I wasn't a huge pie girlie until I had pies from Briermere Farms! I like my fruits separate from my desserts but the blueberry crisp pie was very solid! The blueberries weren't too sweet or sour. The pie crust was pretty flaky without being too buttery. The chocolate cream was still my favorite pie because the filling was super tasty with a strong but not overpowering chocolate flavor. The whipped cream was fresh and wasn't too sweet either! Their rhubarb squares were also DELICIOUS! With just a tad bit of tartness, they are filled with buttery goodness and a brownie vs cake mixture. The line moved pretty quick and it was nice to be able to check out their produce while waiting. Lots of parking options. read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

A great pit stop to grab some fame fresh produce and baked goods! They have a lovely selection of seasonal produce, fresh flowers, jams, and baked goods. My only complaint is that it's a bit on the pricey side. Still, it's worth it if you're out east on the north shore. read more

See all

The jellies and jams taste like just picked fruit I just stopped in to stock up up up for the winter. Five stars read more

I'm not a pie person. Decided to get the raspberry cream pie, this is the best pie I've ever had end of story. I don't have much else to say. The fruit is fresh farm to table. The ingredients are wholesome. You can taste the difference. The consistency of the jam on the pie was perfect balancing sweetness and tart. The cream was made with real dairy and had added such a fresh contrast. The pie crust clearly had no seed oils and was a perfect pie crust the traditional way. It was on the dry side as it should be because nowadays pies are made into an oily mess of crushed graham crackers. This is just as real as it gets. A delicious pie. Farm to table. Must try. read more

If you're on the east end of Long Island and you're driving through Sound Ave to wine country, you owe it to yourself to spend $42 on this pie! I mean, look at it! And the picture really doesn't do it justice. It is fresh, creamy, with in season fresh fruit (they also have the compote version which is great too), and the crust is just awesome! This place is almost always crowded, but worth the wait. Oh, they also have a decent farm stand and other delicious baked goods too, in case they sell out of the pie. read more

Briermere Farms - Photos and captions do not do this baby justice! - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

The best pie. The raspberry cream pie is my favorite and super fresh. The cream is light and airy. I have never tasted a pie so well-balanced. The service is very fast and there are usually many cashiers working. I recommend stopping by if you are out east. read more

Briermere Farms - Raspberry Cream - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Summer/Birthday isn't official until I get my hands (and mouth) on one of Briermere Farms Blueberry Cream Pies If you've never been here, it's a lovely road trip to the east end of Long Island. It's very pretty out there, no matter which season you choose to travel. Whether you're appreciating the sunflowers in the summer or the corn in the fall, you won't be disappointed. Thanks Mamma Mia for the best gift ever read more

See all

I recently moved to Long Island and heard a lot of about this place. For some reason, I thought it was more of a sit-down and enjoy kind of establishment but it was all outdoors and it was ore of a pick-up-and-leave kind of place. Nonetheless, since I had never tried fruit pies before I was very eager. I ordered the raspberry cherry pie, as well as some pastries and vegetables. Everyone was very nice and knowledgable. The first pie I initially wanted was not currently available so I did decide to go with my second choice. I brought the pie home and ate it 5 hours later after heating it in the oven. My first bite was not love at first site. The raspberry was very strong and I could hardly taste the cherry. Everything tasted very Tart to me. As the days went on I did keep eating the pie even though I didn't love it at first - I don't like to waste food that I paid for. After a few days of eating it, it didn't taste as strong anymore and I genuinely started to like it. Im not sure I would say I love fruit pies but I am open to trying another flavor as the pie was very well done. read more

See all

Got the chocolate fudge cake and it was delicious. Customer service was amazing. They take all types of payment. Expect a line but it moved fast. Highly recommend if you are in the neighborhood. A community staple for sure. Beautifully adorned with plants vegetables and locally sourced fruits. read more

Visited for a long weekend and our family bought two pies in three days. We also bought zucchini to go, which tasted delicious on the grill. Beautiful and affordable flower bouquets. Worth every penny. read more

Briermere Farms - Peach cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Amazing Blueberry cream pie with so MANY fresh blueberries. It's absolutely delicious. I saw the fresh peach pie...I'll have to try that next time. Can't wait to come back read more

Briermere Farms - Blueberry Cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

You know the pie is gonna be good when there is a long line. Take it from the Georgia boy. The peaches and cream were delicious.

