Mama's Custom Cookies

5.0 (23 reviews)

ModerateDesserts

Open • 10:00 am - 5:00 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Mama's Custom Cookies Photos

Mama's Custom Cookies - Fire truck cookies - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Mama's Custom Cookies - This is the cookie made for my daughters baby shower. So beautiful!!! - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

+21

Mama's Custom Cookies - the date of her wedding - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Business Info

Health Information

Powered by Local Health Department

View Health Score

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mama's Custom Cookies

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Easy to order and pick up. Great local business! Have ordered twice now, for a bachelorette party and business opening. Not only do the cookies look perfect, they taste amazing. My photos don't do them justice!

Amanda B.

It was an absolute pleasure working with Rosemary! She answers emails right away, which is so important when you're trying to coordinate vendors. And the cookies came out AMAZING! Usually when you get fancy sugar cookies they're pretty but don't taste great. These were delicious and absolutely gorgeous. They were such a hit at our party, we had several guests comes up to us to ask us if we had an extra that they could take home. I sent mama's several pictures of my vision and wrote down some of my ideas and she literally translated what was in my mind onto the cookie! It was my first time ordering from here and I will stick with them from now on. Blown away!

Look how perfect the cookie matches the decor and napkin. All favors were individually wrapped and tasted amazing.

Erica B.

My saving grace for a cookie emergency. I totally forgot to order cookie favors for a party I was hosting and it was two days before the party. I called and went to at least 5 bakeries to find out they all need a weeks notice to do something like this. I then called mama's custom cookies who said they were busy, but could help me in this short notice. I was so relieved. Their cookies are great tasting and reasonably priced. The quality is spectacular and they pay attention to every detail. Each cookie I received you can tell was treated and designed with care. I was so happy with my experience with Mama's custom cookies. Thank you!

I recently ordered cookies for my baby shower and they were perfect! They were made well, they were delicious and professionally packed (no broken or chipped cookies). Also, they were quick with responding to my questions....I wanted a different color so I reached out and I received a response within hours. Great cookies and customer service!! Highly recommend!

Sarita P.

I ordered twenty four custom cookies from Mama's for my baby shower. I showed one of the employees a few sample pictures of what I wanted and was assured that the staff would be able replicate them. Upon receiving my order, I noted that the color on a few of the cookies was different than what I'd requested, however - the remaining sets were almost identical. The cookies although pricey, were very cute and tasted pretty good. I was proud to display them on my dessert table and guests were happy to take them home at the end of the party.

After seeing the beautiful cookies produced by Mama's on their Instagram page, I emailed Rosemarie on a Saturday night not expecting a reply until Monday, but I received a response shortly afterward. She answered all my questions and made a suggestion of a different set of cookies that were not shown on the Instagram page to go along with my Beauty & Beast theme for a bridal shower. I loved her suggestion, and the cookies were gorgeous with so much detail! Huge hit at the shower! One young mom sent us a picture when she got home of her 5-year old daughter, who is a B&B fan, eating one of the Belle's dress cookies! Not only were the cookies beautiful to look at, they tasted good too! Too often I've had "special" cookies at events that were visually appealing but tasted like cardboard. Mama's cookies did not disappoint; they were enjoyable to eat as well!

Caitlin R.

Ordered 25 elephant cookies for my sister-in-law's Sprinkle. Took a risk ordering from here since I've never used them before, but the cookies were adorable and delicious. On top of that, Rosemarie was easy to work with and very responsive. Glad I took the risk! Would definitely use them again.

Eva Y.

Mama's specializes in custom cookies. They make the most delectable tasting cookies!!! Designs are amazing. Service is phenomenal. I would highly recommend them! Rosemarie is a pleasure!!!

I can't not rave about this business enough! Not only did they add a custom date to the Jameson bottle and match all the frosting to the beautiful hand drawn ones -- but the cookies were the best tasting cookie I've ever had!! People are still talking about them and they were 100% the highlight of the party. Also so easy to work with. Could not recommend enough!

Joann K.

This review is overdue. I found out about Mama's Custom Cookies from a friend. I was looking for a party favor that people would enjoy and not throw away. I'm so happy I went with Mama's. I received so many compliments on the cookies. The design is exactly what I asked for, the cookies were beautiful, the price was competitive and they were delicious! I will definitely use Mama's in the future.

See all

D S.

0

9

2

3 months ago

Ordered 50, very fancy/detailed cookies for a bridal shower and cannot say enough positive things about our communication, interaction, the quality of the end product and the taste of the cookie. Each one was perfection from icing to wrapping to ribbon. Bonus was that they were delicious !! Thank you co much.. No pictures because ALL the cookies were snatched up before I could get one. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Angela L.

Elite 21

85

186

357

3 years ago

The cutest fire truck cookies for my son's 4th birthday! Customer service was great and the whole process was super simple. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Loraine P.

1

4

1

4 years ago

I requested a custom made cookie for my daughters baby shower. The cookie mad for me was just perfect. Not only is the artistry beautiful but the cookie itself was delicious. I highly recommend Mama's Custom Cookies! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Melissa G.

