I'd been CRAVING pizza and I wanted to try something new. Yelp never steers me wrong! Found Nonna's Pizza! Awesome place! The staff were so friendly and welcoming! Thank you Ladies! I got the bbq chicken pizza, Hubby got cheese pizza and we shared a Caesars salad. The portion size is awesome! Nice slice and the tomato sauce is so good! The Caesar salad was perfect for us to share. The croutons tasted homemade! So yummy! You can dine in or take it to go. We sat in and enjoyed the dining area. It's well kept and we enjoyed our meal. We are looking forward to returning soon! read more

See all

Got some pretty good pizza at this simple looking place in Crestwood. It gets most of its business from takeout but there's a few tables if wanting to eat inside. Nonna's Goodlife Pizza has a few locations including this one that happens to be one of the few places around here that's not a big time chain restaurant. For sure there's the pizza, but there's a whole lot of other stuff on the menu. The prices are higher than the crappy bigger chains, but the pizzas are big, and it's a lot better quality. Came at lunch and there were only a few other people in here eating. It's mostly a place to get it to go it seems. The pizza is the main thing. Has a ton of choices. Seems to be a pretty good value even with the higher prices because you actually get quite a lot and the pizza is pretty good stuff. It's about $25 to get a medium, which seems like a lot. This also includes a liter of pop. For sure there's cheaper pizza, but this is much better. They're known for the massive Stadium Pizzas, big enough to feed a party. Has lots of flavors and toppings to choose from and they're open later than most places around here. It's located on Cicero Avenue with a hard to get into parking lot. There's more than just the pizzas, as they have a good choice of pastas, as well as frozen treats like yogurt. read more

Nonna's Pizza - Vegetarian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crestwood, Illinois

Me and my gf are from inner city Chicago and went to a late night AMC Crestwood showing and this was a local yelp place that popped up for a late night bite so we decided to try it out. We walked in and we were treated great! The main worker treated us very well and even gave us free cannolis. The cannolis were phenomenal! Me and my gf both ordered our own slices and they were HUGE! "One slice" is like 2 big slices. The pizza slices also came with free drinks which is an obvious plus. I really enjoyed the pizza sauce I thought it was really good and my gf loved their crust. This is my first time here and I will for sure be back! read more

Nonna's Goodlife Pizza on Cicero. This is a late night spot. Came rolling in at 1am from O'Hare. Tired and hungry; there were plenty of other vampires just like me. A slice is a double slice and they will make any kind of pie You like. They have fries and wings as well. It gets busy late at night and new pies have to be fired constantly so bring Your patience with You read more

I don't know how this place won any kind of award it's the definition of average. I've been wanting to try it for months and when I finally did it was disappointing. I was expecting a delicious slice and I got meh. Pizza was fresh so that wasn't an issue it just wasn't that good. Sorry. I will say for $8 you get a big slice and a free small drink so the deal was at least good. read more

This is the 2nd time I ordered from Nonna's in Crestwood due to their hours. I work 3rd shift, and I ordered pizzas for my team. They did not disappoint again! Pizza were delicious and the service was great! I ordered in advance (both times) and the pizzas were ready at the time of my arrival! Really enjoy this place! read more

I ordered a Stadium pizza online and waited over 2 hours for it to get delivered. After calling multiple times asking for updated the manager "Bill, or Bob" frankly I don't remember his name, said they were outsourcing their drivers which lead to the delay and that I was going to receive a $30 discount for the "inconvenience" he asked me to provide him my name and phone number and when I called in the future I'll have a credit on my account. So calling in today I mentioned said credit only to learn that no credit existed and there was nothing they could do. After asking the employee what I could do if this was what the manager told me she pretended not to hear me & disconnected the call. I called back & was transfer to Consuelo who gave me a credit on a 18" because that's all she could do. I feel everyone's frustration after reviewing their reviews & wished I knew this place was this horrible prior. No longer ordering from them moving forward definitely deserves less than 1 star. Extremely disappointed! read more

Great pizza 5star service.. Been coming here for 6 years and counting...recommend coming .. read more

The pizza is always good when I either stop in for a quick slice and/or have it delivered. The chicken wings could be a bit more tender but overall everything was delicious. read more

The pizza was good and the slices are so big until you can share it! The server went above and beyond for us. He even brought desserts to our table to sample! read more