Amazing pies jelly's jams all locally made The best place for pies I have ever Had. Gets crazy busy but moves quickly read more

Strawberry blueberry cream cake was delicious. It wasn't too sweet and the strawberries and blueberries were so ripe. The crust was crispy and fresh. It's kinda pricey for $42 but I guess we are paying for the berries? We got the blueberry crisp too for $28 which wasn't bad and wasn't too sweet. It was crispy and fresh but I definitely preferred the cream pie! The corn was $1 here but one of the ones I picked was molded which was just bad luck. $8 for blueberries. I just can't wait to come back for the peach cream pie. read more

See all

The most charming little farmers market with the freshest produce, gorgeous flowers and most delicious pies. Raspberry cream pie is out of this world! They sell coolers for easy transport read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Best pies in the USA - simple. Perfect butter pastry. No shortcuts, no fillers, delicious real fruit with fine balance of sweet. Absolutely amazing. read more

Excellent pies! Great selection. Pricey but you get what you pay for. On occasions such as Thanksgiving, you can't even get near the place! read more

My friend told me about this spot and I went here today. Their pies are known to be amazing. I got the strawberry blueberry cream pie and strawberry pie. The strawberry and blueberry pie was great! The strawberries were fresh and the blueberries were delicious. The crust was perfect buttery taste and flakey. Would love to come back and try the peach pie. read more

See all

Nothing screams summer like a slice of Briermere pie and the craving hit, so I went! Today's goal was to order things I haven't ordered in the past. I got the rhubarb square (buttery crust, slight custardy layer and rhubarb on top), the apple tart (which I haven't tried yet but many were getting it- seemed like a good compromise of getting that than another whole apple pie) and the Peach Blueberry fresh fruit cream pie. I always either get the strawberry, blueberry or the strawberry/blueberry combo. The peach was very juicy and the pie was delicious- however I am happy I got the pie with Peach & Blueberry than committing to just peach as the peach was tart. The tartness did even out with the cream/crust. I know I said I was gonna get things I haven't tried before but their carrot walnut cupcake is so good- I had to get it again! They were busy but they worked like a well oiled machine with many cashiers open. I also picked up a bunch of items for others (If I'm gonna make the trek- might as well stock everyone up). The cashier was super sweet and offered to help bring everything to my trunk. No one beats this place! read more

See all

As a diehard nyc girl who is general ambivalent about most long island things. I cannot emphasize enough how much I LOVE Briarmere pies! (Specifically the pies because I haven't tried anything else ...yet). A coworker very generously graced me with a taste of the strawberry/blueberry fresh cream pie last year and I have been hooked since! I have gotten the pie last year & this year and I can assure you both were absolutely perfect! The pie is absolutely giant and is stacked with what has to be at least 4 pounds of strawberries & blueberries! The cream is juuust sweet enough where it doesnt overwhelm the natural sweet/tartness of the berries. And i dont know how they do it but the crust stays crisp for days! (At least like 4 days because thats the longest they have lasted with very very careful rationing). I also recently tried the blueberry crisp & it was delicious. I was pleasantly surprised with the filling. Im so used to seeing that thick goop in fruit pies but the blueberries in this pie were mostly still whole with a light thin syrup? But the bottom crust still miraculously stayed crisp for days! I was worried that the fruit quality wasnt going to be as good as the fresh fruit pies but I was totally wrong. read more

