My son is deployed and he requested I mail him black and white cookies in the next care package. I googled best NY black and white cookies and Brooklyn Delights came up. Not only were they so helpful, bubble wrapped the cookies and supplied me with a mailing box they would not take $ for the cookies. It's good to know there are kind and caring people in the world. Thank you to the owner Frank and the staff at Brooklyn Delights! read more

We recently came here for a Too Good To Go pickup. Inside is a small but sizeable warehouse full of delicious treats. A ton of women appear to work there which hell yes. Pickup was fast, especially since they don't have a true parking lot. This is definitely not a bakery setting. You go in, you receive a box of goodies to take home with you. The rainbow cookies are great! Very light but tasty! The black & white cookies are just as good and freshly made. read more

I've been buying the Italian Chocolate Chip cookies at Stop & Shop for over a year and recently the quality has gone way down. Some cookies have very few chocolate chips and others look not baked well and are very light in color. The taste is a little off too. Very disappointed as these cookies were a favorite. read more

Brooklyn Delights - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Brooklyn Delights sells Good memories from home now that we live where decent baked good can not be found

I had a problem with the cake that I bought in the supermarket, and when I called the store, I spoke with Frankie. He apologized profusely and asked my address, and because we were so close he had a package of goodies sent to my house as a measure of Goodwill. I was very impressed!! This man really knows how to run a business! read more

I got their blueberry muffins as part of my shop at home order from Shop Rite. These were awful. They had an odd taste and dense texture. There were only a few blueberries in the whole muffin and they were hard as a rocks .Took a couple of bites and tossed the whole box read more

I received a beautiful box of black and white cookies as a Mother's Day gift from my family back in Brooklyn. Now, I can't comment about their experience regarding placing an order, etc.....I can only tell my side. The black and white cookies I received were packed in two so it was really easy to share if I wanted to- not saying I did...but it's possible. There was a handwritten note with the cookies in a beautiful wood box. The cookies were delicious and really brought me back to Brooklyn every time I ate them. I peeked at their website and they have a nice variety of baked goods! Big thanks to Brooklyn Delights for shipping a little piece of home to this SoCal resident! read more

Not Brooklyn Bakery quality in any way. As someone who grew up in Queens and lived in Brooklyn for five years before moving to Long Island I had high hopes for this bakeries products considering there isn't any quality Italian bakeries in my area. My mother-in-law who still lives in Queens actually bragged about how great the Crumb Cake is and the Black & White Cookies as well. I should have known better to purchase any other products after trying these two. So first off, the crumb cake tastes like plastic coated in fake sugar. Was AWFUL!! Now the Black & White Cookies - ever so slightly less gross. With these all you taste is fake sugar - no flavors at all, just sugar. Had a party for my daughter's 17th day last weekend, didn't have the time to bake lots of cookies, so I purchased the Italian Butter Cookies with Chocolate Chips and the Italian Butter Cookies with raspberry jam & dipped in Chocolate. OMG - maybe it's because I'm Sicilian and used to top quality but these are DISGUSTING!! No butter flavor, actually no flavor except sugar and the chocolate had this funky burnt plastic flavor. From now on, if I don't have time to return to the city for authentic Italian Bakery products, I'll have to find the time to make them homemade. This bakery is disgusting and it's embarrassing they try to claim the Brooklyn name considering the mass production factory is in Farmingdale read more

If I could give 15 stars I would!!! My daughters 11th birthday is in a few days and when I asked her what kind of cake she wanted, she told me "I don't want a cake, I want rainbow cookies." Specifically, Brooklyn Delights rainbow cookies. We live in Missouri but I am originally from Long Island. I was there a little over a year ago for my Godmothers funeral and when getting Italian treats to take home for my girls, my cousin brought me to Brooklyn Delights. She assured me they were the best, and she was so right. A month or two after that, I ordered black & white cookies and rainbow cookies for Easter and we had some happy kids! For the birthday, I ordered the cookies kind of late- my own fault, I was traveling for work all last week and totally spaced. I messaged the company on Facebook and they told me to call the warehouse when they were open. I called today and explained the situation and they took care of getting them shipped to be here on time AND wished my girl a happy birthday. THANK YOU for saving the day for an almost 11 year old and for having the best Italian treats on the planet!!!! -A Customer for Life Christine Paige read more

I had a tasted for a good black and white cookie. Nothing notable in the part of Florida where I live, so when I ran across the ad for Brooklyn Delights I had to give them a try. I was worried about shipping from NY to FL, but their packaging ensured safe arrival. Sturdy boxes, cool packs, lots of bubble wrap. I decided to opt for the cheapest shipping, which took about 4 days to get here. But, upon arrival these hefty delicious cookies were in perfect condition, and were the best I have had. They have several other bakery products which I fully intend to try out in the near future. Highly recommended. read more

Brooklyn Delights - Their 4 oz Black and White Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

best rainbow cookies i ever had!! will def be trying the other cookies as well! yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmy!! read more

I have been having this bakery ship me some cookies to my home in Tucson Arizona, a long way from Farmingdale Long Island. The food always arrives promptly and delicious. While most of my shopping has been online I've had occasion to deal with then on the phone. The telephone is always promptly answered. The service has b read more

I called with several questions recently and spoke with Frankie. He was extremely helpful and friendly. He answered all of my questions (I had several). lol I ordered the box of mini black and white cookies. I had them sent to my home and they then traveled to Spain with my son as a thank you gift for his host family. My son messaged me that the cookies were a huge hit with the family as well their extended family. They come in a beautiful wooden box. I will definitely be ordering from Brooklyn Delights. Great Product and Customer Service! read more

the best of the best!! rec'd my order today and all was fresh and delicious!! thank you for extra box (6) raspberry linzer cookies. thats very kind n sweet of you! will be back in few weeks to bless my local bank with your goodies. wish i still lived in n.y. i would definetly visit them. read more

My first time ordering online. I was not disappointed. The cookies arrived well packaged and fresh cookies. I got them within 48hours. I am glad I ordered them. read more

See all

If I could give 15 stars I would!!! My daughters 11th birthday is in a few days and when I asked her what kind of cake she wanted, she told me "I don't want a cake, I want rainbow cookies." Specifically, Brooklyn Delights rainbow cookies. We live in Missouri but I am originally from Long Island. I was there a little over a year ago for my Godmothers funeral and when getting Italian treats to take home for my girls, my cousin brought me to Brooklyn Delights. She assured me they were the best, and she was so right. A month or two after that, I ordered black & white cookies and rainbow cookies for Easter and we had some happy kids! For the birthday, I ordered the cookies kind of late- my own fault, I was traveling for work all last week and totally spaced. I messaged the company on Facebook and they told me to call the warehouse when they were open. I called today and explained the situation and they took care of getting them shipped to be here on time AND wished my girl a happy birthday. THANK YOU for saving the day for an almost 11 year old and for having the best Italian treats on the planet!!!! -A Customer for Life Christine Paige read more

Best black and white cookies anywhere. Convenient walk up window and reasonable prices.

The best black and white cookies around! Extremely attentive customer service. Very fast shipping- I like to send cases of cookies for gifts.. always packaged well and arrives quick! read more

best Black and White cookies around. Great spot to buy just about anything a deli sells . Muffins are on point also. Staff is great to deal with. Frank thanks for bringing your store to main st . 5 star but would be a 10 read more

They have great snack choices! My favorite is the Linden's cookies or the red air heads. I love this place! The staff are very nice.

Best baked goods in NYS.  So tasty and fresh.  Absolutely delicious.  Highly recommend.  The customer service is also amazing. Very good people. Also, nice to be able to support a small business. read more

I recently purchased a box of your banana muffins which happen to love. However, yours lack the taste of banana are very sweet and have a spicy taste which is not tasteful - sorry guys better luck next year read more

They have a great variety of items to choose from. I have ordered several gift crates as Christmas gifts and got rave reviews from the recipients. This is a great alternative to sending flowers or booze as gifts. This can be enjoyed by all. Customer service is very responsive. I'll be ordering more. read more

I ordered online. I purchased black and white cookies which were great. I also ordered the regular pound cake and the banana pound cake. Both tasted burnt. Yuck yuck read more

Got my shipment of black and whites and corn muffins here in San Francisco. Well packaged and sent out quickly. What a taste of home for this ex- New Yorker. Will definitely be ordering again. read more

I just ordered my forth order only this time I sent my two nieces an assortment box. They loved each cookie as I do! Black and Whites and Linzar Tarts are my favorite, but they are all amazing!!! Thank you BrooklynDelights read more

Hello, I've heard so many wonder things about Brooklyn delights. I was just wondering if you made anything gluten free?