This place is absolutely delicious and worth the drive. The pepperoni perfectly curls and cups the grease. The cheese is perfectly melted and just the right amount of gooey. The crust is firm but still plush enough to eat the crust without it cutting the roof of your mouth. Caesar salad was a BANGER. I did not expect to love a salad just as much as the main star of the show. I didn't even take a photo because it got completely wiped out as soon as the table hit. Service is phenomenal. The staff is limited but you wouldn't even notice until you're leaving. The craftsmanship here is authentic and passionate. The dining experience is elevated but not overly done. The place itself is spacious, perfectly lit and very clean. They even offer very cute and quality merch. I even bought a pullover and loved that it was made with great materials. Love supporting this small local business and I highly recommend! read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Some of the best pizza in jersey shore area. I would highly recommend this spot for anything you may need for a big group for easy food. Pick up is so easy and would do it again. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - 'Lucci Spinach Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Really good pizza. I went just to try the pizza and was not disappointed. The crust is delicious and nice char. They give chili oil on table but the pizza did not need anything. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Plain "cheese" Pie - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Here's the deal true artists delivering amazing pizza and sandwiches! Tough spot to get into on weekends but totally worth it! Most definitely back to explore more creations when km in the area! read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Specially pizza. Whipped Ricotta, Calabrian chile,, broccolini, sausage pecorino cheese, mozzarella. It was outstanding - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Thin and crispy pizza with a great atmosphere. The waitress was attentive and friendly. As good as the plain pizza was, the spinach pie was the star of the meal. Highly recommend. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Spinach pizza - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Solid pizza. Ad a group of four, we split the Soppressata pizza and white Spinach pizza. The whipped ricotta starter was good but could've come with more bread. BYOB. Plenty of parking. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - White Spinach Pie - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Great pizza from 'Lucci. This was the Lucci Pepperoni, which also includes some red onion. The crust was outstanding; crispy bottom and edges, but still having a solid chew (this is NOT one of those paper-thin cracker crusts...) Great flavors in the pepperoni, cheese, and sauce. My only nitpick is that there wasn't quite enough sauce on the pizza. But still 5 stars. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Lucci Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I have to say I am floored by the quality and flavor of the food at Lucci. Seriously a top pizza place at the jersey shore. 10 out of 5 for food for sure! The folks there really care about their product and took the time to speak with us about our experience and shared that they are working hard to create a great experience. I would love to see a little more ambiance - perhaps a cozy vibe, so hopefully that will come in time. Just a little more decor could potentially do it. Can't wait to return for that crunchy crust, perfectly balanced sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. Also, don't sleep on the Caesar salad - it's perfect. read more

See all

I am completely shocked that this place doesn't have over four stars. We LOVED Lucci! What I liked: * Holy smokes, their specialty white pie for October with squash, kale, red onion, and sausage is a home run. The sausage was big chunks of REAL, juicy Italian sausage (none of the fake crumbly stuff), the squash was incredibly flavorful, and the red onion was sliced thin, exactly how I prefer it on pizza * They sell square slices! I'm so sick of whole pie only pizzerias. You gotta' let us taste before we invest in a whole pie * Pricing is comparable to similar establishments ($20 plain pie) * Sourdough crust!!!! * Super friendly staff who you can tell are obsessed with pizza What I didn't love: * The only reason for the -1 star is because unfortunately the square slice was too dry, I think they just reheated it for too long, or maybe they need a little more sauce on it upfront. There were bites that weren't dry/had little pockets of sauce that were the bomb. This is one of those instances where I wish I could give a 4.5 All in all, GREAT place. Well worth the 1-ish hour drive from North Jersey. read more

See all

We've been to this pizzeria several times over the past few years, but this time we hadn't been there since about October. Usually the service is excellent and the pizzas and appetizers are also very good. This last time though, the waiter didn't know what a Margherita pizza was and the kitchen didn't seem to know either, as we were asked if we wanted (mozzarella) cheese on it. When the pizza came out, it was crispy and good--but it wasn't a Margherita. There were no sliced tomatoes nor slices of fresh mozzarella. It was what a plain pizza would be, except it did have whole basil leaves. Also there used to be a choice of large or small chopped salad. This time it was only one size and the waiter never heard it being two different size portions. Maybe it was an off night for both the wait staff and the kitchen crew, as we will go back again maybe closer to summer. read more

