Thank you for producing such nice cookies. I purchased these cookies from sprouts in Dublin, California. I tried both the key lime as well as the blueberry crisp cookies-'outstanding products! Again, thank you very much. P, s, please open a bakery in California. read more

On the way to birthday weekend at the 1708 House in Southampton, Tates is literally right down the block so me, my daughter her BF decided to stop there. My first reaction walking inside was "charming and very colorful"! It's a small store but their selection of goodies is far from small!! You will find baskets filled with their different assortment of famous Tates cookies. Very reasonably priced, only $6.00 a bag! There's baked goods in a very nice showcase, a coffee station, bags of chocolates on display and shelves filled with different types of jams and syrups. There is so much you might be tempted to buy but I was very content with my purchase of 2 bags of chocolates chip cookies! I will absolutely be visiting again and highly recommend a stop into this pretty little bake shop if you're in the area! read more

See all

What I will say about this some perhaps might see it a bit weird but there's a reason. Mind you the stuff that this place has (like cookies) you can get about anywhere but my feeling is if you actually want to try it in person after trying it via stores you'll likely be satisfied no doubt. They do offer fresh cookies & perhaps other items as well and if say they have coffee and such again it's a win-win & intuition senses that service of their place and ambience is identical to what you get in the shop which is top notch. Now if anyone saw me taking a Hampton Jitney/Ambassador/Luxury Liner for this & back look "don't knock it until you try it" & this report might give you a clue. read more

Wow! Never thought I'd be able to get to this place, but glad we stopped by. They had a ton of their regular packaged cookies, some different ones I haven't seen, as well as some really delicious freshly baked treats. We opted for a few different cupcakes and they were definitely extraordinary. We tried the hostess lookalike cupcake and the peanut butter monkey cupcake... both were just so delicious and big enough to share! Lots of coffee and drink options as well, with a great pickup window that's convenient and keeps the crowds organized. There were a few tables to eat outside and the bakery was so nicely decorated. For such a famous place, it just felt so quaint and comfy! read more

See all

Ya REALY Downsized Your Cookies, Eh? But They Are The Same Price. I'm Pretty Exhausted From Getting Hosed Everytime I Turn Around. Your Cookies WERE a Culinary Luxury to me. Now that the last batch were Slightly bigger than Oreos, I believe you have lost a customer. read more

The barista with braids was the rudest person ever. Truly in awe of how nasty she is. I've never met someone more miserable and disrespectful in my life. I literally had to ask her why she is being nasty and rude, and how she can actually speak to a human like that. Then proceeded to say that I cannot wait with my friend while she's waiting for her coffee as I'm holding my coffee. She simply should not work in customer service shops if she doesn't like human beings. read more

Y'all I need sweets to live sorry I had to come here okay... I was just gonna get cookies but I may have gotten more... We all know Tate's cookies, they're crispy, crunchy, have the perfect amount of chocolate, YUM! But I did see they had a limited edition Mint Chocolate Chip flavor which I gasped at the sight of because I LOOOOVE MINTTTT. These had the perfect amount it kept the classic Tate's cookie flavor and added a perfect essence of mint. Also got a brownie which was HELLA DENSE OMG like a solid brick like ZAYUMMM (this is a good thing) I also got fresh coffee crumble cake from the bakery which was FIRE. Equally soft on the bottom and crunchy on the top. Paired it with an iced goldenmilk latte which was beautiful and tasted pretty good but even better with some of the self serve simple syrup! read more

Tate's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Southampton, New York

Fresh bakery items and really friendly helpful staff thanks for the really tasty breakfast items!!

Ahhhh made it to Tate's and what a treat. I wanted to get everything, from cookies to cupcakes to merch! Everything we tried from the big cookies to the packages cookies (ones you don't find at grocery store) - so so good, buttery and quality you can taste. To me, it's a definite stop while in the Hamptons! There is normally a line, but it goes fast and I felt like I had to know exactly what I wanted because the queue behind me is forming while the staff is ever ready to take the order! The pressure! read more

See all

I have written reviews before but it just keeps getting better!! My favorite, now, is "White Chocolate Raspberry cookies!" The flavor is incredible! Second favorite is Oatmeal Raisin! The flavor is very deep in this cookie! My third favorite is the "coconut!" It used to be that the coconut was my favorite but you keep coming up with something even better! Amazing!! Pat Murdzak Pittsburgh, PA read more

