Prices keep going up, but their quality of food and staff keep going down. They've always nickeled…read moreand dimed you to death, but now it's way worse. It's sad when Crosby's gas station pizza is 10x better than tasta. This is a pizza and wings area. There are so many great places to eat at instead of them. I wish they would notice that they are even losing loyal boomers and people who just eat there out of nostalgia. A lot of local police eat there, but my friend on JPD says half of them just do it out of tradition and wanting to support a local place not out of actually liking it anymore. I don't know what happened, but you can't blame covid because they started going down hill years before covid. Maybe covid will be the last nail in their coffin if they don't get their act back together. 10 years ago I'd say they were top 5 in town now they are at the absolute bottom of the list. Ranking pizzas around Jamestown, Falconer, and Lakewood: 1. Perfect Pizza 2. Sauce 3. La Cocina del a nona (they raised prices big time too, but they are still great quality,flavor, and staff) 4. Allen st diner 5. Danny B's 6. Lena's (A lot like perfect pizza, but the crust is doughy bubble gum sometimes) 7. Honest John's 8. Wegmans cafe as well as take and bake 9. Group therapy 10. Crosby's gas station in Falconer and Randolph 11. Pizza Express 12. Blairs 13. Little Caesars 14. Walmart take and bake 15. Aldi's take and bake 16. Brick city 17. Tops take and bake 18. Dominos in Falconer (Lakewood location is garbage and burns everything) 19. 711 (all premade) 20. Subway pizza sub 21. Tasta Honorable mentions outside of the area that have better pizza than falconer Tasta: Napoli in Warren PA Big John's in Randolph Ashville general store pizza logs in Ashville Hughes hotel in Little Valley

Very rude staff, dirty dining area. Just avoid this place. I had bad vibes from the minute we…read morewalked in. Wish we would've gone somewhere else. Pizza was gross And greasy.

Brick oven pizza was awesome and rolled pepperoni with sauce was awesome so large ! Abby was very…read morefriendly and attentive to our needs and we talked for awhile about the area ... we wanted to come back when the rain stops later in May ... We got lots of suggestions thanks again ..

A short walk from the Doubletree. The beer selection was good. I had a pizza - OK, nothing…read morespectacular, but a nice evening with good service and atmosphere.

My latest visit after being a 30 year customer will by my family's last. The pizza was so under…read morecooked that the center was rubbery dough. we even tried to cook it more in the oven but all we got was a hard burnt crust. The following week while placing another order to give it another try I spoke to the owner Randy and he pretty much called me a liar and that the pizza should be doughy and that he would cook it twice but it will be burnt. I wasn't asking for anything free but just to let them know what had happened . I know how the pizza should be after so many years but after being scolded and talked down to this is the last.

Amazing pizza! We stay in Bemus Point usually twice a year for a few weeks. If we stay two weeks we…read moreusually order Lena's at least 3 times. I don't eat bone in wings but everyone else in our party had them and raved about how good they are!

Best pizza ever! Several varieties that you won't find elsewhere. Great specials, too. I know…read moresome folks who drive all the way from Bemus Point because this is their favorite, too.

Absolutely the best pizza in town if you want something delicious and unique. Both the gyro pizza…read moreand the Greek pizza are delicious and you'll be hard pressed to find them anywhere else! Personal favorite: The Suprema, but the Chicken Bacon Ranch is a close second!

Love their subs and pizza are both amazing with a slushy. Thanks for a great lunch…read more Always a friendly atmosphere

Anthony Morse was very friendly and help me carry things to the counter Also helped my son with his…read morepizza order.

there is a very large variety of entrées to choose from including many different pizzas. The…read moreservings are very and I have never had a bad experience staff is friendly and very accommodating. We have had birthday parties there, and the restaurant has given us desserts without charging us. It is one of my favorite restaurants in Jamestown. Highly

The service and food were excellent here! Try the eggplant - it was amazing. Our server was so…read moreattentive and the restaurant itself was very clean and comfortable.

Best Wings in jamestown and the service was good price not to bad definitely worth trying the wingsread more

Updated review! May 2024 4.5 star! YUMMY!…read more Super friendly staff that are attentive, helpful, and fast. Amazing pizza buffet,penne pasta, stuffed pepper soup, salad bar, dessert pizza, and wing refill. Everything was delicious! Only slight thing was the first batch of wings that were in the buffet were on the drier sauce side and softer side when we first got there. I asked for Buffalo sauce they gave me to dip in which was so good! This is only a preference thing on my end. They had a great flavor though and 5 minutes after we got there they were replaced with absolutely perfect saucier hotter crisper wings we went nuts over. Such perfect wings! I highly recommend the buffet. Perfectly priced buffet value. I hadn't been there in over 3 years because of a bad takeout experience with teenagers running it. I think it was a fluke experience. I'm so glad I stopped back in because the staff were perfect this time. The pizza was so much better this time too. I couldn't be happier. I'll be back for sure. 5 star staff 5 star freshness 5 star cleanliness 5 star nice casual atmosphere 4.5 star food 5 star location 5 star price

Terrible service!!! I ordered 2 pizzas the day before to assure they would be ready for a business…read morelunch. When I got there, I was met with confused looks and the worker had no idea what I was talking about. The person that took my order was actually there and said, "well I thought I put the order in.". I had to go to Little Ceasars for a hot and ready pizza rather than what everyone at my place of work ordered! This was embarrassing and I will never order from Domino's again. This also made me late returning to work!!

Driver Maurice from the 2nd st Jamestown Store, is very rude. Wouldn't deliver to my door, my…read morehusband had to go down stairs to get it and, Maurice was very rude, saying he can't wait for customer to come get there food. He doesn't need to be working with the public

Pace's Pizzeria -- Where Pizza Feels Like Home…read more Pace's Pizza in Jamestown has that vibe where it doesn't feel like just another pizza stop -- it feels like home. The staff? Lovely. Warm. Like old friends greeting you. Their outdoor patio is my favorite spot to dine (weather permitting) -- there's something special about sitting outside, pizza in hand, enjoying summer/early fall evenings. I usually get the Pace's Special -- pepperoni, green peppers, onions, mushrooms (and yes, sausage if you want). It's my go-to order. The crust is decent, sauce is good, toppings fresh -- I like it. It's not pushing into my "top pizza ever" category, but it hits the spot every time. What makes Pace's really stand out for me is the family-friendly atmosphere, the kind of service that makes you feel welcomed (not rushed), and the overall ambiance of a local pizzeria where decades of history show. Founded in 1953 by Dino Pace, and now run by Joe & Alyvia Town, they've kept those old-school roots alive with homemade dough & sauce, fresh toppings, and keeping the community in mind. If you want a pizza place where you feel good just being there -- where the patio breeze, friendly crew, and solid, dependable pies are the draw -- Pace's might not shock you, but it'll always steady you. I'll be back (especially when that patio opens).

In 2016,2017,and 2018 I had so many bad experiences (long waits,wrong orders, multiple overcooked…read moredry inedible pizzas, and getting charged for extra cheese that I never received multiple times) that it made me abandon them even though they're my childhood favorite pizza. I recently drove by with a friend who's never been and he asked about them. I have ALWAYS loved their salads with their amazing homemade Italian dressing, cheese, and pepperoni. I was feeling nostalgic and he wanted to try so I decided to give them one last chance after texting my cousin who said that they've been better since covid. I'm so glad I did! This hit me right in the childhood feels! Amazing salads still,great pizza, and friendly service. Very clean, fast, and accurate like I remembered from my childhood. I'm ready to become a long standing regular again!