I visited brick + dough for lunch. We ordered the bread and butter : it was delicious and bread and butter was homemade, that was a nice touch. I had the margarita pizza and vodka sauce pizza. Although both were ok it was nothing to run back for. Dough was super doughy and felt the sauce and cheese wasn't supporting it. Service was fine. The restaurant was pretty much empty with only 2 other people eating at the same time with us, therefore I was a little confused why the food took so long to come out. I honestly felt for a pizza restaurant they have a very limited pizza menu. Ambiance was nice. read more

Brick + Dough - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Great food and wonderful atmosphere! Love their pizzas! I also am so pleased they painted a beautiful image of pizzas on the side of the building! Much better to look at that than two wrinkled women (it's a pizza place, kids. Duh). I read the story about the haters over the change of the painting. Just ignore them, Brick & Dough! Some people will always have time to spread their unhappiness. Keep up the good work, folks! read more

Decided to stop by Brick + Dough for a quick dinner and I'm so glad I did! My sister and I arrived around 5:30pm and we were quickly seated. We started off with the caesar salad and Rodolfo's knots which you can buy individually which was perfect since we only wanted 1 each. It doesn't come with marinara so make sure you order it on the side. The homemade sodas are a must! Now on to the wood-fired pizza, I love that you can customize it with plenty of add-ons. I originally wanted the vodka style pizza but it has meat in it. I am glad the waitress informed me as it does not list it on the menu. Instead, I ordered the NY style pie and my sister ordered the vegan lovers pie drizzled wit hot honey. Both were delicious! And of course we had leftovers to take home too. All in all, our experience here was great! Would definitely be back. FYI: Brick + Dough is BYOB! read more

Brick + Dough - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Fantastic pizza and Italian food. Highly recommended in Montclair. Also a great environment for a nice meal.

Came here for the first time and it was a hit. The service is quick, the orange vanilla soda they make in house was a 6/10 wasn't too crazy about it but I will try other flavors when I visit again. We shared the meatballs as an appetizer and it was the best I've ever had. They literally melt in your mouth. Do not miss out on these ! When it comes to the pizza, we had ordered the regular gluten free pie however when it was brought to the table it was Chicago style which is much thicker. I prefer thinner pizza but we did not mention it be size it looked so good! Pizza was a 7/10 I will define going back to have some meatballs, house made soda and pizza ! 8/10 overall read more

See all

My friend and I came here a year ago before they started redecorating. The food was absolutely amazing, we loved the esthetic and how clean the establishment was. We came back with my sister, the food was still amazing. Except one of the specials was an acquired taste, however, we ate it. We got truffle fries and a variety of different pizzas. They do get busy as of recently and during specific times, reservations are recommended. However, when we did not make a reservation the staff was so amazing in giving other great choices of restaurants to eat close by! We loved it and appreciated it. read more

See all

Excellent wood fired pizza! We recently grabbed some takeout pies here and we were so pleased. Pies run $16-24 - the size is between an individual size and a medium pie. One will not feed two adults but one pie per person will leave some leftovers. We tried the standard NY style, the Sesame + Stracciatella (white pie with burrata and topped with sesame seeds), and the chicken vodka parm pie. All have a great crispy charcoal crust and taste super fresh. I love the sesame pie as it had a nice combo of flavors including some sweet from the sesame seeds. The chicken vodka pie was also a standout but incredibly filling. Even the classic was amazing! Highly recommend! read more

Brick + Dough - Chicken Vodka Pie - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

The first thing I noticed when we walked in was the literal drum of warm garlic knots just waiting to be eaten - I recommend you get at least a few. They are super doughy yet also very crunchy, and have a ton of garlic. Also, before you sit down, much like many restaurants in Montclair, it's BYOB, so don't forget to being something with you. We clearly forget this nugget of information more often than not when dining in the area. We had the meatballs, the arugula salad, and a Margherita. Meatballs can be hit or miss, but these are delicious and come drowned in some really excellent marinara. The Margherita was also delicious; plenty thin with a nice puffy crust that had excellent chew. The arugula salad simple and good was good, my only note was that the arugula was clearly on its last leg and had some yellow and wilted pieces. Not a dealbreaker but it would deter me from getting it again. All in, a great lunch for less than $50; sometimes I forget how much a few cocktails really adds to the bill. I'm looking forward to coming back for more knots, more meatballs, and definitely some more pizza. read more

