Big Ms is a solid right down the middle for 6-7 yards consistent every time pizza slice. The crunch is 5/5 and grease to firmness ratio is where it needs to be. It holds its own to gravity. You won't be disappointed in this slice but it won't blow you away either in terms of flavor. Don't be surprised that your dollar doesn't get you very far here...Seattle inflation has not spared pizza. Recommend hitting the back bar in the Queen Anne location and seeing what they are showing from their VHS collection. Ambiance back there is dialed in which is what brings this place and pizza from 3 stars up to 4 read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

This place was way over priced for a slice. We walked in after the next door sushi spot sucked and then walked out and past this place as well . read more

A can of soda is 4.50. The pizza itself is fine, the crust is thin and the toppings are ok. The sauce is a bit dry but acceptable. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Great New York Style Pizza shop with a dark lounge in back, I'll be back again and again for this awesome pizza and friendly service! read more

See all

Good pizza but the service is terrible. They give you attitude just because they are busy. I'm sorry, am I bothering you by giving you business. No problem, won't be back even though I enjoyed their pizza. I will take my money to other pizza joint. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Good pizza...awful workers. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Stopped by here before attending a concert and was in the mood for pizza. This location was slightly different in the sense that the front part of the place had what I considered to be a traditional seating area but then in the back there was more booth-style seating and a bar. The staff was helpful enough. The pizza was good and flavorful. I love the size of the slices which are bigger than anywhere else. The pizza is New York style which means it's thin. It did take a while for the pizza to come out, around 20-30 minutes so keep that in mind. Generally I decent pizza place. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - The Spicoli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

I've heard a lot of good things about this pizza shop, so I wanted to try it myself. Unfortunately, it wasn't that great to me. The biggest take-away is their pizza. It's New York style pizza, which I love because of the thin crust style. However, our pizza was pretty flabby at the end of the pizza, and even the cheese and toppings were falling off. I've had New York style pizza before and none of my pizza ended up like that. Flavor wise, it's good. The crust/bread was average. Our pizza came with pineapple, however, there was very little of it. They were not kind on the portioning of the other toppings as well. Service wise, it's okay. The workers aren't that friendly. We said thank you to the cashier/server before leaving the restaurant and they just gave us a very small smile and said nothing. The pizza took quite of time to make; around 30 mins. The place is half self-served. As you need to grab utensils, water, napkins, and your table by yourself. The ambiance of the restaurant varied. The main lobby is blend and doesn't have that much seating. However, the bar area is nice, as it had Halloween decorations and nice lighting. Overall, not a great experience and I wouldn't come back. read more

See all

Interesting place. Pizza is sold and served in the front with seating suitable for families and an outdoor area with no tables but a long narrow railing with counter stools. The outdoor area does not show in any pictures I could find. There is an over 21 dive bar in the back serving alcoholic beverages . The bar area has (of course) bar seating and 5 or 6 booths, where we enjoyed our pizza and beer. The pizza we ordered was delivered to us in the bar area. Hard to judge the pizza; for some reason that I had nothing to do with the pizza was half arugula and half pear. The less said about the toppings the better. Crust was good, foldable and able to support the pie. Light on the sauce for my taste. Definitely will return. read more

We showed up 3 hours prior to closing. when we walked in there was already a person at the counter talking to someone behind the register. They made small talk for 15 minutes or so, while we waited for service. The person behind the register also took a phone call before finishing with the person at the counter. After they were done they sold the other customer 4 full pizzas. When it was finally our turn to order we tried to get 1 pie. they told us we couldn't get a full pizza and we had to get single slices. The slices we were given were room temp at best, and weren't anything to rave about. Place is a solid 2/10 there is 0 customer service and everyone working is very lax. read more

Came to get lunch on a Friday around 1:30. There was one other family in at the time, so we were quickly able to order. We originally got the pizza to go, but the pizza is just given on a plate, it was slightly beginning to mist, so we ended up just eating at the shop. The place itself is quite cozy, a good amount of seating, and some nice outdoor seating I'd the weather is nice! The pizza itself is solid! The tables also have parm, herbs, and crushed red pepper. It tasted good, and the size per slice is quite big! One is enough for me, and only ~$6! Good place for a quick and tasty meal! read more

See all

The pizza is mid to thin crust and is massive! Great bartenders. Skip all salads, just trust me. Very cool vibe with the VCR rockin' movies from the 80s. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Wife's head for scale. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Ordered a large pizza half n half- potato pesto and pineapple- jalapeño pizza. It was delicious. read more

See all

Driving by we noticed the "Pizza by the Slice" sign, decided to stop by. So glad we did, great pizza.

