In a city known for extraordinary restaurants, it is surprisingly easy to forget about a few great ones. After visiting Susan Spicer's Bayona, I can assure you this is one restaurant we will not forget.
Bayona somehow combines cozy, intimate, and fine dining all at once. From the moment we arrived, the entire experience felt warm and polished. Kelly greeted us with genuine professionalism, and while waiting for our table, we enjoyed the intimate atmosphere of the beautiful glass-enclosed porch before being seated in the dining room.
Then came the food.
Our waiter, Andrea, was simply outstanding. A true New Orleanian at heart, he moved here a year before Katrina, returned afterward, and helped rebuild this remarkable city. He treated the six of us less like restaurant guests and more like close friends he had invited into his home for dinner. He guided us through the menu, shared his recommendations, helped with wine selections, and made the entire evening memorable. His assistant, Nino, was equally friendly and attentive.
We started by sharing several appetizers.
The Roasted Garlic Flan with warm bourbon-molasses vinaigrette was excellent. The Sautéed Escargot with Herbsaint was incredible and wonderfully unique, and I am glad Andrea encouraged us to order it. The Jumbo Lump Crabmeat Ravigote with heirloom tomatoes, shaved Parmigiano Reggiano, and caper-Dijon dressing was fresh and delicious. You really cannot go wrong with beautiful Louisiana crabmeat.
We also shared the Goat Cheese Crouton with Cream of Garlic Soup. Creamy goat cheese on toasted Wild Flour multigrain bread, sautéed mushrooms, and a velvety Madeira cream made for another distinctive dish that hit exactly the right spot.
The entrées may have been even better.
I ordered the Moulard Magret Duck Breast, seared and served with a fragrant black tea-lavender honey glaze, mushroom ragout, and pillowy sweet potato gnocchi. It was quite simply the best duck preparation I have ever tasted. The sweet potato gnocchi was an incredible addition and paired beautifully with the duck.
My bride and I always share our meals, and she ordered the Fennel Pepper-Crusted Lamb Chop with roasted fingerling potatoes, herbed goat cheese, Zinfandel sauce, and haricots verts. Once again, remarkable. It was one of the most flavorful lamb dishes I have ever tasted.
Our friends ordered the Gulf Fish, a beautifully pan-seared snapper with caramelized leek orzo pasta and leek-tarragon butter, as well as the Pan-Seared Scallops. The scallops were perfectly caramelized and served over roasted butternut squash purée with corn, fish fumet butter, and crisp gaufrette potatoes.
Everyone at the table had the same reaction: outstanding ingredients, tremendous freshness, and creative combinations of flavor that explain Susan Spicer's reputation.
And somehow, we still ordered dessert.
The espresso cheesecake was possibly the best cheesecake I have ever tasted. For something lighter, the sorbets, including berry, strawberry, and mango, were refreshing and excellent.
Andrea was, without exaggeration, one of the best waiters we have ever had. The rest of the staff was wonderful. The food was off the charts.
When extraordinary food, genuine hospitality, and an intimate New Orleans atmosphere all come together like this, you remember the evening long after dinner is over.
Bayona has now moved into the very top tier of my favorite restaurants in New Orleans.
We will absolutely be back. read more