Very nice little shop! I ordered a cinnamon bagel with plain cream cheese and a cup of the banana foster coffee. The bagel was amazing and would recommend to anyone. The coffee however was ok. It was boiling hot and didn't taste that great. I will be back to give it another try read more

We tried the egg cheese and bacon option as well as a bagel with cream cheese. The bagels were good and the eggs fresh. Sandwiches were well made. Would have liked more cream cheese on the bagel. Parking is an issue there if it's busy but overall a good option read more

The bagels are great and the coffee is good with a few different options. Like another review I have to agree that this is not the place for that gooey bacon egg and cheese on a bagel. Microwaving the eggs just ruins it - or they need to back off it a bit. The people behind the counter are super friendly and are working hard. I would love it if they perfected their egg sandwiches! read more

Staff are very friendly the food is fresh and delicious we been coming here every time we go on road trips me and my partner love it so does our pigeons read more

This place has a great selection of bagels and bagel sandwiches. The bagels have as much seasoning on the bottom as there is on the top. Amazing! My favorite is the lox sandwich--lox, cream cheese, capers, onions, and tomato. The service is very fast, accurate, and always friendly. Unfortunately I recently moved 15 miles away but I still drive back to Bagelmania every couple of weeks for a great lunch . Worth it! read more

Good bagel shop with a variety of breakfast and lunch items. Large selection of bagel flavors. I really like the cinnamon buns! They are big and baked to perfection, they also use a very generous portion of icing. I've only been there for breakfast but do intend to go back for the lunch items at some point as they have a good variety on their lunch menu as well . read more

Bagelmania - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

Got sausage and egg on a bagel with cream cheese. Came with american cheese and lacked much flavor. Was looking forward to the cream cheese.

Perfect bagels, perfect crew. We call Saturday BagelDay because we're eating from Bagelmania.

Driving on 95, we were looking for a quick stop for breakfast and we found BagelMania on Yelp. We called ahead so our bagels were ready to go! Incredible selection of bagels! Delicious bagel sandwiches and friendly staff! Lots of self-serve coffee varieties! Definitely recommend! read more

Bagelmania - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

This is the bagel place I dream about! Bagels are always fresh and delicious. I highly recommend the Veggie Mania on a toasted Black Russian - this was my biggest pregnancy craving and I still will drive 30 minutes to get it. Staff is always very kind and prompt (my 2 year old got sick in their bathroom today and they didn't bat an eye when I told them and went so far as to make sure he was okay)! I'll be a loyal customer for years! read more

This might sound weird, but I love this place so much, I actually think about opening my own version of it one day. It's the standard by which I judge all other bagel shops. THE BAGELS are so fresh and have great toppings. The staff is pleasant and fast. The coffee selection is great. I just think this place is as perfect as a bagel shop can be. I'm here for breakfast and lunch frequently and never disappointed. read more

Excellent bagels! I had a ham and egg breakfast bagel with veggie cream cheese and it was wonderful! Definitely messy, but scrumptious nonetheless! read more

Came here on my way to Atlantic City, just needed something to eat because the wawa down the street was crowded as hell. The sandwich I got was really good with a lot of cream cheese, but I got a smoothie too which tasted like grape cough syrup and it melted really fast even though it was in the 40s that day. read more

Excellent excellent bagels. I try to stop by every chance I get in the mornings to grab breakfast and coffee here. Service is fantastic as the people here really get to know you as a regular. read more

No lie this place makes bagels on par with NYC. Perfect texture, taste, and they're large. I always get chicken salad there but my coworkers have gotten egg sandwiches, cold cuts, and tuna and have equally raved. Everyone who works there is friendly and makes a genuine effort to get to know you. If you live in Newark and haven't gone here yet you've been missing out. read more

Bagels most excellent! Perhaps it's been decades in the Deep South, but I hazard a guess they're just really fresh yet appropriately toothy. Good range of coffee flavors, too, although they could use a true dark roast like French or brewed espresso. read more

Super friendly people with amazing food! They don't slack on the cream cheese thank goodness! Of course if you go there a little before closing time their bagels aren't going to be as fresh but they're still really good! Oh and this might sound weird but they have a lot of drink options to choose from. They get a lot of sodas and juices and coffees and it's good to have all the options that you wouldn't even have at a restaurant. They have free wifi, but they could stand to do a deep cleaning sometime. I think it's about time throw in some extra cash and replace the ceiling tiles and have a fresh coat of paint on the walls. But the food is absolutely delicious and so filling! It's great for breakfast or lunch and the prices are super cheap too! read more

Very good food and the staff is wonderful, however the owner is very confrontational and it is not student friendly. I'd recommend Hot bagels on Main Street for the same quality of food and exceptional experience read more

Absolutely horrible. I wish I drove the extra 5 minutes to get a real egg sandwich on campus. This was the WORST bacon, egg & cheese on a bagel that I've ever had. They microwave your eggs & that was enough for me to be completely turned off. My bagel was super salty and the whole sandwich was so unenjoyable I ended throwing half away. It's very cheap but not even worth the $3. read more

This is by far my favorite place to get a bagel in Newark! The prices are outstanding, quality of the food (breakfast and lunch) is incredible, and the staff is efficient and friendly. Can't say enough good things! read more

First time but won't be my last time . Really nice folks working here. Very clean and organized. Great variety of options from breakfast to lunch. Fresh and well prepared. Reasonably priced. Thank you Bagelmania team read more

I'm sorry, but i disagree with the other commenters here. I was raised on Staten Island bagels, and these bagels are by far the closest I've found outside of the city to a true New York bagel. So if you're driving down 95 and want to skip the Exit 1 toll in DE, get off at Exit 2 and do yourself a favor, get a toasted ET bagel with plain cream cheese from Bagelmania. You won't be disappointed. read more

Bagelmania! EpicBagel! Bagels-R-Us, Bagelboocreek! (i just like calling it by different names) Overall great experience there! It was a bit toasty in there though (not just the bagels) if u know what I mean. They were playing country music on the radio and I felt like they should re-name the place Kentucky Fried Bagel. My everything bagel was more like an EVERYDAY Bagel! Aka delicious! My bfs coffee was not very hot, but we arrived there pretty late in the day. The pizza bagel was delicious. The service was excellent. Definitely will go back. Best Bagel spot in Newark read more

The bagels here are awesome. Everything is fresh and they always get our order correct. The selection is great and the staff is always very friendly. read more

Bagels here are a little tough and chewy, they claim fresh made... but I'm thinking fresh made about 10 hours ago, not 3 hours. Inferior quality on just about everything compared to Newark Deli. Still... it's got lots of seating and have a full coffee bar. Even if the 'gourmet' beans aren't especially rare or interesting. read more

Great customer service I normal go at lunch and order a tuna or chicken salad both very good! Seating is tough I normally order To go I alway wish they had wraps. read more

Alicia is amazing! How she remembered my favorite sandwich.... and all my fav additions like cucumbers, sprouts, onions and tomatoes, on toasted oat nut bread read more

The bagels here are amazing. The best I have had in the Newark area. But, if you are craving a good classic like an egg and cheese on a bagel, do not get it here. They microwave their eggs in front of you using a wall of microwaves... But, if you live close grab a bagel and make your own egg sandwich at home. read more

Ordered turkey chili, take out, and when I got back to work.. ice cold Never had a problem before but when I called to let them know their chili was cold, I got an "oh I'm sorry" Never going back read more

This is an ok place. Didn't live up to my expectations as an independent bagel shop, but better than Dunkin' Donuts. First off, don't order any of the egg sandwiches, they microwave their eggs and everyone knows that's not acceptable in a restaurant. Especially a breakfast centered restaurant. Neither of the workers could tell me what the turkey bacon tastes like as they were vegans. Nothing wrong with vegans, I have many vegetarians and vegan friends but when they worked as servers or chefs they always tasted the food they served (but they worked at upscale places). Otherwise staff was adequately friendly. I would skip the turkey bacon by the way it tasted like cheap dog treats. Now to the main event, I got an everything bagel and it had a decent texture and chew. It's downfall was the chunky salt on the outside. I love salt and this was way too salty, incredibly oversalted. Maybe this was just a random bagel that ended up with all the salt flakes. The bagel otherwise seemed very ordinary. I would have preferred more toughness on the outside like the bakery bagels I prefer. In sum, it's decent but definitely don't go out of your way to go here. read more

I love everything about this bagel shop. The people are so friendly and the bagels are absolute heaven. I also love that they offer gift certificates. read more

Great handmade bagels and a bunch of nice guys behind the counter!!! They have a nice variety of bagels and make some really creative sandwiches. read more

This place is just excellent. The coffee is great and the bagels are baked on the premises. Great selection of soup at lunchtime.

Being from New York, Im picky about my bagels. Ive tried all the places on Main Street but havent found a good one. This bagel at Bagelmania was by far the best Ive ever had in the Newark area!! Soooo delicious! 10 out of 10, will absolutely be back all school year! read more

Great service, good food, and faster by far than McD's. If you want good food fast, Bagelmania

Lasangna bagel !!!!!!!!!!!! Delicious as well as most of the other items that i have bought there. Give it a try! You wont be disappointed!

We come here for years and it's always good. I bicycle with a group of friends every morning. Bagelmania is our "Go To"stop for breakfast. Bagels are delicious, great selection of breakfast sandwiches and coffee great. Staff is always friendly and service is fast. read more

Bagelmania - Loyal Bagelmania Bikers! Our favorite breakfast spot - Bakeries Near Me - Newark, Delaware

You are better off at Dunkin or some other quick breakfast place.Even stopping at a grocery store for bag of bagels and cream cheese will be better. read more

customer service is everything to me especially when i am spending my hard earned money...on 11/15/2019 i was sitting in my office wanting a bagel so i used google to find a local shop and i came across this location and called them well lets just say first impression is always your last the woman who answered the phone was very fast talking & rude but does not stop there so was the owner...i asked the woman was this such and such on the street that was close to me and she said " no this is bagelmania suburban drive" i said "oh i am sorry i am looking for the one on such and such street" she said " oh well this not it and this ...establishment" in my head i am thinking duh that's why i called she then proceed to sarcastically say "thank you" and disconnected the call...oh i am not finish i called to report it to the manager and he david told me he was the owner so i told him what happen and he told me " i've been in bussiness over 20+ years no that's not how she answers the phone" and by the way he was acting non concerned about the way she spoke to me and him declaring his years of services let me know that i am not the first the pair of rude people have treated this way...so moral of my story is that i will never buy anything from there or support anything they are affliated with read more

After being a customer on and off since the shop opened i will not be returning. The owner insisted that using their "buy 9 and get the tenth sandwich free" coupon book has now led to customers "Taking advantage of them". Very short sighted owner who is obviously frustrated with much more than the coupon book decides to question my integrity over a $4 sandwich and walks away "growling" in frustration. I am all about supporting small business but will no longer support this one. read more