ever had. The banana pudding cookies are my new addiction. Love this place! Wish I could give them 10 stars

Came about 30 mins after opening on a Saturday morning and they had all the flavors available, good customer service, and a clean shop. The cookies were delicious. No complaints, will return. read more

Absolutely phenomenal fresh baked cookies! Every bite makes you yearn for more all without giving you a stomach ache half way through lol! My favorites are definitely the Butter Pecan Cookie and the Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookie! Hands down .... Best cookies in Bay!!!! read more