Every time we spend a weekend at the lake we order a pizza one night from Coppola's. Tonight we ordered a supreme 16". As per usual, the crust, texture, "doneness" and toppings were all on point. Don't let the average ratings keep you away. I am a pizza guy (definitely my kryptonite) and I highly recommend!!! read more

Yum. Just yum. This is some good pizza. The crust has great texture, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese blend is tasty without being too greasy. I am a sucker for a pizza with crispy 'roni cups, and Coppola's delivers on that front too. read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

Had takeout pizza. The pizza was very good, will try some other dishes the next time we order! read more

I've never tried it, but I smelled it and my son has had it many many times and says it's great. I just don't get out there enough, but I'm just telling you the pizza is fantastic. I give more than five star read more

One of my top pizza places, and my favorite in the around Chautauqua! My family comes from Pittsburgh to vacation in the area every summer and we've been getting Coppola's since the year they opened. Despite being very busy sometimes when we come in, the staff buzz around the back like bees and pump out pizzas in reasonable times. I can't remember a time when they weren't friendly or helpful. Plus it's a family owned business and we recognize many of the faces each time we return. The storefront stands out from the moment you approach it, with a bright white, red, and green paint job. A couple of patio tables have given us some nice outdoor seating when the weather is right. Inside is small with a few more tables, drink refrigerator, and lots of decor with Andriaccio family photos. They added shelving by the counter during the pandemic to help organize and speed up the takeout process. Now let's talk pizza! We LOVE the cup-shaped pepperonis! It's a shame most places don't use them, because the edges crisp and provide a great taste and crunch. Perfect amount of cheese and the sauce isn't acidic like some places where it's agitates the mouth and stomach. They also offer giant round and sheet sized pies which are great for our big vacation household! I'd love to try the unique shapes they've made too, like a Chautauqua Lake and Buffalo Bills pizza! A number of custom pizzas are also on the menu, but we always go with the classic cuppies! Whether it's getting our traditional first-night-at-the-lake pizza for dinner, or a quick lunch when we participate in the Bemus Point art shows, they're always convenient. Can't say enough about this place and we'll be back soon. read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - Medium pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

I used to really look forward to coming to the lake and getting Coppola's. Getting a pizza place in Bemus at all was glorious and better, it quickly became one of my favorite pizza places in the US, despite living in the NYC area. Unfortunately, it's steadily gotten worse since it opened. Pizza quality has gone down, price has gone up, delivery has gotten less competent, and most troubling, this year they stopped making breadsticks, which I loved. That's fine, I guess, but they also refused to make them at all when asked. Aren't they just pizza dough in a different form? Is it that hard? I'd have paid anything for them. Oh well, the combination of disappointments means that not only have they dropped from my top five places in north America, but also that I won't bother ordering from them multiple times each summer anymore. At least I won't gain summer pizza weight. Also, I'm writing this review after ordering. "45min delivery time" and it's been over an hour. Losing again. EDIT: Finally got it. Decent if sparse toppings, but less interesting crust-- looks like a typical freezer-section-of-the grocery-store type thing. It still tasted better, but it's definitely not something I'd go out of my way for anymore. Too bad. read more

Ordered the Chicago style and it was not fully cooked. When we got home, we ended up putting it on our oven for 15 more minutes and it still didn't cook - what a disappointment !!! We were in the mood for pizza, so we literally threw this one out and ordered from Crosby's. First time in my life I had to throw out a pizza. We were afraid to eat the raw dough at risk of getting sick. We had a good pizza from Coppola in the past but likely won't be going back. Bummer. read more

Great pizza, wings and service. ''Twas a busy Saturday night and my pizza was ready on time - much appreciated. read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - Wish I took a pic of what's inside the box - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

This was a big fail for us. I feel like 2 stars might even be generous. Our food was luke warm when it arrived by delivery (maps said it was a 13 min drive from restaurant). None of the containers were vented, so the fries, onion rings, and chicken fingers, and wings just steamed the entire time and we're all mushy. The pizza had potential (The Godfather) if it would have been warm, but I was surprised at the lack of ingredients actually on it after reading the description on the menu. This will be a pass for us next time we're in the area. read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - Godfather pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

