My friends and I were craving deep dish. This place had been on our radar for years. I can't believe we'd never been here before. What you need to know: -- Delicious pizza, both deep dish and thin crust -- More of a carryout location, i.e., no bar or table service -- BYOB for dine-in customers -- Very nice people This is now going to be one of our go-to spots for delivery and carryout. If you want a slice, they also do slices. Just an amazing experience all around. read more

Highly recommend Bartoli's! It's really good. I had carryout delivered to my Airbnb on a very cold January night and it was absolutely delicious and appreciated. I picked up another pizza later in the week. Love their thin crust especially. read more

I would lay down my life for these motherfuckers. The best pizza I have ever had. Get it 2-3x a month and never disappoints.

The pizza from here was pretty decent! We got 1/2 Bartoli's chicago classic and the other 1/2 the Diavolo. The Diavolo has a real kick to it so fair warning to those sensitive to spicy stuff. Toppings on both sides were generous and not skimpy. Overall pretty good thin crust which makes me want to order from them again! Their menu has some good items I would like to try! read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - 1/2 Thin Crust Bartoli's Chicago Classic Pizza + 1/2 Thin Crust The Diavolo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Updated to say we still love this pizza and also now enjoy the pepperoni! Great for takeout.

I did an online order for pickup, and the pizza was ready before the promised time. I did show up way earlier and just sat down and patiently waited. This place gets really busy with pickup orders. At least about 10 people within a 10-15 minute window. The staff was great. Very friendly and efficient. I did enjoy seeing The Blues Brothers wall as well. It seemed to be a fan favorite. I ordered a large Deep Dish with Italian sausage. The pizza was definitely big and very filling. The crust was cooked perfectly and just the perfect amount of cheese and sausage. The sauce stood out to me the most. Nice and chunky, acidic and seasoned perfectly. Very flavorful which made the rest of the pizza stand out. I'll definitely need to ask for more sauce when I return. read more

See all

Love both their thin and deep dish options. Great pie and crust. They also have slices for $5 which feels like a whole meal in one slice.

Pizzeria counter service vibes. Good ingredients done fairly well. It's competent. I'm not writing home about it but I'd come back.

Bartoli's remains my favorite neighborhood pizza joint, especially for their unique deep dish and affordable prices. While so many places have raised prices to the point where a pizza costs most than a steak dinner ($30+ for a thin crust cheese pie???), Bartoli's keeps the prices reasonable and the quality high. Their New York style is serviceable, perhaps not quite on the level of say Zaza's or Paulie Gee's Wicker Park, but certainly a nice alternative, especially when slices are available. For me, it's their deep dish, easily the most underrated in the city. Skip Lou's. Always skip Giordano's. This is the best deep dish crust, with excellent, "pully" cheese and a less sweet, slightly tangy sauce. I don't eat deep dish much, but every month or so I get a craving for Bartoli's and it never disappoints. Honestly, you could make a hell of an appetizer out of the crust and the sauce, it's that good. Looking forward to enjoying this delightful cheat meal for years to come! read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Cheese Deep Dish - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I wish Yelp had the ability to do half stars because I'd give them a 3.5/5 if possible. First of all, the service is incredible and the interior was nice and clean. Dinner for 2- including an appetizer, pizza and dessert came to around $45 which is pretty affordable. Let's talk food: the wings were cooked well but wish they had more salt and pepper. They were good but not blow your mind good. The pizza had a nicely cooked thin crust but it did get oily and soggy the more you let it sit. I liked how the pizza was packed with meat but it was a hair too much cheese, but still delicious. For dessert, I tried their brownie (super rich and soft) and Eli's cheesecake was standard. Overall recommend checking them out if you're looking for a new pizza place to to try in lake-view. read more

See all

Food was great. I recommend a deep dish pizza, beer-battered fries, and some wings. I got the mild wings and they were savory. The service was great. The place was also very clean. read more

Was not a fan of their deep dish, but their pasta dishes are delish. Service is always fast and friendly.

I paid $30 for a medium deep dish cheese pizza and got it delivered through DoorDash, and I have a Dash pass so the delivery was free and fees were reduced. I would pay that all day long though - the pizza was HUGE and the crust is to die for. I can't speak to the service of the ambiance but the delivery actually was very fast. Would recommend! read more

Came here with my daughter, sil, toddler granddaughter, son, and husband at about 6 pm on a Sunday evening. We were the only ones eating in at first but it filled up fast. You order in front and they bring the food to the table. Son was in from out of town and wanted deep dish pizza, and son in law has celiac and needed gluten free crust. We ordered a small deep dish (the one with all the meats- forget the name), a small gluten free crust with sausage, and a salad with chicken. Food came out in less than 45 min. The deep dish pizza was very good- and I'm a NY style pizza girl. It was more than enough for 3 of us- we took 2 slices home. The salad was delicious- lots of chicken and avocado as well as other tasty things. Son in law said the gluten free pizza was good too. Place was clean and the service was good. Would come back for pizza. read more

Another excellent deep dish pizza. Half cheese for not so shorty, other half sausage mushroom and black olive. Parking is tricky but the food is amazing. Always love pizza from my favorite Cop family! read more

Ordered pizza and wings tonight everything was perfect will definitely be going to back

A true neighborhood pizzeria. Right near Addison on the Brown line, the cute cashier was smart and knew great customer service. Maybe not food wise, but was attentive and forthright. Surprisingly, the pizza is not too filling even though both slices are large in appearance. Known here for the thin crust, I got both and both left me feeling pretty good. Remember, these are not New York slices, so feel free to use a fork and a knife to eat these. I will not judge you for doing that. Deep dish pizza is not pizza, it is casserole masquerading as pizza. Jokes aside, very good pizza at a great price. read more

Kudos to the manager for reaching out. That was very much appreciated! We will be back!

Such a great pizza place. I forgot to take a picture before we at because it all looked so good. We normally do takeout and it is always very good. But there are a few inside tables and a few outside tables so this time we dined in. We sat inside and got such hot, delicious food. It's order at the counter, but we were checked on a few times. Great place to bring the kids and not stress about anything. They serve big slices as well as whole pizzas. Their spinach deep dish is my favorite in the city. read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Thin crust pepperoni pizza with peppers and onions. Dry wings and 3 lonely cheese balls. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

We went with Bartoli's for our late night food at our wedding for 150 guests. We absolutely loved working with the staff and they made the delivery for seamless for our event. Our guests loved it and had multiple people texting us the next day asking where the pizza was from. We will definitely be ordering from them again! read more

Bartolis is such a good pizza joint that's not overly touristy! Their thin crust and deep dish are both delicious. I personally like extra cheese on my deep dish and theirs is SO cheesy. We haven't eaten in but take out and delivery is always good. read more

We tried this place out last weekend when we had family in town. Bartoli's is in our area and I had never been so we decided to give it a try. We just ordered pick up, but there was some seating available for those that wanted to dine-in. All of the tables were occupied and there were groups of people waiting. The operation in the back was a little hectic since they were busy, but the person at the counter was still very friendly and made sure to provide great customer service. The pizza was good. We ordered one tavern style and one Chicago style. Their Chicago style was on par with a many of traditional Chicago establishments. Overall it's a pretty solid option. read more

First time having deep dish pizza. I came here on recommendation from one of my favorite Chicago YouTube channels (Luis Gusto). The pizza is super cheesy and the crust is excellent. Sauce and meat were great. One thing is.. it seems everyone in Chicago has an opinion on which location has the best deep dish (but apparently local Chicagoans go for tavern style over deep dish). Best bet is to leave The Loop and explore a neighborhood, and this place didn't disappoint at all. read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