26

9

6

2 years ago

Easy to order and pick up. Great local business! Have ordered twice now, for a bachelorette party and business opening. Not only do the cookies look perfect, they taste amazing. My photos don't do them justice! read more

Mama's Custom Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Business owner information

Rosemarie D.

Thank you so much for your wonderful 5-star review! We're thrilled to…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda B.

140

14

13

4 years ago

It was an absolute pleasure working with Rosemary! She answers emails right away, which is so important when you're trying to coordinate vendors. And the cookies came out AMAZING! Usually when you get fancy sugar cookies they're pretty but don't taste great. These were delicious and absolutely gorgeous. They were such a hit at our party, we had several guests comes up to us to ask us if we had an extra that they could take home. I sent mama's several pictures of my vision and wrote down some of my ideas and she literally translated what was in my mind onto the cookie! It was my first time ordering from here and I will stick with them from now on. Blown away! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erica B.

Elite 26

8

227

178

6 years ago

My saving grace for a cookie emergency. I totally forgot to order cookie favors for a party I was hosting and it was two days before the party. I called and went to at least 5 bakeries to find out they all need a weeks notice to do something like this. I then called mama's custom cookies who said they were busy, but could help me in this short notice. I was so relieved. Their cookies are great tasting and reasonably priced. The quality is spectacular and they pay attention to every detail. Each cookie I received you can tell was treated and designed with care. I was so happy with my experience with Mama's custom cookies. Thank you! read more

Mama's Custom Cookies - Look how perfect the cookie matches the decor and napkin. All favors were individually wrapped and tasted amazing. - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ivee G.

75

38

15

5 years ago

I recently ordered cookies for my baby shower and they were perfect! They were made well, they were delicious and professionally packed (no broken or chipped cookies). Also, they were quick with responding to my questions....I wanted a different color so I reached out and I received a response within hours. Great cookies and customer service!! Highly recommend! read more

Mama's Custom Cookies - a baby shower cookie - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Mama's Custom Cookies - a heart shaped cookie - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Mama's Custom Cookies - congratulations cookies for a baby shower - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarita P.

Elite 21

99

259

164

5 years ago

I ordered twenty four custom cookies from Mama's for my baby shower. I showed one of the employees a few sample pictures of what I wanted and was assured that the staff would be able replicate them. Upon receiving my order, I noted that the color on a few of the cookies was different than what I'd requested, however - the remaining sets were almost identical. The cookies although pricey, were very cute and tasted pretty good. I was proud to display them on my dessert table and guests were happy to take them home at the end of the party. read more

Mama's Custom Cookies - Little cutie inspired cookies - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dawn M.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Delicious cookies, wonderful customer service, spotless store and just great all around. Do not hesitate in placing your order. You will not be disappointed. Grateful to have found this shop! read more

Business owner information

Rosemarie D.

Thank you so much for your incredibly kind words and glowing review!…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pat M.

0

6

1

4 years ago

After seeing the beautiful cookies produced by Mama's on their Instagram page, I emailed Rosemarie on a Saturday night not expecting a reply until Monday, but I received a response shortly afterward. She answered all my questions and made a suggestion of a different set of cookies that were not shown on the Instagram page to go along with my Beauty & Beast theme for a bridal shower. I loved her suggestion, and the cookies were gorgeous with so much detail! Huge hit at the shower! One young mom sent us a picture when she got home of her 5-year old daughter, who is a B&B fan, eating one of the Belle's dress cookies! Not only were the cookies beautiful to look at, they tasted good too! Too often I've had "special" cookies at events that were visually appealing but tasted like cardboard. Mama's cookies did not disappoint; they were enjoyable to eat as well! read more

Mama's Custom Cookies - Beauty & Beast themed Bridal Shower - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Caitlin R.

9

19

10

7 years ago

Ordered 25 elephant cookies for my sister-in-law's Sprinkle. Took a risk ordering from here since I've never used them before, but the cookies were adorable and delicious. On top of that, Rosemarie was easy to work with and very responsive. Glad I took the risk! Would definitely use them again. read more

Mama's Custom Cookies - Elephant cookies for baby boy Sprinkle - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristen L.

Elite 26

364

240

165

7 years ago

While I personally did not order/pay for the cookies from here, I did have the pleasure to receive and eat one. My office ordered custom cookies for employee appreciate day and they were the most adorable thing ever. Each cookie you could tell must have taken so much time, and there were a whole bunch of variations. They were in the shape of our companies logo and incorporated our companies colors, and they had a little note like "We appreciate you" written on them on icing. It was such a nice treat to get at work. Everyone that sits around me has varied versions, so you could really tell how detailed these were. They looked like the kind of cookies that are strictly pretty and end up being hard as a rock and taste bad, but these were not like that at all. They were delicious. The cookie and the icing were soft and the tasted so good! I wish I had another one, but they were so big, itfilled me up. These cookies are great for branding, events, a party favor or anything really. I want to order them for events in the future!! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eva Y.

Elite 21

53

128

386

8 years ago

Mama's specializes in custom cookies. They make the most delectable tasting cookies!!! Designs are amazing. Service is phenomenal. I would highly recommend them! Rosemarie is a pleasure!!! read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sara M.