I was so excited to go to this bakery but was so disappointed. the employees were not friendly and could not recommend anything. we purchased cupcakes and they' were dry and not good. It was also very expensive . read more

Was super excited to get some sweet treats from Tate's for a bday celebration and check out the original bake shop. I worked in the service industry, so I don't say this lightly understanding all the pressures that exist- but the customer service was unprofessional. The two people helping us were condescending, irritable and downright rude not just to us but other customers in the store. Maybe it was too close to closing time - but if it was my business I would want to be aware. Will probably not be back. On the flip side the chocolate mousse cake with chocolate cookie crust and the peach raspberry crumble were delicious! read more

This place was trickery trash people were not helpful and I would would have rather had a gluten free cupcake and I have never said that before these employees should be beside themselves read more

I mean, how cute is this place?! My kids would've destroyed everything inside in 1.3 minutes if it weren't for their cute outdoor sitting space! The vibe is totally what you'd expect and absolutely adorable. I had to snag some gifts for a few people (and a mug for myself!). They have a TON of delicacies beyond cookies. Worth a stop for us non-locals! read more

THIS is where it all started for the famous Tate's cookies! You'll see Tate's cookies sold everywhere these days from local grocery stores to supermarkets and even Costco and Target. But it all began here in the Hamptons. First and foremost, just know that you can't actually purchase freshly made cookies here. I learned that a few years back when I was hoping to find some freshly baked warm cookies and was bummed. They're manufactured in bulk at an off-site factory. BUT, their famous packaged cookies are available for sale, along with cakes, cupcakes, ice cream sandwiches, and daily dessert specials. Their cookies actually come fairly close to tasting like homemade cookies, at least for packaged cookies. I actually try to stay far away from ultra processed foods, but I will make occasional exceptions for Tates. I shared them with a neighbor who enjoyed them as much as I did. In fact, she enjoyed them so much she came here the following day and bought 3 more different kinds for me to try (thank you, my friend!!). This shop is fairly small, but cute and fun. Workers are always nice and I always find something to get. read more

See all

The customer service at this company has been extremely disappointing. I ordered six items for delivery to my corporate office but only received five. After multiple calls between the vendor and UPS, I was informed the missing package was returned to Tate's due to a zip code discrepancy and advised to contact them directly. When I spoke with a representative, I was told I'd receive an email update after they consulted a supervisor about reshipping the order. A week passed with no response. Upon following up, another representative stated they would "look into it" but could not guarantee reshipment, citing their policy against refunds or replacements for this type of issue. Throughout the conversation, the representative was dismissive and rushed, especially when I explained that keeping payment for an undelivered item was unacceptable. Tate's refund policy claims: "At Tate's we believe in 100% customer satisfaction and will work with you to ensure you are happy with your purchase. If your order arrives damaged or you are dissatisfied for any reason, please contact Customer Service at 631-780-6511." Based on my experience, they do not stand by this statement. Regardless of whether the order is reshipped or refunded, I will not be purchasing from Tate's again--directly or through any retailer. read more

No trip to Southampton would be complete without stopping by the original Tate's. The quaint, homey interior is small but packed full of delicious sweets, savory pasties and coffee and tea options. Staff is friendly and patient, as people try to decide which of the many baked goods to select. Lovely option for grab-and-go treats and snacks, it's popular, so plan for a little wait at peak times. read more

See all

I have always been a fan of Tate's Bake Shop cookies from the grocery store. To find the actual store in The Hamptons, we had to go inside to check it out. You can dine indoor or outlook with some sweets or order coffee/tea. We ordered an Oreo cupcake and it was perfect, the flavor, texture, no dry, not too sweet and a good sweet treat. read more

See all

The original Tate's is a cute and quaint outpost. It's small inside and the line moves quickly. There's a good selection of breakfast bakery items including a sour cream coffee cake and assorted pastries. The blueberry muffins were the best thing we had. The croissant was also good. We would pass on the cinnamon swirl next time, it really didn't have any flavor. There's also a large beverage menu with seasonal drinks like strawberry lemonade. We picked up some bags of cookies and there's other assorted bagged desserts like chocolates and even a tate's candle! Parking was easy even on a Sunday morning as they have a lot. read more