Super disappointed. This was our first time ordering. We ordered 5 slices - thought we ordered a full cheese pizza but we ended up with a single cheese slice and had to go back up. All except 1 slice was pretty burnt. We didn't even eat 3 of them cause they were too burnt. Also, we ordered cheese pizza. We usually put some red pepper flakes on our pizza but we wanted to try this regular first. Good thing we didn't because the cheese pizza by itself was INCREDIBLY spicy. Like "someone knocked a full pepper container into the sauce" spicy. I didn't finish my piece cause it was uncomfortable to continue eating. Many better pizza places to choose from in cap hill. read more

We came here for a quick bite late at night, but ended up staying for quite a while as we ordered whole pizzas for ourselves. These ended up coming out around 30 minutes after we ordered (they warned us of this before we placed the order). We ordered a 18" Macho Man and a 14" Umberto Classic which came out to around $75, which I find a little pricey for a pizza place. This was about enough to feed 5 hungry adults, but I think I had room for a bit more. The Macho Man was very meaty and totally hit the spot for a greasy pizza! Personally, I preferred the Umberto Classic. It comes with a sweet balsamic glaze on top and the arugula balances out the cheese and meat fairly well. The crust on both pizzas was very good! Thin, but still thick enough to hold up its toppings and remain crispy. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Favorite pizza. Yummy yummy yummy. But know, the Capitol Hill location isn't as good as the Queen Ann one :)

Love having this place in Queen Anne. Not enough places in seattle are open for late night eats. But Big Mario's Pizza is open till 2am which I absolutely love. I order from here regularly. The pizzas are always great. The thin crust holds up and doesn't get soggy from the toppings. While it's not straight up crispy like slices I've had in NYC, this is still a delicious slice of pie. Our go-to is a large pepperoni. Pear Gorgonzola is also insanely delicious for any vegetarians or honestly non-vegetarians alike out there. Some point out that it's sort of pricy but come on guys, so is all of seattle. Also the 18" is quite large and the slices are big. Overall, 3 large pizzas fed 10 hungry adults with some slices left over. Sure dominos is cheaper but you get a very different pizza. The northlake location had a 20% discount for healthcare workers- not sure if that is honored at other locations. read more

So I am not sure if some of these comments were done by past employees or owners of other pizza places. After reading the reviews, I was expecting really crappy service. I walked in to nothing but pleasant smiles, and very courteous waitress. I wanted to add that the back area was packed and she was very busy, but was still incredibly polite. Peter said we take 20 minutes and that's about what it took. I got my pizza and went back to my hotel was very pleasant surprise by the pizza. I will definitely come back to this place. Give it a shot. Ignore the haters on the other reviews. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Great boxes - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Probably my favorite pizza place in the city. It's a bit overpriced to be honest, but it is the closest I've found to a true NY slice. The folks working here are very nice. The bar in the back is a cool vibe as well. Great place to start or end a night in the neighborhood. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Cheese Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Picked up three pies to have dinner with friends. Ordered classic pepperoni, Mediterranean, and classic cheese. Oh my gosh, the crust. The crust is outstanding. Toppings are generously applied and the flavors are all there. The folks that work are are very nice, and prices are swell. We love you Big Mario! read more

First and last time at Big Mario's. ordered two overpriced calzones. the veggies was stuffed with arugula, overwhelming any other flavors. the meat calzone was limp, undercooked and almost flavor free. Plus no sauce provided. Worst calzones we've ever had. Don't know about the pizzas, but the calzones are really expensive and not good. read more

This one was a tuff one. I originally wanted to just throw out a 5 star because I love this place. When I put on my review hat and actually write it out, it's just a hole in the wall pizza joint with great vibes... wait.... that's far from a bad thing... it's a great thing when that's what your looking for. Why I love this place? Is always there when I need it, it's simple, decent size slices, the people inside are friendly including the staff. I often find myself coming here on a drunken night of fun or sometimes after happy hour when I'm still hungry. Now for a realistic review from my average visit. My last visit I came after work when everything else was closed and I was just kind of hungry. It was a weekday, I got parking right up front. There were about 10 other customers inside. Only one remaining tray of cheese pizza so I had to wait 5 minutes for the next meat pizza. Their normal water dispenser was out of water, pretty much the entire time I was there even after bringing it to the workers attention. Luckily they have a bar in the bar and the lady gave me and my partner water just fine. By then our pizza was ready. My pizza it was greasy but not more than any other pizza I've eaten. Large size and almost well placed ingredients. There was a random bread bubble on my slice which mean a random toppingless bubble in the middle. There plenty of cheese and pep to cover the bare spot. The actual setting arrangement and cleanliness of the bar is barely passable but it's passes. Very retro vibes. It could use a few touch ups and love. Either way, it never stops me from coming with friends and loved ones. I will admit. It's not my favorite pizza and there is better in the area, but sometimes there just too much of a hassle. And the other places that aren't as much of a Hassel have terrible pizza. This pizza is good. You won't be mad you avoided the downtown madness and stopped here instead. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Pep - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I was craving a slice of pie and missing aka Joe's pizza. The slice you can buy for 2.50 late at night in nyc. Anyhow, I heard about this place and stopped by for a slice. I folded the pie, and the crust was a little on over cooked side, so it didn't fold as well. Usually the slice is longer and little more on undercooked side. It was ok but satisfied the craving . read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Stopped by because our hotel was within walking distance from his place and we were starving. There were a few people ahead of us ordering and there were two employees working the front. One at the register and one grabbing the pizzas. The girl working the register was rude and unfriendly. I smiled at her and said hello before ordering and she gave me a dirty look. Talk about awkward. We waited about 10 minutes to get our pizzas and we left, didn't want to eat there with a rude employee walking around. The pizza was not my favorite, too greasy for my liking. It was also cold and hard. It had definitely been sitting around for some time. Pass this place if you can. read more

See all

Please don't claim NY style pizza and then use a "special" spicy sauce. There's nothing NY about that. It's your own thing. Will some people like it? Sure. I will add my spice with chili flakes if I want it, though, thanks. read more

Ah yesss, one of the classic spots in Capitol Hill that opens late, perfect for late night drunk adventures and post-clubbing food. I have been here once before, a few weeks ago. I remember waiting in line for almost 30min with some friends after clubbing, so around 2am, so I was just chatting with them to pass the time. However, I did not end up getting anything back then because eating that late would not do good to my body. Instead, just yesterday, there was a party and they catered Big Mario's for dinner, perfect! They ordered a bunch of pizzas, and I personally tried the Pepperoni and the Coppa Cabana, 1 slice each. One slice is already quite filling and greasy, even though they are thin pizzas. The crust is slightly tough, quickly turning into cardboard texture while I was eating it. The pepperoni is very salty but also quite flavorful. I wasn't much of a fan of the Coppa Cabana because of the pepperoncini, though it is another pizza choice. I do like the arugula as a topping. Structure wise, it is a New York style pizza, but I was a little bit underwhelmed by the experience. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

We are here 3 nights in a row while on vacation from California. The two guys working Sunday evening were super nice and the pizza is awesome. We especially enjoyed talking to them and the one guy looks like a young Jack Black lol! Highly recommend. read more

We always go to the same pizza place, but wanted to branch out and try somewhere new after our neighbors suggested that they always get takeout from here. We called to order takeout, so I can't say much for the ambience or service, but the pizza was ready within the time window that they suggested, and they did offer us, utensils, plates, red pepper, and Parmesan. We didn't order anything fancy, just a plain pepperoni pizza. But all the pepperoni was double stacked, so I feel like we really got a good deal! In my opinion, this kind of pizza mostly resembles a New York style. Contrary to popular belief, I think pizza crust is the best part of a pizza, and I could've eaten a whole plain pie of it from this place - no sauce or cheese required. The pizza was fresh when we got it and cooked all the way through but not burnt. It definitely is the perfect takeout pizza if you live in the area, or are visiting the Seattle center and want somewhere to go - I would recommend! read more

Decent thin New York style pizza, above average for a place that isnt in NYC. Not overly hipster.

After watching a Mariners game we were hungry for some local pizza. This place was a few blocks away from where we were staying, but got high Yelp ratings, so we placed an order for take-out and I walked a few blocks to get it. I arrived before the pies were ready, so I had a cold Rainier in a can while I waited! This place also had a pretty large bar and outdoor seating area. We got the Potato Pesto and Macho Man pizzas. When arriving home, we dug in. The pizzas were so good that I forgot to take a photo for the rating until they were both half eaten (sorry Yelpers). Anyway, I recommend this place for anyone who likes quality pizza. Great crust, ample toppings, unique offerings. And like all great pizza, it was just as good cold the next morning for breakfast. The picture of Mario on the pizza box cover, just like the pizza itself, is classic! read more

See all

Big Mario's hits the spot every single time. The crust is honestly one of the best parts--crispy, chewy, and just really well done. And the flavor? So good. It has that perfect, classic pizza taste that makes you want another slice even when you're full. Whether it's a quick slice run or grabbing a whole pie with friends, Big Mario's always comes through. read more

delicious yum yum immaculte this was so good like best pizzanin the world come here i highly reccomend read more

See all

I'm only reviewing the dining area - Big Mario's is convenient and quick when I need food in the area! A slice is a bit pricy ($6-7) but they're pretty large. I like that there are a few types to choose from that rotate daily with some fun speciality flavors - keeps me on my toes! Service is quick - they heat up the slice in their oven then hand it to you whether you're seated or on the go. read more

Pizza hits so much better after midnight! It's so great to have a Big Mario's in Queen Anne near Climate Pledge Arena because you're always craving a slice or two after a concert. After a recent concert several weeks ago on a Sunday, there wasn't a lot of choices to get food around there. Luckily, after walking back to my friend's place and hanging out for a little bit, Big Mario's was still open. With a bar in the back, they were still making fresh pies. I got two big New York style Daily Special slices, which had sausage and olives and mushrooms and it was perfect as I perused my phone with a beer. The slices were about $5-$6 and piping hot. I devoured, finished my beer, got home and went to bed happy. Thank you Big Mario's and all late night pizza spots for staying open until 2am. read more

See all

This place ticked a few boxes for me. Close to climate pledge. Good pizza. Dive bar in the back. What more could my heart desire?! read more

I had a pretty good pizza here. I went at like 9:30-10PM on a weekend and it was pretty busy. I mention that because the pizzas were being freshly baked right in front of my eyes and I got a fresh slice so that may be part of it. It wasn't like a 10/10 authentic NY Pizza slice but still a lot better than a lot of the horrendous stuff that Seattle calls "pizza". The vibe is very alternative so if that's not your thing then beware. Drinks were really expensive but that's just how Seattle is. read more

Big Mario pizza is honestly the best!! I went here for my first time over the weekend and I don't know how I haven't been here before. Their pizza makes me rethink eating pizza and how good it should be. The pizzas are large and they have so many uniquely delicious options. This place also works as a bar in the back, another great quality! I want to give a shout out to Steve who really helped us and had such a fun attitude, he really went above and beyond! Can't wait to go back. read more

Big Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Do not order take out from this joke of a restaurant. They take over 2 1/2 hours to make a single pepperoni pizza because apparently it's rocket science. If you're that "busy" stop taking to go orders you idiots. read more

Who ever made that pizza need there ahh ate!! That was sooooooo fing goood!! The prices are so fing good too!

Don't waste your time getting pizza here. It's another place that lies and hides the true cost of your order with a fee that isn't even a tip. The restaurant keeps it all. Boycott any place that has these hidden fees to lure you in and get as much money as possible last minute. Only go to places that have prices that include everything minus tax. Stop hidden fees and lies. read more