0

22

10

5 years ago

I can't not rave about this business enough! Not only did they add a custom date to the Jameson bottle and match all the frosting to the beautiful hand drawn ones -- but the cookies were the best tasting cookie I've ever had!! People are still talking about them and they were 100% the highlight of the party. Also so easy to work with. Could not recommend enough! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristina W.

0

6

0

5 years ago

The "Eggs Hatching October 2021" cookies for my daughter's pregnancy announcement at Easter were absolutely perfect! Adorable! Delivered very fast and well packaged - no breakage. The family announcement was a success and my daughter loved them! Thanks!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa N.

0

2

0

3 years ago

what an absolute pleasure it is deal with rosemary at mama's custom cookies. they make every occasion that much more special! not only are the cookies delicious and beautiful; but the customer service is outstanding. read more

Business owner information

Rosemarie D.

This review made our day! We are so grateful for your kind words.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joann K.

Elite 15

27

156

365

9 years ago

This review is overdue. I found out about Mama's Custom Cookies from a friend. I was looking for a party favor that people would enjoy and not throw away. I'm so happy I went with Mama's. I received so many compliments on the cookies. The design is exactly what I asked for, the cookies were beautiful, the price was competitive and they were delicious! I will definitely use Mama's in the future. read more

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Melissa L.

0

1

8 years ago

Mama's Custom Cookies made beautiful unicorn cookies for my daughter's 6th birthday. The girls at the party were so excited when they got them and the parents also raved about how incredible they looked and tasted. Everyone's face truly lit up. Behind the scenes, Mama's Custom Cookies went out of their way to accommodate me when we realized I mistakenly gave the wrong date for the party. Even though their schedule was already booked solid and it was my error, they stayed late and worked overtime to get the cookies done on time for the party. Thank you so much! read more

Mama's Custom Cookies - Unicorn Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

T V.

1

6

0

7 years ago

I ordered some of the construction themed cookies for my son's 3rd bday as he absolutely loves tractors. I needed them shipped to Westchester and was so happy when I came home the day before the party and they were nicely packaged and waiting for me. We were pleasantly surprised that they also tasted great. It's been my experience that many bakers put so much focus on the aesthetics that they don't deliver on the taste. These were beautiful and yummy! I will definitely order from here in the future. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Karen F.

0

2

0

7 years ago

We had my daughter's wedding shower yesterday and the Sunflower cookies Rosemary made were not only beautiful, they were delicious!!! I hate when cookies only look pretty. NOT THE CASE HERE. AMAZING COOKIES. What a pleasure to work with. I can't wait to use them again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Felicia O.

0

5

0

8 years ago

I've been ordering cookies from Mama's for years now. Every time is exceptional!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Doloes P.

74

7

0

12 years ago

Mama's Custom Cookies are the best, they look awesome and taste great. I have ordered from Mama's Custom Cookies many times. Have given them as gifts, people love them. Rosemarie is very personable and gets your cookie order done on time. I wouldn't order from any one else. She is Number One for Cookies read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Craig P.

0

12

0

11 years ago

Great cookies ! Rosemarie did a great job on my daughter's Sweet 16 cookies that were a 1920's themed cookie. They were very popular and disappeared off the candy cart as soon as they came out. On another occasion she made Sesame Street character cookies that I gave to a friend of mine in Lancaster Pa. My friend loved them and placed a subsequent order. read more

Business owner information

Rosemarie D.

It is always a pleasure to work with you Craig. I am so happy to…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Mama's Custom Cookies

3335A Park Ave
Wantagh, NY 11793
Directions
(516) 670-2768
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.mamascustomcookies.com

Hours

What time does Mama's Custom Cookies open?

Mama's Custom Cookies opens at 10:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.

What time does Mama's Custom Cookies close?

Mama's Custom Cookies closes at 5:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Mama's Custom Cookies is closed on Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Fri 10:00 AM - 5:00 PMSat-Sun Closed

Payment methods

Does Mama's Custom Cookies take Bitcoin?

No, Mama's Custom Cookies does not take Bitcoin.

Does Mama's Custom Cookies take credit cards?

Yes, Mama's Custom Cookies takes credit cards.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Mama's Custom Cookies have bike parking?

Yes, Mama's Custom Cookies has bike parking.

Does Mama's Custom Cookies have parking?

Yes, Mama's Custom Cookies has parking options.

Other Amenities

Is Mama's Custom Cookies wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Mama's Custom Cookies is wheelchair accessible.

From the Business

Specialties

Mama's Custom Cookies - A delicious treat for any occasion. We create custom decorated sugar cookies for your special day. Allow Mama's Custom Cookies design team to create delicious homemade custom decorated cookies to give as gifts or favors for your special occasion.

History

Established in 2012.

Mama always enjoyed being creative. Her background is in graphic arts. One day a friend asked Mama to create a custom cookie. Mama welcomed the opportunity. Once Mama's friend shared the cookies at an event Mama started receiving several calls to have custom cookies created for other events. That is how Mama's Custom Cookies LLC was created. Our company is based on the belief that our customers' needs are of the utmost importance. Mama's team is committed to meeting those needs. As a result, a high percentage of our business is from repeat customers and referrals. We would welcome the opportunity to earn your trust and deliver you the best service in the industry.

Meet the Business Owner: Rosemarie D.

Rosemarie DeMaio has a Bachelors Degree in Graphic Design and Interactive Media Design.

More Info

Health Score

Review Highlights - Mama's Custom Cookies

“Rosemarie did a great job on my daughter's Sweet 16 cookies that were a 1920's themed cookie.”

Mentioned in 5 reviews

You might also consider

Sweet Spot Cafe

4.9

(26 reviews)

1.1 mi

Wanted something sweet after my sushi dinner and found this nearby. Excellent gelato enjoyed the…read morepistachio very much, perfect after dinner spot would return if in the area.

This is an awesome spot! Candy/ice cream store on steroids!…read more As the name says they have all things sweets. Candy, cakes, ice cream, floats and more. Toppings and different cones etc. There's candy options are in the back of the store. There's seating inside and outside as well. There's not dedicated lot but street parking was available when I was here. The gentleman working the counter that day was super nice and patient with questions and our group taking our time to decide as there's alot to chose from! Awesome vibe here. Great snack or dessert spot. I'll definitely be back!

Photos

See all

Spoons Ice Cream & Cereal Bar

One of the best ice cream shops on Long Island!! They have ice cream infused with so many types of…read morecereal. My favorite is the Krispie Kat without rice Krispie treats. It's a perfect mix of M&Ms, Kit Katz, and Frosted Flakes. Spoons is not your typical ice cream shop, it's a walk up window behind cara mia restaurant. It is definitely worth a trip. I highly recommend checking them out.

This spot never gets old. I love how endless the combos are- I always try different mix-ins when I…read morecome and it never disappoints. The staff is so helpful and friendly too! Also the prices are so great for a substantial sized dessert. This place is such a treat in the summer.

Photos

Ice Cream Swirl w/ Reeses Pieces, Oreos, & a Toasted Marshmellow

See all

The Worst Cookie Company and Smoothie Cafe

5.0

(7 reviews)

0.1 mi

Super yummy goodness!…read more We first tried this spot via Too Good To Go and were immediately hooked! The mango cheesecake cookie is incredible. The PB blondie was top notch. Everything is fresh and delicious! It's a small counter inside a smoothie shop since I believe they're just starting out. I can see this tiny company going places!

I was unfamiliar with the neighborhood and wanted to google the area to see what I could explore…read more I see a funny name - The Worst Cookie Company! lol! Not too many reviews yet because they just opened in Feb. of 2022. (And this is May 2022) Very small inside and shares the space with a smoothie place. I walk in and the girl greeted me warmly, and patiently told me about all the cookies in the display cases. I bought 5 - 2 chocolate chip, a cannoli filled, chocolate with raspberry, some kind of crumb cake square. OMG!!! When I got home, my mom inhaled the cannoli! The chocolate with the raspberry is excellent! They are big and a bit heavy, so I eat just half at a time. They are moist, not greasy, not dry. I will have to go back! I think they have brownies? But not that day. Have limited hours.

Photos

Chocolate Peanbut butter cookies

Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Sandwiche

See all

Rice Krispy Treat Chocoalte Chip Cookies

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar

This is an old school ice cream shop across the parking lot from All American burger…read more The line was out the door over 4th of July weekend but the staff was prepared. The ice cream was delicious but a tad expensive. For a treat, it was worth it.

Marshalls used to give good portions for the high price, but Now their portions are so small in…read morelarge containers, just not worth it. Seems other reviewers had similar experiences. They make the argument that their product is homemade with quality . I agree that it does taste good, just not enough for the price. I am Long time customer, that will be going to competitors more often to get my money's worth. Shame...

Photos

Vanilla chocolate chip

See all

Ice cream with whipped cream and cherries

Dolcezza

4.4

(10 reviews)

2.8 mi

How cute are these lattes?! tried some holiday drinks && I'm totally obsessed! Coffee is so…read moredelicious, they both taste so good and I love being able to taste the strong espresso as well! They have such great coffee and fresh whip cream which is absolutely 10 out of 10 So cute inside too! Make sure to stop by!!

Went in and the place was empty on June Tuesday @ 540, and I know why. I ordered 2 small gelatos,…read moreno toppings, etc. The scoops we very small, kid size, in fact and it was $11.20!!! That is insane pricing. The taste was well below average. The girl working there was sitting on a comfy chair, doing absolutely nothing. She was polite, but i felt sorry for her, with no business coming on. This place needs to close or lower their prices. It is definitely not worth stopping in.

Photos

See all

Capri Bakery

We go on great Italian bakery hunts whenever we go into NY. We visited a bakery earlier in the day…read morethat will remained nameless here, and had disappointing pastries. Our main goal is always to find a fabulous cannoli- they failed- but Capri did not. Capri had delicious cannolis! We bought two big boxes of cannolis and ate them for three days after we drove back to our home state. We also bought a box of an assortment of pastries and cookies. They tasted good every day. We would definitely return. We didn't give 5 starts because the bakery itself lacks a little quaintness and magic. It's a bit generic and bland and could use some refreshing and imagination.

When I visit NY from GA I take some of these treats back! Absolutely delicious! Everything is fresh!read more

Photos

See all

The French Workshop

Very cute, bright and sophisticated French bakery that operates more like a cafe. I don't expect…read moreplaces like this in my hometown, so I was happy surprised when I was looking for a place to meet a colleague that was close to my father's house. And they have a few vegan options! Don't expect macarons nor tarts, but that blueberry croissant I had was so delicious. It was more of a whole grain pastry than a traditional buttery croissant but because the blueberry filling was so sweet, I was happy for a less decadent pastry. I love that they have a nice array of coffee and matcha drinks too. I'm pretty sure the word has been out for some time now, but when that Starbucks line in the parking lot is just too much, The French Workshop is a better option (however, on a rainy Saturday in May, that line inside was considerable. People know what's good!) There's plenty of seating, too and if you are good at pretending, you almost feel you're in Europe (ignore the suburban strip mall that surrounds you).

I was just there today with a friend for coffee at 530pm. By 723pm a girl walks in with a big…read morebull dog, she plants her dog with its duty hole and balls resting on the seat to us was utterly disgusting. Children and other customers sit in these seats. How is it that management says nothing?? When are we going to stop praising the dog as the go anywhere animal and allow others separation and peace? Something should have been done. I didnt appreciate it. The Review Guru* Long Island NY

Photos

Croissant with Pistachio Cream

Outside tables

See all

Espresso bar area

Bongo Burrito

4.1

(66 reviews)

1.3 mi

I ate everything and forgot to take pictures! While driving I never pay attention to the store…read morefronts, I only saw this while I was looking for a parking in the lot to go to Charlie's Pharmacy nearby. Hidden gem to me, well worth it. You'll have a light and hearty meal with small plates that are quick to your table, take my word for it. Chicken burger taco was great and had a nice sauce on it. If you like pork on your fork, the carnitas taco was delicious. These tacos came packed with a decent portion inside. Not too much where the taco falls apart, but more than plenty for you not to complain. I'm coming back for more small bites to eat. Good: -Pork Carnitas Taco -Chicken Burger Taco -Yuca Fries -In addition to the waitress, bus boys were fast with napkin requests and plate removal Bad: -Parking lot behind the restaurant can be crowded but be patient

Food 20/10 Ambiance: Perfectly unique…read moreService: Fantastic!! My boyfriend and I went to Bongo Burrito on a Saturday night at around 7, we didn't make a reservation. We sat at the bar and got a drink while we waited. The bartender was friendly and one of the owners, Joe greeted as soon as we walked in. He knew my boyfriend from high school. Soon enough, we were sat at a cool picnic style table which could probably fit 6-8 people! I forgot our server's name but she was very sweet! I got a watermelon margarita and the drinks were definitely generous to us! The atmosphere is really unique and interesting. Spacious, and not too loud. For those who read my reviews you know I'm a salsa girl! Chips & Salsa: Nice kick in the flavor, not too chunky, not too loose. Delicious!! They also had bottled sauces on the table. The Mango Habanero was a favorite of the two, they also had Green Habanero which was good as well! Appetizer: I was excited to try the Mexi Mac N' Cheese. The ghost pepper cheddar sauce was NIIIICEEE and the chorizo and peppers gave it an awesome flavor. Meals: I ordered the Birria Quesadilla which came in the best plate I've ever seen. I'm definitely a "dipper" so it was great to get a side of pico, guacamole and sour cream. The consommé was superb! The quesadilla itself wasn't overpowered by either meat or cheese. Really nice balance - which is key to an amazing quesadilla, like this one. My boyfriend got Kandi's Chimichanga and when I say it's huge I mean it's HUGE! I tried and liked it a lot. He ate as much as he could and was more than satisfied. The boom boom sauce was insane also. I loved the outside area. I can't wait to visit again and try the coconut shrimp appetizer and much more! Awesome spot. Definitely will be recommending this place.

Photos

They have an awesome selfie machine (which I suppose is just called a "camera") You can post to social or text it

Guac

See all

Cauliflower tacos. Mouth wateringly delish.

The Cup Coffeehouse

After a day at the beach, I desperately needed a coffee before heading over to a friend's house in…read moreJericho. Every cafe seems to close at 4pm on Sunday in LI, but we found The Cup Coffeehouse on Google. Staff were incredibly nice and we got about 6 drinks to go. The vanilla matcha was really good and the Americano that I had was also great. My husband had a frozen hot chocolate and I liked that one was well. I'm not usually a hot chocolate fan, but this one wasn't too sweet. All in all, a great spot that's open late for coffee and drinks!

This is a cool spot to get late night coffee and meet with friends. How many coffee shops do you…read moreknow that only open starting at 6 pm?

Photos

The drinks

CDs

See all

Tweedle Dee Milkshake

Krisch's Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlour

Massapequa Foodie Find: Krisch's Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlor If you're looking for a fun family…read morespot with amazing food, this is it! The kids' cheeseburger comes on a fun car-shaped plate that was a huge hit, and it even comes with ice cream and sprinkles for dessert! I ordered the classic cheeseburger with their special sauce, and it was pure perfection. It's the perfect local spot with great nostalgia and even better food. I've got to be honest, I absolutely loved the food and desserts, but the service was just okay. I'd like to think it was only because they were very busy, but our waitress didn't check on us a single time, even though she consistently checked on the tables right next to us ‍. I had to go out of my way to catch her attention just to get the extra sauce I needed, and I eventually had to ask a completely different staff member to get sprinkles for our dessert. Si están buscando un lugar familiar, divertido y con comida increíble, ¡es aquí! La hamburguesa con queso para niños viene servida en un divertido plato con forma de carrito que a los niños les fascinó, ¡y además incluye helado con chispas (sprinkles) de postre! Yo pedí la hamburguesa con queso clásica con su salsa especial y fue pura perfección. Es el lugar local ideal, lleno de nostalgia y con una comida aún mejor. Tengo que ser honesta: me encantó la comida y los postres, pero el servicio estuvo regular (just ok). Quisiera pensar que fue solo porque el lugar estaba muy lleno, pero la mesera no se acercó a nuestra mesa ni una sola vez, a pesar de que sí estaba al pendiente de las mesas de al lado ‍. Tuve que hacer señas para llamar su atención solo para pedir una salsa extra que necesitaba, y al final tuve que pedirle a otro empleado que nos trajera las chispas (sprinkles) para el postre

If I can give negative stars I would! Went for my son's elementary graduation. It was only 3 of us…read moreand plenty of open tables. We ordered and an hour later I had to get up and hunt down the waitress who informed me that the kitchen was backed up, she came to our table 10 minutes later and said I think they are working on your order and my son ordered a lemonade....20 minutes later no lemonade, no waitress and no food I would have approved the manager but she was fighting with another customer and very rude to everyone We walked out. No one even cared. Always wanted to try but now I will never return

Photos

Inside

Krisch's Our Famous Seasoned 1/2 lb. Hamburger Deluxe

See all

Scoops & Cones Cafe

4.7

(52 reviews)

1.6 mi

Very good I go here after buying comic books and it is so good they have so many optionsread more

I was dying for an Italian ice and since it's winter many of the local pizzerias didn't have any…read more My boyfriend came here and ordered me a rainbow. He said the service was excellent and that they offered a variety of cereals on countless ice cream options. When I ate the Italian ice I was so pleasantly surprised! Soo tasty and fresh and the cherry had actual cherrys inside!!! My new favorite place to go for an Italian ice. Soo happy to find this gem!

Photos

Peanut Butter Banana Sundae

See all

Lulu's Organic Juice Bar

4.8

(25 reviews)

0.1 mi

Nice little juice bar and healthy eatery. Now I've only had the health shots and wheat grass, but…read morethe food looks good. Owner is nice and owns a spot in Lindenhurst as well. Shop is nice and clean and also has some grocery shelves filled of dietary products.

LOVE Lindenhurst location & still recommend to friends & strangers alike. For years I have driven…read moreover 15 minutes on a regular basis for smoothies, juice, & food, with minimal dissatisfaction. WANTED to love this location 1 minute from my house, unfortunately it has not provided the same experience. Service is hit or miss, some staff has come from Lindenhurst but a lot are new & do not make consistent menu items. For the cost, being happy with the end product is expected. Have also had to wait an eternity for pre-ordered items. Similar & more consistent options available in the vicinity. Plenty of parking in the lot out front, additional parking in back. Entrance in back as well.

See all

Bagel Corner

4.2

(11 reviews)

1.3 mi

These bagels are great! They differ from other bagel places with one major difference you will see…read moreright away, that is, turn your seasoned bagel over, check both sides and you will see the difference, that most places make their bagels with one side covered in seasonings, this place makes sure both sides of their bagels are heavily seasoned. What ever recipe they use in both regular and egg bagels, they are delicious. Their breakfast specials are not only easy on the wallet but also filling and tasty. The staff is friendly and very helpful. They will take the extra step to make sure your order is done to your satisfaction. Special orders like large orders of mini bagels done in all your favorite seasonings is not a problem. The management is experienced to make sure you are satisfied. If you haven't tried them, get over there and give them a shot, you won't be disappointed. There is limited seating inside but you will be made to feel at home if you should find seating to enjoy your eat in order.

We used to love this place when it first opened. The girl behind the counter was so friendly. She…read morewas so sweet to the kids and families coming in. She left. Now the owner runs it ?!? He's so grumpy, the food is not as good. My husband likes to put bacon on his cc bagel. I asked for it on the side so it didn't get soggy. They charged me $5 to have 3 strips of bacon on the side. That made a cc bagel with bacon $10. Yeah.. going back to Bcafe and waiting on that line bc i'd rather 30 min than rude and overpriced

Photos

See all

Outside parking lot

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Melissa C.

0

2

0

11 years ago

Mama's Custom Cookies created over 1,500 custom cookies for several corporate events I managed last week. Not only were the cookies beautiful, but they tasted great too, and Rosemarie is a delight to work with. I'd highly recommend her work to anyone looking for customized desserts. read more

Karen C.

0

3

0

11 years ago

I love giving Mama an idea of what I'm looking for and then letting her create! Sweet 16, sports, anniversary, get well, congrats, holidays, we look for occasions that we can order cookies for :). And they're not just beautiful, they're delicious, too!! read more

Carla S.

0

3

0

11 years ago

Highly recommend! The owner was fantastic to work with. She did an amazing job creating my son's 1st birthday cookies. Her detail work is beautiful and the cookies taste as good as they look. I will be sure to order from Mama again very soon. read more

H M.

0

2

0

11 years ago

Mama's Cookies are the best. Taste as good as they look. The owner is fantastic. I have used her several times and will be using them again this month for my dd birthday. read more

Angela C.

1

4

1

11 years ago

Great to work with! Creative and the cookies are absolutely delicious! I will be working with them again for sure.

Lyric D.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Rosemarie is always professional and a pleasure to work with. The store is clean and well put together.

David F.

0

1

0

11 years ago

Ordered 4th of July cookies. Looked great and tasted great. Family is hooked.

Becca G.

0

2

0

11 years ago

pleasure to do business with!

Mama's Custom Cookies - desserts - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Mama's Custom Cookies also viewed

Thin Cookies

4.7

(64 reviews)

If you're in Hicksville, this place is a must-visit! They…read morebake their thin, crisp, incredibly delicious cookies right in front of you. There's a brief wait while they prepare your order fresh, but watching them make your cookies is part of the charm. They have tons of great flavors and delicious drinks like hot chocolate to pair with them. Great vibe, fun experience, and amazing treats. Good luck keeping any left by the time you drive home!

We were driving around Hicksville killing some time between events and drove by "Thin Cookies"…read more Curiosity got the better of me and I made a U Turn and dropped in. Ambience - feels like a utilitarian kitchen or company lunch room. The kitchen is clearly visible in the open layout and you can watch the staff making the cookie dough. Food: we ordered the 6 cookie box. I asked for Peanut Butter, but they ran out. I settled for chocolate chip and Kit Kat. The cookies were all thin, leading me to think it would be brittle like a cracker. I was pleasantly surprised that they were so soft and chewy. Must be the butter! TL/DR: thin cookies creates small portion cookies that don't make you feel guilty when you eat more than one.

A Pound & A Half:Cookies & Cupcakes

5.0

(2 reviews)

I was looking to find a special way to send my mother some treats on Mother's Day and I stumbled…read moreupon Pound and a Half. If you are looking to send a special treat to someone in your life do yourself a favor and reach out to Alyssa. She responds very quickly and is very open to working with you and getting your input on what you want while giving her advice based on her experience. I ordered a tray of cupcakes assembled into the shape of flowers and a tray of brownies. They looked amazing and were also very delicious. The cupcake was moist and tasty but not too sweet which is exactly what I was looking for. We got a mix of the chocolate and vanilla and I don't think you could go wrong with either. The tray of brownies was made so well, it had walnuts and the outside of the brownie was nice and crisp but the inside was moist and delicious. We got a medium size tray that came with so many that we put them in the fridge and they were even better when we popped them in the microwave for 20 seconds the next day. Huge thumbs up to Alyssa and Pound and a Half!

Alyssa is a great baker, is amazing and such a pleasure to deal with. She made these wonderful…read morecupcakes for my daughters bday party and they were a hit with the kids and adults. We also purchased a mini brownie platter from her and all that was left was the tray, no crumbs.

Batter Up Bakery

4.3

(92 reviews)

I was only inside this bakery for a few minutes to hand-deliver some literature the day before…read moreEaster, but WOW!...The look and aroma of their cakes, pastries, and donuts hit me like very few bakeries do these days. I look forward to returning as a customer (I am from Syosset) very soon. They seem very friendly and, based on the line outside the store, very popular in the neighborhood. 'GREAT to know there's still a place to get this kind of baked goods in the general vicinity of my hometown.

My sister in law order a birthday cake for her dad. The strawberry shortcake was very good. Cake…read morewas moist and whipped vanilla frosting. We would check this bakery out.

Smallcakes - Syosset

4.4

(89 reviews)

This is one of my favorite dessert spots in Syosset…read more Pros: + Amazing cupcake flavors - the peanut butter cup by far is my favorite + Cupcake smash is my go to by far + Great selection of baseline flavors + Rotating daily flavors too! I love that there are several seasonal ones + Friendly staff - generous portions Cons: - Limited seating inside IG: QueenOfAdventureNYC

I love these cupcakes so much that I chose them for my birthday celebration this year. We don't…read morelive near here, but we happened to be celebrating with family on L.I. this year, and this is what I chose. Specifically, I ate 1/2 of the hot fudge sundae cupcake that I shared with my grandson, and I also had 1/2 of the peanut butter chocolate. Two excellent flavors. So much flavor and so incredibly fresh and moist. LOVE THIS PLACE !!

Gemmies

5.0

(5 reviews)

I ordered a bunch of cookies and bread from Gemmies for a party I hosted and it turned out they…read more were the most popular items there. People kept asking me where I got those delicious ricotta cookies from and they absolutely loved the apple pie. It's rare to find a bakery that focuses on taste as well as the quality of the ingredients. I will definitely recommend Gemmies to all of my friends and family. Its going to be our go-to bakery from now on.

i've only had their English muffins but if they are an indication of the rest of their output,…read moreterrific. Chewy, textured with a sort of stone mill flavor. They come individually wrapped so they stay fresh and can be kept in freezer until use. Tried Citarella's which are good, too, but these have a distinctive real bread taste... perhaps it's the yeast.. Highly recommend.

Crumbl - Levittown

3.9

(177 reviews)

•$$$

The best Cookies hands down. Service is quick and efficient establishment is always clean.read more

Crumbl is another popular cookie shop that serves more than just cookies. Over the years their…read morerotating menu has now included other desserts in addition to cookies such as cakes, pies and brownie creations. Some flavors I find can be either hit or miss depending what it is. I recently like the Martha Stewart collection they released this week. There was a special deal they were also giving out two chocolate chip cookie thins for free. The thins were perfectly soft and chewy. Just enough saltiness to the sweet. The coconut layer cake had light fluffy layers like a cloud. It was just enough sweetness with layers of light creme and shredded coconut and toasted coconut on top. Service from the employees is usually good. They greet every person who enter the store saying welcome to the store. So always a great customer service experience.

Special Sweets

5.0

(1 review)

I have ordered from these guys several times, and have been amazed each time. The mini cupcakes are…read moreperfect for class parties as everyone can get one or two without feeling like they are too much sugar. They taste so good! Even the non chocolate lovers in my family are known to enjoy a piece. Ordering is easy and they're very responsive to emails. Lastly, the amazing cause it supports makes these treats just that much sweeter.

Sunflower Bake Shop

4.4

(12 reviews)

The best cake you will have. The icing and chocolate cake are the best I've had. Such a good…read moretexture and sweetness level. You would never know it's gluten free. Even so, this beats all cakes with gluten.

Ok so I saw Sunflower shop on Yelp. It is in West Hempstead a store in the middle section with…read morenarrow streets and difficult parking or turning around. Many minutes later parked the car and went to the shop which notes open until 8pm and call if door not open. I went, it was closed O(see pix) I called and left a message. I did some shopping in a few other stores in the area and then left. More than two hours later I got a phone reply that they were out. Clearly. Must be a business landline. What I was told from one of the other merchants is that they take orders and do very nice specialty cakes. They also have their own agenda of when they are there and not. So for other bakery needs go to the bakery down the block at Riesterer"s. I did. I can not say how good Sunflower bakery foods are. If I should have a need for some particular specialty cake that another bakery can't make, I could always their number. Other than that I have nothing else to say,

Sweet Karma Desserts

4.3

(176 reviews)

•$$

I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with this bakery! From the knowledable staff to the…read morequick responses to all of my questions and their patience, they created the perfect cake for my baby's first birthday. I will be back over and over again. Not only was the cake magnificently beautiful, it was also delicious. I was able to get two different flavors for the tiers as well. One flavor was chocolate with salted caramel and the other was vanilla with chocolate mousse. My guests kept coming back for more. The cake shop is small and located in a shopping center 5 minutes from my house. It's decorated with their beautiful cakes and they sell some desserts as well as create custom. When I picked up the cake, they even went out of their way to teach me how to properly transport it as well as cut it. I will be running back

We ordered a two tier cake for my baby shower, and six gluten free cupcakes. I had a very specific…read morevision, dripping pink icing and fake flowers cascading down the cake and some pink cupcakes with little ghosts. Sweet Karma made a beautiful cake and cupcakes beyond what I expected! And to top it off it was delicious. All the guests ranted about how good it was. Delivery was also fantastic, on time and very helpful. Thank you so much.

Mario's Bakery

3.3

(132 reviews)

•$$

Visit Date: January 3, 2024…read more I came here with my family after we ate breakfast at the diner for my dad's birthday. I looked around at all the offerings and finally chose one of my usual favorites a linzer tart. When I ate it later in the day it was good but kind of dry. I don't know if that's the bakery's fault though in general these pastries are on the dry side. I also ate it much later in the day when it was less fresh instead of eating it right away so that could have been it too. I would come back to this bakery again!

Ran in here at the last moment for large cupcakes. I had to stop myself from ordering extra items…read morebecause the turnovers were calling my name. The friendly young lady boxed up my order quickly. The bakery was smelling delicious and was fully stocked with cookies, pops, and cakes.

Mama's Custom Cookies

Mama's Custom Cookies Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mama's Custom Cookies

Reviews With Photos

More info about Mama's Custom Cookies

Payment methods

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Mama's Custom Cookies

Review Highlights - Mama's Custom Cookies

You might also consider

More businesses like Mama's Custom Cookies

Sweet Spot Cafe

Spoons Ice Cream & Cereal Bar

The Worst Cookie Company and Smoothie Cafe

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar

Dolcezza

Capri Bakery

The French Workshop

Bongo Burrito

The Cup Coffeehouse

Krisch's Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlour

Trending businesses in Mama's Custom Cookies's area

Scoops & Cones Cafe

Lulu's Organic Juice Bar

Bagel Corner

8 Mama's Custom Cookies reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

Mama's Custom Cookies - desserts - Updated August 2026

Best of Wantagh

People found Mama's Custom Cookies by searching for…

Trending Searches in Wantagh, NY

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Wantagh, NY

People who viewed Mama's Custom Cookies also viewed

Thin Cookies

A Pound & A Half:Cookies & Cupcakes

Batter Up Bakery

Smallcakes - Syosset

Gemmies

Crumbl - Levittown

Special Sweets

Sunflower Bake Shop

Sweet Karma Desserts

Mario's Bakery