See all

Delicious cookies, baked goods, coffee, ice cream and more - all made locally on Long Island. read more

Tate's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Southampton, New York

See all

Purchased Tate's Bake Shop LEMON COOKIES.... They were crispy and thin but far from Scrumptious. The lemon flavor tasted very chemical ..not real fresh lemon juice flavor although it says it in the ingredient's list that there is natural flavor...and that the bag mentions the best ingredients... Tate's needs to go back to redoing their recipe for this cookie... read more

It's a delight visiting the actual Tate cookie store. You will see a variety of cookie options for you to purchase. They have limited outdoor seating and parking at the back. I ordered the key lime bar but it was too sweet for me. I ordered the blondie cookie as well. The coconut flakes could've been smaller which would make it tastier. read more

See all

SO happy I got to check this spot out. I've been a huge fan of Tate's cookies probably, ever since they came out in stores in South FL. I pick them up almost every time I go grocery shopping (it's one of my guilty pleasures lol.) I visited the Hamptons over the holidays and made it a must to check out their bake shop, which was so cute! The spot is so warm and cozy. Feels like a mom and pops store and was decorated so nicely for the holidays. Upon arrival we were greeted and decided to grab a few Tate's cookies, their crumb cake and a chocolate mousse cake. The cookies were obviously great but my favorite thing was their coffee cake. I think it's one of the best I've had! I'm glad I was able to grab a few pieces to-go (seems like they run out quickly) and had them with a cup of joe in the AM over the weekend. So fresh and not overly sweet, just how I like it. Love seeing spots like this flourish! read more

Tate's Bake Shop - New Years Cake - chocolate mousse - Bakeries Near Me - Southampton, New York

I'm absolutely obsessed with Tate's! The cookies are amazing--I felt like I was in cookie heaven, especially with the limited edition flavors they offer. My favorites are the blueberry and walnut chocolate chip; they're thin, crispy, and perfectly buttery. While I was there, I also tried a cupcake and coffee, and both were excellent. Definitely a 10/10 experience! read more

Visit Date: November 11, 2022 I took my son here on Veteran's day. He was off school, I was off work and his dad was okay with me picking him up early. We stopped at three different places in the Hamptons that day. I need to be way more careful with my money so we just picked up two cookie packs and I got a coffee. There is so much here, so many baked goods, so many coffee choices. It was nice to see the original tate's bake shop. If you can make the visit here it's worth it. read more

See all

Agree with all the other post as far as knowing that they don't have fresh cookies there. Would be nice though to have cookies. The cupcake was ok, nothing special. Their coffee cake muffin was really good, moist, and flavorful. Coffee was ok. Not very hot in temperature so didn't stay hot very long. read more

I've always been a fan of Tate's cookies and often buy it in NYC so I was very excited when I walked by the bake shop. I came around 12 on a Sunday and there was already a good amount of people waiting to order. My friend and I got a key lime bar and lemonade to share. The bar was absolutely delicious. The key lime bar was the perfect combination of sweet and tart and the shortbread crust was delicious and fragrant. The lemonade was fresh and they have syrup on the side so you can add as much or as little syrup as you want. Definitely a nice stop if you're in the area. read more

Tate's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Southampton, New York

See all

We have always loved Tate's - whether fresh from the Southhampton shop or mass produced in thos famous "green bags" in nearly every local store. Classic Choloate Chip, Lemon and the limited-edition flavors (Caramel Coffee was amazing). are a must for us. We enjoy Tate's and seeing the company grow over the years is exciting. read more

I received a chocolate chip pie from Tate's Bake shop in South Hampton by mail, and the presentation was nice--it came in a plastic casing inside a box. However, when the three of us tasted it, we all agreed it was beyond tasteless and awful! I would never serve this to guests. Since they advertise a "complete satisfaction" guarantee, I called their customer service. Unfortunately, they only have voicemail, and despite calling for four days in a row, I never received a callback. Very disappointed with both the product and the lack of customer service follow-through. read more

Underwhelming. Love tates cookies so we made a trip out here from Merrick. They sell the same cookies I buy in my local supermarket. I was hoping to try fresh Tate cookies but they don't have anything of the sort. We bought a couple of pastries to try and they were ok at best. I wouldn't go out of my way to come back here. read more

The rustic bread is so delicious! I could not stop eating it and now I can't stop thinking about it!!!! And yes, everything else is tasty and worthy too!!!! read more

