Drove by The Perfect Pizza many times in my lifetime but never stopped in until tonight! Was pleasantly surprised by how good their pizza and wings were and will be defiantly be stopping in again! Our waitress was patient and pleasant and the owner was very friendly as well. Made sure we had everything we needed. Got a large pizza for our group with the works on it as well as a medium cheese and pepperoni. Also tried their lemon pepper wings and medium wings which were cooked crisp and delicious! The restaurant is fairly small but kept clean. There was a steady stream of customers picking up pizza as well as eating in. Give them try! A local establishment who has been in the area for 30+ years and hopefully many more years! read more

The Perfect Pizza - Created a Large Pizza with cheese, pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, mushrooms, peppers, olives and onion! It was very good! - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Late on posting this as it has been about a month since I was here, but better late than never! My family and I were in Jamestown for a weekend and when it was time for dinner my 5-year old daughter wanted pizza. I always turn to Yelp when we're away from home and found The Perfect Pizza less than 2 miles away. My daughter loved it at first sight. A Michaelangelo (the world famous TMNT, not the world famous artist) figure as big as her greeted us and she was thrilled. As we sat down the waitress showed us where we could find coloring books and crayons for my daughter. It is a small place. Clean, casual, a bit eclectic in decoration, and feels very homey. Like your local pizza place you know and love. The waitress was very friendly, attentive, and helpful. We got a simple white pizza and a couple subs. My chicken tender sub was great; simple, crispy chicken, nothing fancy, but solid. I don't remember what sub my husband got, but I remember he got a large and liked it, but couldn't finish it. The pizza was a hit with my daughter. It felt a bit greasy, but I think only because it looked like there was a little oil on the pan to keep the pizza from sticking. It seems like a popular place as there was a steady stream of to-go orders picked up. I would definitely go back if we're in the area again. read more

The Perfect Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

The food is great. We love the pizza and wings. However, every time me go the bill is off. The owner rings up what the waitress puts on the check and it's always a few dollars more. Tonight, she tried to charge me $10.00 more. When I questioned her she was visibly annoyed. She rerang everything and got the same total as the waitress the second time. I understand an issue maybe once but not every single time. read more

Lousy customer service! Been a longtime customer, but got delivery today and order was wrong. Owners wife argued on phone they weren't making it right. They made it wrong. Lost a longtime customer for good with the lousy customer service! Go elsewhere wear they care and fix the issues. read more

Been a loyal longtime customer, ordered delivery today got wrong flavor wings, called owner wife Pam argued she was not making it right for us. Now you lost a loyal customer and we are going elsewhere. Awful customer service! read more

This place is a little "hidden" in a plaza where it can easily be missed, but it certainly deserves more attention! We wanted to try a pizza place that's different than our usual go-to spots... And we found this place because of the good reviews they have in many places online. Then this place quickly became one of our new go-to spots! They're very friendly inside and the food is great. The pizza is above average for sure. I hesitate to call anything "best," but their wings actually might be some of the BEST in the Jamestown area. In fact, their wings are so good that we went back a few days later just to get a whole bunch more wings! If you're on the hunt for a new place to try, I highly recommend giving this place a shot. read more

The Perfect Pizza - Chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Don't trust their website -Call - They close early and pick and choose their hours at will - Went there on a Sunday with 3 other couples at 7:30 - Website indicates open until 9:00 pm- Three employees were in the dining room watching football and the manager indicated they were only doing takeout orders and only until 8:00pm - Have gone there before during their business hours and found them closed - Poor customer service. read more

I was just driving through and was in the mood for pizza. My aunt and I both agree that it is by far the best pizza and wings we're had in a long time. Me suffer with heartburn and I am happy to say we didn't get heartburn. read more

The Perfect Pizza - 1 Large pepper pizza and 20 hot wings w/ blue cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Owner of this small business works personally to ensure you have a great product every time. Friendly staff and excellent food. The atmosphere is very relaxed. One of my favorite pizza joints in the area read more

Amazing extra cheese pepperoni pizza with medium wing sauce on the side for dipping. They got our order perfect read more

The Perfect Pizza - Got our order perfect! Very yummy - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

We went here over the weekend specifically for wings. We ordered 20. Two flavors, medium and teriyaki. They were delicious and crispy. Pleasant staff. Only negative was the restroom which needs serious cleaning and renovation. read more

This is absolutely ridiculous. I ordered pizza and wings and was not pleased. As you can see, this wing was the smaller than my big toe. Unreal. read more

The Perfect Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

We've been going here for years. We love their white pizza with all the veggies. It's the only take out pizza place we patronize. They're the best! read more

would be a 4 star rating but for one thing. what kind of pizza place is closed on friday??

