Go to breakfast: B52 Bomber or steak & eggs Go to lunch:…read morecream cheese poppers & club sandwiches. If you ask the locals what to get, they're picky but if you're a visitor to Martha's Vineyard, im sure you will enjoy what they serve you. Everything is made fresh on the island so the locals has a high expectations when serving and being served. Its rare to get good services like this anywhere. Service is always great. It is located in the airport but open to the public to get a feed. Breakfast is all you need here, portions are very generous and seasoning is mid. You dont need much seasonings anyway, gotta make sure your cholesterol is low. Health is wealth my friends. Im not a coffee drinker so someone else can rate their coffee. They have tea and cold drinks, nothing to brag about, its hot and cold. Its a cute little restaurants that all visitors should check out before flying out or visiting the island. They serve alcohol here as well BUT, per West Tisbury bylaws, alcohol can only be served with food order. Enjoy!

Food was tasty, prices are fair, and portions were slightly generous…read more Just as importantly was the speed of service. The waitstaff were all punctual and attentive and the kitchen staff was very fast. At not point were we concerned about our flight. Because of the building it has potential to get loud. If you are flying off the island eat here. It is better to eat here for the convenience of location, fair pricing, and speed of service that to risk all that by going into town at O.B. or Edgartown.

A great spot to visit on your way to South Beach. Snacks, drinks and even prepared food to help…read moreyour beach day be better. Staff is helpful and friendly and the shop is fun to explore. There are even some items for gifts. There are picnic tables so that you can eat there too.

This was our go-to place for years but this season it really took a hard slide and we will not be…read morereturning. The service has always been inconsistent but turn in product quality and the increase in prices has put the final nail in the coffin. If you choose to go, double check your food for accuracy there are frequent mistakes. Coffee is not great.

The coffee here is really solid. The espresso is typically well dialed in and the espresso itself…read morehas a classic nuttiness with notes of milk chocolate and honey. The taller Brazilian guy who works FOH (typically behind the espresso machine) is super nice and kind but everyone else that works up front by the registers are not as friendly. They have a wide variety of pastry's. The patio is amazing with plenty of seating and there's quite a bit of seating inside as well!

Friendly staff. Great food - fresh and yummy . Clean restaurant (and restroom). Recommended!read more

I've been coming to this spot since 2020, and every experience has been exceptional from the…read morecustomer service to the food. This visit (8/17/25) was EXTREMELY different. First, it started with my smoothie order. I wanted a mango smoothie and I was told only berrilicious was available. Moments later, my friend had a mango smoothie. Very interesting that she was able to get one and I wasn't. That was a lapse in actually checking first, since he didn't know. Then, I ordered a sweet potato, black bean burger. When I started to consume the burger, I noticed that it was very burnt on the outside and undercooked on the inside not a desirable bite and it was bland. I requested another sandwich because it's a high chance it'll come out the same way, I'd rather have a tuna salad on a roll. The server then asked my name for the order (2) more times. Then, said she needed to talk to her manager about changing it. She speaks to her manager in Spanish and not talking good about me. Assuming that I don't understand Spanish as a Black woman or American. After five minutes she handed me a hot sandwich. I asked what it was, she said it's the tuna sandwich you asked for (which also had burnt toast). I responded I don't want it like this and you didn't take my order. You said you needed to speak to your manager. She cuts me off and says well what do you want? At this point a refund because your customer service is horrible. I know this is not the norm because the way the workers were looking at her and apologized to me, I knew this was out of character for this establishment. Within two minutes, another manager handled it the way it should have been, an apology for a burnt burger and an immediate action to remedy the situation (refund). That is the only reason I will return, but the server and the manager speaking bad about a customer in Spanish, is a poor look for this place. If it happens again, I will know better, and have a lot more to say because I won't be disrespected, but I will return for now.

Cute cafe. Service was good. The hummus wrap was overpriced but was fresh and tasted good. Chai was…read moreunsweetened and tasted good. Love the outdoor patio.

Came here on my vacation because we were hungry and didn't know where to eat. I ordered a BLT for…read more$9.95, not sure if it was worth it. The bacon was crispy and salty and the bread was not your regular loaf of bread, but for that price I was hoping for more quality. It was good but not the greatest. I also ordered a medium iced coffee which tasted okay, but it wasn't worth the $3. I also noticed how long I had to wait. All these other customers came in, ordered and got their orders ahead of us. Just because I had a sandwich doesn't mean I have to wait that long. The man did apologize but waiting twenty minutes is not good service. Little disappointed, but what can you do? I was ravenous so I completely forgot to take a photo.

Honestly I got a bacon egg and cheese with cream cheese on a bagel and it was one of the best…read morebreakfast sandwiches i've had in a while. Keep up the great work Murdicks I will be back.

Delicious lobster roll. Amazing flavor. Big chunks of lobster. Sticker shock at $32 for 1 sandwich…read more(I've been away from New England for many years) but what else can you expect on the island?! It was worth every single bite though. Friendly staff. Small little hole in the wall but just grab your Sammies and go eat by the ocean. Definitely recommend!

Best and LARGEST lobster roll on the island. Hefty warm roll filled with chilled, large chunks of…read morelobster salad. So amazing I wanted to go back for another. If you really want to treat yourself, get the frozen Arnold Palmer (frozen lemonade with iced tea) or the old school Stewart's root beer.

Just had gluten free lemon cake! Wow! Just the best little slice of cake ever!…read more Really. Honest. My god I need to turn around and get another slice.... Or a whole cake! (Chimes in the guy I work with that I shared it with)

The food here is always good! Breakfast is tasty. I love their lentil curry soup especially in the…read morefall. My favorite is the Grey Barn Bratwurst with saurerkraut, but that is to be no more. Hopefully they find a good alternative supplier. Call your order in ahead in season 'cuz it gets crazy busy.

This is next to a great grocery market in the area (small "town") - bought a few years back (it's…read morethe old Fella's in West Tisbury) ; nestled in between the only grocery open year round close to up-island and next to the post office, also the only one in area that services this small town of mostly farm land. It was discovery of a coworker who was ranting about their bfast sandwiches- YEA - they are pretty spectacularly tasty!! I have had 4 items from this menu and today... I tried the pizza- I ATE THE CRUST - soft enough with a slight crunch - perfect dough, sauce was seasoned and is homemade- excellent. Best lil' spot to catch a quick bite. They are a slice app customer!!! Excellent!

The buffalo chicken pizza is loaded with toppings. The crust is rather thin but a generous mix of…read moretoppings and cheese . I'd say it's more tasty then many other pizza shops on MV.

We are always looking for good Q on Martha's Vineyard and Fella's gets it right. This BBQ is…read moresauced so if you prefer dry rubs and long smoke time, it's not for you. The sauce is sweet, and vinegary with a nice finish. Tonight was BBQ night with legit chicken, ribs and pulled pork. Moist chicken and fall of the bone pork ribs. The pulled pork had big chunks and sweet sauce. Meals come with corn bread and another side. The cole slaw was not over dressed but had a bit too much celery salt. Enjoyed our meal, we will be back.