Excellent pizza from this surprisingly diverse restaurant strip in Belmar which also has burritos, Indian food, Greek, etc. We had decided on pizza as we used to live in NYC and are suckers for well-made thin crust pies. We had the white pizza and the pepperoni and they were both excellent! Nice amount of char and crisp on the crust and a good sauce to cheese ratio on the pepperoni pie. The white pizza had the perfect combination of cheeses with some shaved parm on top for good measure. Only downside was that we'd forgotten to take our leftovers in the box they provided but that's on us! Definitely a new favorite and will be back. read more

Ahhhhhh(cracks knuckles)....walking into the minimalist masterpiece that is Lucci you are confronted with the dichotomy of a simple layout no frills or pomp and the smells of an exquisite experience about to hit your palette. We had our infant with us and had yet to feed her at a restaurant as she eats homemade food even when we're out. Our waitress was warm and considerate and we ordered right away. Well, after the whipped ricotta, meatballs, pasta fagioli, and Caesar salad hit the table, everyone ceased talking and we began the ride, infant included. Meatballs were soft and delicious. We did not leave any trace evidence of the whipped ricotta, Caesar salad was amazing, authentic and still crunchy. The baby ate most of the bowl of pasta fagioli and was smiling and licking her lips the whole time. We moved on to devour the spinach pie and new edition penne vodka. The pizza was hot, thin crusted, flakey and smooth as fuck. Piece after piece disappeared off the tray. The penne vodka had a kick and my daughter crushed it until she was full. We finished with one of the top three tiramisu I've ever had in my hundreds of tiramisu's. Every ingredient was authentic and perfectly paired. I had no bloating, no sticker shock and we left laughing into the cold night at our baby who was still gnawing on now soggy crust. We can't wait to go back and spend another evening there. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

We recently got takeout from here: a piping hot pizza with super thin crust and flavorful sauce & cheese. Really delicious! Just wish they had a slightly bigger menu. Looking forward to dining in soon. read more

Great location, pizza was unbelievable, fantastic staff and ambiance. Can't wait to try more pies

A breath of fresh air down the shore, took out a plain with sausage. Very good ingredients cooked very well. Great flavor and not too cheesy. The dough is fresh, thin and crisp. Love the sausage, great flavor. I saved a couple of slices for my wife, and will be back to dine in and try the meatballs and salads. While waiting (I arrived 10 minutes early) it was busy, with food flowing from the kitchen and a happy vibe. The place is clean and the staff is very friendly. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - The classic plain with sausage! As the menu says "Whole Milk Mozzarella, Fresh Mozzarella, Milled Tomatoes, Basil" - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

The chopped salad was delicious. The sausage on the pizza was of high quality. It was delivered cold. Not tepid or warm but cold.Like the slices you see before reheating, collecting dust at any pizza joint. The Galley, Tony's, Dominic's, Lupo and others are all able to deliver a hot pie. At this price it should be a given. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - NAY! .........People say the meatball sandwiches are very good. - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

The pizza was ok, salad was ok. Very pricey for burnt pizza. I really don't see what the hype is on this place. Don't think I will be going back. read more

Wow! Best pizza I have ever had hands down! Also had the Italian sandwich was amazing and the bread was next level. Honestly the meal and experience was made so much better because the staff was so nice. Start with some wings at 10th Ave Burrito right next door and finish with some pizza at Lucci! read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Plain pie and pepperoni and red onion pie. - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Excellent pizza.. fresh basil, thin crust. Highly recommended. Service was excellent. Loved the simple decor. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

I've never had a classic pizza of higher quality than at Pizzeria Lucci. The dough is so thin and crisp it could give you a paper cut, with five slices here about equal to two standard ones. The undercarriage is flawless, making for the cleanest eat I've had, yet it still delivers rich, top quality ingredients. Every element works in harmony: the light char, subtle fluff, fresh cheese, and vibrant sauce all showcase elite craftsmanship. You can tell the chef has the whole process down to a science. I'm rating it an 8.5, the second-best pizza I've had on the Jersey Shore, just behind Sea Bright Pizzeria. The only thing holding it back from the high 8s is that while the quality is maxed out, it lacks that extra spark/ the exotic kick or burst of flavor that sets the very best pies apart. read more

See all

The pizza and other food are well prepared and enticingly presented. The seating policy is a bit questionable. We rushed to get there before 8pm but arrived at 8:01, stuck behind traffic due to an open bridge en route. The host refused to seat us. Very disappointing that they were not the least empathetic. We were starving and went to Vic's a few minutes north where the staff were much nicer. read more

