The mashed potato bacon pizza is worth the hype. Their house beer compels me to say that they should stick to pizza. Drinkers, don't fret. If you are a twenty-something who wants to get drunk and sweaty they have a full bar and a back room that turns into a dark, sloppy dance floor. Then you can stand in line and wait for a drunk slice at midnight. read more

Amazing service!!!! Our waitress was so friendly and took fabulous pics of us when we asked. Delicious pizza - recommend the Mexican street corn pizza. read more

In a town of amazing pizza, Bar is the GOAT. Best atmosphere, best beer selection and hands down the best pizza, as mashed potato pizza towers over clam pizza and the red sauce pizzas also rock. Now that our daughter is no longer at Yale, we scheme for ways to work Bar into our travels through Connecticut. read more

Came here for pizza and beer after a hike Pros: - Loved the ambiance - very chill and the space is large enough to accommodate big groups; really liked the decor and vibe - Out of all the pizzas we've ordered (pepperoni red pie with mozzarella, bacon mashed potato white pie with mozzarella, and red pie with mozzarella) the bacon mashed potato def stood out but was a tad salty; it did taste like garlic bread though! - The large pizza is huge! Never saw anything like it before - Clean bathrooms Cons: - Not the best pizza I've had but would come back bc of the space read more

BAR - A large pepperoni red pie with mozzarella and a large red pie with mozzarella - the size is ginormous - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

You MUST get the mash potato pizza!!! It is so delicious and one of my favorite pies from BAR.

Was told by a local that mashed potatoes on pizza was a thing in New Haven (I know, WHAT? Simple math. Potatoes = love, pizza = love, so potatoes + pizza = love LOVE!). The place had a cute lounge with a fully open patio area, and even the restaurant side felt and looked like a lounge area. The restaurant has very dim lighting, with a industrial look to it. Our server was super friendly and helpful in helping us decide on the menu. The large pizza was huge, I would say at least for 4 people+. We had a party of 8 and shared a large pizza and a bowl of salad, which probably was a little less serving wise per person than average. I would maybe recommend 2 medium pizzas for a large group with the salad. I really enjoyed the mashed potatoes on the pizza with bacon - it was served hot and fresh. The pear salad was a good appetizer too before the pizza, and nice to add a little greens to balance out the meal ;) The only minor complaint I have is that we ordered a pitcher of the classic mojito and I expected it to be very refreshing since the description said it had house made mint cane sugar or something, but the mojito was average at most and the pitcher wasn't even stirred, so it was super boozy on top and super sweet on the bottom. I wouldn't order the mojito next time, but I'd for sure return for the pizza and salad :) read more

BAR - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Whenever I'm anywhere near New Haven, I feel like I'm obligated to visit any apizza joint because they have a unique style and flavor all their own. After checking out some reviews on Yelp, I found myself at BAR. The white pie with mashed potatoes and bacon was recommended in many reviews and my server said it was what they're know for. I actually thought the pie didn't really live up to the hype. It was good, but had a soggy crust and it was not really pizza in my opinion. We also ordered a red pie with mozzarella (also commonly referred to a "plain pie"), and that was more like it. It was really tasty......the crust however was very thin, especially compared to a lot of other apizza places in the area. They have just 1 salad option and it comes in 2 different sizes. It had leafy greens, apple slices, blue cheese chunks and pecans mixed in a vinagarette dressing........which didn't really appeal to me at first, but after tasting it, I found it to be surprisingly awesome. The space itself has a really cool vibe. Dark wood surrounds you and a couple of bars make for an old school steakhouse type of feel. The menu consists of 1 page of pizza and about 5 pages of beer and spirit choices. I didn't drink any alcohol when I visited but they had some really interesting options. The pizza was the reason why I went, so for that alone I can only muster 3 stars, but the overall atmosphere was really cool and the server was quick and friendly, so I'm going to bump it up to a 4 star review. read more

See all

Most important thing, and you can judge this comment all you want... Don't sleep on the BAR salad, best salad in the world. Salad aside, BAR pizza is up there with the best of them. Mashed Potato obviously is infamous and perfection. The vibe of BAR is also so cool, go for a nice family lunch or a friend dinner when you're unsure if you want to turn up... BAR is the best of both worlds. Solid beer choices usually too. So, just Go. It's a must. read more

Love love love BAR! What an amazing experience. Great pizza, top shelf drinks, and awesome service. There really is nothing else to say other that this spot is amazing! If you are in new haven, you HAVE TO come here. We will be back! Thanks Phoebe for the great service ! read more

