Had not been here in several months, just had not been on the radar. Prompt service, wife ordered salad & a slice, I ordered the new to me classic cheeseburger w/tater tots & wife & I split an order of onion rings. Salad was FRESH and tasty, pizza was very nice, rings were crispy and tasty as were the tater tots. I was skeptical about the cheeseburger but took the chance and it did not disappoint. Probably one of the better burgers I have had in Leander. Music was a little loud and hard but we will definitely be back! read more

I'll start with service because that's the high point. Our server was polite and stayed on top of our needs. He didn't hover, but he was still responsive. This is why the restaurant has two stars and not 1. The pizza slices are huge! I was pretty impressed when it appeared. However, my cheese slice did not have cheese Co the whole slice (see the pic). Also, parts of the slice had the cheese cooked too well. I liked the crust, but seeing as it didn't taste like a nice cheesy slice, it was a fail. The chips and queso tasted like Velveeta with boring chips. My companion actually thought the chips were stale. Our server was willing to exchange this cheese dip (it could not be classified as queso) with salsa, but even that was barely passable. We did not eat this appetizer. The only saving grace is that it was Margarita Monday and it was half price. The salad was disappointing as well. I don't know what it was, but it tasted off. I liked the cheese and olives, but it didn't taste right. Cups are fully recyclable, which is nice, but each refill comes with another cup, not a refill to the cup you are using. Unless they are actually recycling them or customers take them home to recycle, this is a huge waste. My companion had two refills, so he left 3 cups. While this saves dishwashing, it seems wasteful. Overall, this was a major disappointment. read more

See all

Overall the food is good. The issue? The price. There is very little value for your money. My mom and I got a large pizza, one ice tea, one ice water and 10 bone in wings. $52.49 was the bill. And this was without tip. read more

Brooklyn's is in our neighborhood rotation for happy hours and watching sports. They have a separate large dining room and a large bar area with plenty of bar and high-top seating options. If you want to watch your favorite NFL team, they have the Ticket and your game will be on one of their many TVs. UT fans get there early as the bar does fill up. If you are dining with the Fam, the restaurant's dining area is perfect, and they have TVs there as well. Pizza is king here, and if you are feeding a large crew, their large is humongous. Some of their plates, like the chicken fingers, are easily shareable. They have a full bar with drink specials and a decent craft-beer tap list. Hubby likes that they usually have Sam Adams seasonal on tap. If you are an early bird their HH is excellent with discount drinks and food options. read more

I had the Itslian sub and it was mostly lettuce with some fries for $16. There was very little meat and, in fact, I was couldn't really tell there was any meat on it at all. The bread was fresh and delicious. Service was adequate but had to flag down the waiter to get the check. Wife said her sausage grinder sub was good. The slice of pizza was $10.25 but it was so large my 19 year old grandson couldn't finish it! Bill for 5 of us was $94.87 and they charged a credit card use fee of $2.85. All in all pretty good at a reasonable price. 3 stats because nobody really complimented anything they had and nobody said "we'll come here next time we are in town." read more

See all

Wings and salads (Greek and Caesar) from Brooklyn Heights this evening. Kind of a last minute thing, but the food was delivered early! Called the store after ordering to follow up on request for crispy wings... message got through! Wings were very good, medium buffalo sauce. Salads were a bit in the small side, but very fresh and dressings were tasty. Will order again! read more

See all

No sleep till I find my waitress... where did she disappear to? Food was average. Ambience is fun read more

The service was excellent however the wings, although flavorful were on the tough side so much so after gnawing on three wings I gave up. read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - Buffalo Hot Wings - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

I pre-ordered dinner for my family whom I was meeting over in round rock from the Brooklyn Heights location on Lakeline Boulevard, which is near my home. I got all kinds of confirmation that the restaurant had received my order and that it would be ready at the specified time which was 5:30 PM. When I arrived at the restaurant, I was advised that something had misfired and they had not put the order in.. the young lady apologized profusely which I did appreciate, but this was a huge disappointment, especially since I was taking dinner somewhere else . here are the order confirmations: Your order has been received Grubhub is now confirming your order with Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria for takeout scheduled for Today, May 7, 5:30 pm. Keep your phone handy - we'll be in touch if there are issues. Any questions? Contact Grubhub at (877) 783-5777 Order #841029755725598 From Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria (512) 456-0468 3550 N Lakeline Blvd Leander, TX I did order through the yelp app and it looks like it is picked up by GrubHub for distribution. I did a takeout order to avoid confusion. Suggestion; I there needs to be someway when an order comes in that the restaurant is clearly notified so it just doesn't sit in there computer upfront. We have been to Brooklyn Heights before and eaten inside for the most part. We did do one other pick up order and had no problems with it so we definitely will go back and I will update my review. The salad and pizza we ordered or delicious so I am adding a third star to my original two stars.! read more

