Had the red velvet cake for my birthday! Absolutely delicious. Moist cake and amazing cream cheese frosting. I will always recommend this place as everything I've ever tried has been fresh and tasty. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Red velvet cake - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

I've gotten a few TooGoodToGo from here and it put me on to a fantastic place. The treats in this place are amazing. Everything on the shelves from here is to die for. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Strawberry cake - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

Cute local American style bakery in a stan alone shop right in the center of Levittown. Popular locally and always lots of bread, pies, cookies, cakes, donuts. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

This is a wonderful bakery. Large selection of baked goods. They have vegan options too. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

Great service! Excellent card it cake, so fresh and soft. The cake pops are good and very soft! Ambiance is very clean and soo much to choose from! I can't wait to go back and try more read more

Hello Sweet Surrender, is the hair extra! I was hoping for better quality with the new owners. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Donut with hair on it! - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

Haven't been here in awhile, but the treats are still AMAZING!! Great service and low prices.....I got everything pictured for less than $20!! read more

See all

We used sweet surrender for our daughter's Sweet 16 Birthday. the service and the desserts were wonderful. The manager delivered to the venue in Wantagh. In addition, this past week they generously donated a crumb cake to the church of St Jude Annual Fair. It was truly scrumptious and everyone who partake only had good things to say. We truly appreciate your service and generosity. We found a new bakery for our future events. Diane & Jon read more

To all of you who think Duncan makes great donuts, try Sweet Surrender. We got a dozen today and they were excellent. The jelly donuts actually had jelly in them - not just the little squirt we're used to. And the cream filled had lots of cream. This is definitely a bakery to which I'll return. read more

So fresh and yummy! Went late in the day, almost closing... and hey we're so soft and fluffy! read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Marble filled donut, cheese danish - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

When this was Levittown Bakery it was 5 star when they sold it went down stuff didn't taste the same I think sweet surrender sold again went one time prices are crazy cakes are dry over baked not a fan anymore not worth the money and disappointment read more

OMG the goodies can't be beat here! Delicious rye bread, cheese Danish, and Jelly donuts to die for. The service is great! This Bakery is just like the neighborhood bakeries were in the old days! read more

This was my first time trying this bakery. we picked up some donuts and a pastry. it's a small bakery with a very good selection of items. the kids enjoyed their donuts and chocolate cigar read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - donuts and chocolate cigar - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

Wow! They had such a huge selection that I didn't even know where to start and everything made my mouth water. I bought a rainbow cookie bar and their last piece of brookie. I am a tough critic of brownies and very particular abt them. This one HIT.THE.SPOT! I never forget a good brownie spot. I could do without that dabble of chocolate frosting on top that holds the mini chocolate chip cookie in place but the brookie itself....wow. I knew I had to snag the last piece on display. Perfect crunchy fresh tasting edge and the middle was the perfect consistency of gooeyness and had a rich chocolate bite!! I was disappointed in the rainbow cookie bar though because the cake portion was dry :T The rest of their display looks pretty awesome and peaked my interest to want to try more of their items. I will definitely swing by again when I'm in the area next time! read more

See all

I used to love this place. Fabulous cookies, cakes and the best thing they had--raspberry crumb squares. Light small and just the right proportion of raspberry to crumb. The cookies were still good (not as good as before, almost tastes like the are using crisco instead of butter) but the raspberry squares, are no longer good. Someone no longer works there who made them bc the raspberry squares today were gigantic, mostly crumb, very little raspberry and lacked flavor. I took a couple of bites and threw the rest of the one I was eating and the 3 others away. Just awful. read more

Bought a cake from sweet surrender the other day. Was extremely disappointed. The presentation and quality was the same as a BJ's or costco cake only it cost $60.00 BJ's or costco would have been half the price. read more

Went there today for a $5 cannoli! Their pictures looked good on their instagram, but omg it was horrible! The cream tasted too sugary with no taste of the ricotta! But worst of all was their nasty Latin cashier girl! She was so rude, no smile and not even a thank you! Never going back there! read more

Such amazing cakes and pies ! Most delicious crumb cake and apple pie I have ever eaten. Both were so fresh and make with quality ingredients! I was thrilled they delivered to Long Beach ! read more

This bakery is the best. Love everything there from their pastries to their cakes to their breads and especially their amazing donuts. A friend just dropped off a few donuts and I tried the pistachio donut for the first time. Wow!!! If you like pistachio you have to try it! Can't wait to go get a few more. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Pistachio, Boston crème and jelly donuts - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

Hafeez runs a great bakery with excellent baked goods and a different selection from others. The service is great and quick. And Hafeez's wife does a nice job painting the windows on holiday's creating a nice appearance. They are currently renovating as of January 1st so we will see what the new ambiance is like. read more

Rip off people over charging for donuts and any person that dont question there prices

Great customer service wide variety of baked goods, including sugar-free, and everything is delicious. Hard to leave there without buying one of everything! read more

While living in the Island Trees area for more than 10 years, I never stepped foot into Sweet Surrender Bakery until I more recently needed a special occasion cake for an event we were planning for our daughter and was taken aback by the amazing customer service I received the minute I walked in door - particularly one of its staff members, Kathleen. I explained the type of occasion, cake and design I was seeking and Kathleen worked with me according to my budget and walked me through different options, providing great advice in the process. During each interaction I had with her leading up to my 13 year-old daughter's big day, she was just as friendly - even more so- than the time before and so were the other staff as well as the owner. Since I couldn't pick up the cake the day of our event, another member of my family picked it up for us that morning so my my daughter, husband and I never saw it until it was presented during the reception. We were amazed by how beautiful the cake turned out. Kathleen and the decorator worked collaboratively to bring our vision for our daughter's special event to life based on her beach/nautical theme with great detail. Not only did the cake look beautiful while fitting within our budget but it tasted delicious, receiving compliments from friends and family. Sweet Surrender Bakery and, Kathleen in particular, are living proof of how you can provide just the right balance of affordability, great taste and customer service without having to sacrifice any one area for the other! It is for this reason that I am proud to now be among Sweet Surrender Bakery's many customers and highly recommend Sweet Surrender Bakery to anyone who is looking for a bakery that will work according to your budget and vision, making sure your needs are 100% met! read more

With so many bakeries on Long Island to choose from Sweet Surrender is a standout for me. Why is this? Two different reasons, one they make amazing rainbow cookies (which I am eating while writing this review) and secondly they make canoli cream chocolate chip cookie sandwiches. These are to die for and an absolute must have. The bakery itself is actually know for something called a crannoli which is a canoli/crossiant/doughnut all in one, but to this day I still haven't tried one. Definitely on my list of top bakeries! Glad I don't live close by or I'd be stuffing my face with baked goods everyday. read more

See all

If i could i would give this place Negative numbers. Horrible new owner treats long term customers like garbage! I been buying special order birthday cakes from this place for over 20 years. This new owner is a joke! He hides behind the title manager. He introduces himself as a manager and how he has to follow protocols when there is a problem. He even has the women lie for him behind the counter saying he is the manager. The man is a Joke! I spent a lot of money on a birthday cake again. The butter cream was shiney, greasy and left a film on metal utensils and mouth. The cake looked like a mess on the outside. I was truly embarrassed by this at my party. He told me when i saw the problem i should have brought the cake back right away. So in the middle of my party i should drop everything and ruin the party some more to run to a liar. I spoke with the "manager" that evening on phone. I learned the next day when he was not helping me and driving my anxiety up after ruining my daughter's birthday cake and had her almost in tears that day. That i demanded to speak to the owner and that's when he said he was. I fought with this man for a while. Telling me i should be quiet in his place of businesses so other clients could not hear. All i wanted was my money back for a cake that ended up in garbage. And i brought a piece like he asked and pics for proof. He only wanted to give me some money back and store credit. I said absolutely not and proceeded to fight with him. Telling me over again to be quiet. I said he might not know anything about baking but he as the owner had to take responsibility of his baker screwing things up. Finally over and over of standing up for myself he gave me my money back. No one should ever have to go through that. I will never be returning while this man owns this place. I feel bad for the women working behind the counter, they were all wonderful. This man is destroying this place. I would say stay away from special order cakes unless u want your party ruined. I could only imagine if this was a wedding cake. How much he could have ruined someone's wedding day. Helen was a great owner. Wish she was still there. Even though I had one problem in the last. It did get fixed when she was still there. read more

Sweet Surrender is hands down one of the BEST bakeries in Levittown. I brought the Rainbow Cannoli Crumb Cake to my work holiday party & everyone absolutely LOVED it. My family and I have been buying cakes / pastries from here since they opened & they have never let us down. The workers are delightful as well. read more

See all

We've been going here for years for sheet cakes for birthdays. This time we cut the cake at my kids party and it was kind of tough getting through the bottom layer. Once I ate it I realized the top layer was fine, but the bottom one was very dry and hard. Obviously I had to serve it since this is the cake I had. I called the next morning to let them know how it was. I got a call back from the owner the next day who asked what was wrong and then essentially completely described how they changed things 3 months ago and add a simple syrup to the cakes and it couldn't possibly be dry. I said well then it definitely wasn't on this part of the cake because it was dry. He then said, I'm not going to argue with you, what do you want me to do? Just a shocking response honestly. I said I don't want you to do anything I just wanted to let you know. Would it have been nice if he offered like a $10 voucher for something? Sure. But at this rate I don't want to go back there with that attitude anyway. I figured I'd make the call and not give a bad review because people deserve the right to make things better. But when you deny it could possibly be the way it was, and then act so rude, a bad review happens and I'll make sure myself and others don't go there again. This was like a bj's cake with a higher price tag. I'll just save that extra $40 and go to bj's next time. read more

So my bridal shower was yesterday and everything was beautiful until I saw my cake.... My mother in law ordered my cake in June and spoke to the baker requesting the cake. They said they could do it no problem. When she went to pick it up they didn't have the cake ready. After waiting they brought out a cake....but nothing like what we asked for Looking at the cake on the right i can see they put a white boarder then realized omg it's supposed to be blue and put blue on top. The flowers were supposed to be gel they just put some prop on the corner... the dress should be textured and it's put together by two pieces of fondant. I'm writing this so prevent brides from going through this.... So upset and the girl working there was so rude to my in laws Sweet Surrender of Levittown how dare you... not even an apology for this mockery of a cake. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - What I got - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

If I could give a lower review I would. After researching bakeries I settled on this one. I looked at their galleries and read their reviews and initially felt comfortable. I sent multiple images for a special 40th birthday custom cake and made it clear that I wanted the cake to look as close to the images as possible. I gave creative leeway in the placement but not the design. Fast forward to the day I picked up the cake and the disappointment was overwhelming so much so that I almost bought a generic cake. It was sloppily made and looked like the person just gave up or ran out of time. I reached out about discussing a partial refund or something. And was told (after spending $590) that they were comfortable giving back $25. I heard they have new owners but a word to the wise would be to stay far away and go someplace else that may charge more but would treat you like a valued customer. read more

Wonderful filled donuts!!!! Here they actually fill the donuts to the maximum. Buy here instead of horrible Dunkin' crap products! Support AMERICAN FAMILY BUSINESSES!!!! Really great rolls and bread too! read more

I am blown away with the cake I had from Sweet Surrender! I reached out on Facebook regarding if they were able to make a custom cake on short notice(less than a week). Helen was the one who I spoke to over the phone. I was able to order the cake and what I received went above and beyond my expectations! The cake was perfection and exactly what I wanted. Helen was so creative in helping me design this cake. She offered suggestions and was so helpful. The price of the cake was very reasonable. The cake tasted fresh and delicious! When I picked up the cake I couldn't help but order some desserts they had at the counter also. The workers were also so helpful at the counter. I look forward to ordering more delicious cakes from here! Highly recommend. read more

Sweet Surrender Bake House - Custom cake! - Desserts Near Me - Levittown, New York

Raspberry crumb cake to die for and my husbands favorite black out cake location. I have ordered a few occasion cakes from here and they are works of art read more

Not much ambiance its a bakery, some stuff looks good bread was not that amazing. Some of the pastry looked nice.

First time ordering from this bakery for Easter. They had plenty of staff assisting customers. The young lady that helped me with my order greeted me warmly. I asked for suggestions on what to order and she told me they are known for their rainbow cookies. They had rainbow cake and rainbow crumb cake as well. I ordered an assortment of cookies and a strawberry shortcake. Everything tasted fresh and was delicious! The rainbow cookies were exceptional! The bakery looked clean, stocked with a wide variety of baked goods. I will definitely return to this bakery and try there other baked goods'! read more

The deserts are out of this world!! We love this place!! My kids always recommend us getting pastries and cookies before every Holiday. read more

I went to this place for something swweeeet! I wanted to get a donut but my stomach started talking to me and said hey Mike leave the donut and take the conoli! The lady behind the counter suggested the cannoli filled donut! I looked at her in disbelief and said a cannoli filled donut Shirley you can't be serious! She said I am serious and don't call me Shirley! I said ok took one and left! It was an awesome donut check this bakery out and get something swweeeet! read more

See all

This was a recommendation in Yelp, and I figured I'd check it out, especially so since they have their own unique product, the crannoli. Though I'm not necessarily a cannoli guy, I'm up for trying anything if it's innovative - and even moreso if it's good! At any rate, here is the rather inconsistent tale of the tape: Boston Cream Doughnut Intriguingly square in shape, it has a decent chocolate topping, but where it really shines is in the filling. A very good, satisfyingly flavorful vanilla custard with the right texture. What holds this doughnut back from true greatness is the doughnut itself. It has a slightly firm texture that doesn't quite fit with the good chocolate topping and the excellent filling. Brownie Topped with a thin layer of fudge and mini chocolate chips, the brownie itself is simply not that chocolaty. You take a bite and the fudge topping dissipates, and with it most of the chocolate flavor. Bewildered, you take another (this time tentative) bite, which simply affirms your initial impression. As good as it looks, where oh where is the chocolate? They do offer another version, which contains walnuts. Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Doughnut A standard chocolate cake doughnut with peanut butter frosting and a real Reese's peanut butter cup quartered and appetizingly stuck into the frosting. Well, the doughnut is not chocolatey enough, and the peanut butter frosting is more sweet than peanut buttery. Disappointed! Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Essentially the same brownie as above, but containing mini peanut butter chips, topped with a layer of peanut butter, then ganache. There is a smattering of those same peanut butter mini chips atop the ganache, with the circumference of the whole 7" diameter pie ringed with a chocolate buttercream. The buttercream is decently chocolatey. The peanut butter layer is not sweet, a decision I support, and I would like to know which brand they use - as it's rather good for that straight up (slightly salty) peanut butter flavor. Unfortunately, as aforementioned the brownie is the same as their regular one - and though the fudgy texture is there, the expected/commensurate chocolate flavor is not. Eaten together, the flavors blend nicely, and perhaps it's here that the lack of chocolate flavor from the brownie stands out. Crannoli Sweet Sensation's signature creation has a great look, and is rather large. To me it set out what it meant to do, and as such to me it was just ok. I'm not a fan of cannoli in general, but if you are you may well like this innovative confective culinary creation. I was a little disappointed in the selection, in that there is no longer a choice in the selection of crannoli flavor. They used to have 11 different flavors, and I was set on checking out at least two or three of them (Chocolate Peanut Butter, Nutella, and Cappuccino). However, the woman working the counter told me that they only had the regular one available. Sigh. Éclair Mini Similar to my impression of the Boston Cream, the éclair has a excellent custard, but the shell is just there, and the chocolate on top is somewhat lacking. I'd say that the custard alone carries the éclair through . . . Key Lime Tart A rather tasteless tart shell with a lemon colored lime custard, topped with a green lime flavored mousse, topped with a very tart lime wedge. The mousse had a light but decently tart flavor, which was outpaced only by the tartness factor of the custard below. Nothing, however, was more tart than the actual lime wedge on top! Still, while not being overtly tart, it was enough as such to enjoy this citrusy confection. Marble Muffin I had this both heated, and not. I was struck by and appreciated its freshness on the half I ate at room temp . . . ! Still, there wasn't much marbling (see my picture), but I guess that was the (bad) luck of the draw. While I was disappointed that Sweet Surrender didn't have the other 10 varieties of crannoli, I applaud them for their innovation nonetheless. I asked what they use in the way of shortening, and the answer was both butter and oil, depending on the the baked good. I didn't probe further, but may do so on a subsequent visit. Generally I'd say that this bakery would rise to the level of greatness if they took their chocolate game to the level it should be . . . . In combination with the other elements of their baked goods, such would make them a dangerously tasty entry in the bake shop game. read more

See all

Solid bakery in Levittown. I had passed it plenty of times and finally got around to stopping by. Even an hour before close they still had a ton to choose from. I had the rainbow cookie bar which was delicious and huge! You can tell them use the real type of jam here and not Smucker's. Smells like heaven inside if your version of heaven includes lemon bars. Prices are very fair considering the quality. Two rainbow bars for $6. Will definitely return. read more

What a delicious bakery! My mom and I got two cakes from Sweet Surrender for my dad's birthday party. They were both so delicious, all our guests told us the same! We also got him a jelly donut to taste and a few pastries. My dad didn't stop talking about the jelly donut all weekend! Love having such a great bakery so close! read more

See all

Pastries are subpar. The muffins were ok nothing to go back for and the doughnuts were lacking flavor. They stop serving coffee at 3pm so if you're looking for an afternoon pick me up it's not here. read more