This place is on the pricier side, but the food is delicious! We got the south western fried chicken and the bbq bacon buffalo burger. Both were delicious and we had great service! read more

Black Sheep Cafe - Southwestern Fried Chicken and BBQ Nickel Burger - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

Great restaurant in Provo that I'm glad my friend who went to BYU suggested. Definitely get the buffalo nickel burger and the hog jowl nachos, those were my two favorite items. The restaurant is small but cute and our server Sami was helpful and super friendly. If you're in Provo definitely stop by the Black Sheep Cafe for a meal. read more

See all

Food is solid, love the southwest vibe and creative fusion between Mexican and Native American. I would recommend Black Sheep for friends and family! read more

Always a favorite when we are in Provo. Food is consistently delicious. Dining area is small, so it can be hard to get into during the dinner rush. read more

Great, unique food. Flavors are fun and the quality of the food is excellent. The ambiance is charming (and tight) too.

If you're looking for something new to try Black Sheep Cafe might be for you! They offer really unique dishes - some we've loved (their burgers) and others that weren't for us. They offer trendy different options so go knowing it's not your typical American food. You either will love it or leave wishing you had gone to a tried and true. It's definitely on the more expensive side making it even more of a gamble. I really enjoyed a burger there but went back and the menu had changed making it hard for me to want to go back. Give it a try for yourself if you're adventurous and are willing to risk not loving your meal. The service is friendly and timely making it a good experience. read more

Food very tasty. Service excellent. Ambiance okay. Great place for lunch. Looking forward to our next visit.

Great food offering a lot of unusual options. Atmosphere is nice and service is friendly.

Green Chili stew is the best soup I've ever had in my life no joke- always order it with the frybread and honeybutter. Don't forget to try the Cactus pear lemonade! Service is always great and love the ambience. read more

Black Sheep Cafe - Green Chile Stew Soup, Frybread & honeybutter - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

See all

Not only is the food here amazing, but it's unique and the presentation is beautiful! I love the burgers and fries especially. The burger with boat cheese on naan bread is like nothing I've had before! Make sure to book a reservation because it's gets busy! read more

Black Sheep Cafe - Black Sheep Burger - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

See all

We have been here a couple of times, food was good but a little salty and therefore we don't eat here as much.

Outstanding, gourmet food. Love the flavors and unique tastes of the appetizers as well as the main courses. Delicious! Have gone back several times. Will again. read more

This used to be my favorite restaurant in Utah. I've probably sent 50+ people there. But, it's changed. There is new ownership and obviously a new chef. The food quality is down and the prices are up. I would love to know where the old chef went. I got the Green Chile Navajo Taco. It has really gone downhill. They used to have a sampler plate with three Navajo Tacos. This taco was smaller than 1 of the 3 and cost more than the 3. It wasn't as good either. I would love to see this place make a comeback because it used to be my favorite place. The people I was with didn't like it either. Will give it a go again in a few months. read more

Greasy food, not a ton of flavor. Rice and beans were the best part. Surprised by how many good ratings this place gets. Ambiance is also super off putting. Pricey for what you're getting. read more

Black Sheep Cafe is owned by the same parent company as Communal (and Chom and Pizzeria 712-- the bulk of the good restaurants in the area). I think Communal is the best restaurant in Provo, and Black Sheep is positioned a notch below. It's also a notch less expensive (but not cheap). It keeps up the consistent, good quality food that the Heirloom Group is known for, with good ambiance, good service, and a small price premium for these because it's Provo and your options for nicer dining are limited. We've always gotten some kind of Navajo taco meal (I think hog jowel was our favorite), but the stew is excellent as well, the beans that come as a side are surprisingly good, and the cactus lemonade is delicious. Make a reservation a few days in advance or you will have a hard time getting in. read more

Amazing menu!! Try the hog jowl tacos. Unlike anything you'll find at another restaurant

So, I didn't expect much from this restaurant, but I left happy and full! The green chili frites were AMAZING! I loved the honey lavender fry bread, but the others weren't fans, so I had it all to myself (yum!). The filet mignon bruschetta was not as good as we expected - it was really bland, so I'm glad we tried the other appetizers as well. I got the chicken sandwich, which was good, but ended up stealing one of my husband's steak tacos, which were AMAZING! Our friends loved their burgers as well. Overall - if you aren't a fan of something you got, try something different, since there is a lot of variety between dishes. read more

Absolutely by far the best place in Utah County that I have found for an authentic and original meal coupled with a quant atmosphere.

Meh. The food was a 3/10 for me. I got the steak tacos and they were pretty disgusting. The fried bread and nachos were just alright. It took 45 minutes to get our food, and they never take our nasty appetizer leftovers off the table. It was loud and crowded and I couldn't hear anything the people at my table were saying. The only reason this does not get a one star is because the manager (at least I think she was the manager) was very nice to us and let me park my stroller in the corner. read more

great food! too many hipsters working here almost cost them a star but the food is soo soo good i can't bring myself to do it.

One of the best burgers I have had. Drinks are a bit underwhelming. Love the changing menu. Waiters are nice and helpful. read more

I really enjoyed my experience at Black sheep. We neglected to make a reservation for a Thursday lunch, and the place was quite busy. After 30 minutes they luckily got us in. We started with the lavender honey fry bread, which was excellent, and comfortably split between three people. I got the Black Sheep Navajo Taco which while not being absolutely stunning, was good and filling. When I asked for extra pico de gallo they made it fresh and brought it out warm to me! Others got their Goat Burger, which was stunning and likely the best burger I've tried in the Provo area. I would get that if I were to go again. Their sweet potatoes fries were great, and nice and thick. Their normal fries were seasoned with rosemary and cojita and were also good. Fry sauce was excellent. Prickles Pear Cactus lemonade was tasty, but honestly didn't taste too different that a standard pink lemonade. Overall it was tasty, had a good atmosphere, and the service was great. read more

Black Sheep Cafe - Lemonade with the rosemary fries. - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

Excellent high quality unique dishes fusing Mexican and Navajo cuisine. Cozy ambiance, very friendly staff. Other tables were appropriately social distanced during COVID. read more

Black Sheep Cafe - Green Chili Stew & Bleu Fire Shrimp - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

Met a friend here for lunch. I ordered the wedge salad and the sweet potato wedges, but the salad was swimming in dressing. I asked for napkins to soak it up from the front desk because my waitress didn't come by for quite some time. And once she came by she just agreed that it was a lot of dressing; I wish they would have offered me a new salad considering how long I was struggling with it and my pile of dirty napkins. The dressing just overwhelmed the entire salad so I couldn't taste anything else. I was not impressed; $20 wasted. I won't be returning. read more

Hog Jowl Taco. If you win the Nobel peace prize or the Pulitzer Prize you can order this taco. If not, you don't deserve this taco. read more

Fabulous every time I visit this place. Love the Navajo taco, lavender honey fry bread and delicious nachos. Service was great.

I only ever get the green-chile stew, so I can't speak much to the other items. The stew is incredible!

This is actually a really great place to take a date. We only waited about 10 minutes on a crowded night, and then another 10 to actually receive our food. Temperature and taste was perfect; food was flavorful. I got the beef soft tacos. The presentation for some reason reminds me of Thai restaurants. The waitress was very attentive, checked in on us frequently. Having only been here twice, I didn't know the place all that well, and she (the waitress) actually had some awesome tips and suggestions on where to start depending on what we like or don't like. All in all, I consider this an awesome spot for dates, right up there with Red Iguana. I give Black Sheep Cafe an A+ and 5/5. I recommend. read more

Food was pretty good. Had the hog Jowl tacos. They tasted like bacon. I brought my Navajo friend here to get a better understanding of Black Sheep's "traditional" Navajo dinner cuisine... basically the tea, and some of the use of the blue corn. That was it. Even frybread isn't traditional if you know where the use came from. This was American Southwest cuisine maybe.... but to use the Navajo culture to sell your overpriced food is lame af. read more

Yes, some of the food is very unique, but it's not for everyone. Some of the food pretty pricey. The service is very good. Very hard to book a table. But if you're walk in will have a better chance, depending on the day read more

Very good food and the service was so quick. The staff was very nice; even in such a busy day.

I'm not much of a lemonade person, but I tried their cactus pear lemonade drink anyway. I very much enjoyed it. The cafe is known for contemporary Native American cuisine. I've never had Native American cuisine so I honestly can't compare it with the traditional cooking but I asked what the best sellers were. I was told the Navajo tacos so I ordered the green chile pork taco. It's HUUUGE, fyi. Ultimately, it was an amazing foodie experience. I loved the green sauce. I think that's what sold me and the fry bread was so soft. As for the ambience, it's upscale and has some cool art inside. read more

Black Sheep Cafe - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

We came here once and will probably never go again. The food was fine but it is ridiculously over priced

I have heard good things about this place... and I was in the area and thought I would stop in here to try it out for myself. Was greeted with a genuine feel by the hostess and led to our table right away. After speaking with the server, I made the choice to go with the Red Chile Beef Navajo Taco, while the other person I was with ordered the Green Chile Stew. All I can say is, "This place is legit!" This Navajo taco was so good and so full of various flavors that worked very well together. It was an explosion of flavor... to say the least. My words will come up short in just how good this was. I couldn't believe how good the stew was either. All I can say is, you must come try Black Sheep Cafe. It is worth it. read more

See all

All I have to say about Black Sheep Cafe is that it was incredibly underwhelming. At least the water was ok.

My hubby and I eat there when ever we can (we're from out of town). We love the burger on naan bread and the Navajo tacos are tasty! It's a lot of food so you may consider sharing. read more

This is our favorite anniversary place! The food is so delicious! We love the southwest flare in every bite. Reminds us of southwest food we have eaten in Santa Fe. The green chili stew and the wedge salad are my favorite. My husband loves the chimirelleno. Looking forward to celebrating our next anniversary there soon! read more

I get a hankering now and then for a Navajo Taco, and Black Sheep has a nice one. Lots of great southwestern entrees. Good salads.

Visited once and ordered the Hog Jowl Tacos. Overall, they were fine, but a bit on the small side, especially given the high prices. read more

Black Sheep Cafe - Hog Jowl Tacos - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

I stopped for dinner quick before heading back to my hotel. I was only in Provo for 1 night on business, and this was the perfect stop. Although it was a Tuesday, I had to try the Cactus Pear Margarita and it doesn't disappoint. Very clean and great balance of tastes! Loved it. For food I ordered the Chili Relleno with a side of asparagus and this also was delicious. The service was good and has a unique atmosphere. I'll be back! read more

Black Sheep Cafe - Cactus Pear Margarita - New American Near Me - Provo, Utah

See all