I've gotta say, over the course of the last 8 years, this pizza has gotten worse every year. The mozzarella was clumped on top partially melted... Zero artistry to their pie making... C'mon people!!! It's Pizza!! Take some pride in your work!! I ordered wings .. lemon pepper wings. The 1st time they came out they brought asian spicy garlic who knows what mess.... Then the 2nd time she brought me buffalo wings!!! Bro!!! Lemon pepper!!! I ate them, whatever at that point, just been craving them for three weeks now... The menu says LARGE wings... Ummm larger than tiny?!?!! Nothing special about them... My wife ordered a ribbon garlic bread, she didn't eat it... 1 bite and some... Doughy almost finished bread that was a solid 1 out of 10... But hey, my Dr Pepper and Cherry Coke was amazing .. read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

See all

The food there is wonderful and they do a great job with customer service. We have been in several times with large groups and small groups, but always get consistent quality of food. read more

I'm from Brooklyn, lived there most of my 60+ years. This pizza is a good facsimile of New York pizza. Toppings were excellent. Pizza could have been cooked a little longer. Great service. read more

Look I love this place. But yall are stingy when it comes to ranch. I ordered a large pizza, large salad and wings and I was given 1. When I asked for more the girl ran back and got ONE more I understand my family may like ranch more than others but paying an additional $3 is a little crazy. Is ranch that's expensive?? read more

I'm so torn about this place. I've been here before and things were good. Today I ordered a take out of a pepperoni pizza and a meat lasagna lunch special. I live literally around the corner so I should expect my food to still be somewhat warm when I show up to get it less than 10 min after the order was placed (as instructed). The pizza was warm and just okay. Nothing special and nothing to praise. The meat lasagna was not meat. It was veggie. Full of spinach and mushrooms, which is fine if that's what I wanted. It was also borderline cold and very watery. It was like it had been made prior and refrigerated/reheated. The bread was also cold. If I hadn't been starving and feeding a hungry toddler, I would've just taken it back. I'm still giving three stars because the pizza was okay and the service was fast. Honestly, I'd rather wait a little longer for the food and have it be hot and fresh. It's just not the same when I pay for it then have to warm it up in the microwave. read more

We are regulars . Tried to place an order but said had to pay over phone or they couldn't put order through. We are a family of 7 who comes in at least twice a week. So had to come in and place order very inconvenient. a policy however they let do this before but Cory said not today. Love this place but they should take Care of regulars who spend a lot of money there read more

Really hate to do this since I've been eating here for years, but the consistency of the food is too unreliable. Twice in a row I ordered the wings and there was no seasoning on them. Completely plain instead of Jamaican Jerk. Sucks when you're home and too hangry to drive it back up there. read more

Love this place!! The lunch specials is awesome (huge pizza slices and the lasagna is so delicious!!) and the happy hour is awesome if you love wings!! read more

We have ordered takeout here multiple times over the last few years. Each time, it seems to get a little worse. I have been reluctant to write a negative review for this place, but I think it is time. Last night, we ordered wings. When we got home and tasted the wings, they were inedible. They tasted like they were cooked last week and then heated up in a microwave before we got there. They were so tough and chewy that we just threw them away. In addition, they forgot to add the celery after we explicitly asked them to ensure that it was packed in the take out order (which they said it was!). In the future, we will make the extra drive to go to Cover 2 every time that we want wings. read more

First time we were there pizza and service was good. Second time we arrived and server took our order and when she served it demanded as apologizing that we pay her right then as her shift was over and she wanted her tip. We hesitated, but she stood there waiting so we gave her our credit card. She came back a couple minutes later to finish as we just took our first bite and made us stop to pay her. She assured us someone would help us after she left, no one bothered to come over to serve us as one did replace her. We vowed to never go there early again to avoid her. The third time we went there and asked to sit in a booth as I had medical issues and not able to sit in a bar chair. They said the tables could only be used for large parties. No one was waiting. We asked for the manager and he just said that is our policy (although we have sat there twice). As we left the manager said sarcastically "have a nice day". read more

We've been regulars of this restaurant for many years all the way thru Covid and before. Sadly last night was a huge disappointment and lack of service. On arrival we were told at least a 30 minute wait for bar area but there were tables open in "The Family area". The place was busy so we were heavily involved in chatting, before we realized nearly 25 minutes had passed and NOBODY had approached for even drink orders. People around us who arrived after already had drinks etc. overall not a great experience and will not be using that area again. Not one person apologized or made any excuses. Are they going down hill by lack of staff. read more

