Order Thin Cookies Takeout or Delivery
Thin Cookies Photos
Thin Cookies Popular Desserts
You might also consider
Recommended Reviews - Thin Cookies
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
I finally tried this place after seeing so many videos about it, and i'm so glad i did because these cookies are SOOO good. The prices are super reasonable, i got 12 cookies for ~$13 and each one was really good. They came warm, with a slightly crunchy exterior and a soft inside. My favorites were the double chocolate chip cookie and the regular chocolate chip, but my friend really liked the snickerdoodle. I also got the iced latte for $6, which is a really good price for Nassau County! The inside was also such a vibe i loved the yellow chairs and the vibrant interior - there was so much seating. It was also so interesting seeing how they make the cookies. I will definitely come again I am absolutely obsessed!!!
Honestly I stopped in on a whim. I was coming back to work on a lunch break and passed them wanting a little sweet treat. I didn't realize that this is the only location on the island so it intrigued me. I wanted to sample them all but opted for a 6 pack. In order of favorite to least: strawberry shortcake x 2, chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, oatmeal, and birthday. The texture on all these were nice. Thin, crispy, but also chewy in the middle. I knew the strawberry shortcake would be a home run so i picked up two, it tastes like the outside of the ice cream bar which I love. Chocolate chip was also great with bigger pockets of chocolate than I thought. I'd say the remaining three were on the same level of enjoyment. Great texture, just okay flavor but birthday was definitely the weakest of the bunch. I did like these cookies though and would like to try different ones next time.
This is my third time ordering these, and they are always a huge hit!!! I will be buying many more:))
Did you know each cookie is hand scooped, hand rolled, and weighed to ensure consistency?! This is New Yorks famous thin, soft, & chewy cookie and not to mention #viral We tried and loved: Snickerdoodle Oatmeal Raisin Chocolate Chip Double Chocolate Chip KitKat Easter Egg -- Grab a box to bring over to someone's house. The packaging is so beautiful!
Thin Cookies in Hicksville, what I like about them-fresh made, big variety, monthly changed flavors, LOTS OF HOURS of availability, friendly help. I do not go often but I do like their thin cookies from the standard chocolate chip to the more fancy ones that come out fresh and into a little divider box. Seems many have found them and there are many busy hours particularly on a late Sunday afternoon. There are lots of places to get cookies and a few shops specializing in just cookies. Yes you can buy a bag from a store or you can go in and get them while you wait. NOTE: I did note that they changed the brand of small containers of chocolate and regular milk. I also noted that I and yet another took a bottle reviewed the ingredients and put it back.
I finally got to try Thin Cookies, and the classic chocolate chip cookie was definitely my favorite! You can get them in counts of 6, 12, or 24. They also have plenty of seating if you want to dine in. I'm really looking forward to going back to try one of their coffees!
Finally found my fave cookie on Long Island. Was a fan of Insomnia as well as Levain in NYC. These are the best. Super thin and chewy. I prefer Tarra's and Tate's over any others but these are superb. Highly recommend the regular chocolate chip as well as the Double Chocolate Chip.
The cookies here are so good - thin and chewy with a slight crunch. The location is pretty large and open - you can see them making and preparing the cookies as it's basically an open area. They have tables for you to sit and enjoy the cookies as well. They have 3 flavors that's always on the menu - chocolate chip, double chocolate and snickerdoodle. They have 3 rotating flavors each month. Cookies are also not too expensive - you can get a dozen for $13.
It was my first time visiting Thin Cookies. I ordered chocolate chip, double chocolate fruity pebbles, and cardamom. I liked the chocolate chip out of all of them. The cookies are thin and crispy. It satisfied my craving for cookies.
I've been wanting to try these cookies but haven't had a chance. Someone bought these over my house for the holidays. They were a hit. Hard to imagine how a thin cookie could be so soft and flavorful! We had the snickerdoodle, chocolate chip and double chocolate cookies. They were so good! Perfect, fresh flavor. Not too sweet and addictive! My friend who bought them over said the staff was so friendly and the store itself is cute with bright yellow seating. Apparently they also have coffee as well. I'm going to have to stop in soon!!
