Easily could be the best pizza in Baltimore. Not pretentious and just plain delicious. Personal sized and semi deep dish style with the best crust ever. It reminds me of a better version of pizza hut's pan pizza. So soft, light, and crispy. Don't forget to try out the homemade dressing! read more

This was our first visit and the food was very good. The pizzas were tasty (had a thicker crust) and the salads were excellent. We'll be back! read more

Possibly the best pizza I've ever had! Biggest selection of whiskey I've ever seen too. I highly recommend checking this place out. It's a fun joint. read more

Amazing pizza!!! Hands down the best in Baltimore with the special dressing! I wish they sold that dressing by the bottle!

One of my fav places in the neighborhood. Pizza is tasty, staff are very friendly. Get the spicy pizza, get some good bourbon, you will have a good time. One of my regular places to take visiting friend and family for a quick and tasty dinner. read more

Pizza was great. I don't normally like deep dish pizza but this one was delicious. The crust was light and crispy and the toppings were good. This is an odd thing to review but the veggie platter was really good. Everything was so fresh and tasty. And the drinks, yes! Lots of whiskeys to choose from and a decent selection of draft beer. We would def return. read more

Came in on a Saturday night after my first pick of a bar was "closed for renovations" and I had to give my Uber driver a quick alternate location. I chose this one simply because at quick glance, it was the next highest rated one on Yelp that was on the same street. It wasn't very busy but had a bit of a crowd. I got a seat at the bar right away. The bartender Carlos was awesome. They apparently have over 700 whiskeys!! Carlos helped me pick one (and didn't purposely pick a crazy expensive one like a jerk which was appreciated). I ordered the antipasti pizza as well. It was good. Different, but totally edible (I'm from NJ so we are opinionated about our pizza). It was a good personal size (if you're hungry) but could have also been shared between two. It has a very thick, fluffy crust and I'd say it occupies 1/3 of the actual slice. So it's good if you're into that. There is this housemade vinaigrette stuff in a glass bottle that people there put on the pizza (not sure if that's a Baltimore thing or what). It was good. Not my thing personally but, still tasty and made eating all that carby crust less monotonous. The whiskey was good. Carlos engaged in light, breezy conversation with me while also having a low-key, watchful eye kinda vibe when the drunk men would come up and talk to me. I don't need help in those situations but it's comforting to know someone is at least paying attention, ya know? Very cool bar, not much in the way of food options but definitely a place to check out especially if you're a whiskey lover! read more

I always get a pizza, salad amd wings when I go here. The food is always hot and tasty. I like that they serve the pizza on paper plates. It's a no hassle kind of place. There are also games if you want to spend time there with friends. I haven't been to their whiskey Wednesday yet but I hear the selection is wonderful. There is only street parking. Its free but spots are limited. read more

I adore bar fly! It's one of my favorite whiskey bars in Baltimore. Hubby and I randomly stopped here one night for a drank and had one of the best night. Ambiance: soft lighting, ample seating Customer service: they bartender made great recommendations on drinks and was super friendly Food : the miniature pizzas were made fresh to order and were soooo good. If you're in the area and want some great food, drinks, and a mean game of darts, bar fly is the place to be. read more

This place is a hidden gem. My wife brought me here because of her love of bourbon but I fell in love with the pizza. The staff is friendly and very knowledgeable. The pizza is flavorful tasty and really like a party in your mouth. Don't forget to dip the crust in the salad dressing, so good!!! You won't go wrong. They also have board games and tables so families can enjoy too. read more

See all

After hearing from plenty of people who raved about Barfly's pizza I finally tried it this past weekend (takeout). It did not disappoint. Great flavor, good crispness to it. I'll be back to try another soon read more

Barfly's - "Build-Your-Own Pizza Pie" - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Barflys is the perfect neighborhood bar! Friendly bartenders, great beer, whiskey, and liquor selection and AMAZING Pizza!!! Seriously, the best pizza ever. The crust is so delicious I can't even describe it.The everything and hot and spicy are my go to favorites! Also, make sure you use the salad dressing to dip! Their salad dressing is life changing. Overall, barflys is the perfect spot to hang with friends, sit at the bar an watch a game, or play a board game (they have a few board games available to play!) read more

