Best bagel shop in the area - and I grew up on New York City bagels. Veggie sandwich on everything bagel is my favorite. Friendliest owners and staff. You won't be disappointed!!!! read more

The content of the sandwich (sausage, egg & cheese) was amazing. Fresh, homemade bagel - thin but very tasty. If you're looking for a great tasting sandwich that isn't going to put you in a coma after eating, this is the spot. read more

This has been my go to place on Sundays before church. They are open very early and perfect for a grab and go. Their menu is extensive with lots of options for add ons or toppings. Coffee is reasonably priced. I can get a latte for under $5 which is great. I've gotten the vanilla cold brew, sausage egg and cheese on asiago bagel, and other breakfast bagels before. Delicious and affordable. I also love how they do sandwich punch cards! Can't wait to redeem them soon~ read more

See all

Amazing customer service. Food was very good and fresh. Everyone was so friendly in there and very quick!

as a New Yorker I know what a good bagel tastes like. In Delaware it is hard to find authentic foods. Bagelmania has impressed me! I will be visiting this place when I get an urge for a tasty bagel!!! Thank you read more

Bagelmania has great local bagels. While we've had better bagels in NYC, that's a bit too far of a bagel run from Delaware, so Bagelmania is a favorite stop. They are consistently good, they have a great selection of bagel flavors and house made cream cheese as well as sandwich options. You can get them sliced, you can call ahead and order specific flavors, and they have good coffee and a few tables for dining in. It smells so good when you walk in! If you plan to call your order in the day before, be aware they close at 2 pm. Toughest part is always deciding which flavors to get in your baker's dozen! read more

Bagelmania - a plate of bagels and lemons - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

What they got right: Hands down, definitely one of the best places for bagels in the area. I'm originally from New York and these are by far some of the best bagels I've had outside of the New York area. They make all of the bagels on site and fresh every day too. They also have a large selection of bagel types and flavored cream cheese which is another added bonus. So if you're looking for delicious bagels and breakfast sandwiches you're good to go. What they need to work on: Beware of the lunch menu. Today I had the Blue Hen Chicken Sandwich on a sesame bagel. This sandwich is the perfect example of why you should never, ever, microwave grilled chicken. When I ordered the sandwich and saw the server preparing it, I was alarmed when I realized she was putting it in the microwave. But it was too late, it was already made, so I had to eat it (sigh). Not only was the chicken tough, it also had a weird rubber-like consistency to it. What a fail. I should have just ordered a cold cut sandwich on a bagel or a bagel with cream cheese. The only reason why I managed to eat it all was because the bagel was good, so that made up for the fact that it was pretty terrible sandwich. Initially I figured they had a small grill there and I'd wait for it to be grilled. If I had known that they'd take a pre-made piece of chicken (that tasted pretty artificial) and pop it in there, I would've saved my $9. Still, I think this business is worth your support and worth the trip for the basics: bagels, cream cheese and coffee. No pictures today (sigh). read more

Excellent selection of savory and sweet bagels with a dense, toothsome texture after toasting that I prefer. Very friendly service. Cappucinos were good quality, too. I didn't order bagel sandwiches but the customer ahead of me bought two and they looked fantastic! My only regret is that they are not open on Mondays which is the day I am most likely passing thru Newark, DE. read more

Wow! There were so many choices. I literally stood there and stared for like 5 minutes before I could make up my mind. I got a honey wheat bagel with walnut raisin spread. Delicious and tasted so fresh. I will say the cold brew was hard to drink. I ended up tossing it. I don't know if it was the syrup for flavor that was added but it was pretty bitter and left an aftertaste. I'd try something other than the cold brew next time. The place was packed for a Sunday morning. Always a good sign. I'll be back. read more

Everytime we come down to visit family this is our breakfast spot!!! The food is always fresh and delicious. Even though they can get packed it is always clean. The staff is always serving with a smile! I have even been able to try new flavored bagels that always leave me pleasantly satisfied. Love those place!!!! read more