My sausages love coming here whenever we're at our place in the Hamptons. Yes, Tate's cookies are available in ever freaking store you can think of in the tri-state area but the store itself has a ton of fresh made baked goods as well that are not packaged and readily available elsewhere. Their cappuccino making skills are on point and my kids enjoy their fresh squeezed lemonade, fyi there is no sugar in it. Staff is always friendly and being able to sit outside and enjoy our treats is a huge bonus plus it's dog friendly out on their patio sitting area too! read more

Tate's Bake Shop - a sign for tate's bake shop - Bakeries Near Me - Southampton, New York

This unfortunately was a massive disappointment. I know we went to visit Tate's in the off season but I still expected a little more from the company's flag bakery. The service was okay, nothing that couldn't be found at a regular chain gas station. What was disappointing was the actual bake goods. The cupcakes were extremely dry and had little to no flavor. The icing tasted like someone colored vegetable shortening. The croissants were equally dry and bland. The little cake bites were also dry and completely flavorless. My daughter got several of the Easter candy specialties and those were at best comparable to old candy left over from two seasons ago. Just very disappointing, Tate's is my daughter's favorite brand of cookie and we drove over an hour to be able to visit the bakery store front. Just a really disheartening experience read more

This place is awesome! By far the best coffee in the area! Also the baked goods are great! Highly recommend the chocolate chip cookie pie and sour cream coffee cake. read more

Never heard of Tate's until this came up as a POI to visit! The bakery is quaint and charming. The inside has no seating, but a plethora of the famous Tate cookie bags. Many flavors and choices! The bakery has a lot of standard baked goods. I tried the coffee cake muffin, which was a nice snack. The outside is very nice with flowers (when blooming), several outdoor tables and embodies what everyone thinks of when you go to the Hamptons. There is a dedicated parking lot for visitors so no need to stress. The only thing I didn't see at Tate's bakery was prices. None of the merchandise has prices on it (including the famous green cookie bags) and none of the baked goods menu above the register had any pricing. It was slightly annoying to figure out what to order within our budget. read more

Golden Fudge Cake - EXCELLENT! Sour Cream Coffee Cake- EXCELLENT! Coconut Macaroons- EXCELLENT! Lemon Cookies- EXCELLENT! Everything I inquired about, I was told was good. And guess what, everything I tried was good! That never happens! Cakes were moist, coffee cake loaded with nuts. Lemon cookies have such amazing texture, thin & buttery crisp. Wish I had tried & bought more. Not to be missed! read more

See all

Every time I'm vacationing in Amagansett, I stop by Tate's Bake Shop to pick up some goodies. I've been doing since it was Kathleen's Bake Shop so I go way back. I'm not sure what's going on but the lemon squares and peanut butter squares weren't good and such a disappointment when I recently bought them. The original recipe has obviously changed. The lemon curd was soft & gooey like they weren't set and also no tartness to them. The peanut butter squares tasted weird, like they were made with Splenda or some really awful peanut butter. I'm so happy I have 2 copies of the Kathleen's Bake shop Cookbook from years ago. I'll go back to baking them myself. read more

I was really excited to visit Tates since I love their cookies but was slightly disappointed to see the same flavors they sell in stores. They do have a selection of baked goods but I thought I could maybe scoop some fresh baked cookies. Their latte was solid and quite a large cup, and their ice cream sandwich made from their cookies was good too but didn't blow me away. All in all an average experiencing; I feel like there's a lot of potential here! read more

Tate's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Southampton, New York

See all

68 yrs in the Hamptons 20 as a resident. Overpriced and poor quality. Employees couldn't care less obviously Tate has checked out. Don't waste your money go to the Stop & Shop or King Kullen. FYI 7 -11 has better bakery goods read more

I was so glad I finally got to check this place out as I only always drove by to work. On my day off, I decided to go to this place after lunch on a chilly day. They had "BeeHealthy matcha latte" which is a matcha latte with honey and bee's wax sprinkles on top. I added more honey to make it more sweet but I really LOVED this matcha latte. It was very thick with lots of matcha in it and it is rare to find one like that. However, the cupcakes were not that good.. The frosting was too sweet to my taste but it could just be me haha This Southampton location is cute because they have their own cookies with Southampton sign on it :) read more

See all