We arrive at 9:20PM on Saturday and refused to seat us in the lounge area. They did offer to seat us in very uncomfortable seats in the bar area. Do better. That's lame: I politely said, no thanks to the bar area seating and said we'd go somewhere else. The hostess said, "sounds good." read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - Batman - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

Food and service is excellent. Nice diverse clientele. There wings are the best in the area! read more

BE AWARE, THEY CHARGE A FEE IF USING A CCARD. Service was good. Food was OK. But really, a restaurant charging a fee to use a ccard? I've never been to an established brick and mortar restaurant where they do this. And maybe having it somewhere in writing to make patrons aware would be nice. Most people these days don't carry cash. So I feel their taking advantage of that. Shameful!! read more

Met a friend on a Thursday at 2P. She had ordered her drink and appetizer. Michael our very young server was readily available to take my drink order. I ordered a Michilada with Modelo. My drink arrived in a glass that wasn't able to fit the entire beer and you have to ask for it to be dressed. I did get the rest of my beer on the side. The bacon wrapped shrimp way too salty for my taste. My guest totally enjoyed them! The spinach artichoke dip was delicious. Served with tortilla chips and toasted sliced bread, nothing special. We were the only ones in the dining room and I was facing the TV, I asked Michael if they could turn it off and he grabbed what apparently was a manager and the manager said they could not turn it off, but if we could scoot over, they usually don't let people sit in that table, but he was gonna make an exception for us. Didn't help us move our stuff over or move the stuff that was already on the table. It was very, very, very poor service for a manager to speak to us in that way. Ordered another Michelada this time I asked for Taheen and it was just a very very light rim again the Modelo on the side. Ordered another appetizer, the calamari and shrimp two pieces of shrimp and a little bit of calamari for $15 not worth it. Ask for extra marinara. read more

Ordered tonight for the first time using Door Dash. Pepperoni rolls were not including despite it being on the order receipt on the pizza. DoorDash delivered everything they gave him at the restaurant. Looks like the kitchen doesn't py attention to what people pay for. read more

They brought my daughter and her husband the wrong pizza and by the time they brought the correct one out we had already eaten ours so they had to just take theirs home which would not taste as fresh at all, definitely disappointing. Took forever to get our check taken care of, they didn't mark anything off for their mistake & the fact we didn't get our food at the same time. Honestly there's better places with way better service. read more

I enjoy this location much better than the location on Palmer. Since the weather was a tad bad (downpours) on Sat they were not very busy. We sat at a hightop and I was surprised that the bartender would be our server as well. I was prepared for long waits as she had to not only single handily serving the bar, the dining area servers, and us. I could not have been more wrong. We had excellent service throughout. I ordered their sausage panini and it was just wonderful. The panini was grilled perfectly and sausage had just the right amount of spice. Their marinara dipping sauce was a decent compliment but the panini stood on its own very well. Plus 1 ordered wings and there were good sized and a small order was just right for a late lunch. They do have a few decent beers, including locals, on tap. I was pleasantly surprised to see Sam's Seasonal, score! Brooklyn's was a great way to escape the Sat downpours and I'm sure we will visit again. read more

I went here on 9/22 to eat and while I was eating a cricket fell from the ceiling and landed on my food. The server tried to explain that it was "cricket" season! Nasty!!!! There were crickets crawling all over the floor. I recommend going when it's not "cricket" season. Oh and they didn't offer to discount my food or anything. read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

We have eaten at Brooklyn Heights dozens of times over the years we have lived close to them. Lately the food is mediocre and the customer service is really terrible. Don't waste your time. read more

I don't understand why this business doesn't have four stars or more. Don't let the outside deceive you it's pretty big inside. Went on a Sunday afternoon and We were seated right away. Plenty of TVs showcasing the game that night. The menu is huge from subs to salads to wings to pizza to pasta. This did make it hard to decide what we wanted but we settled on a small salad with the medium size pizza. This was plenty for two people and even had two slices left over. Ordered the meat lovers, which was cooked to our perfection. The crust was chewable, and the cheese was not overbearing . All the servings for the food are quite large, upon glazing at other tables. I've also ordered takeout and a pasta entrée made two meals. Service was great. Cayden took care of us, he showed us the right amount of attentiveness and was quick. Wasn't able to take any pictures because I devoured it before hand. read more

Food was good. We came to eat and watch a game. I was informed that the TV We were sat in front of was incapable of showing sports. Then it was over 10min before anyone came and took a drink order. We had a stretch were it was 30min from the time we ran out of stuff to drink before we got another drink. We spent literally half the time here with nothing to drink. It might be some of the worst overall service I've ever had. read more

