I really like this place. The food is delicious with good size portions, the wait staff and host are very professional and the prices, like the prix fixe lunch special, are decent. It looks like there's actual management running the place. Chicken parm and pasta - excellent. Some radicchio salad special was also great. Definitely going back. read more

We usually get excellent service at Bella Luna. Pretty disappointed with the last visit. Our appetizer came out with the dinner. Rather surprised we were charged twice for a refill on fountain soda. Nickel and diming read more

Nice update on the inside. Good lighting, not too overly bright which gives it a good vibe, nice ambiance, and not overly loud as well. You can actually talk to your table person or persons. Though I have not ordered all things on the menu, the food is consistently tasty. Pasta dishes arrive well presented, taste great and the service is attentive. I have tried the salads as well and they are also good, and there are a variety of other dishes that I'm sure are lovely. Fish options as well. They have a nice wine selection, pleasant and inviting not over lit atmosphere. The bar is great to sit at as well. Overall I've never been disappointed and go often enough to notice. A go to place for the upper west side. read more

Made reservations for a small group and we were seated immediately. The place was beautifully decorated and clean wood floors, bar and bathrooms. Waitress was friendly and made good drink suggestion. Food was a nice size portion size. I had the Fillet Branzia accompanied with glass of Pinot and for dessert berry tart. What a beautiful dish! read more

Bella Luna Restaurant - Berry Tart - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Large servings, fresh Caprese, service very friendly and quick. Great music. The raviolis were handmade. I recommend the combo ravioli with beef, cheese, spinach, and lobster. And the vodka cream sauce is to die for. read more

Bella Luna Restaurant - Ravioli - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

We ordered the penne alla vodka and it was delicious! The portions are great and everyone in my family loved their meal. I especially recommend the tiramisu and the hazelnut gelato for dessert (my kids loved them). The service was impeccable. Our waitress was the sweetest and the manager was very respectful, understanding, and kind. The decor in the restaurant truly made the experience that much better the light fixtures were gorgeous and there was greenery all over the restaurant. Overall I will be coming back to Bella Luna and recommend this place to anyone that lives in the city or is visiting! read more

Bella Luna Restaurant - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Sweet restaurant with outdoor seating on Columbus. We went for a relaxing brunch, had awesome aperol spritzes and delicious omelettes. I think what I like best about Bella Luna is that it's a neighborhood joint, but with pretty and delicious food and the friendliest staff I've experienced in a while. Coming back for dinner soon! read more

We came here many times but the last time it missed the mark. The service was unfriendly. Took us a while to get water and then longer still to order. They were not particularly accommodating to kids. The kids pasta was absolutely tasteless. The caprese was very average. The mussels in red sauce were ok. The manager came off like he really didn't like people. Quite rude to be honest. Don't think we are coming back. read more

First timer at this location along w/my good friend. We only ordered a beer but the attention the staff gave us, was amazing!! I will definitely stop by to try out their menu the next time I I am around, so stay tuned.... read more

What a hidden gem. My partner and I found ourselves shopping in Harlem later than we expected. Bella Luna was a quick drive over on a Wednesday evening. We were in luck because it was very close to closing. We were immediately seated after seeing the hostess. In the evening the ambiance is absolutely stunning for a casual dining restaurant. We got right to it, ordering the broccoli soup as an appetizer, spaghetti with meatballs, and the tri-color tortellini with no prosciutto in alfredo sauce. Absolutely everything we had, down to the wine and ginger ale, gave an elevated experience. The broccoli soup had onions in it so I only took a very small taste. It was very creamy, reminiscent of broccoli cheddar soup (sans cheddar). The tortellini was cooked to Al dente perfection, in a lightly buttery yet creamy sauce. Would highly recommend Bella Luna for any occasion. read more

Just spend my 2nd Valentine Day dinner the atmosphere decor is so welcoming and tasteful Italian restaurant, the Grilled Lamb chops with French fries and mixed vegetables delicious and well cooked to perfection,shrimp scampi , mixed green salad, first the bottle water the waiter Jeffrey suggested Moscato Asti bottle that gives you 4 + glasses of wine poured by your waiter that comes back and refills your glass,the attentive concerned that everyone showed,waitstaff friendly and polite Now is not always I eat dessert but you cannot pass on pistachio gelato yummy ,tiramisu made on the premise tartfuto triple chocolate delight read more

See all

Fast service and reliably good food. This place has been in the neighborhood org his for decades and is well liked.

This is a 3.5 star review. I came to Bella Luna for dinner with a group of about 6 girlfriends. It's a nice quiet restaurant on the Upper West Side. I ordered a mango margarita and the white pizza which were both pretty good! My only gripe was how slow the service was. It took about 25 minutes to serve our drinks and took another 45 minutes for them to even take our food orders. I will say that once our order was taken, the food came out pretty fast. It's a nice place for maybe a date night, but not really ideal for groups as the restaurant is relatively small. Would I return, probably not because there are so many other dope restaurants in the city and this was slightly above average. Nothing to write home about honestly. read more

The food is delicious and carefully prepared and presented. Service is warm and attentive but not disruptive. We went just after the lunch crowd left. At that hour, the restaurant is not crowded--it is comfortable, inviting, and quiet. We enjoyed two wonderful lunches there and will return. I recommend it highly. read more

Came here for dinner with a few friends. Service was great. The ambiance was cozy and on the quieter side. Perfect date night spot. We got the Bella Luna Spritz to drink and it was absolutely spectacular, the perfect summer time spritz. Very light. We also shared Bruschetta appetizer. It came sliced in very large pieces so it was a bit messy but sooo good. I also got the Eggplant Parm and it was to die for. Breaded and seasoned to perfection. Honestly couldn't believe it wasn't meat! The texture was perfect. Overall 10 out of 10 would recommend. read more

See all

I like the ambiance and everyone is friendly - but the food comes out way too fast! Under 5 minutes after ordering. Doesn't make for a great date. read more

I love this place. Good prices and good food. The dishes I ordered tonight were a mixed bag, the minestrone needed salt. And then in an attempt to go on the healthier side I got the grilled chicken salad. The chicken was very well cooked, not too dry. But I didn't love the crunch of the mushrooms. So all in all I wasn't thrilled with my meal but my dad and his friend were very, very pleased. Will definitely be back again to order some of their yummy pasta! read more

Bella Luna Restaurant - Minestrone - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We made a reservation for dinner on my birthday and everything from the food to the service was wonderful. It was a rainy evening and they had bins at the front of the restaurant for our umbrellas. We were seated quickly and once we were at the table I noticed how beautiful the restaurant was with the lighting and wall art. Our server was wonderful at keeping our glasses filled the entire evening. The food was delicious and I sampled a little bit of every dish our table ordered. We finished the evening with a delightful chocolate cake. If I lived in the area we would definitely be regulars. read more

Reliable neighborhood hang. Friendly, relaxed, consistently good food. Seats are not too close, you never feel rushed. Comfortable, good wine list. read more

Rude staff and deliveryman. They charge way too much for some reheated food that lacks flavor.

I thought that this restaurant really hit the spot! We were starving and had been walking all day. We were pleasantly surprised by the prices at this restaurant. $18 for a pasta dish. Not too bad. The portions aren't that large but they are PERFECT. The perfect amount for lunch! Lots of options. FREE BREAD We got: Tricolored tortellini $21 & penne, à la vodka $18 Service was quick! Surprisingly quick. Nice, clean bathrooms. Small place, but cute. Definitely recommend. Fresh and hot read more

See all

I hosted a birthday party for 11; 5 adults and 6 kids at 3:30pm. We spent a day at the Museum of Natural History (we called ahead 2 days prior) and the restaurant was able to accommodate us. The atmosphere was warm and cozy with candles on the tables. The walls were decorated with Christmas lights. The service was top notch! Our order was taken quickly and efficiently. I knew the kids had a simple pallet so I ordered 2 Margherita pies, penne a la vodka, pasta bolognese, calamari as well as mussels and a spicy lamb pie for the adults. The food came quickly and we gobbled everything up! We finished the meal with ice cream and gelato. Our waiter came out with a lit candle on the birthday girl's ice cream and we all sang happy birthday to her. The party was lovely thanks to Bella Luna! Thank you! read more

See all

Cute and casual local spot, with friendly and efficient service. My husband got the Bella Luna pizza, which he liked. I got the linguine with clams, which was nice and briny, but the sauce was a bit too soupy. Still very much willing to go back and try the other items on the menu. read more