Everything was fresh and delicious. Order was made and prepared on time. Great place to have your needs satisfied. Empty stadium pizza box so no pics could be taken. read more

I ordered online an order of boneless wings and 2 slices of pepperoni pizza . The food was ready when they said it would be ready with no issue. At pickup costume service was pleasant cashier greeted me , and smiled the whole time. definitely going bac. read more

Food was amazing and you definitely get what you are paying for. Will definitely be going back again

Excellent pizza and meatballs. The delivery was super fast and John the delivery guy was great bringing it to my room. will always recommend Nonna's Pizza Tony NCAA officials here in Chicago. Five Stars read more

If you hungry and want some industrial like pizza, this is the place. They serve several types of pizza and a slice is basically a half of pizza. Nonna's is a small store front pizza place, they half a couple of tables. The pizzas are all pre made ready to go when you walk in. They also have other Italian food items on the menu. And of course one of my favorite things, they have self serve fountain soda. read more

Nonna's Pizza in Crestwood is a slice of heaven! Huge, cheesy, and oh-so-crispy--totally irresistible! I got the Cheese slice and a meaty to go. My top pick for a pizza paradise. You gots to go grab a slice! ‍ read more

Nonna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crestwood, Illinois

See all

If I wanted to pay $15 for a cesar salad I would've gone somewhere different. Not only did I have to pay additional $4 for the chicken they seemed upset I pointed it out saying I should've known better like I worked there . Horrible service salad wasn't even that good . Don't come for that just come when you need pizza slices with 87% bread . read more

Nonna's Pizza - The photo shows the salad with the chicken breast included. - Pizza Near Me - Crestwood, Illinois

See all

Food was fresh and very appetizing onion rings were not as hot as I prefer, my wife enjoyed her pasta and chicken parm. The service was normal for a spot like this nothing too surprising. The feel of this restaurant is very family friendly. Quick meal and you can even have some leftovers for the next day. read more

See all

Always fast and friendly service and great food! Place is always clean. Keep up the good work!!!

Budget pizza. A step above Dominos and Papa John's. Get the football field pizza if you are looking to feed a family.

literally the best pizza ever I think I order from here like four times a month. You get what you pay for, always fresh ingredients they have great service. The ambiance is great also the ranch is SOOOO GOOOD read more

pizza was great at a great price. food was hot. delivery was fast n driver was very nice. I will definitely order again.

Horrible service and food is cheaply portioned bland in taste and pizza was old . Manager wanted me to bring food back if I was unsatisfied with it what the!!! I said I was home already read more

Nonna's Pizza - Meat lovers pizza of the day looks old and gross - Pizza Near Me - Crestwood, Illinois

See all

They where very timely the pizza tasted great and the size is so worth 4.99 (bf tax). read more

Nonna's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crestwood, Illinois

I wish I could leave no stars! I placed an order online for 6:30 pick up an hour and 45 minutes in advance and when I arrived was told it would be ready at 7 and I was wrong.My email confirmation clearly said 6:30. So much for planning ahead! If I didn't already pay for it with my credit card. I would have left and bought McDonald's, because I am bringing food to a party now everyone has to wait. Very disappointing and may never come back after many years of enjoying the good. read more

I placed an order online for pick up. I set the time 30min prior till I got to pick up the order on time. I get my order and asked if there was two cups of cheese in my bag to verify if everything was correct .i ask the heavy set guy that was working to double check to see before I left because they tend to forget items that I paid for in the bag . The one guy asks this other guy and was rude about it saying if it says it yeah and then I get home and I don't live far but I open my fries and see that they are under cooked . so I had to do your job and re heat them To be consume. Very disappointed Because fries dont even take that long to make.We pay all this money for food and get fries not even cooked and nearly portioned the correct for the price and had 30min to get shit fries. read more

The pizza was very mediocre. It lacked in flavor and sauce. The crust was chewy and needed more time in the oven. The size of the slice is the only reason Ill give it 1 star. They gave me five little winglets for an outrageous $2 per winglet, which was supposed to be half a pound. The wings also lacked flavor or was too hot to taste it. read more

Nonna's Pizza - Meat lovers pizza and wings - Pizza Near Me - Crestwood, Illinois

The pizza was lackluster barely any sauce and the crust wasn't cooked enough flavor waw mediocre the jumbo wings are not jumbo it being a half pound of wings is questionable read more