Bagelmania - Onion bagel with egg and scrapple Spinach and Herb Bagel with scrapple and eggs - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Decided to try out a new bagel place and was gravely disappointed by my experience here. When I called the food in, they told me it would take 3 minutes to make which was a red flag right away! Fresh, good food takes time. When I did receive my food it was clearly all from the frozen food isle which they microwaved and failed to season. Eggs were gray and flavorless. The most flavor I got was from the cheese. My boyfriend got very sick after eating his bagel. The coffee was not any better. I ordered a cappuccino, which tasted more like warm milk. Ended up going to the Starbucks nearby. Hopefully this business takes these reviews into consideration as I would love to see a small business like this one flourish. Using fresh ingredients would be a great start. I'm convinced anyone with a 5 star review of the place is a paid actor. read more

Bagelmania - a person's hand holding a sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Absolutely our favorite bagel shop! Everything so good!! You have to try them. Delicious homemade cream cheese mixtures! All are so good. read more

Just spent $16 on the worst bacon egg and cheese for me and my partner. Came in, both the person making my sandwich and person and the register were miserable. Work sucks but at least be nice. The toast wasn't toasted, the bacon is microwaveable bacon. The egg tastes like it was microwaved too. Wawa could have done better. If I'm paying more for my food the least it can be is decent and not completely microwaved. I've been here before and the food was always good and they had great customer service. I definitely won't be back. - update - My partner just threw up and is sick. The sandwich is the only things he's eaten. Literally never again. read more

Bagelmania - a person holding a sandwich in their hand - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Awesome bagels friendly staff Was in town for a birthday party Spent the night and decided to try Bagelmania for breakfast!! So glad I did!! You should too! read more

This is our favorite breakfast spot especially on weekends. They have so many different bagels made fresh. Love their breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches especially chicken salad and BLT. The muffins are delicious. I don't normally get coffee but I hear other customers rave about the different blends. The service is good and friendly. There is space to sit and enjoy your food and coffee as you talk with friends or watch television. The place is always clean and the staff friendly. The place is packed early in morning but the wait is not long. Love this place!!! read more

Great counter service bagel place. Folks were kind and had so many options. Bagel was quick to come out and tasted excellent, I had the egg white and turkey sausage on pumpernickel. I'll be back soon! read more

Just great breakfast bagel sandwiches in a friendly atmosphere. Lots of varieties of bagels. Something to please everyone. read more

Bagelmania - a man holding a cup of coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Great bagels. Great bagel sandwiches. Service is fast and friendly. Wide variety of bagels and they sell different cream cheeses in the cooler that are absolutely fantastic. read more

Very disappointed! Used to come here as a child and sadden by my recent visit. Food all microwaved, including the meat, my eggs were GREY and to top it off I found HAIR in my sandwich. Service was horrible & beyond unprofessional. When I did inform the OWNER she was very disrespectful and rude , refused to remake my food and proceeded with an attitude. I will not be returning I feel racially discriminated against and will never bring my money here again. read more

Bagelmania - a person holding a half eaten sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

Best bagels in America. The service is awesome but the best bagel on the menu is the cinnamon sugar bagel. A perfect atmosphere with sports decorations really making it feel perfect. My order is 2 cinnamon sugar bagel buttered and toasted. Get this to have a amazing day read more

I love their bagels! I think it's pretty hard to find a good bagel in this area, but these are always fresh and delicious. They have great sandwiches too! read more

Bagelmania - Egg and cheese on everything - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Your average bagel place. I got a veggie bagel with bacon on it too. The bagels are smaller than usually but taste really good. I also got a french toast muffin but it was too dry and I also got a taste of dish soap on the edges... read more

If you charge $2 for meat you should include more than half a slice of bacon. The coffee was hotel quality also but for the price that's ok.