The short take: Fresh, delicious, gourmet dishes provided in a pleasant cafe setting and with very good service. We stopped in on a hot day for a refreshing Sicilian Salad and a Caprese. Both were notably artfully prepared, with the right amount of seasoning. Iced teas were very nice. Somewhat pricey, but not egregious or outside the neighborhood norms. Highly recommended. read more

Visited here on a random weekday while working and walking around the upper West side with coworkers searching for a lunch place. This was totally unplanned but luckily we were able to find some outdoor seating and the staff and the manager or perhaps the owner were very accommodating. Fortunate to say also that the menu is quite extensive and caters to various tastes and discernment in food. For example there are lots of vegetarian only and gluten-free options. Service was quick on point and precise so nothing to complain about. Pricing for the upper West side as expected a little bit on the higher end but the portions were more than generous. For example on my salad that had chicken I was not hunting for the chicken. I will definitely come back here again if I were in the neighborhood as everything was very solid. read more

Bella Luna Restaurant - Chicken Salad - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Super good margherita pizza! Nice ratio of sauce to cheese. Our waiter wasn't super nice but it was a large group of 10 people so maybe he was just overwhelmed. We sat in the covered outdoor seating. We were all crammed in so it wasn't super cute or comfy. So not sure what the inside of the restaurant looks like. read more

Bella Luna Restaurant - Margherita Pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Really it's a 31/2 star. Food was 5 star but service and staff brought it down. It was Saturday night and I went to Yelp for Italian food on UWS. Bella Luna came up #1 . I read the reviews and went to the website. On the home page there was a red box that said "Reservations" Available times were 8:30 & 9:00. I chose 8:30 and had a choice of indoor, outdoor or the piazza. I chose indoor. A couple of pop ups came up noting, that if you really want outdoor and only indoor was available you would not be accommodated. OK, no issue. I had to register on their "Resy" site and I did. Received a text with what clearly looked like a confirmation. Got to the restaurant at 8:20 and was told there was no reservation. Showed the confirmation and the little guy at the door kept telling me I never made a reservation. Ok... text said it was from Resy... isn't that your online reservation booking service? Yes, he said, but we don't have your reservation. Long story short, they got us a table. Funny, tables were leaving, and it really looked as if we were the only ones with what we thought was, an 8:30 reservation. The place was clearing out and there was no one else was behind me coming in or waiting for a table. No one said, I'm sorry, no one said.. please wait at the bar, have a drink and don't worry, we'll get you a table. It was more like... no reservation... wait 20 minutes and maybe we can seat you. So don't make me feel like you went out of your way to help me and that I was trying to scam a reservation on a Saturday night. Maybe you should have said, clearly our system made a mistake, I see your text from the service, I will look into what happened and please, no worries, I'll get a table for you. Our server was Ok. He did his job. The food was good. The Veal Marsala was excellent. Tender and the sauce was exceptional, with plenty of mushrooms. Linguini Bella Luna was good, but I've had better. I'm in NY a lot and spend a lot of time in this neighborhood, I'm always looking for a great place that's close by. Unfortunately, This Isn't It. Because of the way I was treated, I will never go back. A note to the owners... get a new reservation system or make a note on your website that you prefer a phone call. read more

See all

Thanks Bella Luna! My folks came in for my moms 76th birthday and this spot was where she wanted to go. I'll admit We can be pretty critical as actual Italians so my bar was pretty low as most Italian food here is pretty Americanized. I ordered for the table muscles and fried calamari both were cooked to perfection. For the calamari the sauce was made really well I have to say a lot of restaurants mess this up, they didn't. The muscles were also cooked perfectly and their sauce was also made really well. The fish was fresh and very good. Braised lamb shanks for all 3 of us. The lamb was falling off the bone and truly braised also cooked and seasoned to perfection. My mom really liked the mash. We enjoyed our lavish lunch, she was very happy. read more

See all

Bella Luna is an UWS must! I would consider myself a local as I do come fairly often, and it's always a huge hit! The service is amazing and you get your food in about 15 minutes! The place has such a pretty and elegant vibe, truly living up to this five star review I'm writing! They have plenty of options, especially if you have picky little ones such as mine. It's my daughters favorite and she always requests it for her birthday! I've also had some of my lady friends over and they love it just as much as I do! Overall, amazing cost, amazing food, and amazing service! read more

Menu and preparation are excellent. Service less so, but may relate to a particular server. Lovely room. We'll give it another try.

Visited New York City a few months back and stumbled upon this place during their soft launch phase. Came to eat here after watching a show on Broadway, so it was later in the evening and we basically had the place to ourselves. The ambiance was great - lighting and background music were perfect and the wait staff was extremely attentive (not that we had much competition). Our server was very knowledgeable about the menu and helped us to make some selections we were happy with. We started with some calamari and burrata. The calamari was perfectly crispy, yet tender on the inside. The sauces complemented the dish perfectly. The burrata was coupled with figs, prosciutto and some excellent balsamic vinegar - perfect harmony of textures and flavors. Can't remember the exact names of the mains we ordered. The proteins were just ok. My wife had some kind of fish dish which was a tad overdone and needed a little more seasoning. The pasta on my dish was perfect, but I recall the protein to be unremarkable. The tiramisu was amazing - perfect amount of sweetness and subtle, yet distinct textures made for a really enjoyable experience. Overall, I'd definitely come back here again and keep working my way through the menu. read more

See all

This place has been a family favorite since before it moved across the street. The food is always excellent and all of the people who work here are so kind. The ambiance is lovely and intimate, perfect for small gatherings or dates. read more

Some of the best Italian food I've had in awhile. The white pizza and fettuccine Alfredo were absolute perfection. Our server was attentive and the overall ambiance was perfect for a cute little date. It was a good choice for a rainy day. I also ordered the meatballs and they were so tasty. Overall 3 items were shared between 2 people it was great. I'll definitely be back to this gem. Kudos to the chef! read more

Love this restaurant! Everything is great from the wait staff to the consistently fresh and super yummy food. Went on the recommendation of a friend years ago and always go back whenever we're on the upper west side. Today we tried the Bronzino for the first time, and it was definitely a winner!!! read more

Bella Luna Restaurant - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Worst Manager ever!! And the server was very unprofessional his name is Tony, My family and I will never return

My pasta tasted good, until I found an insect in it. The server offered to bring me something else. I declined and they took the pasta off the bill. Gross! read more

The dining room has been updated/redone since I was last there and it looks great. The service was great. The food, however, was just ok. All three of us felt our meals were just ok (and we all got different things). We've eaten there many times over the years, but I don't think we'll go back, unfortunately. read more

I got takeout from here. The seafood pasta was super gummy and not good. I've made fresh pasta before and know what happens when you don't properly dry the pasta or it gets clumped together. That is exactly what happened here. The noodles were stuck together and were gummy as uncooked. read more

This is my favorite restaurant. The food is amazing. The service is amazing. The ambiance is amazing. On my way to it again as I type this review read more

See all

My husband and I have been here a few times before. Nine out of 10 times, the food has been good, but we have usually gone there during the week when the place was pretty quiet. Last night was busy. In addition, they have a new menu now. No more polenta, which was something that drew us there. But we noticed several other annoying issues: 1) I ordered the Bella Luna pizza which could have been good, but for all the chunky pieces of onion that were added to it. Who is the chef / cook? Onions and garlic are used as flavoring agents in Italian cooking, not as primary ingredients. Once I picked them out, there was a large plate of onions that the waiter took back to the kitchen (I wish I'd taken a picture of that); 2) the service was chaotic and several times, we had to request our food / cutlery back because the waiters were too quick at picking up items that they thought we were done with (they should have asked us whether we were done with them in advance). The final straw was when they brought the macchiato at the end, and as the one waiter delivered the coffee, the other waiter took away my spoon, so I was unable to mix the sugar in the coffee. It was exhausting having to keep an eye on what they were doing while trying to have a conversation with my husband; 3) my husband's tomato sauce (on the Margherita pizza) was undercooked. He said it tasted like ketchup. 4) our waiter was visibly upset as he dealt with us, kept throwing his eyes up to the ceiling, sighing and even left our table quickly. We enjoyed eating at that restaurant before, but it is unlikely that we'll be back there too soon. read more