I was enjoying my pizza at first until I felt something scratched my throat, I nearly choked on this piece of metal. I spit it back out and found what looks like a piece of aluminum metal from one of those scrubbers you clean with. Bartolini's please be careful when your preparing food before selling it to customers. This could've been a lot worse. read more

Bartolini's - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

See all

The best food, service and owners . Everything is fabulous ! Although they are famous for the meatballs , the weekly specials are also delicious especially the October schnitzel ! Bartolinis also did a fabulous job catering my daughters wedding - so much great food . The delivery driver was great also . I wish i could post ten stars !!! Debbi steigerwald read more

The pizzas we ordered that were shipped were disgusting. The sausage was gross, with huge chewy chunks that could choke you to death. Avoid at all costs! read more

Bartolini's is the best, most authentic Italian food on the South Side of Chicago. My family found this gem a couple years back, and it has been our go to family dinner night restaurant ever since. The owners are two brothers and are so friendly! They always to make it a point to come to the table at least once during the meal, and you can see them flipping pizzas or serving tables their food throughout the night. The service is always so friendly and attentive, and seating is never an issue or a wait. There's so many good things on the menu to write about. My favorite dish is the cavatelli carbonara. The sauce is so creamy with lots of little bacon pieces, and the pasta is perfectly cooked every time. You get your choice of soup or salad with a pasta entree, but I can never choose because the caesar salad is the best I've ever had and the chicken dumpling soup is crAzy good. The caesar dressing is a little different than your typical dressing, but it is so good, trust me on this one. The chicken and dumpling soup is a crowd favorite because of the flavors and little dumplings. You have to try both of these things when you're there. We love supporting local family run businesses, but that's only part of what draws us to Bartolini's. Their affordable prices and awesome food keeps us coming back every time! read more

Bartolini's - Cavatelli Carbonara - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

I ordered from this restaurant on GoldBelly, the pizza was supposed to be delivered at 4 PM but was delayed and delivered at 10 AM the next day. It came completely inedible. The pizza was fully defrosted and fully saturated from the condensation build-up from the inadequate amount of coolant this restaurant packed it in. GoldBelly said they were supposed to pack it with enough coolant it should last DAYS. I doubt it lasted half a day. I reached out to Bartolini's and they blamed UPS for the little over-the-half-day delay. GoldBelly blamed them. I've ordered from other places on GoldBelly and receive much better packaging than this. Maybe this is different in the winter months, but I will not order from them again based on my experience. read more

See all

Best food in the area. The owners are friendly and welcoming! I highly recommend them

The food is amazing. Besides the wonderful menu, they have weekly specials. It is one of the only places, that I will eat red sauce. You can pick: pasta, sauce, and meat to shrimp, to customize your own. My favorite is Diablo sauce. The fried chicken is golden and crispy. They have au gratin potatoes and fresh made potato chips in addition to fries. They offer different soups on different days, but every day there is Chicken Dumpling, all homemade. Calzones are made to order, baked or fried. The waitresses are great, too. read more

For the price, the food was great. The service was alright, and the decor is decent. A great place to stop on the road.

I wanted to take some dinner to my family who is out of state. So I ordered everything 'deconstructed'. The order taker understood immediately what I wanted to be done, and she offered to separate all items if that's what I wanted. The food is delicious, that is a known fact. The order taker and help there are quick, responsive and thorough. It was packed up separately, so it was easier for me to put in the cooler for traveling. I could not be happier. To the Owners of Bartolinis- Don't ever change, you have a gem and a place where old-fashioned work ethic and talent is nurtured and expected. Thank you read more

We came here to try their meatball sandwich. This place has a bar area with a lot of TVs and a dine in area with a few TVs. I was surprised on how roomy and big it was inside. Their service was phenomenal. Our server kept giving us update and kept checking up on us through out our entire meal. As for the meatball sandwich...the meatball was very tasty. I ordered it with mozzarella and garlic bread with pub stile fries. I don't know if it was the garlic bread, which I didn't get garlic flavor from anyway, but as soon as I picked up the sandwich it fell apart and every fell through, so it made it a tougher to eat. Next time I'll order regular bread and see if it hold better. I also felt it could have used a lot gravy. As for their pub style fries, it basically fries with garlic and Parmesan. A little to dry for my taste, and wouldn't have tasted good with ketchup, so next time I'll probably just get the regular fries as well. And there will be a next time! read more