Been wanting to come by for a while. The place is pretty minimalistic but obviously you come for the pizza. I tried the pepperoni with red onions and mozzarella. The crust has a nice crunch to it and it isn't floppy. So good. The marinara piece was bland and I am a marinara pizza expert. The meatballs were good and you can tell they are homemade. Love the sauce. One of the better pizza's in the area. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Had to try more fan favorites from Lucci after having it for the first time earlier this month. The white pie is great and the meatballs are phenomenal. Super delicate and flavorful. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Opening week... It was busy on a Thursday night at 7 o'clock. Friendly staff, nice and clean and new inside. I ordered takeout, I took about ~10 minutes. The pizza looks, smells, tastes fantastic. Love it! read more

See all

Exceptional pizza in New Jersey, I'm a pizza critic from NYC & this place is worthy of my praise. Service was very good, has that old school pizzeria vibe with some modern twists. Get the meatballs & ricotta, you won't be disappointed read more

This was our first time there. We were there a little before 4 when they open for dinner. There was a line outside to get in. Even with that we were seated promptly. We had the whipped ricotta and caesar salad for appetizers. Both were delicious! We ordered the plain pie which was outstanding! The pie was thin crust and it was well done which I love. The crust was the star of the show. Very flavorful! We had the tiramisu for dessert. It was amazing! My husband and I will definitely be eating there again! read more

The pizza and salad were tasty, but they won't fill you. Service is non existent since you order at the register, you get up to fill your own water glass( no lemon, no ice), similar to a cafeteria. Pre paid 20% tip at register while ordering. Learned not to do that again. Asked for red pepper, oregano and parm cheese. None offered from waitress. Great gross profit business for owner, change the kitchen layout and you could make your own pizza too. read more

Don't typically leave reviews but felt compelled. I work at a highly respected pizza shop so I'm a bit of a pizza snob. Service was friendly and attentive and you can tell these guys really care. Got there right when they opened and ordered a pizza, Stracciatella and meatballs. Everything was great. Pizza was perfectly charred. Crust was crunchy and airy and pizza was thin but sturdy. Food was so good that I decided to take a Caesar salad home too. Good decision. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Good News: great meatballs & chopped salad Bad News: service is not great. These are not smiley and welcoming folks. You are paying good money for their products and they are politely impolite. Pizza is just ok If you can deal with crappy uncomfortable seats and mediocre service then you will be satisfied. I do take out there so I am not disappointed in the people who serve there..... read more

Simple and delicious. Get the Pepperoni Lucci pie and the meatballs. You won't be disappointed. read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Pepperoni Lucci - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

This is probably the finest pizza place in the general Belmar area. Try it yourself and decide if I'm right.

Do you like thin well done pizza? If no, don't come here. If you do. This place is for you. I would say in the shore area. This is a close second to Rosie's for best pizza. It's got great flavor. Great char. We got the pepperoni with onion pie. Fantastic. Two people can easily split this. I understand it might be pricey for some people but I would rather pay $5 more for a pie than get your standard pizza. read more

Great pizza. Did takeout only. Neapolitan style pizza, tangy sauce, good crust and flavorful toppings.

Got the meatball sub to go which was 19.00 and change. Wow I can say I have never had a better mb sub in my life. meatballs were outstanding and everything else in it was perfect. Bread was very good. Next time will try the pizza. Can I give them a 10? read more

Omg !! This pizza was wicked good thin crispy crust with nice char bubble. The sauce tasted like fresh plum tomatoes. With whole milk mozzarella cheese. I ate the entire pizza by myself. Very bright and clean inside the restaurant. Definitely would come back here read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

One of the best pies I've ever had. Love it well done, great toppings. Long wait time is worth it (ordered during 5 on a Friday, created my own situation there). Will be going back read more

The food is so delicious. The staff is friendly and the food is served quickly. The chopped salad with the Classic plain pizza were the freshest, flavorful ingredients. I came back the next day for the Chicken Milanese sandwich. I would drive an hour to the shore just for that sandwich. read more

Went here the other night, got the caesar salad and then the pepperoni pizza. Both were pretty good, the wait was a little long. It's mostly dine in here too. Not a bad place read more

Pizzeria Lucci - pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Fresh, flavorful pizza! Love the simple and quality ingredients. One of my favorite pizzas in the area! We got Lucci special pepperoni and Lucci special spinach and loved both. Ordering was simple on the website and pizza was done on time read more

Pizzeria Lucci - Lucci Special Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Ordered a Lucci Pepperoni to go last Saturday night. One of the best pizza's I ever had. Will always get pizza from this spot. Fan for life. read more