Highly overrated. Was excited to bring their famous raspberry cream pie to Christmas, but it mostly tastes like any other cold pie. I will say the cream tasted amazing if you eat it the day of. However the rest of the pie was pretty average. The worst part though was when we found not 1 but 2 long pieces of light blonde hair hidden in the cream... there might have been even more but we threw the pie out after discovering two. For $35/pie, I'd expect better hygiene.... read more

This Apple Crisp pie was the worst Pie I have tried . The Apples on the inside was horrible and not edible and was the weirdest consistency. Almost feel like I got one from a bad batch?? When I say this Pie was terrible it was terrible! read more

Briermere Farms - Apple crisp - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Stopped by after a wine tour. They have fresh produce and fruit. The thing to buy here is the pie! I bought the apple crumble pie and it was delicious. Also picked up two bags of Long Island potato chips. Definitely recommend if you like pie! read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Decided to take a little road trip with the family to check out some farmer markets out East. First stop was Briermere Farms. What a great first stop. Pretty planters were on display for customers to admire while shopping. I bought an apple pie, chocolate cookies (without nuts) and a container of yellow grapes. EVERYTHING I bought was delicious!!! The staff member that rang me up was so polite and patient. I had questions about a strawberry plant that I was looking to buy and she was so honest when I was 'beating the bush' about whether the plant was still alive and if strawberries would still grow this summer. She told me that strawberry season was over and that the plant wouldn't produce anymore strawberries this season. I appreciated her honesty and because of that honesty and how delicious everything I bought was, I will definitely return to this market in the future. Wishing Briermere Farms continued success in 2021!!! read more

See all

The prices are more than the store brought pies but it's worth the splurge if you are in the neighborhood. The pies are a crowd pleaser and everyone in the world seems to know about them. The ingredients are fresh and it's all homemade. You can also pick up some pastries and tarts, apple cider, donuts, cookies, jams/jellies/and syrups as well as other items including some produce. read more

See all

Visited on Christmas Eve. The method they have for getting in line and being called up to the register is organized and efficient. I really appreciated being able to get my DELICIOUS pies and apple cider quickly during the busy holiday season! read more

Hello this review is from Beckey and Charlie! We drive to Long Island a few times a year to visit my mother in law who lives in Mastic Beach. Our trip is never complete before we stop at Briermere Farms for a few pies and other treats. This is a great company that is family owned and you can certainly feel that- because they make you feel like family as well! I wish we could give 10 stars or even 20 because this is much more than a 5 star company! Hands down the best Pie Stop ever and we will keep going back year after year. Thanks for being so awesome! See you again soon. read more

Heard that the pies at Briermere Farms are incomparably delicious, so had to stop by on the way home from a day trip to the North Fork. Since Briermere is so popular it draws a large crowd, but the place is run like a well oiled machine with orderly lines, many open registers and minimal wait times. We bought a raspberry peach fruit pie, chose that flavor because peaches are in season now. Couldn't wait to get home and dig in. Honestly this pie is the best I've ever had - by far! Loaded with fresh fruit, not overly sweet, made with a light flaky crust. At $20 this big pie was a bargain. The verdict: Briermere's stellar reputation for homemade pies is well deserved. read more

Briermere Farms - Pie Menu Today - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

I've been here twice so far and the first time I was here I only got apple pies and apple cider. Recently my friends told me about the blueberry cream pies so I came back. I bought the fresh blueberry cream pie and the cheaper jam version. The fresh premium pie is nearly $40 while the cheaper jam version was probably somewhere in mid $20s. The fresh blueberry is 10x better than the jam in my opinion. $40 is pretty steep but the amount of fresh blueberries on top is worth the price. Not one bad blueberries in the bunch! The parking lot seemed a bit tiny from what I saw but I think people are in and out fairly quick. With the pandemic going on, they have multiple stations that allows social distancing. Overall a great experience and I'd come back for more. read more