I wish I lived here so I could eat Coppola every week. It was so good. We ordered a 16" of The Undertaker Pizza (aka Meat Lover's) and 20 medium wings. The pizza was amazing. The toppings were fresh, flavorful and plentiful. It had a perfect proportion of cheese to sauce, and a nice amount of crust - not too thick, not too thin. And it was cooked perfectly. The wings were also excellent. The medium sauce was great - not too spicy, but still great Buffalo flavor. And they were also cooked perfectly. Slightly crisp on the outside, juicy and tender on the inside. We ordered it to-go, which was very easy. Just a quick call and it was ready when they promised. read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - 16" Undertaker (aka Meat Lover's) - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

See all

We had ordered some take out while staying in the area for a few nights. We were sadly disappointed. To start the delivery took quite awhile to arrive. The food was ice cold and the wings and fingers weren't packed properly so they were soggy. We tried The Godfather pizza, which is the premier pie on the menu and is advertised as the best seller since 2008. Most pizza places I have been to previously would load the premier pizza with toppings. This came out looking sad and bare. The crust was a little soggy and the quality was slightly above a frozen pizza. The wings has decent flavor but as I mentioned before were packed without punching holes in the lid of the styrofoam container. The texture was soggy and a bit rubbery from this. Finally, the chicken fingers were slightly more crispy than the wings. But their texture was also was hurt by the packaging. The quality of the chicken was poor. It was a ground up chicken patty, definitely the cheapest quality frozen stuff you can find. If you are in the area you would be better off finding something else. We ordered leftovers as snacks and ended tossing it all out because the original meal was so disappointing. Also to note when we arrived at our rental house there was a Coppola's box in the trash with a lot of pizza left from the previous guest read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - Godfather pizza, wings and chicken fingers - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

Have loved Coppola's pizza for years and has always been awesome! Have ordered multiple times with the new owners and pizza is never fully cooked! Just ordered a thin crust pizza and it wasn't even cooked. read more

Place has changed and not for the better.... Picked up 2 Pizza's, one was overcooked with hardly any sauce the second was given to us totally uncut. The taste and the quality of the pizza has really gone down hill. Need to find a new go-to place. Sad because they are in a great location. read more

I personally think they are the best pizza on the lake. Love their crust. Get the Giardino!

Love the pizza!! The cowboy pizza is our family favorite! Best local pizza place for sure!

I feel as if you shouldn't allow 3 year olds in your kitchen touching people's food. It is unsanitary and unprofessional and should not be around knives that are on a counter. The health department would not be enthused I'm sure. read more

We had a pizza that was a square 24 slice. You could choose to pick toppings per quarter. It was amazing. We had tropical, cowboy and one with many different meat toppings. It fed the 6 of us that afternoon and leftovers to snack on later! Great place to choose. You can't go wrong! read more

Coppola's is one of the only places that delivers around Bemus Point, and we enjoy ordering from here often. Their pizza is delicious, but so are their wings, salads, fries, etc. Their delivery usually doesn't take as long as it is estimated so that's always a nice little bonus! read more

AMAZING pizza and great calzones! The staff were so friendly to this tired traveler and the food really hit the spot. Thanks for a terrific meal! read more

The pizza is best hot. Omg. So delicious. The gentleman who run this establishment are hard working, patient, and conscientious read more

Family owned and operated. Always always so kind and friendly. Pizza is awesome!!!!! Indoor area is so cute and clean. Seem to be very community oriented which is also a plus in my book. Check them out, they won't disappoint! read more

I make a point when i come in from out of state to my favorite pizza shop in Chautauqua County . The dough is perfectly cooked. The ingredients are fresh an the service is above top notch. Supporting local is important when i come back home. The pizza shop has been a staple in the bemus area for years. Consistency an great service. Repeat customer for life. read more

Bad experience. Bought a 14in margarita pizza and a cannoli. It was far from the standard margarita pizza. No sauce. No fresh mozzarella. And basil burnt to a crisp. It tasted gross. Keep your penny and spend it somewhere else because this is far from worth it. If I could give this place Zero stars I would. I'm extremely disappointed. read more

Cute neighborhood pizzeria - we want to live upstairs! The best deal is the sheet pizza sampler with any four specialty pizza flavors or custom toppings. Our party of six loved this pizza! read more

As far as nifty little places to go for a pizza, a wrap, a sub, a simple snack or meal Coppola's is pretty darn pleasant with a friendly staff. Though the food isn't really all that much for me to Yelp out about, the attention given to the customer is. It's a far better bet than going to anyone of the chain pizza shops. read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - Front - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