Barfly's - The most delicious pizza ever with the salad dressing to dip! - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Let me tell you how it is. 1) Barfly's basically offers three things on their menu that you need to know about: salads, stuffed subs, and pizza. If you've never had a stuffed sub before, you need it. In your mouth. Now. The antipasto salad is amazing (and they have a pretty great house dressing) and their pizzas have the best thick crispy crusts. The Boy thinks the crust sort of resembles sourdough, which I don't know, might be right? Either way, it's good. 2) On Mondays, all drinks are $3.50. That's right, $3.50. Except for like, bombers. Which is fine because that's still an awesome deal. 3) If you can't find street parking, you're usually guaranteed to be able to park at the Shoppers lot and walk over. Also, the bartenders are awesome. Tip them well. read more

I love Barfly's. I'm a recent convert. My roommate and her boyfriend have been going forever, but only recently have they started dragging me along. And thanks to them for that--this place is awesome. It isn't ever too crowded--even on Friday, during prime happy hour time, there's room to move and never a line for the bathroom. The drinks are priced on the same level as the rest of the neighborhood, but they've got great beers on tap. I enjoyed SEVERAL Franziskaners on Friday. Their pizza is world-class, with this great Parmesan crust thing going on, and it's served with this awesome garlicky salad dressing. The bartenders are great, the atmosphere is friendly. This place is the perfect bar. read more

Barfly's In addition to being my favorite Mickey Rourke movie is also my favorite Locust Point bar. Chill friendly staff (see Dyana she's the best) and a comfy clean bar environment. A perfect amount of TVs tuned to relevant sporting events and great classic/modern rock playlist. The food is soul warming pizza and sausage/meatball rolls that you can customize to your hearts content as well fresh salads (get some dressing to go too). BUT THAT'S NOT ALL!!! The reason to go is their smart, rotating, draught selection for the true beer aficionado; Including an impressive selection of bottles. If you hate the pretentiousness of micro brews they got you covered with your favorite macros bud/miller etc.... It's not delivery, it's not DiGiorno, it's BARFLY'S!!! read more

Stopped in last night for a quick bite as I'm housesitting in the neighborhood. Cute little place, very busy for a Monday night. I was lucky to get a table in the back. Had the small side salad and an Italian hot cut. The small side salad for $4.00 was the perfect size for me and had plenty of cucumbers, green pepper, tomato, onion and feta cheese. Try the house dressing! It's on every table and is delish! The Italian hot cut was also very good with just the amount of cheese to be gooey but not messy. Very flavorful and came with a bag of UTZ chips. Great deal for ten bucks! I highly recommend this place for a quick tasty bite! read more

I checked out Barfly's on a friends recommendation and I have to say, this place did not disappoint. Atmosphere was great, very clean and inviting. There were three big TV's at the bar showing the college football games but they were not overbearing. Service was attentive and very friendly. There were some interesting microbrews on tap, including Tupper's Hop Pocket Ale which I haven't seen around very much. Prices are reasonable. The pizza is fantastic. They only come in one size, but two 10" pies was more than enough for the three of us. I'm not usually a fan of the deep-dish style, but this is an exception. The crust was light and perfectly cooked, not doughy. The cheese was fresh and not overloaded, and the sauce and toppings were tasty. I'll definitely be stopping by Barfly's again. read more

Loud, live music greeted my boyfriend and I when we came here with our two friends who live in the neighborhood. Under our friends' recommendation, we ordered the spinach pizza pie. Bf and I shared the cold cut Italian sandwich. Food was good, and I thought it was nice how the bartenders checked in on us, especially since we were sitting at the bar. I was a little annoyed that after a glass previously filled with Sprite was empty, it was refilled with water. FYI, it seems like a place where the locals frequent. read more

Such good deep dish pizza and I love the house ranch! Our favorite pizzas are the buffalo chicken, hot and spicy, or meat. Embarrassed to say my husband and I can get them as personal pizzas and *maybe* only have a slice or two to bring home‍ read more

Great brews Great food- get the wings double baked, amazing. Great bartenders and nothing but friendly read more

First time here, will be back. Pizza was so good we ate two there and took one to go. Cool atmosphere. Owner Doug made our day!

First time here and I will be back. Pizza was so good, we ate two there and took one to go. Cool atmosphere. Owner Doug made our day. See you soon. read more

Federal Hill is definitely growing on me. There are quite a few spots that I would be happy to call my neighborhood bar. Barfly's is one. It could be yours too, and should be if you like whiskey; they have about 170 or so different types, and the number keeps growing. I snagged a few seats at the bar, a couple of beers and ordered pizzas while having a nice chat with some folks sitting by the corner and the bartender - Mike. He is fantastic at his job, certainly knows his whiskeys and manages to keep service running smoothly as the only one there. The hot and spicy pizza is exactly as promised. Barfly's pizza is your deep dish style - similar to Matthew's. Not always my go to, but it was chilly and rainy, so it was the perfect pie. This one is loaded with toppings - red sauce with pepperoni and onions. The spicy part comes from the hot peppers and pepperoncinis. I like that they use a blend cheeses - parmesan & mozzarella - which balances the flavors. Since I don't love the red sauce on pizzas, I also went with a Spinach White Pie. The white sauce is a little garlicky and creamy, and the pizza was topped with spinach, fresh garlic, onion and a blend of the same cheeses plus feta. It usually comes with mushrooms, but they were out of those, so we got to add whatever topping we wanted - we went with pepperoni. All the pizzas come with their "special sauce" which I think is kind of like a ceased with some extra garlic and maybe some extra parm, since it is rather thick. read more

I am seriously disappointed by this place! I read the good reviews and thought the pizza sounded great, but it was seriously meh. Maybe it was an off night? Was there something I was missing? Yes, it's deep dish, but besides that it was nothing special. I feel like there are way better places to get pizza in the city, e.g. DiPasquale's, Isabella's, Hersch's, & Zella's just to name a few. The beer selection was pretty good but the server didn't have that great of knowledge about any of them. The service was also meh. Maybe if you keep drinking a lot they're nicer? I felt like the server was getting along a lot nicer with the table next to us (which kept ordering more shots) but didn't seem keen on our party eating pizza and just drinking a few beers. read more

Barfly's - Shrimp pizza. It was OK but I wasn't blown away. - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Been to Barflys a couple of times, this time being the worst. Ordered take out and were given 2 wrong pizzas. Decided to eat the pizzas anyways and both were less than average. I have had good experiences at this place before, so I will be back and hopefully next time my experience will be better. read more

I've been coming here for years. They treat ya right and always offer very appropriate drink suggestions. Clearly, the pizza and dressing are amazing. But the chill atmosphere and outstanding staff make this more than just a place to stop for ten minutes. Nice low key lighting, good throwback music, and relevant games on the television all make for a night that can keep rolling until close. I enjoy Barflys very much. One can't ask for much more. read more

Barfly's - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Love the pizza here. I'm pretty sure I can eat it every day so living right around the corner doesn't help. It's not a traditional New York pie, more of a buttery thicker crust. Kind of reminds me of a way better old school Pizza Hut crust. Personally, I think the pizza here overshadows everything else on the menu Word of advice, don't call ahead. I haven't had much luck with them answering... Doesn't mean they're closed though! read more

Best place in Fed Hill and possibly all of Baltimore for Pizza. It's absolutely delicious! Only problem is my husband and I used to share a pizza - now we get our own. It's that good! If there's space, we like to sit st the bar. MIKE will make whatever cocktail you want. He's the best! So are all the other staff. Do yourself a favor and go check this place out. You won't be disappointed!! read more

Love this place! The pizza is amazing and the atmosphere is very cool. Have gone back a couple times since moving to Baltimore

Went a little late with our two small kids- note- this place is NOT kid friendly as Yelp suggests. It's not that they're kid-unfriendly, it's that it's a bar first, and while kids can eat there, it's not somewhere I'd bring them again. We had an issue with our order, and it took over an hour for it to come out. The lady with blonde short, curled hair was VERY sweet and accommodating- she kept us filled in on what was going on, as well as approximately how much longer it would be. The male bartender hardly made eye contact with us when we arrived, and he rushed by us several times, and was pretty rude. The lady on the other hand, was amazing. To her credit, she did get my son's cheese pizza out very quickly, as we had hoped/planned for. It was only okay- there wasn't much sauce on it, and the cheese was browned to a crisp, on top of crispy dough. He ate it though, but it wasn't like some super yummy cheesy pizza. The crust was perfection though- I loved it! Our food finally came out and my white spinach pizza wasn't very good. It tasted like a pizza version of quiche. I wasn't expecting that at all... the buffalo chicken pizza was my favorite. It was just as it should have been, and I'd go back just to order that (IF she was serving us, not the rude guy) My dad had the hot and spicy and he was happy with it. The wings came after our pizza (they were supposed to be an appetizer) and they were good, but nothing to write home about at all. We ate quickly so we could leave soon. I couldn't tell you what beers my dad and brother had, but they were happy with them. The manager or cook came out to personally apologize to us too- that was very nice. I feel bad that they were apologizing so much, but was glad that they were genuine about it. They ended up taking our drinks (a very watery, not-yummy Shirley Temple and a few beers) and the wings off our check. We didn't ask them to do that... honestly it wasn't worth the wait. But they seemed to genuinely care about whatever mistake made us have to wait so long, and because of that, and because of that buffalo chicken pizza, I'll be back. On a date, WITHOUT my kids. :) read more