Excellent pizza, excellent atmosphere. Excellent Swartz TV is everywhere. Great crowd. I don't get what all the bad reviews are about. $6 for this bad ass pizza. Service was amazing. Kat was a great waitress. read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - $6 slice amazing - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

I like the environment for watching a game. They have many tvs and a good sized bar. Good beer selection. I ordered the veggie lasagna that comes with a salad for lunch. I enjoyed the pepperoni rolls appetizers. My nephew ordered the chicken Parmesan, which came with a side of angel hair pasta. Very good and a very large plate. read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - Veggie lasagna lunch size - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

We regularly visit here with our family and have loved every visit until today. Tonight during our entire meal, a large group seated in the family side, away from the bar, who was clearly drunk yelling, being obnoxious, and even pounding on the table. We spoke to the waitress twice and on the second time they finally spoke to the manager, who did nothing. After a few more complaints, the server for the group's table came up and asked that we be patient as the group would be leaving soon. We told them that we needed to speak to the manager, he just said he was sorry, but that the group would be leaving soon. Still no action. When we got the check, 20 minutes later, the waitress informed us that we weren't the only ones complaining. We ended up leaving before the group, no one intervened, nothing was compensated, nothing was done. We came to relax at 5pm on a Thursday, but instead we left disappointed and stressed. read more

Uhggggg I don't even know what to say.. I have ordered a pizza to go from here and it's been okay. I decided to dine in we got two appetizers just to try them since we have never dined in. The spinach artichoke dip was dripping in oil, and the bbq chicken pizza roll was soggy and slightly cold. I honestly didn't care that much because I was here for the pizza. The pizza smelled so good! Unfortunately the dough was dry and the garlic tasted sour. Huge miss and then our bill came and was almost 80 dollars ! Just no. read more

Our waiter was very rushed and forgot to take my order the panini just a burnt mess with piles of meat in a row and the sausages were under cooked. The place had a nice ambiance but not great. The tables were wobbly and unbalanced Plus the chesse tasted like plastic. Only come here for drinks I would not come back read more

Pizza was tasteless. Wings were ok. I rather go Randall's and make My own food at this point ‍ read more

I've heard mixed things about BHP's service et al and decided to try them for a quick lunch. Ironically, their service was fast and friendly, but that's about all the good I can say. At first glance, this is a semi-casual pizzeria/ristorante. However, it really aspires to be a pizzeria/sports bar. Note my picture of the bar area facing towards the main dining section. You literally cannot get away from a screen. Anywhere. In the bar, in the dining room, wherever, and the volume is loud enough that you have to raise your voice to be heard. This is during the 11:30am lunchtime, not Happy Hour. All would be forgiven if they served an excellent pizza pie - but alas, the slices I had were mediocre at best. Lukewarm everything, a too-soft crust, and a sort of 'eh, we'll throw some cheese on it' attitude. Yes, I'm being harsh but there are some truly excellent pizzerias in the Austin area. I'll try them again sometime when I'm in the mood to watch 5 sports teams at once and cross my fingers that I just came on a bad day. TLDR: Come for the TV coverage and friendly servers, not the pizza. This place scores a 2 out of 5 on the 'CTJ Scale', as noted below. 5 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Jesus good. Would be OK passing away after finishing a plate here. 4 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Mary good. Would be OK being seen eating here by Mother Mary. 3 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Joseph good. Would be OK having a beer here with Jesus' Dad. 2 out of 5 stars: Come-to-the-Apostles good. Meh. Wouldn't have my last supper here. 1 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Nobody good. I wouldn't have my penultimate supper here, either. read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - Haven't seen this many screens since I was taken to a Chuck E. Cheese. - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

See all

I am visiting Texas and have been looking forward to trying new places. I have heard that the Austin area has a lot of great food and so far I have not been disappointed. Brooklyn Heights is a great place to eat with family because it is a sit down restaurant that is open late. I ordered the raviolis and I was surprised to see that the raviolis were green! They were still good! I got the rose cream and it was so good! It was a mix of alfredo sauce and red sauce. The service was not great but it was not bad either, it was very average. There are options for vegetarians and the options seemed really good! read more

Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria - New American Near Me - Leander, Texas

Th ambiance is very nice. The food is not that great. I ordered a pizza, the dough didn't seem like it was cooked enough, the cheese was rubbery. I customized the pizza and they did not comply. I ordered a wrap with onion rings. The wrap was ok, it lacked flavor. The onion rings were really good. I was hoping that Brooklyn Heights was going to be fantastic and I was sadly disappointed. read more