See all

Nice little out of the way place. We got a 10" Margherita pizza after stopping at random on our way through. The pizza was good and the service was prompt and friendly. It's got a tiny little sit down area and it looks like all the locals get it to go. We were there off season and on a chilly day. I would assume that during the peak touristy season, the place gets crazy packed... read more

See all

Awesome pizza. Highly recommend the Godfather. Love the sauce and great for kids as well. The staff is extremely friendly and helpful! read more

Coppola's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bemus Point, New York

Great pizza! Made a mistake and got a 24 inch, but we're gonna eat ever bit of it. The crust was fantastic not too soft not too hard Just the way I like it. Pepperoni was this tiny little cups which way cool and really nicely spiced. We'll definitely be back. read more

Huge pizza with big flavor and wings that teenagers devoured. We are at Lake Chautauqua for a family vacation and wanted an easy dinner on our first night. We chose Coppola's based on Yelp reviews and we were not disappointed. I recommend following my plan, we walked up to order take-out and then strolled along the lake while our pies cooked. We enjoyed standard pepperoni and cheese for our teens then the Tropical and Godfather for those wanting more toppings. Great pizza, local flavor and good value. read more

Ordered pizza from here tonight as andriaccios was closed and it was honestly the worst pizza we have ever had. The cheese was barely melted, the mushrooms were dried flakes( I have never seen anything like it before) we had to order breadsticks in order to qualify for delivery and they were terrible too. Very dried out with 0 flavor. I always say you can't go wrong with pizza but unfortunately you can here. read more

A "Greek Salad" $14.00 - a minimum of ingredients. Tourist rip-off. Ask prices before ordering.

I moved to Bemus Point 7 years ago ..I ordered a take out pizza from Cappola's and I have to say it was the worst pizza I've ever had... Never ordered from there again...about a month ago I was asked to place an order for a neighbor bc her phone was not working so I thought ,,,oh well as long as they will be delivering for her I'd order a sub( how can anyone mess up a Sub)....I won't go into all that was messed up but OMG ...that's it never ever order anything from there again..they should be ashamed to serve the food they do read more

Went to Coppola's for the first time last month. It was incredible. I had heard mixed reviews but I wanted to give it a chance. I got the Godfather pizza toppings on a hot sub... wow! So much flavor. I highly recommend that and if pizza and wings is your favorite, their wings were outstanding. I live about 15-20 minutes away. My wings were still piping hot when I got home. That is hard to do! read more

This place makes me sad that I don't live in New York to have this pizza whenever I want. My boyfriend and I bought a large pepperoni and Chicago style pizza for dinner with the grandparents and everyone was satisfied, which is hard to do! I spend a lot of time in Chicago so I am skeptical of most deep dish outside of the city but this one was fantastic. Every staff member we talked to when we picked the pizza up was so kind. It's a cute location and I'll definitely be back when I'm in town read more

Best pizza anywhere around Chautauqua. Changes the game. Food came quick even though they were busy and they're in a good location.

The price of a specialty pizza should reflect the amount of toppings. Ours had very little toppings or cheese for that matter. Crust was tasteless. Chicken wings were not crispy at all. Overall flavor was ok. Not sure what the hype is about. read more

Ordered the white pizza, flavor was good, just needed a bit more cheese for my taste. Wait for pizza was ok, considering the sky opened up with sheets of rain, and the place ended up packed! While waiting noticed one of the guys making the pizza was checking with another customer to see if the pizza was done enough for him. Thought that was very considerate. Cashier was very polite and friendly. read more

On a trip to the Chatauqua Institute we stopped in Bemus Point for lunch. Cute little town and great lunch spot. Yes it's a pizzeria, but you have got to try the steak & cheese sub it's amazing, Made with thick tenderloin or rib eye, the meat was AMAZING!!! read more

Staying at the KOA this weekend and was in the mood for some pizza. Coppola's Pizzeria was fantastic. Got a 1/2 cheese, 1/2 pepperoni pizza. The sauce was delicious and not too sweet. And the pepperoni's were the old style small pepperoni that char a little bit on the end creating a little grease cup. So good. We also got the Godfather pizza. I highly recommend this pizza! Lastly - the customer service was excellent. My wife went to pick up the pizza and our youngest child fell asleep in the car on the way. They were very accommodating with bringing the pizza out to her car during a busy time. Five stars for this great pizza joint. read more

I'm so sad to hear you closed your Erie location!!!I ordered from there once a week, we loved the white pizza and enjoyed your wings.