BAR - Mashed potato bacon pizza and sausage mushroom/pepper - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

This was better than I had expected. A good number of beers available, split between bottled and draft. (They had a nitro available!) Bar service was quick and I enjoyed my Milk Chocolate Stout. There's a pool table (no cost- but they cap you if it's busy!). We sat down for pizza (group of 5) and got a large pepperoni red pie and a small white mashed potatoes and bacon pie. I thought the mashed potato pie was so good! Would recommend. I thought the pepperoni pie was mediocre. We weren't completely full - I'd order a medium and a large between 5-6 people if I went again. Service is a little spotty and rushed, but they said they were busy. We had pitchers of their mules and really liked the Green Chili Mule! read more

Upon arriving at BAR I went straight for the Bar where I met Rachel behind the Bar! Sweet as she was she helped me with beer selection as she handles the BAR like a true champ giving folks some of the best drinks but also Pizza options with a taste of Sappori D'Italia! Personally I picked a nice IPA with a small (not not so personal white garlic Parmesan with With mashed potatoes sausage meatball out of this world Definitely a good laid back atmosphere where any family or group of friends would feel happy to enjoy one of the hottest spots in New Heaven! Rachel thanks for everything hope to see you next time as the Bar never disappoints read more

See all

This place is always a good time. If you visit CT or new haven you gotta try this place and their mashed potatoes bacon pizza and their toasted blonde beer. The atmosphere is always so happening and filled with great energy. I will always revisit this place. You're welcome fellow reviewers. read more

When I think of amazing pizza, the first place that comes into mind is BAR. I was lucky enough to grow up down the street and have yet to find pizza that revivals this place. There is usually a wait for a table even if you try to avoid the lunch and dinner rushes. The longest I've waited is 20 minutes and we spent the time walking around the beautiful neighborhood exploring the unique boutiques. The pizza is the thinnest crust I've ever had! Cheesy, crisp crust, I can eat a whole medium pie myself! Although I love toppings, my go to at Bar is their red pie with mozzarella. It's simply delicious!! And don't forget to try their salad- mixed greens, candies pecans, pears, crumbled blue cheese. Having some greens with your dinner makes you feel less guilty for eating a whole pie read more

See all

Outdoor seating, dog friendly. Would go early if you don't want to wait. Outdoor seating was fine, however, you are sitting next to a one way street, and have cars parked right next to you or honking at each other because they can't pass. That aspect was really annoying, but otherwise, overall an ok experience. Service was great. Tried different pizzas and you can't go wrong. Would try their mashed potato pizza topping! read more

Bar is a great place if you want to dress up or just kick back and relax for a casual night. There are four rooms -- bru room (beer & pizza), front room (pool tables, cafeteria style tables, bar room, cocktails), lounge area, and back room (clubbing/dance floor). The Bartender is very knowledgeable. He's quick to improvise and made a mean strawberry mojito. I also love how they brew their own beer. But what I love most about Bar is their Mashed Potato Pizza. If you're a potato lover, you must try this! It is AMAZING and I've never had anything like it. read more

BAR - Mashed potato pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Not about to get lost in the land of Frank Pepe's, Modern Apizza and Sally's, the promise of brick oven Pizza, freshly brewed Beer and Dancing luring in locals and Ivy League students for over a decade, it was en route from Manhattan to Mystic that a stop was made at BAR in New Haven, a nearly 45-minute wait for tables benefitting solo diners willing to dine at one of two actual Bars where the full menu is available. Originally established as a Microbrewery but quickly developing a following for New Haven's signature style of charred Pie, the Food options actually limited to just that and a lone Salad with plenty of customization available, it is shortly after seating that diners are greeted by one of several bustling staff members, Beer flowing from taps almost endlessly and Pies emerging from an enormous oven at a rate of one every couple minutes. Open every night of the week - as well as for lunch Wednesday through Sunday - with three sizes of not-quite-round Pizza presented on baking trays, it was perhaps fifteen minutes after placing an order that two "smalls" arrived, the bartender's flirting with an EMT in uniform unfortunately delaying water refills but the sixteen slices hot and fresh with 3-4 more than capable of sating the average diner. Reportedly using a gas oven instead of the competition's coal, an odd fact as the oven closely resembles Pepe's and Modern with Pizzaiolos using lengthy wooden peels to insert and extract Pizzas, there is nonetheless no doubt that this is New Haven-style on first taste, the Crust extra thin and medium-crisp but still capable of being folded whether one selects simple Mozzarella and housemade Tomato Sauce or BAR's signature white Pie with no Cheese but a carb-load buoyed by garlicky Mashed Potatoes and Bacon Crumbles. read more