My brother - the venerable Prince of our family - contends that those who do not like pizza are "downright un-American." I do not know if this is true or not - but, given that he said it to me when in response to his statement of "let's have pizza for dinner," I said "I don't like pizza." I suspect that his opinion is weighted by the desire to either get his way with regard to our menu for dinner; and/or mock me, his older (yet shorter,) sister. This mocking is a theme in all my family functions. I happen to have a Sarcastic Ass Father (see my Jacobs Field review for evidence) which has in return caused my brothers and I to become very very sarcastic children. I - actually - am the least smart ass of the three of us, my mannerisms, tact and grace tending to mirror that of my Beautiful and Gracious Mother. *smirk* The fact remains that I - do not - like most pizza. I do not think this makes me un-American - given that I vote, exercise my right to free (and, Internet loud) speech and am a product of the capitalist driven machine... it may make me a minority, though. As most people - American and not - tend to like that which is the cheesy-gooey concoction which is 'za. But, if you think this dislike of pizza odd - let me tell you two very good reasons why I don't like pizza: 1. When I was growing up, my Beautiful and Gracious Mother worked all day and went to graduate school at night. This meant that we three children were left alone with our Sarcastic Ass Father - who I still maintain was shocked at the age of 30-something to find himself married with three smallish children - this same Sarcastic Ass Father only knew how to (at the time) make three meals: Scrambled eggs with cheese, burnt hamburgers or Chef Boyrdee pizza out of a box. This meant that we had a variation on those three meals EVERY NIGHT when my Beautiful and Gracious Mother had not had a chance to prepare a meal in advance for him to heat up. That added up to a LOT of shitty pizza. Usually with onions (which I hate) and/or pepperoni (which I have no quarrel with, yet gets boring after the fourth or fiftieth time you have to consume it.) My dislike of pizza was born with those crappy Chef Boyrdee pizzas. How could it not be? (And, yes, for the record I also do not like scrambled eggs or well done meat of any variety... the only way to eat eggs is poached or hardboiled; and, the only way to eat red meat is bloody rare.) 2. I am VIOLENTLY allergic to anchovies. So much so that even a smidge of anchovy oil or paste will send me to the hospital where they have to pump me full of steroids and adrenaline to keep me from expiring from anaflactic shock. Did you know that many pizza sauces contain anchovy paste? Neither did I until this past winter when I consumed pizza - NOT ONCE - but, twice (from different restaurants and the second time after I asked if their red sauce had anchovy paste in it) that caused me to have to visit the ER. Strangely, most places have no clue if this is an ingredient in their red sauce or not. Scary, scary stuff. Anyhow... to say that I *hate* pizza would not exactly be true. Because every once in a while I like White Pizza. You know, olive oil and garlic instead of sauce. C'est tres bon! Not every place has this concoction. And, many of those which do make it in such a way that I do not find it palatable. Perfect Pizza? Does just what it's name says: Makes perfect white pizza. Tonight I had white pizza with olives, mushrooms and bacon. Tres yummy! I also shared some butter/garlic chicken wings with my Beautiful and Gracious Mother... also, tres yummy. read more

Absolutely in love with this place!! Their pizza AND wings are delicious!! Ordered a large ext. Cheese and pepperoni with 3dozen wings...all perfectly made! Two dozen made extra crispy and one dozem regular...all exactly as i wanted. This is my first time ordering from here and certainly will NOT be my last! The people were friendly...the restaurant was even themed for halloween!! Extremely impressed with all aspects of my experience! read more

The Perfect Pizza - Yummy...the family has began to dig in!! - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

These were the worst wings I have ever had in Jamestown. A City where bad wings should not exist. I should have known when I went in and it smelled so bad of OLD grease that I smelled like grease when I left. I was only there about 5 mins. The wings tasted old. The sauce looked like it came from a tomato can and tasted bad. The Parmesan were equally as bad. It all tasted old. Ill never go back. I rarely write a review here but these were pretty bad in a town that has so many other choices. read more

Very disappointed with the pizza dry yuck with crumbly toppings of "meat" tasted like hamburger. This was the all meat pizza. The price on the online menue was $19.95 or so for supreme it was $27 . No one was wearing a mask or gloves while preparing the pizza. WE ARE IN A PANDEMIC. They were not requiring customers to wear masks or sanitize their hands. I won't be using their services again. read more

In my opinion, Lena's has the best pizza in Jamestown. The pizza is loaded with mozzarella and the sauce is simply delicious, very sweet and savory. The crust is very tasty and crunchy. The heavy cheese can be overwhelming but overall Lena's makes a great pizza! read more

There are a lot of pizza joints around this area but for my buck Lena's makes the best. It's loaded with a tasty sauce as well as cheese and they seem to get the crust just right for the style of pizza they serve. It's also a pleasant place, friendly with a strip mall location. However, though this area has some great beef on weck, Texas style hot dogs, and beer batter fish fries, pizza is not one of the areas stronger points. read more

name says it all! they have perfect pizza! can't beat their pizza and wing deals. I like crispy wings with extra sauce and they always deliver ! I prefer ranch over blue cheese and sometimes they mix it up and give me blue cheese. sometimes they forget to give me my extra cheese too. other than those 2 things they are amazing. when that happened once they fixed it and another time apologized a lot and gave me credit for next time. they are really awesome. Nice family run place read more

The Perfect Pizza - Best wings in town hands down - Pizza Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Love the wings here! We always get the large pizza with double order of wings special! The medium sauce is to die for so I always dip my pizza in it! They also have amazing parmesan garlic wings. They have so many flavors of wings and even offer gluten free pizza! Love this little place! I wish they served beer and wine. read more

I have been going here for nearly 20 years! Where I first ever tried my fist chicken wing at a young age! The chicken fingers are really good and covered in sauce! Just the way I love.. fast and friendly service! The chicken finger pizza is also very good as well, me being a fan of it... not as many sauces to chose from as I would like, but the ones that are available are really good! I have to say, no other place in this area has chicken fingers as good as Perfect pizza.. I have been all over Lakewood and Jamestown and not yet have I found a place. I urge for the menu to have more items, such as wing soup or possibly a Buffalo Chicken lasagna! Yes that exists and it would be so great coming from here! read more

I grew up in Jamestown and the surrounding area, as such I have tried many pizza and wing outlets and have seen many come and go through this small area. I was 4 years old when my parents first took me here and when i stopped back again in June it was the same delicious perfect pie I first tasted back in 1990. The crust and sauce are made the same way as back then by the owners he is the only one making the crust and sauce so its always consistent. Toppings and cheese are always fresh as well. It really amazes me that after all these years and going so many times, (as a kid we always went on Fridays!) That the pizza is always the same Crust crisp but fluffy, sauce sweet and plenty of it. Cheese and toppings as far as the eye can see. The Perfect Pizza! Wings are tried and true big juicy Buffalo wings that would give the ones at the Original Anchor Bar a run for there money. Service is always pleasant and fast never an empty drink. Food is always still steaming when it gets to the table. If you have been to this Gem then you know all about it if not what are you waiting for! read more

Consistently the most well-balanced pizza I've had for the past 25 years. Their pizza has a moderately sweet sauce, medium thick crust that is soft but not doughy, salty blend of cheese and a variety of good toppings. The wings are best when ordered "extra saucy and extra crispy". read more

One of the best pizza places in Jamestown and you can't beat the prices!

Great Pizza but order ahead. There were six people in the back looked like Mom Dad and children. So mom serves great and as fast as Dad can make (create) it. Kids .....well "in the way" would best describe their usefulness. So i own a business and have my kids help as well. I know they can be a bit challenging.....but these kids did nothing but slow everything down. Took an hour and six minutes for a large pepperoni and 10 wings. The pizza was sent from heaven though so those with the patients of a saint are in luck. read more

Note: this review is for the location on 902 E 2nd St, Jamestown, NY...though pretty much everything also applies to the location on Fairmount. Best pizza in town. This is the quintessential Western New York pizza. Loaded with tasty (slightly sweet) sauce and plenty of cheese, with a crust substantial enough to handle all of it. Good quality toppings too. All of this comes at a very reasonable price. The wings are really good too, some of the better wings than you can get in town. Though honestly, most places around here have good wings. If you're a restaurant in WNY and you don't do good wings, shame on you. I did dock a star for their hours of operation. Aside from Wednesdays, Thursdays and Fridays where they have lunch hours, they're only open from 4 pm to 10 pm. This is especially troublesome during football season. The games start at 1, and nothing goes better with football than pizza and wings. read more

I enjoy Lena's, best pizza in town in my opinion. The only downfall is the lack of delivery, but it's worth the short drive any day. Large with extra cheese and pepperoni is my choice, with a double order of butter garlic wings cooked 18 minutes. Usually runs a little over $20, but It's hard to feed the family for less. Amazing food! read more

They make a very good pizza, quick and cheap. Square slices make for good eating (is this an upstate NY thing? I see it a lot). Sauce is indeed plentiful, and usually ends up in the lap. They are not stingy with the cheese. Good stuff. read more

This IS good pizza for the AREA , however ... there is ALOT lacking in their customer service skills , they are almost to the point of being rude . I have had 2 unpleasant experiences with Lena's . For my money and what I look for , I will be choosing Tasta Pizza in Falconer as my option for pizza / wings . Lena's to ME is just not worth the " attitude " . read more