I am not a whisky person, but I enjoyed the mixed drink options and the pizza was by far my favorite part! My pizza included shrimp on a spicy red sauce pizza which was so delicious and even as a personal sized pizza I took half home for breakfast leftovers YUM!! read more

Been going to Barfly's now for over 3 years... at first I thought, and secretly hoped, it was a seedy locals bar. I found out that it's a whiskey Mecca with the best pizza in town along with an ever changing line up of great beers on tap. Always a great spot to watch the game. read more

I was super excited to try Barfly's both because the reviews for their pizza were superb and I'd passed it countless times. It's a little hole in the wall local neighborhood bar that always is lively, but would be easy to miss if you don't know what you're looking for. They're known for their drinks and their pizza! The pizza was definitely good, but I wouldn't say it was lifechanging. We got the veggie platter to start and I was really impressed by how fresh and tasty the veggies were. It came with a great ranch dip. I ordered a sausage pizza (create your own with Roma's sausage) and it came out decently fast. The service here was excellent! Our waiter explained to us they make the dough fresh every morning and all the ingredients are freshly prepared. The style of the pizza crust reminded me of Chicago deep dish. I definitely enjoyed my pizza, but I think next time I'll try something with more toppings because the plain sausage was a little lacking for me. This place is worth a stop if you're looking for a casual eat and some thick crusted pizza! read more

Barfly's - Create your own pizza with Roma's sausage and 2-cheese - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Barfly's is a small bar on the small peninsula of Locust Point/Fed Hill. While it's a whiskey bar, I tend to grab a pizza whenever I'm there, quite delicious! If you're looking for a personal pizza or sharing a pie with your significant other I suggest Barflys. read more

Seemingly inconspicuous bar in Baltimore with a huge whiskey selection. When I say huge I mean you probably can find almost anything you could think of. The pizza is a solid Pan pizza with a Parmesan sprinkled on the crust and baked for a crispy finish. What truly is unique is the dipping sauce. Though I love ranch for dipping their house made sauce is phenomenal. read more

Barfly's - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

We loved this place! Great pizza and great drinks and I really loved the house salad too. The dressing was delicious! Best pizza I ever had? Not sure about that BUT it was really yummy! I can't wait to try other toppings. Fun atmosphere and great service. read more

Barfly's - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Another pizza place to add to the books! Very similar crust (thick and chewy) to Mathews in Fell's, which I quite enjoy as long as I'm in the mood! There were a lot of different options for specialty pizzas. The pizzas itself are a little larger than a personal size... if you're super hungry you may be able to finish one, but if there is another food can definitely be split. Next time I'd love to eat in and enjoy the atmosphere of the bar. Looks like a fun and lively place! read more

Very mixed feelings about this place. First of all, the pizza is delicious. It's essentially the same pizza that you can get at Matthew's or Our House, great deep dish crust. The chicken club pizza was especially great. Also, the bartender was friendly and helped us choose some new beers to try. Now, the problems. The service was a little slow, and it wasn't very busy in there. But the biggest issue was the food that ISN'T the pizza. We ordered 2 appetizers, the caprese skewers and the garlic bread. The skewers weren't anything special, pretty much just cherry tomatoes and the small balls of mozzarella you can buy at Harris Teeter, on a skewer with a little balsamic. But the garlic bread was one of the worst appetizers/dishes I've ever had at a restaurant. It was literally a (non-toasted) sub roll, served open, with sliced cheese melted on it and a little garlic. I hate to send back a dish, but I came pretty close, because it was ridiculous. Maybe the least effort I've seen put into a dish when dining out. Bottom line, the pizza is very good, and stick to that half of the menu like your life depended on it. read more

I lived in Bmore for a while and would stop by Barfly's occasionally. We stopped by last night while visiting. I used to like it, but now I love it. It's turned from a beer bar to a top shelf whiskey bar with fantastic food. The pizzas, sandwiches, and apps are all fresh and delicious. The salad dressing is a must for the crust. Doug and Mike were fantastic with suggestions and ideas!!! read more

Great pizza. Great selection of whiskey (and other beverages). Great bartenders. Everyone is always friendly, including all the patrons. Now back to the pizza. This pan, mini deep dish pizza is a personal size and cooked to perfection. It has a perfectly crisp crust with added parmesan cheese cooked around the edges. There's so many to choose from and I can't pick just one that's my favorite! And if your one for condiments, I mean even if you're not, you must try the house dressing ! It's phenomenal and addicting! read more