Walking by, I decided to stop in and see if I could get a little taste of home. Ordering was…read morestraightforward, and placing a to-go order at the counter was quick and easy. One thing to note: the prices on the printed menus were about a dollar lower than what I was actually charged, so it may be time for them to update the menus to match the current pricing. We ordered a whole cheese pie, and it was more than enough to feed two people. The crust had a nice chew, the sauce was well-balanced, and there was a good ratio of sauce to cheese without feeling overloaded. Personally, I would've liked a little more cheese, but that's simply my New York preference--not a flaw in the pizza itself. Overall, it satisfied the craving and reminded me of a classic neighborhood pizzeria back home. If you're looking for a solid New York-style pizza in the area, Vinny's is worth a try.

About our 10th delivery order from Vinnies (plus dozens of on-site visits) we ordered a Diavolo for…read morethe first time. Certainly, we expected it to be spicy. WE did not expect it to be inedibly, sickiningly SALTY. Both of us took bites we promptly spit out rather than swallow. WE phoned to warn them that something was dreadfully wrong with the sauce. The response was , "WE KNOW the Calabrian peppers are not just hot, but dreadfully salty." Friends, I don't care that VINNIES knows ... as a customer, I want to know that before choosing to waste my pizza dollar. The pizza was in our trash chute while still warm. We will think twice before ordering from Vinnies again.

Nice atmosphere, staff was friendly. Reasonably priced for this part of Atlanta. Ordered a Greek…read moresalad and it well made, lots of olives and peppers . Dressing was very tasty. Not the best but again, the value and overall quality were there for the price point. Kids had wings, pretty decent, large size wings. Now for the Pizza. Not bad, not bad at all. NY Style, large slices. Cheese pizza and a pepperoni. The pizzas were 18 inch for the large and again, reasonably priced. Typical NY slices, lots of flavor, could have been cooked a little more but not a big deal. Pepperoni were nice and not too spicy or greasy. Would definitely come back.

Buckhead Pizza is always a good idea. I usually get "The Lenox" pizza but this day I was feeling a…read moresalad so I got the 1/2 Caesar salad with steak. It was delicious. They also have 1/2 off bottles of wine on Tuesdays so I enjoyed a nice South African Sauvignon Blanc. 10/10. The bartender was great. It was early in the afternoon so it was quiet and chill. I had a wonderful relaxing lunch

Went for the lunch special which is two slices one topping for $6 and a drink I had the special…read morewhich was one size plus a small salad with a drink (10$). The pizza crust is actually pretty good, it's thin crunchy and the toppings are generous but definitely could use a little bit more sauce and cheese. So be sure to ask for extra cheese if that's how you like your pizza. The salad is very good,it's a giant portion for a small and has enough toppings to fill your hunger. would definitely go back for the lunch specials

Zero! Walked in no service silent bartender tonight and very disappointed energy in general so we…read morewalked out.

The Pizza by the slice has that New York Crisp. We also like the lasagna,…read moreSpaghetti and meatballs and often the specials. Great neighborhood hang out.

Delicious pizza and good homemade brownies. Good value for the money. Reasonable cost. Onsite…read moreparking Great staff Kid friendly.

The pizza tasted great, the NY style had yummy options and was not greasy. The greek salad was…read morefresh and flavorful. The garlic garlic knots were delightful and mouth watering. The beer options could have been better, but we did go on a Monday. Service was braggworthy! Michelle took care of My hungry teenagers and my husband was deeply impressed with her mind-reading abilities. Definitely a gem in the Big City! Pizza & FIFA soccer made the ambiance a winner in my book. I will always be back!

First visit during a work week lunch. Pretty good. If you go for one of the lunch specials, be sure…read moreto look online in advance & hold your ground if the special is different than expected. I was told the special was only cheese slices & a salad when I'd thought it was slices & a drink. I got a single slice of the meat option & a drink instead, which frankly was fine & about the same price but later checked & confirmed the special was as I'd thought. Anyway, the pizza was good. Nearby Atwoods a bit better on the pizza itself. I'll probably go again & try something else.

A nice late night fill, they stay open until 2am and make each dish to order. The wait was a little…read morelong but the pizza was decent. The price for what you get is a little pricey if you get toppings so it would probably be best to get a whole pizza instead of a slice. It did scratch the late night cravings though . They have bar seating , drink specials and booths to sit at. Lights at the top which makes it feel like a club

I placed an online order and receive confirmation that my order and been received and would be…read moreready in 30 mins. After waiting 30 mins and having to fight to find a parking spot, I was told my the unapologetic and nonchalant server that "oh they must not have sent it to us" which didn't even make sense because I ordered directly on the site. This was a waste of my time and owing to dietary restrictions i can't eat after 9:30 so I'm rushing to find something else to eat quickly if I can. If not I just have to go to sleep with no food because an hour was wasted (and gas)! You all have to work on your efficiency and customer service. This was unacceptable

Amazing pasta, excellent customer service, and a great atmosphere. Everything was fresh and…read moreflavorful, and the staff was friendly and attentive. The vibe is perfect for a relaxed meal or a special outing. Definitely a must-visit in Midtown--I'll be back for sure!

I usually enjoy this place, however this particular time. I called at least 15 times to order and…read moreno one picked up. When I arrived to the store nothing was going on, they just were intentionally ignoring the calls. Also terrible service from the staff when I did arrive. Wnt be returning.

I've been here several times. Really enjoyed the seating area outside and the little lounge area at…read morethe front. Pepperoni slice with ricotta cheese was pretty good. I appreciate the crisp to the crust. Nice flavor to the sauce. Liked the pour options for beers/spirits. I was able to taste several different types of cocktails without it hurting my pockets. I go for maybe 1-2oz each time. Friendly service though I didn't really interact with many of the workers since it's pretty much self service. Decent prices. Will be back for sure!

The food was hot fresh and delicious. The service was fast and polite. The ambiance is a sports bar…read morevibe with multiple games playing on tv's but not too loud and very clean. We ordered a slice of the Stracciatella and the Dynamo. Both were really yummy and I was very surprised to find out. I enjoyed the hot honey. This was a good vibe. You should definitely come here for a hang out.