Nonna's Pizza - the inside of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Crestwood, Illinois

So I placed the order over the phone because the coupon that I received from my passed order had no code or anything , I placed my order and told the young lady about the coupon never she mention hey bring the coupon. I arrived to to pick up the pizza and she is charging me full price for the pizza I told her about the coupon and she says to me you had to bring it in! Really how come you didn't tell me because the coupon doesn't say anything about bringing it in, really upset I visit this place all the time to buy slices and this is the treatment that I get. Last time I come here Bad business read more

If I could give zero stars I would. Walked in at 1145 pm. (Closes at 1am). One worker washing dishes, one taking an order on the phone, and other worker sitting down playing on her phone. Place was empty. I just wanted a slice of pizza. Stood there for five minutes with no help from worker sitting down. As I was leaving after not being served, another person walked in and worker then stood up and helped that person. Maybe because of the uniform I was wearing ? Hmmm read more

So I was a repeat customer here but after my last order, I won't be ordering from here again because I ordered thin crust pizza and I used to love the Xtra thin Crust, because it was the thinnest pizza that I have ever tried and we loved it, but the last few times we ordered the pizza was regular crust not thin. I called the restaurant back and spoke to Heather who was the same person who took my order over the phone and I specifically asked for extra thin crust. I asked to speak to the manager and she says she is the manager so then I tell her my complaint and she says well that is thin crust, so I say I've gotten it way thinner than this. So she says I just talk to the cooks and that's as thin as it gets. She doesn't even try to give us another pizza to replace it, she was kinda rude and therefore we won't be ordering from them anymore. They lost a good repeat customer!!! read more

Food was made wrong and wouldn't refund anything. Driver couldn't come so we had to pick it up. Horrible customer service. Manager and employee unacceptable. read more

We went to order 2 stadium pizzas for a family party that was supposed to be ready for pickup at 5, we got the pizzas at 5:40, after asking us what we got at 5:20 after not making our pizzas. read more

Haven't been here in a while and very disappointed. Mozzarella sticks had no marinara sauce. Garlic parm bites had no marinara sauce. Stadium taco pizza had barely any toppings on it. Came with no sour cream or salsa. For the amount of money spent, it is ridiculous. More than likely will be my last time ordering from here. read more

The staff is nice and accommodating but the security guard or the guy who is pretending to be that person is weird as hell. I feel like they have a job to someone who really needed it which is a good thing but he just watches his laptop. read more

We ordered 2 pizzas for a birthday party today we called the place only to be told the the driver was stranded by the owner on the phone and that they are "short staffed" the owner was rude. So now no birthday food and party was ruined.we will never order again ever I suggest you all do the same. read more

Gone here for YEARS (10 plus). Went in today and asked for cheese and a meaty with 2 drinks, hands us the cups and then we go sit down to wait for the pizza that's CLEARLY in the window with all the slices already hot. Two other customers come in and get THEIR slices right away. We went back up because we didn't understand why they got theirs and we didn't since we were seated for 5 minutes. The workers put our pizza on the mobile order shelf. Now I'm not sure if they were dumb or stupid but they fit those characteristics. Noticed a sign on the front door that read, "Now Hiring" No shit! You need to replace the two on the front counter... $6 for a slice. Screwing yourselves over read more

Awesome pizza and even better operating hours!!!!! The double dough pizza by the slice is a crestwood classic and you only get the full experience if you go after midnight. Definitely meets the demand of the consumer. read more

Me and my friends tried to enjoy some late night pizza with some appetizers consisting of jalapeño popppers and mozzarella sticks. We understand it was 2:30 and closing time so we know that we couldnt be there much longer. We recieved our pizza immedialty and we were waiting for our appetizers. While waiting, we sat down and waited until a very rude male security guard decided to yell at us telling us to leave. We were very nice to the security officer saying we were simply waiting for our appetizers. He was not having it. Started to go for his taser/ gun ( was unaware of what he was concealing) he made us wait outside and wait for our appetizers. Much of the staff was on our side and the secuirty guard started yelling at the staff. This is unacceptable behavior and me and my friends will never return to our favorite pizza spot again. read more

Great reasonable pizza. Though the crust has recently changed!? Why Nonna's? Why!? Great food, great prices, fast, & never any attitude. For as busy as this place gets, the staff is great. read more