Great soup!!!! Tuna salad and turkey hoagie great. Best chicken tenders and mustard! Fast and efficient service. read more

Where was the chicken? Not on the sandwich that's for sure. Ordered a chicken parm sandwich but needed a magnifying glass to try to find the chicken. Thank you for the bread and cheap mozzarella sandwich. If it was good mozzarella then maybe this would have been a slightly better review but sadly it was not. So if you are looking for a nice hot sandwich maybe keep looking. read more

Absolutely the worst pizza I've ever had anywhere so called Italian made with underripe ordinary sliced tomatoes. I suggest they not try to imitate Italian style pizza read more

The rudest service. I love it here just to start out with. The best buffalo calamari ... always happy eating in and take out. Never an issue til tonight. Didn't even heat up a slice of pizza for my 16 month old... waited over 20 minutes. Got muscles in red sauce instead of white never got french fries or shrimp we ordered. We paid cash. Never got refund. Had to leave with my two little kids ... plan on trying to contact owner for refund but the daughter was nasty and stole ... literally stolen money and didn't give us the food we ordered. Update Went back today and they called police on me for asking for my money back or food we didn't get. End result they gave me cash back but it was dramatic and they were terrible. I'll never ever go back police were kind but they didn't need to be called... they wasted officer time read more

We were at Benny's when Linda K(gave a 1 star review on the same night). Her person of events aren't entirely accurate so I'm not sure I believe all of what she said. She stated two times she used her mom's credit card, yet says in the review she paid cash. She called the woman at the register stupid...in front of her young children. She said she was going to post all about this on tik tok and that she had 12k followers. Seemed like she exaggerated everything to us. Our meal was very good. read more

Been coming here for years but very disappointed lately. Ever since Covid, this place has been doing great but now they're fat, happy and greedy! I ordered a sandwich in the store. With no one else in the restaurant, a staff of four people, it took them twenty minutes to make a sub. When I got home and checked out my sub, there was barely anything on the bread. Paper thin tomatoes, a thimble full of brown lettuce and they forgot the onions. The truth is, they weren't willing to give me fresh LTO, probably because they couldn't be bothered. The meat in the sandwich, was less than half of what it should've been. They used about four ounces of turkey for a whole sub. Anyway, I won't be going back to Benny's. I spent almost $30 for a sub, soda and chips? Insulting! read more

Benny's is one of the best discoveries of the year! The quality of the food is impeccable, the service is excellent and the people are all so friendly and personable. The restaurant is super clean and this place comes highly recommended. We ordered the sausage and pepperoni pizza and penne vodka and both came out so good! I will definitely spread the word around! This is a go-to place anytime of the day! read more

I took my 83 year old aunt for a ride to the shore and stopped by Bennys for a slice of Sicilian pizza and panini. It was delicious! I even bought the remaining slices to take back to Massachusetts. I will be back on my next visit to see her! read more

We have been ordering from here for years now. Every. Single. Time...we are greeted with a smile and a thank you for being a customer. The food is delicious, made with all fresh ingredients at a very good price. You feel at home instantly where the owner makes you feel like family. I tell everyone how great Benny's Pizza is. Don't miss out. read more

Amazing pizza pasta eggplant chicken cutlet sandwiches. homemade sauce! My good to place!

Delivery driver couldn't find my place and then delivered a dropped pizza. I sent a photo to Bennys and they didn't even respond read more

Bennys Pizza - This is how my pizza arrived after the delivery driver couldn't find my place. I emailed bennys but they didn't bother to respond - Italian Near Me - Spring Lake, New Jersey

Not only is this place ran by one of the kindest people on the planet, but their food is incredible. I've had it all, here.. from the cheesesteak to a chicken wrap to penne vodka to a cheese pizza pie. And everything is as good as it gets. They've managed to also turn their place into a great spot for a date night. Can't go wrong here!! read more

Have been ordering here for the last 6 months and it's now our go to go pizza, dinners, cheesesteaks, salads and sandwiches. Everyone in the family proclaimed best local cheesesteak! Delivery is always extremely quick, even throughout covid. Benny has been a savior during COVID - ordering almost 3-4 times a week! read more

A disaster from start to finish. I called and ordered baked ziti with a side order of meatballs. I also wanted to order broccoli. The person who answered the telephone said I could not order broccoli as a side order. I said I HAD TO HAVE A VEGETABLE with my dinner as a matter of health. He said I'd be getting some mixed vegetables with the dinner. Fine. The dinner came, and there were no vegetables at all and no salad dressing for my salad. I had ordered Italian dressing on the side. I called up and the young man told me NO vegetables were included and he had made a mistake. Then he informed me all of a sudden that he COULD send over a broccoli side order and it would be an additional seven dollars and it would be a half an hour later. Fine. An hour later NO sign of the broccoli. Every time I called the place I was put on hold for a long period of time. PS the bread that came with the dinner was stale. They really need to get their act together. VERY DISORGANIZED. read more

Very good local pizzeria. I've eaten from here at least 6 times. Consistently good pizza. Great crust; good cheese and sauce. Good entrees ( go for the salmon ). I also recommend the avocado salad. Also the staff is very friendly, nice guys. The restaurant has about eight tables on each side, some just quick sit down with benches, and on the other side chairs and table cloths. Not really restaurant dining, per se, but you can grab a bottle of wine from across the street and eat in if you like. read more

This is our go to pizza place because its so close to our home, but they have so many other delicious options! The owner is kind, courteous and always makes you feel at home! The staff is also friendly. Love the pizza, salads, meatballs....just about everything. We've used Bennys many times to cater our get togethers and family parties and always get the stromboli when I'm going to a friends as an appetizer. I recommend Bennys to everyone, it is top notch. read more

This review is based solely on the pizza. We went here one night on a pizza tour trying 5 slices from 5 different spots. Benny's was incredibly disappointing. The pizza was raw. It might be telling you something that it was 8pm on a Friday night and we were the only people there. Even if the pizza had been cooked, the sauce was flavorless and the crust tasted like wet cardboard. I feel terrible writing a bad review but I just don't get that it's a pizza place and they can serve a product this poor. read more

Benny's is the best. It's well taken care of inside. Great customer service. Friendly people all around.

We ordered delivery it took over 85 minutes to arrive. We got the nonnas pizza. The pizza dough was is very raw, along with the cheese being burnt. Also i hate to say this, but it had no flavor really. I would not recommend this place. read more

Best pizza in the area, especially the Nona's pie, they also make the best cheese steak that I've had in the area, I'm surprised by all the negative reviews. read more

First time ordering from Benny's and had great expectations since I saw that my neighbor had a delivery from them the night before. Ordered Pizza and Chicken Marsala dinner online. Delivery time stated was going to be 1 hour, finally delivered 2 1/2 hours later after 2 phone call followups. The Chicken Marsala had to be reheated in the microwave as it was not hot and unfortunately not great. The pizza was horrible!!!! Luke warm, thick, doughy crust and flavorless. Very disappointed - first and last time for Benny's Pizza & Subs. read more

Great example of small town pizzeria of NJ that I even not growing up as a kid in NJ but as an adult got to appreciate. Order t veal dishes are really good not just t pizza read more

A perfect pizza shop. Excellent, fresh ingredients, courteous staff and delicious food. My family choose Benny's time and time again.

Love Benny's! They make the best pizza. The white pie is amazing. They are always trying new ideas. The staff are so pleasant and aim to please!! read more

Very good food, and they have a wonderful staff that always makes sure your food is always up to par for dining needs. Would highly recommend a nice plain pizza, always good no matter what time of the day. read more

I ordered the pizza to-go, other than the pizza being unbelievably hot, the cheese came off the pizza as I was taking my slice from the pie. The pizza itself tasted like typical pizza, albeit it came in a smaller size. Since I ordered the pizza to-go I was expecting to receive some napkins in a bag to accompany the relatively expensive pizza, to clean my hands from the grease coming from the pizza, but no. read more

So clean.think Benny may have a germ \ dirt phobia. Best healthy salads.good cheese steaks and chicken cheese steaks. Full meals are amazing. Waiting for salad and mussels to be delivered now. Love it . I read more

in a competitive Pizza environment this place does not disappoint. strongly recommend the meatballs/meatball parm. it's become our go-to spot read more

Always happy with the food here. Pizza, dinners, salads, subs. Never had a problem. Have gotten take-out and delivery and we are always happy. I don't know who these other reviewers are. The place is always packed and we really enjoy it! read more

Grabbed a slice and it was ok, place was clean my slice was a little undercooked on top and ashy on the bottom. Will try again when they are busier to see if it was just a off day read more

I eat a lot of pizza and I order from Benny's all the time. Not sure where some of the other reviews come from - it's quite popular in the town. Perfect balance of crust, sauce and cheese with delicious sauce. I like to order them well done. You can also get jumbo pizzas (20") which are great - full sized slices for home. The one thing they are known for is the pizza can be a little greasy - it has been this way going back years to the original place (Irene's). Dab it off some if you must - it's totally delicious. I've also have had salads, various appetizers, different subs and cheesesteaks from Bennys. Always good. You would be hard pressed to find nicer people to boot. read more

This is my favorite local place to grab pizza or a sub for the family. Great atmosphere, everyone is very friendly and makes your order as quick as they can. I recommend the avocado salad with chicken, it is amazing ! Cheap price for a dozen garlic knots and those are good too. I would totally try the penne vodka pizza it is a MUST TRY. read more

Wanted to try a new pizza place so decided on Benny's . It took an hr to get here. As i was looking out the window i saw the delivery guy running with the Pizza in his hand to our door . When we ate it was cold and still doughy . Very very disappointed should have gone with our first thought and got Chinese!! read more

Benny's is the best from the moment you enter, you are greeted with a warm smile, and always excellent service and food. The Meat Ball Parm Sub is literally to die for. Benny's salad's are fresh and made with romaine salad, not those dandelion salads that are all the rage. It's good authentic Italian food and service. Everything from a slice to a nice dinner is outstanding and has a small twist that distinguished itself from others. Thank you to the entire team at Benny's, you all work hard, and do a nice job read more

Come here multiple times per week for the buffalo chicken pizza, and they cater all my events. Top quality for a quality price.

I eat at Benny's Pizza every weekend and am never disappointed. The pizza is awesome...lots of varieties to choose from. The subs (hot or cold) are also very good. So far, everything that I have tried on the menu is worth eating again and again. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. read more

I went to Benny's tonight to get a few slices to go. Can someone please explain how 2 chicken parm slices and one cheese steak slice and 2 0.99 Arizona iced teas were $13.35? The drinks were only $2. So the slices were around $3.50 each. The only reason I got those kind of slices was because that's all they had left. Could of got a whole pizza for that price. Bring back Irene's read more