Bartolini's - Meatball with garlic bread, mozzarella and pub style fries - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

Our first time here. Really casual dining room with a fun bar. Looked like lots of regulars in there. It smelled great walking in. We went there for the Elvis cheeseburger which was well worth it. It had a lot of taste and we'd get it again for sure. We split it and felt we had to try something Italian too so we split the meat lasagna and took half of it home. It tasted homemade with mini meatballs layered in it. Never thought of dessert until our waitress suggested the homemade cheesecake. It's made in a bowl as an individual serving. You can add caramel, chocolate, or raspberry topping but it doesn't need it because it is the BEST CHEESECAKE EVER!!! Our waitress Melissa was super attentive and friendly and owners/managers walked around checking on tables which we really liked. Definitely worth going. We'll be back!! Enjoyed it a lot. I already went back to Bartolini's and I had a calzone on this second visit. I already know it is all I will ever order from here because it was so delicious. If you love pizza more than life itself try a calzone here it is reasonably priced and with up to three ingredients. The crust was light yet crispy and hot straight from the oven. I've never had a better one anywhere and if you love pizza you'll understand when I say this calzone is juicy and at least ten times better than you hope it's gonna be. We may go back this weekend. I'm hooked on this place! read more

You can't get food better than Bartolini's serves! The quality and care that goes into their dishes are top notch. Plus, where else can you go where a family business puts their heart and soul into their work, putting their customers first? Bartolini'is the best! read more

Love the Goldbelly delivery! The sauce is everything!! We would eat an old shoe dipped in the sauce. We inhaled the pepperoni thin crust. Meatball deep dish pictured. We are now fans. See you in person next time I visit Chicago! read more

Bartolini's - Meatball deep dish - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

Awesome pizza and service. Get it thin crust and well done you won't be disappointed.

I enjoy their meatballs. The calzones are also tasty. The "beer flight" samplers from the bar compliment the food nicely.

Growing up in the area, I always enjoyed this traditional Italian restaurant. Always my go to for a good dinner.

One of a handful of suburban pizza places I'll skip my local Aurelio's for. I'd say they have a better menu of non-pizza food too, including those famous meatballs. read more

Went in for dinner with my daughters, and the ambiance was so friendly, being greeted when walking in. We did not have to wait long for a table for 5, we had the cod dinner, pizza, chicken tenders, and cheeseburger. The girls and I loved it. Can't believe we moved to Midlothian over a year ago and we just tried this place!! We sure have been missing out. read more

Stopped in for lunch today. Sat outside as it was a beautiful day. Ordered the round guy appetizer to start. Great marinara sauce with it and the 3 of us devoured it. It was Thursday so calzones were the special ($3 off). I ordered a pepperoni, sausage and green pepper, my buddy got pepperoni, sausage and bacon. My other buddy got the wings. Let me just say the calzone was outstanding. My buddy said his wings were good as well. Our server was very nice. Wish I could remember her name. Will definitely be back on a Thursday!! read more

Great service. Great beer selection. If you expect good Italian food, you will be disappointed.

Bartolini's has a large Italian menu with a wide selection of soups, salads, sandwiches, full dinners and pizzas. I love their Italian breaded steak sandwich! read more

Absolute the best Chicago Deep Dish Pizza hands down. No need to go anywhere else. They also sale on Goldbelly. Do yourself a favor and order some and their meatballs are spectacular. read more

Went Saturday night with girlfriend for dinner and was great as always. Had the calzone which is huge and she had the lasagna which is very generous portion. Never a bad meal here read more

Bart's is like family that I enjoy visiting. Welcoming with great meals, specials and service. Aunt Shell's LIIT's are the bomb. Good people. read more

The place is really nice and clean. The people there are very nice it was our first time and they took the time to explain what they're known for etc. tons of food they give you on your plate. I would definitely come again. read more