See all

Iconic farmstand that lives up to the hype- if you know what to get. Focus on the fresh breads and in season fruit pies and you will go home happy. I love the strawberry and blueberry pies! The homemade jams are good too. Pricey but worth it and a highlight of summer for as long as I can remember! read more

Yum ! Yum ! Yum! Delicious fresh homemade pies ! What a wonderful treat ! Ok you can't eat this all the time but once in a while treat yourself ! They do make the best pies ! Today I purchased the peach raspberry or is it raspberry peach LOL , not too sweet with a bit of tartness and flaky light crust ! There's no skimming here ! Worth every cent !!!! FYI They accept credit cards. They also sell other baked goods , cookies and bread . ... flowers and some veggies too ! Everything was set up nicely for social distancing and everyone was wearing a mask ! Thank you ! read more

See all

This place speaks for itself- mostly well known for some of the most best pies on Li, maybe New York. Simple fresh ingredients, helpful efficient staff with multiple registers so the line moves quickly. It wad nice hearing the registers great the local regulars. Such an extensive menu it's hard not to buy pie, fresh bread and jams! There's even some fresh fruits and vegetables for the choosing. read more

You want Long Island farm fresh food? Look no further than Briermere Farms. This place has it all fresh juices, pies, chips, vegetables, cookies etc...I drove 80 miles from Manhattan to come here for some fresh pie & they did not disappoint. I went with the blackberry & apple which was a delicious combo. I also had the chocolate cream pie which tasted like fresh chocolate pudding with soft pie crust. And my favorite one was the Raspberry cream pie. It's so bright red & beautiful & tastes even better. It's tart for sure but the cream balances it out so perfectly & you're left with a sweet & tarty yumminess in every bite. Make no mistake folks all of this food is grown on their farmland & served fresh from farm to your table. Staff is friendly. Selection is plenty but get there quick because good food sells out fast. Plenty of parking right outside & restrooms around the building which are very clean. read more

See all

I stopped by here in late April while I happened to be in the area and asked the (very nice and friendly) cashier to recommend a cream pie. We ended up getting what she suggested: the Fresh Fruit Strawberry Cream pie. It was definitely pricier than I expected, but it was also one of the best things me and my fam have eaten through the pandemic! Not too sweet, the strawberries were perfect, and the cream/custard base was perfect. read more

Briermere Farms - Strawberry cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Everything in the pies are stewed/boiled. Apple pie-- how do you mess up apple pie?? They do! Its boiled apples in a pie crust. It tastes like baby food. I was so disappointed. I got Strawberry-rhubarb, Strawberry peach, apple pie, cookies, chips and a cherry pie for Christmas. Im so glad I didnt have friends over because this would've been embarrassing to serve. Completely over rated. Don't waste your time Their pies are "made in Brooklyn". This is a total rip off. My 13yr old could've made a better pie with frozen store bought crust. Save gas, time and $28/pie and go to Costco. read more

See all

I've never actually been here for pies, only have had pies at home. Yesterday was my first time for pick up. Picking up a pie was smooth and friendly. There was a very clear line and cashiers with different numbers. You get called to the number and then place your order with the worker. My boyfriend and I had a very friendly experience with this yesterday. We both got frozen apple crisp, which is $25 each. They had a lot of other pies available that we want to get next time. Also appeared to have ciders, apples and other things that a farmers market would have. A very pleasant experience! read more

Always delicious fresh fruit pies. Great veggie and fruit stand too. Find your garden ants here too.

Fresh and balanced pies. Everything was divine. The strawberry rhubarb was my fave. Collect them all!!! read more

See all

The pies are great. Although prices have been going up. Because of this I have to lower the quality. It is not worth the money they charge but it is far better than a lot of pies you can find elsewhere. I will still get them but instead of purchasing 4 pies I'm down to three. Eventually it'll just be two pies. read more

Really delicious. Such a great variety, friendly & quick. Whenever I come to the Hamptons I get items from here! Their cream pies are soo good.. 100% recommend you must go here read more

See all