See all

Lots of people rave about BAR and I can see why. It's got that underground feel thanks to its misnomer of a name, an inconspicuous entry way and uber dark interiors with exposed plumbing. They've also got a live DJ in the evenings that transforms the back room into a dance club (what else did you think those snazzy dangling light fixtures were for??). However, while some might be crazy for its ambience, I'm not so sure I'm crazy about the food. If I hadn't heard about the place from a friend or the internet, I probably would never have known the place served pizza. "Pizza", though, might not be the most fitting term to describe what they serve. Don't get me wrong. Their toppings are the downright freshest I've had in New Haven. The combination of the white pie with clams, a CT classic, I'm told, was supreme. Of all the white pies I've tried, BAR's probably wins. The clams were unbelievably fresh and succulent. When paired with fresh dollops of soft, rich ricotta, my tastebuds were jumping for joy. I've also had the pleasure of trying their red pie which I think is just as solid. I've thrown on all sorts of toppings--mushrooms, sausage, basil, mozzarella, artichoke, garlic--they're all great. The pies here are also ginormous. My Asian eyes may not be very large, but believe me when I say they bug out every time my pie gets delivered to my table. It never ceases to surprise me. You could easily feed 5 with a large pie, but of course, if I were you, I wouldn't want to share my pie either. What could possibly be wrong with BAR then, you ask? My gripe with BAR stems from the fact that their crust is not crust. True, there are all kinds of pizza, but I would like to think there's a minimum crust thickness that should be observed in order to be deserving of the title. The crust at BAR is so thin that by the time the pizza is served to you, the center of the crust has become sodden. As a result you have to eat your pizza with a fork and knife which is a whole lot less fun than eating with my hands. The parts of the pizza that aren't soggy are the edge pieces, but even these have started to yield to the moisture from the various sauces and toppings. A workaround could be to choose the white pie only (garlic, oil and mozz) which is lower in terms of moisture content and to avoid any juicy toppings like mushrooms or tomatoes and to instead go for herbs or crispy bacon, but that eliminates half the menu!! It is for this reason that BAR gets a 4.5 from me. I love going for its toppings and the ambience, but the wet flatbread that I'm served is not pizza!! If they would just double the amount of dough they used, they'd end up with a 1/8" thick crust which would still be thin enough to cook quickly while thick enough to hold itself together and to please a picky pizza eater like me. :) read more

See all

Pizza was the perfect balance between cheese and sauce. Crispy but not burnt. Best pizza I've had in CT so far.

If you are into designer pizza, this is the place to go. But unlike some designer pizza that tends to taste horrible- BAR is the exception. An abundance of options, fantastic cocktail list, and great beer selection. Most definitely try to book a reservation if you can or come in to leave your name and walk around and explore new haven. This place is heavy on the wait time. But it's well worth it. read more

Pizza and beer are two of my favorite things BUT pizza and a brewery all under one roof and I am definately in my happy place. I am sorry to admit that over the weekend was my first time at BAR (as Vincent T. notes - the hipper cousin of the other pizza establishments in the New Haven area) to meet a group of friends for a drink and a bite. We had a bit of the wait so we headed to the bar area where we grabbed a drink. They have a variety of their "house beers" on tap as well as an extensive tap list of other local (and non local) breweries. One of my friends is not a beer drinker but she was happy with the wine list (offered as Red 1, 2, 3, etc). It did not take long before our table was ready and we were brought into the dining room that doubles as their "tank room". The lighting was a bit low and could cause problems for people with bad vision but we were able to browse the menu with the help of our phone flashlights. The menu is not flashy - it's a pizza restaurant and with the exception of their BAR salad (which I highly recommend) that is all that is on their menu. BUT don't think that they have "Specialty Pies" on the menu because they don't. Just a long and overflowing list of ingredients for you to create your own. When ordering keep in mind that the crust is not think but thin and cooked at a high heat. The more toppings the heavier the pie - making it possible to lose your slice before it gets to your plate. Yes - we did make that mistake (so many toppings, so little time) but no slice was lost, I can assure you of that. I definately recommend this place as part of New Haven's pizza trail - thin crust and fresh ingredients - just make sure you come with your appetite as the pies are served on cookie sheets. read more