See all

Amazing food!! Haven't had anything I didn't like. The Ugly Potatoes are FIRRRRE! Owners are awesome. Always friendly, great sense of humor... like an Italian uncle you wanna watch a Sox or Bears game with :-)~ We dine in and the vibe, because of the owners, is always welcoming. Also catered for several house parties (anywhere between 30 to 70 ppl) and EVERYONE always RAVES about the food. Always piping hot, even when catering is delivered. I honestly LOVE the fact that we have this GEM on the Southside. read more

Should have waited a while to eat my huge/small sausage pizza. Too hot! Was one of the best tasting suburban pizzas ive had. Cheese and sausage. Lots of atmosphere an good waitress. "EVITA". Plus lots of parking on a main street. read more

See all

Always the meatball sandwich,I've had pretty much on the menu through a lot of years,just cant go wrong,always great to support your local and smaller restaurants read more

This place has a great Cajun Alfredo sauce (which I didn't even know was a thing). It's not too spicy and has just enough kick to make it really delicious. The dragons milk stout was pretty tasty. The meatballs is the big draw and they were really good. The best part was the dessert nuggets!! They give an ample amount of fried dough with ice cream covered in a ton of caramel sauce. This is enough to satisfy any sweet tooth! read more

Bartolini's - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

Great food, fast service, and fair prices. If you dine in, you'll more than likely have one of the two owners come by and say hello.

Ordered $129 worth of food, 4 pizzas 1 looked great but once in the middle complete dough. Very disappointed one of the owners called sent him pics his response looks great, I say exactly until you get around the outside... Not sure why he wanted to debate what I received. Mind you I'm only referring to 1 pizza out of 4. Guess your gotta ask for a family size WELL DONE to get a decent pie... Will be my last time there read more

Bartolini's - Looks great - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

See all

We have tried our first Bartolini deep dish via Goldbelly and it was fantastic. Fresh ingredients, wonderful sauce and a great crust. I could not believe how great a frozen pizza could be. Up next is the thin crust. I have ordered other deep dish from some other Goldbelly clients, but they paled in comparison to yours. We will be ordering again! read more

One of the best casual Italian restaurants I've been to, it's a must if you're in the neighborhood. Great calzones, appetizers, pizzas, and of course, meatballs! All served by a friendly staff, Bartolini's is a must-visit classic restaurant!! read more

Great Service! The owner went to every table, we ordered drinks the server was friendly and had great suggestions. The mushrooms in my pasta were so fresh! Loved it and will be back! read more

Always great food. Great take out option. Pasta is always hot, pizza perfect, family friendly, even my pickiest family members. Desserts are very good too. read more

Everything is amazing at this place but the destination item is the meatball sandwich. Both owners are awesome and make sure to check in on their customers. I have never had anything less than a great meal here. read more

Best of the best! My family's favorite! Awesome food, great service and fun family atmosphere! Been going there since it opened.

Finally!!! Went back to Bartolini's .. Can I say this visit was even better then my first? The three meat pizza ..meatball appetizer..fresh baked cookies. I was also very impressed when one of the owners, was visiting tables.. Making sure everyone was satisfied. Such a great guy!! Atmosphere is super! The Elvis burger was incredible!! You must try this super establishment!!! It won't disappoint! read more

See all

Solidly meh. Got 3 pies shipped off Goldbelly and these were not great. The sauce is god awful, and the crust is just plain hard on the outside/uncooked on the underside. All 3 pies sucked...ate 2 slices off each and threw the rest away..which blows because these were far more expensive than the Lou Malnati's yet maybe only half as good. Sidenote: Lou's would be the best if THEIR crust didn't suck (Lou's sauce and cheese are the best). As it stands, Giordano's is my favorite deep dish. And don't come at me with Peaquod's...their sauce blows goats too. read more

Their deep dish pies via GoldBelly nationwide delivery are some of the best we've had, dare I say even better than Lou Malnati's? Price is a bit steep at $120 (including shipping) for three 12"pies, but they're super dense and packed with toppings. Great sauce, lots of cheese, and decent crust. Recommend! read more

Bartolini's - Deep Dish via GoldBelly nationwide delivery - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois