This is a solid pizza place where the pizza is good and the service and value makes it a solid recommendation. I ordered the Pace's Special and I love the individual size and price. I swapped out onions for jalapeños. I appreciated that the mushrooms were fresh, not canned. The Montepulciano wine was nice. Our table enjoyed it. We shared a small tossed salad but I'm not sure I'd recommend it. The service was friendly. We sat in the back corner table so she could tell quickly if we needed anything. I enjoyed Pace's and would come back again read more

See all

In 2016,2017,and 2018 I had so many bad experiences (long waits,wrong orders, multiple overcooked dry inedible pizzas, and getting charged for extra cheese that I never received multiple times) that it made me abandon them even though they're my childhood favorite pizza. I recently drove by with a friend who's never been and he asked about them. I have ALWAYS loved their salads with their amazing homemade Italian dressing, cheese, and pepperoni. I was feeling nostalgic and he wanted to try so I decided to give them one last chance after texting my cousin who said that they've been better since covid. I'm so glad I did! This hit me right in the childhood feels! Amazing salads still,great pizza, and friendly service. Very clean, fast, and accurate like I remembered from my childhood. I'm ready to become a long standing regular again! read more

Pace's Pizzeria - I hadn't been back after several bad experiences in 2016,2017,and 2018. I'm happy to say they're better again! Expensive, but good! - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

I've been coming to Pace's for 35 years. My mom has been a customer since the 1950s-60s, when her sister worked for Mr. Pace. The current owners are committed to maintaining the same level of quality, the light, crispy crust I remember. I really enjoy the short but yummy selection of wines. I notice that many customers get wine, but there are also beer options available. The pizza is always light and wonderful, a very consistent product. I love the dining room, and that it hasn't changed since my mom and I would come for pizza in the 1980s. There's also the addition of the back (outdoor) seating area in warm weather - so lovely. Another bonus: This is a favorite with locals, and there is a friendly neighborhood vibe. read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Outdoor dining. - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Delicious!!! It was busy on a Sunday evening but we were sat quickly. My husband enjoys their house salad. And the pizza is so good! The crust is perfect and the flavor of the sauce is just right! I wasn't a fan of the Meatball Boat (chopped meatballs and bread covered and Baked in cheese) but that because I misunderstood what it was. The meatballs tasted delicious and I would try a meatball sub another time. The prices were very reasonable. The restaurant is quite small and cozy but there's a back patio also available. read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Taking pizza home - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Very great pizza, for sure one of the best in town. 10/10 recommended stopping buy or ordering from Pace's

Best pizza in CHQ County! Hands down the best crust. Great service too! We've eaten in and called ahead to take out. Never disappointed!

We went on a warm evening, just looking for something to satiate our pizza craving. Pace's certainly didn't disappoint! We started with a caprese salad, followed by their margherita specialty pizza (I loved how many vegetarian options they had, by the way!) which was quickly gobbled up between the two of us. And of course, you have to try a cannoli if you're stopping here, so we did. Overall, a great place to go if you're looking to fulfill your pizza fix and your taste buds are craving more than just the run-of-the-mill franchise pizza places. read more

Pace's Pizzeria - caprese salad - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

They absolutely have the best pizza ever the best customer service. I really can't say anymore. I think they're the best pizza in town. I love them. Go down and try it. They open at four. You won't be sorry. read more

Best pizza in jtown. We really like the patio The service was very good. Prices are reasonable. The pizzas are as good as any pizza from Buffalo,Pittsburgh and NYC Classic Pizza read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Best pizza ever ! - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

We split the large pepperoni, mushroom and green pepper pizza. The crust was thin. The sauce was pure Italian. The mozzarella cheese was the most flavorful of my life. We loved it. Add a nice salad, beer and great service by Maddy...five stars. But wait! A new back deck is so pure urban. (Inside is traditional pizza joint. Very clean too.). The deck is a classy warm weather place to chow downtown on pizza and sip wine, beer or non-alcoholic drinks. $40.66 before tip. read more

See all

On our yearly road trip from Wisconsin to Maine we have chosen Jamestown New York as our night number one. We have fallen in love with this very quirky town. Kind folks, struggling folks all reside in this unique western New York town known for the birthplace of Lucille Ball. We were lucky enough to have restaurants years ago before pandemic, and now a pizzeria joint has survived and flourished in Jamestown. Pace's Pizza cares about family, beautiful food, affordable food, and kindness. What a wonderful spot to pull into at 8:15 PM on a weekday and join a joyful restaurant. We are welcome and we get a hug, sit on Luca's Patio out back joining other locals. This trip a young couple who teach in town and sell real estate. We order a gluten-free pizza, the meatball float, and a bottle of red wine. We leave after 9 PM with our to go food for our long drive through the entire state of New York (Jamestown to Albany) pushing east to emerge in New Hampshire where family resides. Kudos Team Pace's Team #wittestyle read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Isabel bids Pace's Thank You & Good Night - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Another hometown favorite on our Lakewood list. My family quietly ate two large pepperoni pizzas as fast as they can deliver them to our table. When it cone to my family eating, a quiet table means the food is great lol. This is authentic Italian American style and flavoring pizza. My fav was that it was thin crust super easy to eat. Very family friendly of course and yay they have a wine selection. You have a choice of eating inside or the newly added outside patio area for dining. Parking is a little limited but since it doesn't get crowed parking wont be much of an issue. They are quick here, service was and friendly. Be sure to add this place as part of your Lakewood dining experience. read more

I am sooo disappointed. I've always wanted to try paces pizza. I've lived here forever and never have. Excited to tonight. How disappointing!!. Seriously. I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese. Extra toppings are about two dollars. As you can see this pizza doesn't even have cheese on some slices. $35!!! Never again. It's terrible the sauce tastes like Hunts sauce from the can. ‍ I'm not even finishing it. read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Where's the cheese? - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

Love this place and they have had really nice wines in the past plus owner is a sommelier. Seems tho they have "dumbed down" their offerings to flights and got rid of their good wine list and recommendations. They do a great job with pizza tho. read more

Good pizza ,great survive' Like the back patio if I have one complaint it would be a little pricey. I'd recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a good pizza. read more

I came up to vacation at lake Chautauqua, and my parents and I were wanting local pizza. Being an intense researcher, I was looking for a place that did thinner crust pizza. Am very happy that we picked Pace's. We got a large pizza with green peppers and onions. It's served tavern style, with square pieces. Great sauce and cheese ratio. Crust was crispy enough. The people were very nice on the phone and didn't feel rushed, even with a busy house. Would get it again. read more

Excellent pizzas and service! We'd highly recommend you try them. We can't wait to go back!

It was the first time we ever tried their pizza since we moved to to the area in 2005. Wish we had tried it sooner! The pizza was delicious! We did take out so I don't know what their sit-down service is like. We will go back and eat-in and test their service. read more

The new owners carry on with the Paces tradition of quality and tasty pizza while giving the modern take on the classic pizza

Came back to Pace's after moving to Arizona, forty-years ago-same great guy, same great pizza! read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

Amazing food and service. The ambiance is relaxed and friendly. Decently priced and great value for the cost.

Pace's pizzeria, well I just tried this place and I really don't think it's good. Their garlic bread is...ok, staff are nice, it's a little small for how many tables it has, very greasy, salads are very soggish with Italian dressing but tastes somewhat good...I guess, and the pizza is very greasy and oily and I don't think it really tastes that good. It's got nice music, dim light, their tables aren't very clean, they've got lots of crumbs on them but nice table cloths. The bathroom doors don't shut properly with bothered me a little. Super nice people, definitely. It was good, definitely not my right hand resteraunt, so yeah it was good. read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

This pizza is fresh and delicious. Make sure you try the Pace's specialty pizza, a perfectly crispy crust topped with tons of fresh veggies and the perfect amount of cheese. Garlic bread is also amazing. Charming and friendly staff. read more

Pace's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

The pizza is better than the service. Second or third best pizza in the area. I also enjoy their salads.

Meh...went there tonight. Apparently reservations are standard? We were grudgingly sat at a table for the 4 of us practically on top of a nice older couple. It felt like our party of 4 became a party of 6. The place is so packed and tight that the waitress can't get around to do her job. While you sit and wait for your pizza, you can either shake hands with your neighbor or stare awkwardly at something. The pizza was....pizza. When you try to get it off the serving stand, all of the toppings slide off and you are left with a saucy piece of thin crust. Our family all thought it was really tomato and basil heavy. We always drive past and think it must be great because of the crowd, but we decided we will not be back. Not really sure what the fuss is about. read more

Best pizza ever and i have traveled to a lot of pizza places all over the world!!! --Sam read more

I cannot duplicate this pizza crust at home. I have been going to Pace's since I was 16 years old (over 20 years) and it is MY favorite pizza and it is cooked to perfection every time. The owner is great (the staff varies in friendliness), the decor comfortable and the pizza terrific. Worst part it that I haven't lived in that area in 10 years or more, but everytime I go back, I stop there. Now, I know very few people there and my family has left neighboring Warren, PA. I miss the place. Do try! read more

I've been here several times over the past six years and it's always delicious!!! read more

See all

Best pizza in jamestown!!! Wait 65 years in business says it all!!!! Always yummy and salads oh so good Great! read more

One of the best pizzas you will ever have. Casual but nice place, been there forever. read more

Just ordered to go Pizza was excellent Loved the crust In business since 1953 Now I know why read more

Some of the best pizza we've ever had! The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside, but soft inside. Great sauce to cheese ratio. So good we're getting it again two days later on our way back through Jamestown. read more

Had a white pizza there that we really enjoyed. We ordered a medium saying to ourselves that we'd take some back to the hotel with us for the next day but ended up eating all of it. We got a white pizza with ricotta, tomatoes and onions. The ricotta was so so good. I loved the crust. This is a totally casual pizza spot that has clearly been around forever. A great find. read more

Pace's pizza has been a tradition with my family and Friends ! When friends come from out of town We always get pace's . So glad the new owners are passionate about keeping it authentic . Wonderful service, great house wine ! Salad is a must . read more

Checked table cloths, lots of booths, pizza on a metal tower on table, looks like homemade crust - classic Salad was just shredded iceberg lettuce with too much shredded cheese and two slices of pepperoni, sprinkled with Italian seasoning. Not what I was hoping for when I ordered a salad. read more

Absolutely a place to go!! Class act all the way, great food and great people!!! Have traveled to Jamestown just for there food.

Delicious pizza for the whole family, great wine and beer selection. Friendly faces and a great place to make memories.

really good. would recommend. amazing. Lord have mercy on Paces' Pizzeria. Amen. Real

This place is very small and you have little room to walk to your table here. They put up giant mirrors to make it seem bigger but they can't fool me that easy. The salads are as basic as you can get and the pizza comes out extremely hot. Like burn the hell out of your mouth hot after all of the toppings slide off because they don't know how to make pizza. Parking isn't great either. We had to park across the street and cross to get there. They need to relocate big time. Bigger restaurant. Bigger parking lot. Better pizza. read more

I have been coming to a Pace's for thirty years, it was at one time the best pizza place in town, however in the last few years they have slowly declined. Tonight was probably the worst pizza I have ever had, a frozen grocery store pizza would have tasted better. The crust was like cardboard - just tasteless. I'm not sure if they've changed their recipe or cheapened out on the ingredients, but everyone in my family agreed that it was terrible. I'm so disappointed, as this place was once a true hometown favorite. Sadly, I will not be returning. read more