Great fish fry to go! Fish was cooked perfectly & my broccoli just right!…read more 10 minutes, & done!! Ty!!

Everything was delicious. Service was friendly. Our favorite breakfast spot in the area hands down.read more

Such a nice little restaurant. The place is very clean and nicely decorated. It's much bigger on…read morethe inside than it looks like on the outside, so don't let a full parking lot scare you. I had the eggs Benedict with home fries. The eggs Benedict was really good. Eggs were perfect and the sauce was nicely flavored. The home fries were not the best. They needed to be seasoned better and were under cooked. I'll give them a pass on those. Server was on top of everything and very friendly. I am eager to try them for lunch and dinner.

While visiting my daughter at Alfred, we decided to go to village cafe for breakfast. Was seated…read moreright away. It's a cute cafe out there. Had the tuna melt and chicken philli sandwich, really great tasting for the price. The service was 10/10 definitely worth it.

The menu is fabulous in giving you plenty of options. Food…read moretakes a while to get to you & that's expected. 1st thing we notice the cheese pizza my daughter ordered had pepperoni. We simply removed the pepperoni not a huge deal. My BF made sure to ask for his food not to be crispy, well toast had black edges. My chicken tenders were dark brown (overcooked) instead of golden. The food was great flavor wise. Just the lack of attention from server. The servers don't pop in to check on you much. The place looked pretty clean. Bathrooms fairly clean, very small.

Ate there yesterday 2/24/26. Very disappointing. I ordered the chicken wings and my wife ordered a…read moreWestern Omelet. I had to return the chicken wings because the meat was black as were the bones. I believe the fryer grease was old as well. I chose not to have a substitute meal. My wife's omelet was questionable as well. Some of the ham in the omelet was gray in color. It was not appetizing and it went to waste. Unfortunately, we will not be returning.

This recently updated location is a top tier terrific dining choice for everyone. Breakfast, lunch,…read moredinner? Great options await. Looking for something sweet? Definitely a great choice, ice cream, pie, cake... Yup, you guessed it, Settlers got it all. (The peanut butter pie, and carrot cake are straight up FIRE) Service is professional, warm, friendly and more importantly, QUICK. The ticket times from order to heal tend to be VERY brief. Moreover, this restaurant is VERY family friendly, has a warm, modern and welcoming vibe and low sticker shock prices that make a visit budget friendly. It's one of our family go-to restaurants in the Batavia area that has never once disappointed us when we visit.

Came with a larger party to Settler's, and I was impressed that they were able to get us in and out…read morewithin an hour even though they were on the busier side. Solid chicken tender sub and mac and cheese. My husband and I had to wait a little for these to come out even though everyone else's had hit the table, but we didn't mind since they were clearly being made fresh. Our waitress was friendly. Good stop for breakfast or lunch, and it was cool that they had a whole ice cream counter.

Excellent diner ! So much to look at , decor wise . Food is outstanding , so is the service …read more Pancakes are huge . I can't say enough good things about this business - only that I wish they would expand to the Buffalo area (but being in the middle of nowhere is part of its charm ) .

Great little spot. Everyone was friendly and our server kept us posted on when she would be at our…read moretable and when out food was coming, which was great. I I loved the fresh flowers on every table. I had the table of knowledge breakfast which included home fries, 2 eggs and bacon and coffee. My fiance had thr special which was breakfast blt and home fries. Everything was great. Loved all the tschotckes.

Charming down-to-earth restaurant where a hearty filling breakfast is served with a smile.read more

Stopped by with my friend before we set off for our drive home after a couple days around…read moreLetchworth State Park. We came in around 10AM on a Saturday and it wasn't too busy. We were told to sit wherever we wanted so we did. Our waitress took our drink orders right away. We both opted for black coffee. The coffee was pretty good, but I'm not exactly a coffee snob. I ordered the Breakfast Garbage Plate with sausage, homefries, and scrambled eggs. It comes smothered in sausage gravy which I happen to really enjoy. The serving size was generous and I thought my food was pretty good. The only gripe I had was the potatoes could've been cooked a little more. Some of them were a bit firm. My friend ordered the Hungryman Plate. He says it was decent but had similar complaints about the potatoes. They were also a little underseasoned. Again, the serving size was generous, especially the pancakes. My friend shared the pancakes with me but unfortunately they were a little lackluster. They were a bit soggy which was disappointing. They weren't completely inedible, but we didn't finish them. The waitress noticed and asked if we needed a to-go container. We said yes but we weren't aware that we would be charged $0.75 to take something to go. Not a huge deal, but it's annoying to feel like you're getting nickel and dimed. Since the pancakes were just meh we probably would've just left them if we had known we'd be charged extra to take them. It seems like breakfast options were limited in the area, but John & Sarah's is a totally OK place. I wouldn't be opposed to returning if I were in the area.

Stopped in for breakfast on my way through Avon. The food must be good because the place was packed…read moreat 9:00 AM on a Wednesday. The staff were friendly and the service was prompt. I got the shaved steak omelette and it was delicious. The interior while charming is in need of some updating.

Love this place, dining here for well over thirty years. Food is always great and affordable,…read morestaff is friendly and welcoming, Friday Fish fry is on point!

I stopped here with my wife on the way home from Geneseo for lunch. The staff greeted us right…read moreaway and let us sit anywhere. The dine looks small from the outside but actually had quite a few tables and didn't feel crowded. I ordered a turkey club with bacon and my wife ordered a BLT (she always. Requests the bacon be very well done). Our food came out within 5-10 mins. And was perfect! I'll definitely stop here again. Friendly staff good service

Service was good. Food was very good and reasonably priced. Here on vacation and wanted a good…read morehot breakfast. This place was great.

The food was really good! Strip steak & shrimp was awesome. The bathrooms were clean, and the staff…read morewas super kind.

A nice diner in downtown Warsaw. Clean, busy and friendly staff. I got the patty melt and it was…read morecooked exactly as I asked. I would have taken a picture but I was so hungry and it smelled/tasted so good that it was not an option. My side order of sweet potato fries, again cooked perfectly. Not hard or dried out like most places. They even remembered the honey!!!! So if you are in Warsaw, you need to go. Prices are mid ranged and the cups of soda are huge!

The Fish Fry was AMAZING!!!! OH MY LORD!!!! The beer batter was delicious! Yet the fish itself had…read moretaste too!!!! Fries were soft yes crispy... also got some onion rings thing but TASTY!!! The slaw also hit as well 5 out of 5 must east!

Good food, but I don't like how they changed the fried pickles. Back then it was a huge box of them…read morefor 9$. Same price and it felt like I got so much less :(