We were greeted by a kind cashier. The area has some seating in it but was pretty empty. We opted for the box of 6 cookies. There wasn't any label on the cookies or way to identify the cookies so we had to guess what we were eating. The cookies are indeed thin and good. They have a good outer crisp but are also gooey in the inside. They are not, however, my ideal type of cookie to have. It's definitely an option if someone is looking for a good cookie and health-conscious! I looked at the nutrition info online and the servings state 48 per serving, but I'm not sure what that is referring to. Is that grams? But it was pretty good for a thin cookie!
Have been wanting to come here for awhile as I always pass it, so I was happy I finally got to try it! Shared a few different cookies in the flavors chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, Twix, and Halloween sprinkles. The cookies were thin, light, and airy. They were full of so much flavor and absolutely delicious. Plenty of seating too which I always appreciate. So happy to have this place so close to home!
Passing through Jerusalem Ave, I had to stop by and pick up some of my favorite cookies! This place is always so clean and the waft of freshly baked cookies hits you hard in the face when you walk in. They have their staple cookies and then 3 seasonal flavors. I picked up 12 cookies and could barely wait to get home! I got all 3 of their seasonal cookies with Twix being the absolute best. Their cookies are indeed thin and are crisp on the edges and chewy in the middle. Serious perfection. I haven't been here in some time and noticed they updated their packaging! They used to pack it in a box with wax paper in between the layers of cookies but now they got this whole cookie divider thingy inside the box! If my protruding gut didn't stop me, I could've devoured this entire box of 12 cookies.
2 months ago
If you're in Hicksville, this place is a must-visit! They bake their thin, crisp, incredibly delicious cookies right in front of you. There's a brief wait while they prepare your order fresh, but watching them make your cookies is part of the charm. They have tons of great flavors and delicious drinks like hot chocolate to pair with them. Great vibe, fun experience, and amazing treats. Good luck keeping any left by the time you drive home! read more
3 months ago
We were driving around Hicksville killing some time between events and drove by "Thin Cookies". Curiosity got the better of me and I made a U Turn and dropped in. Ambience - feels like a utilitarian kitchen or company lunch room. The kitchen is clearly visible in the open layout and you can watch the staff making the cookie dough. Food: we ordered the 6 cookie box. I asked for Peanut Butter, but they ran out. I settled for chocolate chip and Kit Kat. The cookies were all thin, leading me to think it would be brittle like a cracker. I was pleasantly surprised that they were so soft and chewy. Must be the butter! TL/DR: thin cookies creates small portion cookies that don't make you feel guilty when you eat more than one. read more
2 months ago
On Sunday, we decided to get some cookies. We got four more cookies and two Cosmo brownies. They were delicious. Service was good. I got my cookies within less than one minute. read more
7 months ago
I finally tried this place after seeing so many videos about it, and i'm so glad i did because these cookies are SOOO good. The prices are super reasonable, i got 12 cookies for ~$13 and each one was really good. They came warm, with a slightly crunchy exterior and a soft inside. My favorites were the double chocolate chip cookie and the regular chocolate chip, but my friend really liked the snickerdoodle. I also got the iced latte for $6, which is a really good price for Nassau County! The inside was also such a vibe i loved the yellow chairs and the vibrant interior - there was so much seating. It was also so interesting seeing how they make the cookies. I will definitely come again I am absolutely obsessed!!! read more
Honestly I stopped in on a whim. I was coming back to work on a lunch break and passed them wanting a little sweet treat. I didn't realize that this is the only location on the island so it intrigued me. I wanted to sample them all but opted for a 6 pack. In order of favorite to least: strawberry shortcake x 2, chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, oatmeal, and birthday. The texture on all these were nice. Thin, crispy, but also chewy in the middle. I knew the strawberry shortcake would be a home run so i picked up two, it tastes like the outside of the ice cream bar which I love. Chocolate chip was also great with bigger pockets of chocolate than I thought. I'd say the remaining three were on the same level of enjoyment. Great texture, just okay flavor but birthday was definitely the weakest of the bunch. I did like these cookies though and would like to try different ones next time. read more
4 months ago
This is my third time ordering these, and they are always a huge hit!!! I will be buying many more:)) read more
Did you know each cookie is hand scooped, hand rolled, and weighed to ensure consistency?! This is New Yorks famous thin, soft, & chewy cookie and not to mention #viral We tried and loved: Snickerdoodle Oatmeal Raisin Chocolate Chip Double Chocolate Chip KitKat Easter Egg -- Grab a box to bring over to someone's house. The packaging is so beautiful! read more
Thin Cookies in Hicksville, what I like about them-fresh made, big variety, monthly changed flavors, LOTS OF HOURS of availability, friendly help. I do not go often but I do like their thin cookies from the standard chocolate chip to the more fancy ones that come out fresh and into a little divider box. Seems many have found them and there are many busy hours particularly on a late Sunday afternoon. There are lots of places to get cookies and a few shops specializing in just cookies. Yes you can buy a bag from a store or you can go in and get them while you wait. NOTE: I did note that they changed the brand of small containers of chocolate and regular milk. I also noted that I and yet another took a bottle reviewed the ingredients and put it back. read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thanks so much, Mindy! We appreciate your support.