See all

Amazing pizza place with staff that are welcoming and friendly. Along with the great pizzas their appetizers are also so good. Some of the items on the menu can change during the year making it another reason to go back and try out the new dishes! read more

This has to be the best brick oven pizza I've ever had. Excellent service and the ambiance is lively & always pleasant. Thank you Mike read more

Love love love this place. The food, specifically and obviously the pizza is awesome. It's BYOB so bonus and the staff is very nice as well read more

See all

Great meal and overall time here! Our server was super nice and friendly/helpful he really guided us through the menu and gave some great suggestions. The restaurant itself is super nice and cozy while being spacious, but oh man the food is unreal. We had the meatballs (so big and flavorful and smothered in sauce), the mushroom pizza which was loaded with mushrooms, super flavorful and unique. Also got the vodka pizza which was really great, we got extra vodka sauce on the side so we could really drown it and loved it. My friend got the gluten free and she said it's the first gluten free bread she's had that actually tastes like real bread and loved it. read more

See all

Would've paid double for how good the bread was, everything was delicious and was prepared so fast. Dining team was amazing read more

See all

I don't write a lot of reviews, this is probably like my fifth. But I just really felt the need to leave one here. I had the pizza. Ordered takeout. Really good wood-fired pizza. I already want to go back. Got the pepperoni with red onions. Fresh ingredients. But the star of the show is the dough. Tastes just like naan (indian bread), which is oftentimes the mark of a good wood-fired pizza to me. Light and chewy at the same time. Pretty good cheesy breadsticks too. Sorry for the half-eaten pizza! For those curious, I had fun with one slice. House made ranch, Mikes hot honey, and chili oil. Street parking is available and it's a nice sit-down dinner spot inside. Nice hostess. BYOB. Simple and just right. read more

Brick + Dough - Pepperoni and onions. Had some fun with one slice. Ranch, Mikes hot honey, and chili oil - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Brick & Dough in Montclair, NJ is an absolute gem! From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was warm and inviting, setting the perfect tone for an incredible dining experience. The appetizers were mouthwatering, the pizza was perfection -- crispy yet soft crust with toppings that burst with flavor -- and the friendly service made it all the more enjoyable. A surprising highlight was discovering a new cola from Boylan Bottling Co. The taste was so amazing that as soon as I got home to Maryland, I ordered a 12-pack for delivery. Trust me, that cola is a game-changer! If you're in Montclair, NJ, make sure you put Brick & Dough at the top of your list. You won't regret it. Amazing food, fantastic service, and a place I'll be dreaming of until my next visit! My only regret is not getting pictures to share. But, I can tell you, there were four of us and we shared five appetizers and four pizzas and we ate everything! read more

The gluten free pies are amazing! The customer service is great! Very clean environment!

Montclair is close to me, but isn't a place I go that often. I am always nervous about parking since I am not the best parallel parker, but I was happy to find plenty of parking spaces available behind the restaurant. We had a 5:00 reservation and when we arrived the place wasn't that busy. However, when we left at 7ish, the place was slammed on a Wednesday night. It is BYOB which is great. We started with some garlic knots, and they were a great preview. The dough was outstanding and the sauce was tasty. We spit two pizzas, the chicken vodka parm (which was my favorite). You could really taste the vodka sauce. It was chicken thighs, which I normally don't like but they were so moist and tender. You wouldn't have known the difference. Then we had the margarita, which was really good. We also split the arugula salad, which I wouldn't get again because it was just dressing and arugula, nothing else in it. I would definitely go back here for pizza again. Service was great and the pizza was delicious. read more

See all

Written about this restaurant before, but I had to do an update as I've eaten there multiple times since. My family loves it--both for eating in and taking out. Definitely one of the top contenders when we're considering Italian food. For appetizers, I highly recommend the garlic knots, cheesy breadsticks, and the bread + butter (this is so good we even asked for the butter to go). As for the pizza, we love the NY style, white, and vodka. I've heard the Buff Chick is good as well and the straciatella is next on my "to try" list. The restaurant interior has a nice ambiance, but the lighting can be a bit dim for those with vision issues. However, outdoor seating is an option in those cases. The servers were attentive and came by routinely to check in and fill up our waters. read more

See all

I was pleasantly surprised while eating at brick & dough. its super casual, but still nice. Service was great. the inside is large and spacious. they also have outdoor seating. i loved the housemade lemonade, but it needs vodka. the pizzas come in small, personal size, but can easily be shared. theyre close to $20. we ordered the chicken vodka parm, i loved this, but i will be honest..i dont think this tasted like vodka sauce. theres a little bit of flop on the crust, but it holds the weight of the chicken. they have a set menu of their regular pizzas, but also have specials. we tried one of the specials - the garlic pesto sauce with mushrooms. AMAZING. i loved this one alot. i would come back again for sure. read more

See all

This place does not miss!!! I was introduced to them for the amazing pizza but the weekly Thursday sandwiches and Walnut Windough breakfast sandwiches on Saturday are also incredible. With a menu that caters to the picky eater classics or the adventurous foodies there is something for everyone. Everything is always cooked to perfection and packed with incredible flavor. The staff is always super friendly and service is quick and attentive. I highly recommend dining in, or taking your food to go to pair with beers at Montclair Brewery across the street. I love keeping up with their Instagram for the latest items and specials, and the dreaded alert that the Saturday breakfast sandwich has sold out. Set your alarm and wake up early, it's so worth it. read more

See all

I hosted a baby shower at Brick & Dough today, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. From start to finish, the team went above and beyond to make it a truly special day for my family and friends. The pizza and salad were absolutely delicious and every guest commented on how much they enjoyed the food. The service was exceptional... attentive and genuinely warm. There were a few additional guests that joined at the last minute and they accommodated them seamlessly. The private event space has a great atmosphere and a lot of light that works well for big gatherings. I'll definitely be coming back. I can't recommend Brick & Dough enough, whether it's for lunch or dinner or your next private event. Thank you Jason, Mike and team! read more

4.5/5 stars. I went on a Friday at 4pm, thought it would be more busy but we were the ONLY people there. Made us feel a bit awkard since it was so quite, no even some background music playing or anything. For app, we got the garlic knots and the straciatella and wow, simply delicious. So fresh, so airy, absolute perfection. Get yourself at least two, you wont regret it. We then got the Chicken Vodka Parm and the Buffalo Chicken +Bacon Pizzas, and both were good. Not amazing, Im not sure what exactly was missing but it was good. The crust was airy, good char on the dough, not bad at all. read more

Brick + Dough - Top : Buffalo Chicken Bottom: Chicken Vodka Parm - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

this Marguerite pizza had no flavor and the crust was doughy when it wasn't burnt. The sauce had no salt and was practically tasteless. Extremely disappointed. read more

I actually like the pizza and bread at this establishment. The menu is short sweet and to the point. I don't have a picture but I like the pizza and I'm a pizza fanatic. read more

I want to give this page a 3.5 but you cannot do that on Yelp. I liked it, I just think it needs some tweaks. We walked in and literally no one helped us for a good 5 mins, finally the girl from behind the counter yelled to us if we had a reservation. I said no but she was still able to seat us right away. Idk if this place is newly renovated and they are still decorating but something is definitely missing. The one wall in the main dining room is all black, there's low lighting so it looks very unfinished and bare. Our server was very sweet and helpful with our questions. We started with the poutine and Caesar salad. The salad had zero flavor...good Caesar should have a strong flavor and this tasted like nothing. On the other hand, the poutine was delicious. Warm, comforting, definitely a must order. For pizzas we decided on the chicken vodka - this can be skipped, again not much flavor. We preferred the meatball ricotta. However the dough on both pizzas were cooked nicely and that's a plus. We saved room for dessert and so glad we did! We got the lemon poppyseed olive oil cake, I was not expecting it to be warm but it was (a good thing) . The berry jam on it was too sweet for me so I pushed it off but the cake itself and the whipped cream were *chefs kiss* read more

See all

I've been here twice and absolutely love it! Last time we came we ordered a margarita pizza, one of the square slices, and the poutine. Left feeling so full and satisfied! The ambience is beautiful, the food is delicious--especially if you're in a carb heavy mood and staff is attentive. Would love to visit again when they have their weekend biscuits! read more

Loved everything about this place and have been recommending to everyone. Various options on the menu for everyone to enjoy and I appreciate they also have vegan and gluten free options. Staff was very nice and checked in on us in a timely fashion. I loved the idea of their homemade Sodas very unique. Location was nicely spaced, perfect for catching up with friends or a casual date night. Child friendly and also BYOB. My friends and I loved every second of our time there. Street parking is available as well as suggested to make reservations ahead of time. Thank you for a lovely experience! Ordered the Ny style, buffalo chicken and chicken vodka parm pizzas, blistered shishito peppers, blueberry basil and passionfruit homemade sodas, cheese sticks and marina and Caesar salad! In love with everything! read more

Great pizza! Love watching them hand throw the dough. The people who work there are amazing. read more

Pizza served fresh and hot. Good taste. Dough decent but I've had better brick oven pizza crust. Pleasant waitstaff. Prices are on the high side for what you get. read more

I'd been to the old location before and liked the pizza there. This location is even better because the local traffic isn't as crazy and also there seems to be more parking. Ordered 3 pizzas to share between 4 people: Buff chicken Pepperoni Ny style (cheese) All were tasty with generous amount of toppings. The crust was really good and chewy. The pepp crust was a little burned but not too bad. I still think that this is some of the best pizza in nj and fairly in line with my favorite spots in Manhattan. Prices are reasonable ($46 for those 3 pizzas) read more

See all

Listen yo - there's no doubt I have the sickest flow But right now - this is all about a pizza place called Brick & Dough If you didn't know - let me tell you - let the whistle blow This place is phenomenal - everything is mind-blowing like a magician's show What on earth are they doing in that kitchen, yo?! Every bite hittin' like a vicious blow from Mike Tyson and Riddick Bowe When the pizza arrives - you see nothing but fire like Bam Bam Bigelow Right when you taste it - the impact is instant, yo Some of the best pies ever - Meatball Ricotta hits my soul The Buffalo Chicken is ridiculous - it's like a triple dose Of goodness - from the chicken to the chives to the ranch - it's kinda simple, yo Yet so complex with the flavors - nothing is middle road Let's say you had a bad day and you hit a low You want an elevated sandwich wit' chicken, bro? It's all about "The McBricken" tho Their Bread + Butter is the best bread and butter - it's the G.O.A.T. I would come here for this alone - point blank the sh*t is dope Good food - good vibes - that's how they keep this ship afloat So many incredible dishes - Top Chef steez - it's Chris's show Jason is amazin' - when he drops a dope idea - it's all systems go Breakfast pop-up on Saturdays - The Windough - the kid's a pro Kaitlyn wit' the best buttermilk biscuits - jealousy from the bitter foes They GO BIG - it's nothing small like a piccolo Bulgogi, Asiago Chicken, Hash Katsu, Pop-tarts - you will dig it, yo Once you realize how good this place is - you'll say "this is home" See the Brick & Dough sign on the building - that's a symbol of love like a Mistletoe It's more than just pizza - you can't put them in that pigeonhole 110 Walnut Street - you can see and feel the inner glow The flavor of every dish can be felt all the way down to your little toe Tell every Anne and Jane - every Rick and Joe Brick & Dough - some of the best food ever - that's my official oath I'm Ciphurphace and I approve this message. read more

See all

I first tried Brick + Dough over the summer in 2021 and after sinking my teeth into my first slice, I was hooked! They specialize in coal fired pizza which is the best way to have pizza in my opinion. Their dough is light, slightly chewy with a solid crisp around the crust. I ordered the pepperoni (a classic!) with a chilled bottle of Boylan Root Beer. The pies are personal sized so it's definitely enough for one person and it can also be a treat for later if you have any leftovers. About 8 months after having it for the first time, I returned to Brick + Dough over the weekend. Why I stayed away for so long? I have no idea. My boyfriend and I escaped the cold and sat inside and ordered garlic knots with a side of homemade marinara sauce to start. The sauce was light and not too acidic which is a plus for me. The knots were packed with flavor and the perfect texture. They're only $1 each so there's no shame in loading up! For the main dish, of course I ordered the pepperoni pie with a Boylan. It was just as good as I remembered. My boyfriend ordered their special -- a cheeseburger pizza. It was AMAZING! Brick + Dough has a warm and friendly atmosphere and pizza that I will keep you coming back for more. If you're ever in Montclair, NJ, take a trip to Brick + Dough! read more

See all

Absolutely incredible pizza that I still dream about... I would seriously considering moving to Montclair to be able to eat here more often. Only thing better than the pizza is the fabulous family that owns this spot. Truly incredible people who make incredible food! read more

This pizza was amazing the only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because they charged me $3 for onions on half of my pizza! That was excessive. read more

Brick + Dough - So good! I had to eat a slice in the car lol - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Solid pizza, I tried their gluten free pie and it was doughy and thick just like a Chicago style. The pepperoni is very flavorful and spicy. I see what all the hype is about regarding their GF pizza. Definitely one to visit! read more

Brick and YO! This place is the shizz as the youngsters say. As soon as I walked in I was in a dream. The pizza was really fantastic and the crust was the best part. But my favorite thing was the buffalo chicken wings. Soon enough if I eat too much I will be flying away because those where the show stopper. It was also super rad because you can see the chefs cooking as you dine. Overall a super great experience and will be coming back. read more

Decided to try this place for our Friday night date night after seeing somebody post about it on Instagram. It is located on a main corner in Montclair, where there are a lot of restaurants and people out and about. Parking is not the greatest, but that is to be expected of Montclair. Upon walking in, it was a little confusing as to whether or not this was a sit down restaurant, or an order your food and bring it to your table yourself kind of place. The man that was standing in front of me even asked if I knew whether or not we just sit down or order at the counter. Luckily, we had made a reservation and it was an actual sit down and be waited on kind of place. We were sat promptly. We noticed the place kind of lacked some decor. It really has a lot of potential, but the walls were very bare, and it kind of gave it an echo-y warehouse feel. The wait staff was not bad and promptly came over to ask us what we wanted to eat and to open our wine bottle (it is BYOB). We ordered immediately because we were starving and our food came out in a decent amount of time. We started with the Ceaser salad which was amazing and actually a really large portion for the price. We were able to split it amongst the two of us. We both then ordered regular, NY Style pies and I added hot honey on mine. The pizza was absolutely out of this world. Not too thick, not too thin, just perfect. I was actually quite blown away. For desert, we had the panna cotta which also blew me away. I'll definitely be coming back, whether it be just for takeout or for another date night. Hoping to see some warmer decor in the place. read more

Brick + Dough - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Is it the BEST wood-fired pizza I've ever had? No, for a couple of reasons -- the toppings were not super flavorful (the vodka sauce was just okay, same with the meatballs), and the crust was a little too grainy (maybe from cornmeal?). Was it still really good pizza? Yeah. The crust was perfectly fluffy and had great flavor, the garlic knots were surprisingly awesome, and the price point is comparable to what you would expect from a place like this in northern NJ. It's worth a visit! read more

See all

So we decided to try this out again, and I am so happy that we did. The cheese stick was just as good as the last time. Instead of both getting sandwiches, we went with the meatballs ($15) and the turkey sandwich special( $20). The meatball were 1000% my favorite and I would return for it anyday. The sandwich was also very creative and yummy. My favorite bit was the focacia, stuffing and the cranberry mayo. The turkey was good, but the sausage stuffing just had so much flavor. read more

See all

Absolutely a must-return restaurant for all that they have to offer - pizza, salads, appetizers, and desserts. Every one of the pizzas were delicious, including one with vegan cheese. Their margherita and forager pies were fabulous as well. My group also enjoyed the Carnitas pizza and another one with sesame seed and hot honey, which was delightful. Worth the drive and the prices! And exceptionally great customer service to top it all off. Job well done Brick + Dough! read more