Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed • Closed

    Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 11,204 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Smoked Lick BBQ - Smoked Chicken Leg and Thigh

    Smoked Lick BBQ

    4.1(23 reviews)
    6.6 mi

    While visiting Hilliard from Texas for work, I wanted to experience how other states do barbecue,…read moreso I decided to try Smoke Licked Barbecue. First impressions were great. The restaurant was very clean, and the staff were incredibly kind and accommodating. They even allowed me to sample a few items before ordering, which I appreciated. Unfortunately, I arrived just before 5 PM and they were already out of ribs, which was disappointing. I ordered the brisket, pulled pork tacos, street corn, and coleslaw. The brisket was very tender and moist, but I felt it could have used a little more seasoning. The pulled pork tacos had excellent texture and were enjoyable to eat, but the flavor was mild enough that, if I'd closed my eyes, I'm not sure I would have identified it as pulled pork. The coleslaw was also a bit lackluster for my taste and could have benefited from more seasoning. The standout side for me was the smoked street corn, which was flavorful and easily one my favorite parts of the meal. Overall, the service and cleanliness were excellent, and the food quality was solid. I just personally prefer a bolder, more seasoned barbecue flavor profile.

    Everything you could expect out of a BBQ spot: Flavorful, moist, succulent, scratch made, well…read moreseasoned, good bark. I really respect the creativity out of their menu and the chances they take with unique dishes and appetizers. This isn't your run of mill BBQ place but instead a place that thinks OUTSIDE OF THE BOX and pulls it off masterfully. Customer service is Phenomenal. While I waited on my order the cashier was kind enough to let me sample TWO of their real cane sodas! Location wise it's kinda outta the way but it's well worth the drive and money well spent! We can't wait to return!

    Photos
    Smoked Lick BBQ - Pretty much the whole dining area.

    Pretty much the whole dining area.

    Smoked Lick BBQ - Sausage, brisket, green beans, corn, house, barbecue sauce, rolls

    Sausage, brisket, green beans, corn, house, barbecue sauce, rolls

    Smoked Lick BBQ - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Der Dutchman

    Der Dutchman

    3.6(363 reviews)
    0.5 mi
    •$$

    Holiday order check in - I heard so much about this place that I ordered Christmas Pies. Very well…read moreorganized for pick up, and super cute place from the gift shop, the food area store for pick up, I really want to go back and try the restaurant. Pies, were very good and can tell cooked from scratch. Will order again for holidays and events.

    With Thanksgiving right around the corner, my wife and I decided it was the perfect time to place…read moreour annual pie order from one of our favorite Amish-based spots: Der Dutchman. When we pulled into the parking lot, it was clear everyone else had the same idea--place was buzzing with holiday energy. Since we were already there (and since homemade comfort food had been calling my name all morning), we figured we'd sit down for lunch first. Because of the holiday rush, the regular menu wasn't available, so the buffet was the only dine-in option. Honestly? No complaints here. We were seated in the main dining room, close to the buffet--dangerously convenient. There are three buffet stations: the big salad bar in the middle and the hot lines on either side. The salad bar was simple but fresh, with finely chopped lettuce, plenty of dressings, and all the toppings you could want. But let's talk about the hot line because this is where Der Dutchman shines. Fried chicken that's crispy, juicy, and everything comfort food should be. Chicken and noodles that tasted like something grandma would make on a cold day. Honey ham and shredded roast beef that were both tender and flavorful. And of course--the true Midwest essentials--mashed potatoes, stuffing, and green beans. The kind of plate that warms you up before you even take a bite. The buffet is all-you-care-to-eat, and trust me, I cared to eat plenty. My wife and I both kept it simple with water and lemon, and our waitress didn't miss a beat--friendly, efficient, and on top of everything even with the crowd. We left full, happy, and ready to tackle the next mission: pie pickup. And naturally, you can't walk through the Der Dutchman bakery without something extra catching your eye, so a box of donuts came home with us too. Zero regrets. If you're craving true comfort food or want a little taste of Amish-style cooking, Der Dutchman is always worth the trip--holiday rush and all.

    Photos
    Der Dutchman
    Der Dutchman - Swiss roll

    Swiss roll

    Der Dutchman

    See all

    Pioneer Pizza - Deluxe minus onions

    Pioneer Pizza

    3.6(49 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    Honestly, it's a pretty pricey pizza place. The pizza was super delicious, but expect to pay a lot…read morefor it. It was ready on time and like I said, very good. I got some wings too, and they were unbearably salty.

    Got a tip from a friend to check this place out. Took a drive out to Plain City to try Pioneer…read morePizza out. I was met my a super nice girl (didn't get her name) , they were super busy already. I ordered a medium 38 mm pepperoni, cracker crust and hot honey. FORGOT to order the garlic butter crust. I sat down and watched some basketball in the dining area, they also have a bar area next to it. Not even a doubt that they can accommodate a lot of people. The pizza came out pretty quickly even though they were busy. The pizza was cooked perfectly, the sauce had a great tomato flavor. nice and smooth. They then layered the perfect amount of Grande cheese, then loaded up on Ezzo's pepperoni and then topped it off with a good amount of Hot Honey on top. This was a perfect pizza and the taste. Yummy!!! I did get to talk with John-the Regional Manager while I was there. He said they had been in business since 2019. They emphasize that the customer always comes first. They make their dough fresh every day. Besides the indoor area they have a patio also. A rarity is they have their own delivery drivers, not wanting to have to depend on another company. If you get the opportunity you have to check them out. You won't be disappointed.

    Photos
    Pioneer Pizza - Front door & dining area.

    Front door & dining area.

    Pioneer Pizza - Ham and pineapple

    Ham and pineapple

    Pioneer Pizza - Back dining area & bar.

    See all

    Back dining area & bar.

    Beef 'O' Brady's - O'Brady burger with fries

    Beef 'O' Brady's

    3.2(97 reviews)
    6.7 mi
    •$$

    Ate lunch yesterday at Beef 'O' Brady's in Hilliard. This is my second time eating here, the first…read morebeing back in probably 2007 or so. That first time, I ate there for dinner with my wife and we enjoyed it well enough. I vaguely remembered it as being a dark-ish pub type place with televisions and high booths. It was still that yesterday. I got there a few minutes after they opened at 11:00am. I had looked at their website before going and decided upon the Fish 'n' Chips combo. From the BoB's website: Fish 'N' Chips Combo Delicious beer-battered cod fillets fried to a golden brown, served with tartar sauce and fresh lemon. This combo also came with fries, cole slaw, and I added a drink. The waitress was very friendly and brought my drink out quickly. My Diet Coke tasted more like soda water than soda so I asked her for a replacement. She said she would get it from the bar this time and see if it was any better. She did and it was. My fish 'n' chips came out quickly and was quite hot (as cooked food will be). Lunch came in a plastic flat dish with a checkered sheet of paper lining the bottom. All told, there were 3 pieces of fish - each slightly smaller than a deck of playing cards, a goodly portion of medium cut fries, a small cup of cole slaw, a small cup of tartar sauce, and a wedge of lemon. I ate a couple of fries as is before I added ketchup. Nice and crispy, hot, and fluffy on the inside. Good enough to eat sans ketchup but I really like ketchup. It made them better. It also soaked through the paper lining so I ended up scraping all of the food off of it into the dish and throwing away the paper. No need to add bits of soggy paper to my lunch. I next tried the cole slaw and I was disappointed. It was room temperature which is puzzling, plus, it tasted...off. Not food poisoning off, just...weird. I added pepper to it and it did not improve. I set it aside and started on the fish. The fish was very good. Nice and crunchy batter, extremely flaky fish inside, and had an excellent fresh flavor. I really enjoyed it. I sampled the tartar sauce and like the cole slaw, it was room temperature. To me, both cole slaw and tartar sauce should be cold. The tartar sauce had an OK flavor. Nothing memorable. The wedge of lemon I ignored. I finished my lunch and it was filling. I did not have room for dessert even though I was eyeballing the cheesecake on the menu. I also did not need a refill on my Diet Coke. The combo was priced at $13.99 and the drink was $3.19. Overall, a decent lunch with the fish being the star. Excellent waitress, good service, quick turnaround time. I may or may not return.

    Tacos were waaaaay too spicy. A choice should be given for soft or hard shells and mild or spicy…read moremeat. Will never order these again!

    Photos
    Beef 'O' Brady's - Inside

    Inside

    Beef 'O' Brady's - O'Brady burger. Look at those spices and that cheese.

    O'Brady burger. Look at those spices and that cheese.

    Beef 'O' Brady's

    See all

    Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...