Went back to BAR after we couldn't get a table at Sally's. I had the lobster pie and it was superb. Huge chunks of lobster with a great lemon butter sauce. Best pizza I had the whole trip. My friend had the anchovy pie but it had too many anchovies and the pizza was so salty it was almost inedible. Overall though great pizza and this time I move them ahead of Pepe. read more

First time at Bar. Saw it was recommend on sites for pizza. Decided to check it out. First there is a parking lot across from Bar but if it fills up they will close it. And there is outdoor and indoor seating. As we read on their site they were known for their mashed potato and bacon bits pizza. I would say do not get that pizza. If you're there for pizza stay away from that specialty pizza. It really wasn't that great In my opinion. It was more of a gimmick pizza. Not great. Maybe get a regular cheese or something with actual sauce and cheese. There beer sampler though was fantastic. They have some great beer to taste and I would recommend getting it. read more

BAR - There beer sampler - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

We went to BAR which is the favorite of most of the college kids (we were told) in town. The pizza there was pretty good, they're famous for their mashed potato and bacon pizza.One note on BAR, they're a little too hip for their own good sometimes, and they lack in some of the soft skills. I.e. their hostess was too cool for school. Honestly, it wasn't for me. I couldn't really get past the bizarre flavor of potatoes on the pizza, it would've been better had the potato been sliced thinly than as mashed potatoes. But the mashed potatoes were also just mealy also, all in all disappointed in that toppings choice. But we ordered a second pizza, as one does normally, with more traditional toppings and the end results were heavenly. The crust was cooked well, but I tend to still find it comical that any place calls itself an Italian pizza shop. Pizza's in the States across the board have too much sauce, too much cheese, and too much toppings creating an end result that is overpowering. True Italian cooking is: less equals more, American commercial Italian cooking is: more more more. Don't get me wrong, BAR's pizza is perfectly fine, in fact it's really good. But to me it's not Italian pizza, okay I'll get off my soap box now. read more

See all

If you are LGBTQ this is not the place. 3 separate queer individuals were discriminated against in one evening at this establishment. The security, managers and owners have had no sensitivity training and have no respect for people with different identities. DO NOT GO HERE. If there is a pride event, UNDERSTAND that it is performative and a money grab. No level of "good pizza" will ever make up for the levels of discrimination, disrespect, and bigotry experienced, not to mention the dumpster smell throughout the establishment and DJ playing only clean versions of songs as if we're at a summer camp for 5 year olds. read more

Staff is very rude would not cooperate with anyone. Gave very dirty looks and overall very bad experience. Pizza as also very bad too.

Yummy! Just like I remembered from years ago! It took a bit of time to get our food but probably not that long- I was just impatient! read more

New Haven is known for pizza. We have been to several pizza places but BAR is by far the best. Plan on waiting for a table most evenings. It is worth it. There are so many choices of toppings and you can make any combination of the choices. We never seem to order enough even though we think we have plenty when placing the order. Be confident, order that extra pie, if you don't finish it you can bring it home. Our most recent visit we ordered plain, mashed potato and bacon and the last pie had artichokes.. There are plenty of beers on available too. A nice private room in the back for parties and several bars to keep everyone lubricated. Run don't walk to BAR. read more

They were ok sucks that there hardly any parking but again the pizza was ok not the best or worst I've ever had it was cool to try the mashed potato pizza that was different read more

Went for an early dinner and had a marvelous time. Got two great pizzas and a delicious cocktail. Waiters were very nice and attentive and the vibes for dinner were chill and fun! read more

Their pizza is amazing. Great atmosphere. Great service. Their shrimp pizza is delicious, served with lemon and cooked perfectly. I'm also a fan of their hot peppers for a topping, they are super hot and delicious. Great quality items. Drinks are yummy and bartenders are knowledgeable when it comes to making drinks. Never disappointed! read more

BAR - Bomb dot com - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Went to bar recently to do some birthday celebrating. We were able to reserve a table being that we were such a large group so that was super sweet! We ordered a bunch of pizzas. All delicious!! Of course we had to have mashed potato and bacon, which is their speciality. The best! The only issue with bar pizza is it is super thin, much thinner than the other pizza greats in town so if you load up on toppings the slices have a hard time keeping up. After a certain hour the back area turns into a full blown night club with some pretty sweet lighting fixtures that pulsate with the music. Normally not a fan of the nightclub scene but given it was my birthday we indulged. read more