2 years ago
I finally got to try Thin Cookies, and the classic chocolate chip cookie was definitely my favorite! You can get them in counts of 6, 12, or 24. They also have plenty of seating if you want to dine in. I'm really looking forward to going back to try one of their coffees! read more
Finally found my fave cookie on Long Island. Was a fan of Insomnia as well as Levain in NYC. These are the best. Super thin and chewy. I prefer Tarra's and Tate's over any others but these are superb. Highly recommend the regular chocolate chip as well as the Double Chocolate Chip. read more
1 year ago
The cookies here are so good - thin and chewy with a slight crunch. The location is pretty large and open - you can see them making and preparing the cookies as it's basically an open area. They have tables for you to sit and enjoy the cookies as well. They have 3 flavors that's always on the menu - chocolate chip, double chocolate and snickerdoodle. They have 3 rotating flavors each month. Cookies are also not too expensive - you can get a dozen for $13. read more
1 year ago
It was my first time visiting Thin Cookies. I ordered chocolate chip, double chocolate fruity pebbles, and cardamom. I liked the chocolate chip out of all of them. The cookies are thin and crispy. It satisfied my craving for cookies. read more
1 year ago
I've been wanting to try these cookies but haven't had a chance. Someone bought these over my house for the holidays. They were a hit. Hard to imagine how a thin cookie could be so soft and flavorful! We had the snickerdoodle, chocolate chip and double chocolate cookies. They were so good! Perfect, fresh flavor. Not too sweet and addictive! My friend who bought them over said the staff was so friendly and the store itself is cute with bright yellow seating. Apparently they also have coffee as well. I'm going to have to stop in soon!! read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you, Fran! We’re so glad you were able to try our cookies over…
2 years ago
We were greeted by a kind cashier. The area has some seating in it but was pretty empty. We opted for the box of 6 cookies. There wasn't any label on the cookies or way to identify the cookies so we had to guess what we were eating. The cookies are indeed thin and good. They have a good outer crisp but are also gooey in the inside. They are not, however, my ideal type of cookie to have. It's definitely an option if someone is looking for a good cookie and health-conscious! I looked at the nutrition info online and the servings state 48 per serving, but I'm not sure what that is referring to. Is that grams? But it was pretty good for a thin cookie! read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Justine! Thank you for taking the time to visit & try our cookies. We…
8 months ago
Have been wanting to come here for awhile as I always pass it, so I was happy I finally got to try it! Shared a few different cookies in the flavors chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, Twix, and Halloween sprinkles. The cookies were thin, light, and airy. They were full of so much flavor and absolutely delicious. Plenty of seating too which I always appreciate. So happy to have this place so close to home! read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you, Ashley! We are so glad you were able to stop in and try…
Passing through Jerusalem Ave, I had to stop by and pick up some of my favorite cookies! This place is always so clean and the waft of freshly baked cookies hits you hard in the face when you walk in. They have their staple cookies and then 3 seasonal flavors. I picked up 12 cookies and could barely wait to get home! I got all 3 of their seasonal cookies with Twix being the absolute best. Their cookies are indeed thin and are crisp on the edges and chewy in the middle. Serious perfection. I haven't been here in some time and noticed they updated their packaging! They used to pack it in a box with wax paper in between the layers of cookies but now they got this whole cookie divider thingy inside the box! If my protruding gut didn't stop me, I could've devoured this entire box of 12 cookies. read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Jean, thank you for stopping in! We are so glad to hear you enjoyed…
2 years ago
This was our very first time here!!! Off a main road, Jerusalem Ave. Bright and spacious and YELLOW!!!! You can purchase them in 6, 12 or 24, to not be too greedy and to be done in one sitting, I ordered 6 for $7. Not bad considering some cookie shops charge twice that for less. You don't feel too bad about eating peanut butter crunch, double chocolate, snickerdoodle and the classic chocolate chip when each cookie is approximately 83-88 calories!!! But of course seven cookies times 83-88 can further widen those hips My friend girl liked the classic chip and the double chocolate. We also ordered drinks Mocha and pitaschio latte. A few people sauntered in and out on the Friday evening. This space was inviting and did I mention YELLOW!!!!! The music playing in the background was loud enough to hear but not interfering with conversation. Another plus, if you eat in, you can actually see the staff (two people) making the cookies. Worth the trip!!! read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you, Judith! We appreciate you making the trip to try our…