I came here recently and got a Turkey on a bagel it was good but when I seen the gentleman in the back put the eggs in a microwave to get cooked it was definitely not a place I would EVER!!! get any eggs on a bagel, would I go back maybe for a turkey on a bagel definitely no EGGS FOR ME!!! Ok read more

Messed up our simple breakfast order. Coffee was yucky! Gave me diarrhea, would not recommend

best bagels in newark, hands down. Veg out or get out. on whole wheat everything, add jalapenos. i have driven 30 minutes to get these bagels on more than 1 occasion and I am kind of thinking about doing it again r i g h t n o w. read more

Best bagels ever. Go weekly. Favorite with grandkids. Cinnamon sugar, everything, poppy seed, Black Russian and plain are some of our favorites! read more

was visiting from Baltimore, Md and my friend and I decided to stop in a have a look.....we were greeted with a warm & friend smile.... after having one of these delicious bagels, could NOT resist buying a dozen to take home, along with homemade cream cheese AND homemade cranberry/lemon scones..... I will definitely take the ride back for these bagels...BEST I've ever had! and of course these homemade scones as well Thank you for making me feel so welcomed! read more

Wow! This place is a Gem! Located inside a shopping center i happened to stumble across when visiting the area! Super friendly owners/ employees! You can tell they love what they do and that is making awesome bagels, creamy cream cheese, desserts and a menu guaranteed (my opinion) to have something freshly made to order for everyone! They have a clean shop and welcoming atmosphere! I love the fact that they have arranged to give back to the community at the end of the day when available! Just an Awesome place and People! Yes i am a real customer loving that places like this still are around and thriving! read more

One of the best bagels I have ever had in my life. Bagelmania is a small bagel cafe with a very warm staff and amazing bagels we all dream about. With a more than generous serving of creme cheese in their giant bagels and unlimited refills of variety of coffee's you are sure to have a memorable time here. Keep up the good work guys! Cant wait to go back here. read more

Absolutely LOVE Bagelmania! I go almost once a week and get either a BEC or a bagel with cream cheese. Either one is a win! Highly recommend the salt or everything bagel. You cant beat their prices either! read more

What a great place!!!!! The food is great and the staff is awesome!!!!! I had the bacon egg and cheese which I loved .....Make sure to stop by here when your in the neighborhood. read more

Bagelmania - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

I eat here 4-5 times a week and I love it. The bagels and soup are always good. And the staff is so sweet and personable.

Great place to eat!! Nice friendly staff with nice seating!! Came in and was greeted with smiles and a wonderful smell of great food!! read more

See all

The bagel sandwich was tasty and appreciated the price. I've had bagel sandwiches from other places, in which the bagels were not as good, and yet cost more. I will be back to Bagelmania. read more

Good place to get some good bagels. It's a little more out of my way which is why I don't come as often but whenever I have to do banking (which is close to Bagelmania) I stop by. I love there jalapeño bagels and their whole wheat everything. They have limited flavored cream cheeses but it's ok because I always get the olive and veggie cream cheese. The olive ream cheese is a little salty so I don't recommend getting it with an everything bagel. I've had their breakfast sandwiches and they were good as well. I'd originally said that I only thought that the owner was nice because every time I'd gone in the past there was always a girl behind the counter that looked annoyed ALL the time. I'm glad to say that I've not seen her once in the past month or two and the people working there now are super nice. There's usually a younger guy a two ladies that are really helpful and patient. I really enjoy going there now. read more

Bagelmania - Watermelon tea smoothie~ - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

The Black Russian bagel is is must try! My order is a turkey sandwich with pepper jack cheese, bacon, lettuce and mayo on a Black Russian bagel. Delicious! read more

Bagels and services were of the highest quality! Could not ask for a better place to get a morning bagel!

The bagels here are scrumptious!!! I love how many sandwich varieties there are. My only wish is that there were meat substitutes for the vegetarians. Do yourself a favor and order the everything bagel with sprouts, cucumber, tomato and jalapeño cream cheese! Bagel Mania is a definite go-to bagel joint if you're near Newark/Elkton. read more

Bagelmania - veggie heaven! - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

The texture of the egg was weird. I read a different review that said they microwave them and that might be the case.