Vaccine proof is required to enter. Should be part of description so public is aware. I was told good pizza, but unable to enter as I don't carry around my medical records. read more

Came in from NYC for a concert and came here both nights. Pizza is so good and our bartender Amber was A-1! I would def come back here because of her! Highly recommend read more

We got a cheese/pepperoni pizza, buffalo pizza, white mashed potatoes and bacon pizza and a shrimp and bacon pizza. The cheese was fantastic, I really enjoyed their cheese pizza. I didn't like their pepperoni pizza; it had a weird taste to me for some reason. The buffalo was also really good. It's a white pie in case anyone cares. The chicken was fresh and didn't taste dry! My daughter loved her white mashed potato bacon pie and my son loved his shrimp bacon pie. I didn't try those because I just couldn't understand putting shrimp or mashed potatoes on pizza. This place is very busy so try getting reservations ahead of time. It took them 40 minutes to sit my party of four. It was also a Friday night so that probably didn't help. read more

Last night we came to BAR & this place is hands down my fav pizza spot I've been to. We live in NYC & seek out pizza everywhere we go. A friend recommended BAR, particularly their Mashed Potato Pizza. Never have I ever had such a crunch to a slice!! Everything about this slice was unbelievable! From the dollops of potatoes (instead of just slathering it all over every bite) to the seasoning. Highly recommended pie! The door guy was super friendly & our waiter was awesome! Attentive, friendly, funny...just all around great staff! We will def be making a trip back to New Haven just for BAR! read more

BAR - Small Mashed Potato Pie Medium Pie with Mozzarella, Ricotta, Garlic & Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

This place has some of the best pizza that I've ever had, and that is saying a lot because I don't tend to choose pizza as my go to food. We had the Mashed potato & bacon pizza, eggplant Parm, and Mexican street corn. All the pizzas were amazing and so delicious but my favorite was the Mexican street corn which is a white pie with grilled corn, queso fresco, crushed Taki's. Unfortunately, we ate so quickly that I didn't get a chance to take any photos. Aside from that, this place has a very chill and hip vibe. They serve pizzas on paper plates and the place has an area that turns into a club after 10 pm or so. There is usually a cover but since we were at the restaurant already we could have gone in for free. I can't wait to come back to this place, would 100% recommend. read more

This place features really good pizza. Wow. We ordered a Mashed Potato Pizza and a regular cheese offering. They were some of the best we've ever had. The beers were ok and get the job done. The music was on point, too. read more

BAR - Cheese and mashed potato pizza. - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Bacon Mashed Potato pizza was underwhelming but still something you should try. If you don't like thin crust pizza, this is not the place for you. We had a large party try to dine in but they require that everyone show their ID to get a seat (a little crazy since we weren't even ordering drinks). As for the pizzas themselves - I tried a margarita pizza (red pie with tomato and basil) and also the famous bacon mashed potato which pie. the margarita was far better in my opinion. The mashed potato pie tasted like pita chips dipped with fluffy mashed potato... I did really enjoy their crusts, it was charred and crispy. read more

BAR - half buffalo chicken half bacon mashed potato White Pie w/Mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Bar is known for serving one of the best pizzas in the area, and I must say they do! I've been to BAR on numerous occasions and have tried a number of pizzas from here. They offer a selection of local beers along with a variety of mixed drinks. The massive thin crust pizza is served on a full sized cookie sheet with fresh ingredients and a super crispy crust. The most popular pizza here is the mashed potato and bacon pizza served white or red, in which I prefer the white. I usually opt for that or the pepperoni pizza which are both delicious. On my last visit I tried something new which was the buffalo chicken pizza which I wasn't a huge fan of. There was no blue cheese on the pizza and the buffalo sauce didn't have the kick I was looking for in it. On my last visit me and my fiance sat at the bar to avoid the wait for the table. We received our drinks and pizza fairly quickly by taking this option. Keep in mind when going to this spot between Thursday and Sunday nights you could expect a long wait. It is very popular with locals. A must-visit if you're in New Haven. You won't regret it! read more

BAR - Mashed potato bacon - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Super mediocre pizza. It's so deceiving because it looks just like pepes, but you literally cannot even compare the two. The crust was absurdly thin, which left me wanting more. It tasted just like a tortilla with sauce and cheese on it. I will say the atmosphere is great and we ordered a couple delicious and strong drinks while we had a 30 minute wait for a table. It's a cool place to spend your afternoon, but don't expect much from the pizza. read more