6 months ago
I found Thin Cookies through IG and had it my list to try for months! I finally took the 30 minute drive specifically for the July Pistachio special I got 1/2 dozen: 2 pistachio, strawberry shortcake, snickerdoodle, double chocolate & butter pecan. The flavor of the cookies was perfect. Tasted like you made them at home. Not too sweet but still packed the flavor considering how thin they are. Two of them were a bit undercooked (which I actually prefer) but being they're so thin they crumbled once I tried to lift them out of the box. I do like a little crunch on the outside while a little undercooked on the inside so I threw them in the air fryer when I got home to crispy them up! Definitely worth a try if you're in the area. read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you, Lauren! We’re glad you were able to try our July flavors.…
3 years ago
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you, Christine! We hope to see you again soon.
1 year ago
We LOVE thin cookies and we just put in an order for Easter! Did you know each cookie is hand scooped, hand rolled, and weighed to ensure consistency?! This is New Yorks famous thin, soft, & chewy cookie and not to mention #viral We tried and loved: Snickerdoodle Oatmeal Raisin Chocolate Chip Double Chocolate Chip KitKat Easter Egg -- Grab a box to bring over to someone's house. The packaging is so beautiful! read more
Absolutely delicious cookies. Perfectly chewy and still crispy - these cookies are probably the best I've ever had. Think Tates Cookies but buttery and without the burnt edges. The chocolate chip is a classic and the double chocolate is indulgent. Plus the owners are kind to all the customers and the space is modern and clean. read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you! We hope to see you again soon!
9 months ago
3 years ago
Woaw! Thin Cookies are thin and packed with flavor. I got this cookie during an event and it's so delicious. I didn't think a cookie this thin can be so soft and chewy. It had such nice butter taste without overly sweet chocolate chips. I wish I had more because 1 was definitely not enough. Now, I really gotta make my way to the shop! read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you! We hope you can check out our shop one day. :)
9 months ago
9 months ago
3 years ago
*** HIGHLY RECOMMENDED*** OMG EVERYONE!!!!! This Place Just Opened. These Cookies Are To Die For They are Thin Súper Soft!! Buy These Snatch them!!! Up for Yourself, Thanksgiving and Christmas Guest!! They Will Not Disappoint You!! Run Out and Get You Some!! Place Is Very Clean Staff Are Very Pleasant Kind and Sweet! You Can choose 1 Flavor Or You Can Mix Match Flavors: Chocolate Chip Snickerdoodle And Double Chocolate Located At: 425 Jerusalem Ave. Hicksville N.Y 11801 read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you!!
1 year ago
2 years ago
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you so much, Jake! We’re so happy you enjoyed our cookies!
2 years ago
Cookies are 10/10. I had the double chocolate and the sugar cookie and I am a satisfied customer and will be making an order for my next bbq. If soft and chewy with a crispy edge is your thing these won't disappoint. read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you, Kiara! We appreciate your support.
2 years ago
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you so much!
3 years ago
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you! We are so glad you liked them. You'll need to come back…
2 years ago
. Cookies are great, but I ordered a dozen and only received six. Very disappointed. Please review your order carefully! read more
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Hi Mia, we truly apologize for this oversight. We have sent you a…
2 years ago
Business owner information
Zohal R.
Thank you, Kathleen! We can’t wait to welcome you back to our shop.
Page 1 of 2
More info about Thin Cookies
425 A Jerusalem Ave
Hicksville, NY 11801
Directions
(516) 744-6911
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
https://www.thincookiesny.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Ask the Community - Thin Cookies
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
1 review that is not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
9 months ago
