Every time we spend a weekend at the lake we order a pizza one night from Coppola's. Tonight we…read moreordered a supreme 16". As per usual, the crust, texture, "doneness" and toppings were all on point. Don't let the average ratings keep you away. I am a pizza guy (definitely my kryptonite) and I highly recommend!!!

Very disappointed with my experience at Coppola's Pizza in Bemus Point. The pizza was already…read moreoverpriced for what I received, and then I was charged an additional $20 for delivery to a location not even 2,000 feet away. On top of that, a tip was added to the bill. Between the high food prices, the excessive delivery charge, and the added tip, the total cost was completely unreasonable for such a short delivery. I definitely did not feel the order was worth the money, and I won't be ordering from here again.

We've been eating here since they opened and we love it! Their pizza and wings are so consistently…read moregood. The service is friendly! The garlic parm wings with the homemade blue cheese is my go to!

This is St. Patrick's Day and Eric has a Rueben Calzone today as one of his Monday specials. I…read moreordered ahead and arrived about 5:15. My order was just coming out of the oven so perfect timing. They included a delicious "thousand island" homemade sauce whose flavor absolutely complemented the tasty sandwich. Normally, Eric features either a meatball sub or a beef on wick. Having now tried both you better order ahead of time as he sells out every Monday.

I'd rate it a 4. Food was very delicious. No salad and no bread with spaghetti. Come on at least…read morethe bread. Every Italian restaurant has bread. Service okay. Not remarkable. And no lunch menu most restaurants offer this service. All in all a nice atmosphere, good food, okay service but no extras.

We had pizza two different days while staying at Chautauqua Institute. The first time the pizza was…read moregreat and we would've given this restaurant a five star. The crust was similar to a Pizza Hut hand tossed but much better. It was cooked all the way through and the toppings were cooked perfectly. The second time the crust was overcooked on the outside, but undercooked on the inside. The pizza overall on the outside and all the toppings were overcooked, too brown, and it was dried out. So a dried out pizza with undercooked crust in the middle. This pizza would've been a one star rating. The first time we ate in the restaurant and were the first people in the restaurant for lunch to order pizza. Again, for the style it was an excellent pizza. The second time we ordered in the late afternoon takeout so that we could bring it back to our condo before the evening show at Chautauqua. My guess is the second time the oven was much hotter, so they could accommodate turning more pizzas more quickly. This made their product inferior by cooking it at too high of a temperature. The restaurant really needs to look for quality control, and consistency. Based on the number of good restaurants in the area, or more like lack there of, if they were more consistent, they could dominate the market.

Aside from the server being efficient and friendly, and the place being clean and welcoming, the…read morepizza and garlic knots here are perhaps the best we've ever had. My husband had the meat loaded pizza and I had the bbq chicken (and at my request, some pineapple as well). The pizzas were so delicious with the house made pizza dough and loaded with toppings -- especially the cheese! Our only complaint is that we are about 500 miles from CJ's, so a bit far for us to go often.

Came home to visit from TN and this does not do NY pizza justice. Do not order the pizza. The…read morechicken tenders and blue cheese hit the spot but the pizza was terrible. The white pizza was just cheese. Anywhere else it has garlic sauce, onions and tomatoes. This was just cheese breadsticks no sauce just dry ass pizza.

I had the beef on weck sandwich. It was one of the best beefs I've ever had! Loved it!!read more

An old mill turned country store. The store part has many…read morehandcrafted items that are cute. I came for the food. Counter service but with inside and outside dining. A pretty extensive menu. I had the deep fried artichoke with spinach dip side, and one of the Taco Tuesday specials taco pizza. The pizza was spiced ground beef , onion,and green peppers. Very tasty. The artichokes were unique, flavorful, and one of the best appetizers I have eaten. Housemade, crispy that dipped into a very good creamy spinach dip. Pizza and wings are on the menu. Sandwiches, pitas, and subs hot and cold. All looked good. I was going to get a half Rubin but saw the taco pizza.

I'm making a bold but very deserving claim that this is the best culinary experience in the area…read more It starts with the beautiful design of space and layout, but also carried through to carefully chosen high quality ingredients at a very reasonable price, and an excellent service experience. Can we get this in a Michelin guide for those traveling to Chautauqua or Lily Dale? What did we have? A perfectly juicy selection of lobster tail full of its own sweetness resting on top of a bed of pappardelle pasta bathing in saffron cream and sweet summer corn for pops of texture. A lumpy deep fried crab cake that crackled on the outside and then fell apart into juicy flakes upon breaking the fried shell. A sour dough bread with herbed butter that melted between the half sliced folds holding it together until fully pulling apart. Iced tea and lemonade Arnold Palmer with flavors that kept us guessing and curious about the added sweet spice profile. Definitely coming back, perhaps every single meal I can when I'm in the area.

Great addition to the Institution/Mayville-area. Staff are…read moreprofessional, attentive and pleasant. Owner is really committed to fresh in season local ingredients and creative/elegant preparation. Nice seasonal cocktails, impressively considered wine list. The menu has something for everyone, except maybe for anyone who wants a traditional meat-and-potatoes meal. (But still... They'd probably like their food!) Not for everyone, just perfect for most.

Great spot in the middle of nowhere with an amazing menu of regular items and also specials. Great…read morebeer cocktail selection. Staff was very friendly and engaging. Log cabin-ish atmosphere with fireplaces. Lots of memorabilia on the walls and lots of charm. Definitely worth a visit if you are in the area.

Beautiful building, beautiful setting. Everything else just seems to be going down hill. Service is…read morenothing like it used to be. No one knows how to make a drink other than pour a beer or whiskey/rum and coke. The food has been hit or miss. But mostly miss. Not worth the drive anymore, if they took reservations they could slow the pace down and make good food. Seem to be more focused on cooking food too fast (which dries it out or comes out underdone) to turn tables to accommodate the lines of people waiting. The ribs were dry, the fish has been wet, chicken wings slimey. No consistency. During snowmobile season you will freeze in there. Turn on the heat.

Small little brick and mortar pizza shop with a full range of bar drinks and beer. Pizza his…read morefantastic. Big slices. Ordered the Buffalo Chicken and Meat Lovers pizza. Great tasting. Great ingredients. Also had a sausage Calzone. Gigantic. Full of cheese. Knife and fork needed. Marinara dipping sauce has a little spice to it. Great spot. Super friendly staff. Even on a Saturday evening, the place was loud and packed. Keep it ip. 8.4 overall.

Geez, did this pizza hit the spot or what?!?! Walked over…read moreafter a long day of skiing and was greeted by the owner himself. Sit at the bar and had a beer as I watched them hand toss my pizza, along with it cooking in a brick pizza oven right in front of my eyes. Have to say they are some of the friendliest staff I've met. And that pizza was to die for!!!! Literally had to unbutton my ski pants the next day. lol Soooo worth it though. Thanks guys, your Columbus, Ohio friend. See you next year.

The service and the food was great. We ordered a couple pizza and the battered fries. We also tried…read morethe fresh turnovers which were a bit hit. Great stop near Lake Findley for fresh pizza.

Vinnie's is incredible! The service was extremely friendly and our waitress was amazing and caring…read moredespite being short staffed. Definitely recommend getting their pizza and wings. The sauce on their spicy oriental wings is super tasty, and we really enjoyed the nightmare pizza. They definitely don't short on the toppings! The food was hot and tasted fresh. With their fair prices, amazing food, and extremely kind staff Vinnie's is definitely the place to try out. We look forward to coming back!