What is there to do in Chicago you may ask? Well, if you're craving pizza, you can stop by Bartoli's Pizzeria. I went inside with my girlfriend and it was crowded, but it was Saturday, so that was kind of expected. We sat down at a little two-person table towards the corner. They don't have a server wait on your table here, so they have you go to the counter to place your order once you're ready. They do the Party Cut, Thin Crust pizza here, which is a Chicago must-try I'd say! I, of course, went with the Bartoli's Chicago Classic pizza. It's named after the place, so it had to be pretty important. It had Italian sausage, mushroom, onion, and green pepper on it. I got a Fountain Drink. It was self-serve, so refills were free. We also got a Nonna Bartoli's Famous Meatball Sandwich. It had two meatballs on French bread topped with their homemade marinara. It was hard not to get dessert, so I got each of us a Cannoli. I tried the Coca-Cola from the fountain and it was pretty good. I quickly switched to Diet Coke, as I'm a big diet soda buff. Their Diet Coke was smooth and tasty. The pizza took about 20 minutes, so that wasn't bad. I would've been worried if it came out any quicker. It arrived to our table hot and fresh. I was impatient, so I burnt my body at first eating it. Oh well, it was worth the pain, because the pizza was great! I loved how I could taste the char on the crust. The Meatball Sammich was great as well! The marinara really made the whole thing for me. Try it out and you'll see what I mean. We took the Cannolis for later. They were both good, but oddly the cream in the second one tasted better. The service was friendly and efficient. They got a minor part of our order wrong, but fixed the issue without hesitation. They even cleaned up our table after we finished. Overall, this pizza place was a great stop and you should add it to your bucket list to try out Chicago's Party Cut Thin Crust pizza. I would definitely order from them again if I'm ever in the area. Date of visit: 10/15/2022 read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - 12" Thin Bartoli's Chicago Classic pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Great gluten free pizza! No celiac reaction from it. The chicken wings are tasty. The star of the show is the ranch. read more

The deep dish pizza was absolutely heavenly. This place was suggested to us by a friend of my husbands, and we were excited to try a Chicago deep dish pizza we hadn't tasted before! It's a small neighborhood establishment the servers were super kind, and seemed like they knew all of the neighborhood people that would pop in for their takeout. They had the Bears game on, which made it even better, it was my last day visiting back home and it just made me so happy! It seems like they do lots of takeout business, and their delivery drivers were in and out quickly. definitely check out the spot! We had a deep dish veggie, and it was mouthwatering read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Veggie Deep Dish Bartoli's Chicago Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I grew up in Chicago and this is by far the best deep dish I've ever had. Gino's downtown has nothing on Bartoli's. Priced fair and the ingredients make for an amazing pie. Sauce is subtly sweet, tons of cheese, sausage was perfect. Will DEFINITELY be back. Staff were also mega cordial and helpful. read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Bartoli's - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

This was my first ordering and Leilani took care of me. She is the pretty young woman that works the front counter. She was knowledgeable, patient, kind and detail oriented. The space was clean and cute and the food is delish! Great neighborhood spot! read more

They were so helpful and kind to us, even after we screwed up our order. Pizza was also fantastic!

Huge pizza! Overall tasted good, I could only finish one slice of the medium pizza. I give it three stars because, 1. It only comes in a med or large pizza 2. When we asked for Half sausage and they kinda places it all over and my friend who was a vegetarian wasn't able to eat much of it. 3. Crust was okay... I've had better I did like the little packets of parm and pepper flakes read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This cost $17 before I tipped the driver $4.50. I ordered a pizza burger with provolone. Where is the cheese or tomato sauce? I ordered shoestring fries for a couple bucks upgrade from regular fries that come with the burger. Nope. Didn't get that correctly either. I got cold, undercooked, extremely skimpy portion sized regular fries. I missed getting a photo of the meatball I ordered as well. That might have been the best of the order, but it arrived cold and undercooked on top of that. Unreal. I have had pizza here before which most of the time was great, but two times was lacking big time. Now this happens. Three strikes and you are out. I feel like I just got food delivered from communist Poland circa 1950. Edit: I have been in contact with the owner and he is going to remedy the issue. He also apologized. I give him credit for being hands on with his business. I hope I will be able to give the place another chance at some point. read more

Pizza as good as Detroit, but don't tell Axel FOLEY Pizza as good as Liverpool FC's expensive GOALIE Pizza as good as Art Of Pizza, which makes it HOLY Pizza is spectacular if you come to BARTOLI Pizza really good, so much better than CANNOLI Pizza really good, fills you up like a STROMBOLI Pizza really good, superior to GUACAMOLE Pizza is so heavenly when it comes from BARTOLI Pizza so good that you have to eat it SLOWLY Pizza so good it makes Lou's seem LOWLY Pizza so good you won't care if it has E-COLI Pizza is amazing when you get it from BARTOLI Pizza damn good, or the CIA's not MOLE-Y Pizza damn good, like a Mexican MOLE Pizza damn good, like Barbie's AUREOLI Pizza that makes Barbie take her clothes off at BARTOLI WHAT If it had a drunk Dad and a Mum with big blue hair, it'd be Bartoli's Simpson. And if it had a creepy Porn Moustache and was a bandit, or smokey, not sure which, it'd be Burtoli's Reynolds. And if these slices were only available for purchase after haggling, it'd be the Barter-oli's System. Just when I thought it was safe to say that the only slice of pizza worth having in Chicago was Art Of Pizza, I found another one that is very similar! And similarly delicious! Art's Pizza is still the best and I think it always will be because nothing could compare to those incredible wedges of deep dish Perfection, but these deep dishes of perfection are, well, perfect too! So you have to try both and decide for yourself! Art is more famous, sure. However Bartoli is uses a similar formula and has a similar taste, a similar consistency, it's similarly spectacular. Similar price too, and similar ingredients. It's definitely the second-best in all of Chicago (which is a massive compliment as this city has amazing pizza), and it's not too far behind. May even be level. Decide for yourself! Skip Pequods and the like. Hipster, dry, overpriced, overrated. The chains are decent, especially Lou Malnati's, but nowhere near as amazing as Bartoli's. So yes, the guy in here was absolutely lovely and his pizza was absolutely delicious. One of the best deep dish slices I've ever had and the second best in town. Also one of the very best in the country because the standard is so incredibly high around here. As I said, other than these two slice places (Bartoli's and AOP), you should probably try a personal pizza from Lou Malnati's which is the best of the local chains, but really nothing compares to a these hefty, homemade, delectable wedges of heaven that Bartoli's is serving up in their cute little North Chicago neighbourhood. Just don't swallow it down too fast, or you'll Burp-oli. Now time to rap. This slice charms Barbie every time it MEETS HER It smells so good and always looks shiny when it GREETS HER She eats it all faster than any client EATS HER No wonder everybody comes to BARTOLI'S PIZZA She thinks that California Italian always CHEATS HER And she falls for anyone that brings her here and TREATS HER It's tasty, thick, and heavy, in the winter always HEATS HER No wonder she comes hard to BARTOLI'S PIZZA WHAT read more

See all

Amazing deep dish. Crust as the heat ever tasted. Ingredients were spectacular. Would eat this every night if I could. Recommend to any and all. read more

Excellent Deep Dish Pizza without a doubt. My buddy and I were fat asses and were starving before the show we went to. We ordered a 14" Bartoli's Chicago Classic Deep Dish Pizza with pepperoni added to it ( ya know because it wasn't thick enough as is pssshhh). It came out glowing I swear to God, it was beautiful! every bite was just filled with whatever sausage, onions, peppers , and cheese, and was loaded with sauce! We had to roll to the venue after, though the Deep dish should be split by usually 4 people haha. Amazing work! read more

See all

The customer service was great, the place was clean and the pizza was AMAZING! As a NY'er I'm always looking for good pizza and have yet to find a place that exceeds my expectations in Chicago. This pizza is a 10/10 and will definitely be coming back. read more

See all

So we came to a pizza joint, and got burgers. Why? Craving! The burger was solid! This place is basic and homey - a real neighborhood joint. We at in the dining room, and it was clean and nice. I'd come back for the pizza, 'cos it smelled GOOD. On my list to return. Definitely give it a try if you are in the area. read more

Outstanding! We got the Union Stockyard Deep Dish Pizza and it was phenomenal. We also got the caprese salad and cheesy breadsticks. We sat outside and it was nice, this place is in a pretty quiet area. Our service was top-notch. Highly recommend Bartoli's! read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Best deep dish cheese pizza, IMHO, in Chicago. It's EXACTLY the same flavor and texture as the original Gino's East on Superior I remember as a kid years ago! And it's no wonder.....Fred Bartoli's name is on the sign!!! IT'S THE BEST!!! BUONISSIMA!! read more

I read up on their historic run, but must say I was disappointed with the pizza. Not terrible, but not the stuff legends are made of. I'd eat again if it were in arms reach, but wouldn't place another order. read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Sausage and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Excellent pizza, I tried it back when they opened and wasn't impressed, but this time it was really good. Will definitely go back. read more

Bartoli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois