I hate to write a negative review, but I do so in hopes that ownership will take notice. Place comes across as "not clean" - and there are no signs that ownership wants to make you feel welcome. Bought 8 bagels, half a pound of veg CC, half a pound of baked salmon salad and the NY Post - $26. Seems really expensive. Quality across the board was middling at best. Bagels didn't seem fresh and the spreads were mediocre. Owners need to wake up and think about what they want to do here. How do they like to be treated when they go out and spend their hard earned money. Really not worth more than 2 stars, but do not want to hurt these guys - only wake them up. My advice : start from scratch, make a plan, close for a week or two and come back stronger and better. This town has endle$$ money - do better. read more

When I saw this, I said three stars I didn't want to come here, it ended up just being convenient. Idk How this place has three stars right now they have incredible bagels and a plethora of options. As someone who's just visiting town, I feel deeply saddened to live really far from this place. I told the cashier I loved her after eating my bagel read more

Bagel Works - Rainbow bagel with egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Huntington, New York

This is my first time at this bagel store.I ordered two eggs, cheese and sausage on an everything bagel. I also had them add salt and pepper to the sandwich, thank God I did because the sandwich was tasteless except for the salt and pepper. The sausage must've been a frozen Restaurant Depot patty with no flavor. And the eggs were bland. The cheese didn't even taste like cheese and the bagel was basic. I'll try Village Bagel Café next and compare the two. read more

I ordered an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. There was so little spread on the bagel it barely covered one half. So basically I paid 5.50 for just the bagel. Come on guys don't be so damn stingy! People, go to bagels o round on Broadway by the Huntington train station. Much much better in every way! Plenty of spread on the bagels and less expensive! read more

One of Huntington's best traditional bagel spot with variety of cream cheeses and sandwiches. Their fresh, in-house-made bagels--especially the everything and cinnamon raisin are my favorite. Aaman makes perfect Sunnyside-up and always greets with a warm smile. It's my go-to breakfast spot every morning. Busy, but Line moves quickly, the lox sandwich with capers highly recommended. For Mother's Day, I ordered platters, and the salmon platter was the highlight of the gathering! read more

Live in the area and come here most weekends. Service is great, bagels are excellent, surprised that it doesn't have better reviews.

There are not many bagel shops in town - and this is the best one. NOT TO BE SEXIST but I shy away from thin young girls who work at sandwich / ice cream / food making places. They USUALLY make sandwiches as if they are preparing them for THEMSELVES . Therefore - they usually make them slim and sparse (because they themselves do not eat much). My BLT was made as if the young lady was being MICRO-MANAGED as she made it , by a person that was trying to cut corners "No, don't use too much bacon!" , "No don't use too much LETTUCE!", "No , don't use too much MAYO!" . I almost heard a little voice in my head go "NO, don't put more than 12 poppy seeds on top of that bagel !". Seriously. I got home and looked at the horizontal profile of my cut-in-half sandwich and there were barely any ingredients . I also did not taste any mayo; but upon my last bite, I saw a single tear-drop of mayo on the edge . So it was there , but probably placed with an eye-dropper ( "No, only 4 eye-drops of MAYO-- NOT 5!!") . PRO-TIP: if you are on line here - and a petite young lady asks "Can I help you?", pretend you are still looking and let the sucker BEHIND you get helped by her. Then wait for the next available GUY (hopefully a chubby one) to make your sandwich. Again: SEXIST ? Perhaps. BUT this has happened WAY too many times to be a coincidence. And not just HERE- anyplace else that hand prepares meals. Not even sure if there were 2 full slices of bacon on the bagel. read more

Best in Town! I have Been living here since the mid 80's and have seen lots of changes. I have to say they have stayed true to its style of bagel production! Absolutely the best in town !! read more

Bought a dozen bagels on Sunday, the seems to be made the day prior. I took them home and you practically needed the tear into it when chewing. Kind of rubbery. Not sure if this is how they make them but can't see myself going back. read more

I guess no one writing these reviews have ventured out of Huntington and ever eaten a real bagel.. every shop in this town is incapable of making a bagel, this is one of the worst offenders. Save your $ and go to farmingdale, Levittown, wantagh to a real bagel shop. Shitty towns but the best bagels in NY. read more

Be forewarned they charge your card more money later in the day and do not respond when you ask them why. We ordered 3 bagel sandwiches. We asked for the two to be toasted and the third to have salt pepper ketchup. They charged our card an extra $3.50 (more then 10% of the entire bill) for "special instructions". Too many other bagel places in town to support a place that charges you extra for salt pepper ketchup and to toast a bagel. Completely ridiculous. Also a side note, I ordered a large coffee, there were no selections as to how you take it, I would assume it would come black unless otherwise requested. It came with milk and sugar. read more

I always order bagels from here cause it's close but come on My salt bagel is basically a plain bagel every time! They aren't fluffy and even. My plain bagels also have a gritty top 90% of the time All I can hope is that the new place that opens actually have nice bagels read more

Bagel Works - This is my salt bagel.... - Bagels Near Me - Huntington, New York

Ordered an SEC on an everything bagel and was pleasantly surprised. One of the best breakfast sandwiches I have ever had. Review coming from a a Connecticut guy visiting his girlfriends family. read more

Wrong order through Grubhub, it happens, I called and they INSISTED they send a new order to me, no kidding truly I just wanted my money back no harm no foul, and I would have ordered food from somewhere else that day. But instead, aFter speaking w someone at 130, I waited until 330 until I had to go to work, starving and hangry. I realiE I had a missed call from them around 4, I guess they wanted to let me know they weren't coming? Also, they pack the reviews on grubhub, they have one person, "Thomas" reviewing every 2 days w 5 stars. Every other review is 3 or below. read more

We went in looking for a fight after reading the reviews, and left with a peace treaty. Here's why: - bagels are very very good - excellent selection of cream cheeses - nova salmon fresh and clean - even the coffee is good - one staff member was quite friendly, the other not so much. So they may not win any public relations contests. But be sensible, don't make unreasonable demands and enjoy your food. I'd return here in a heartbeat simply because the bagel experience is that rewarding. read more

Bagel Works - Peruse the community bulletin board while you wait for your delicious bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Huntington, New York

One star just for the ease of parking have been coming here for over 14 years ... it used to be very good ... must be a change of owners not the same anymore .... oh well read more

Complete ripped me off multiple times - just got two bagels with tuna, and two mini bags of chips, and they charged me ***$28.00***!!! Do not go there - they hasn't be trusted to charge the prices they have on their own menu! read more

Delicious New York bagels done right! Affordable, quick service and they came through with a delivery during the apocalypse to boot. The egg onion is outta this world and the scallion cream cheese was delicious Really hit the spot. Thank you Bagel Works!! read more

I have been to Bagel Works on numerous occasions because I live in the area. Each time the service has been ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE, yet I returned, out of convenience, hoping that perhaps the terrible service I received was a fluke or one-time occurrence. Even with no line, they still manage to make you wait because they are talking to other employees while they spread cream cheese on a bagel. I have never been able to grab a bagel in under 10 minutes. The employees are also downright rude to customers, and have very nasty attitudes. My order came to $4.54, (for a bagel and iced coffee) and the woman yelled at me when I tried to hand her my visa-debit card. She demanded that I had to spend at least five cents more if I wanted to use it. Besides being ridiculously rude and cheap, they don't even deliver on their products: their food isn't very good, and they have never once filled their iced coffee up all the way for me or any other person I've gone in there with. You're really better off going down the block to another bagel store for better food, and much better customer service. I WILL NEVER go back there ever again, no matter how convenient it may be. read more

We ordered via grub hub at work; we work in a nursing home Bayville. We accidentally left it on "pick-up." We didn't realize until it was too late, so when we called, we explained that with the current pandemic we were understaffed and could not leave our facility, and the staff at Bagel Works were amazing. They made an exception to deliver our order to us, and on top of that, they included extra bagels/cream cheese. We are so grateful that they did this for us, it was so kind. The food and iced coffee that we ordered were also absolutely DELICIOUS!! I know that I will definitely going back here; I would certainly make a special trip just for the ice coffee. (Don't worry Bagel Works, we won't ask you to delivery all the way out here again, thank you so much for the great food/beverages/service!!) read more

Great place, great service, great bagels. I definitely recommend this place for anyone in the mood for a good bagel. You are help fast and the food is amazing here. read more

Bagel Works - Bagels Near Me - Huntington, New York

Service can be rude especially in the AM during the rush. Skip the add ons unless you don't mind the in$ane. But the bagels kick butt and are better than bagels almost anywhere nearby and as good or better than most of NYC. read more

I popped in on a Monday morning at about 7:30am to grab a bagel and coffee. Just about $7 for a large coffee and bagel with veggie cream cheese. There was barely any cream cheese on the bagel. I don't mind paying extra for fancy cream cheese, but there should be more than a thin coating on my bagel. Never going back. read more

Bagel Works is what I think of when I think of everything that makes Long Island bagel shops so great. And better than Manhattan. All the newspapers. The coffee. Wide selection of cold bottled beverages. And the bagels and spreads, fantastic. They do everything very well. My favorite bagel from there is the whole wheat sunflower. Before I became more carb wary, I used to buy a dozen of them to bring home to Philadelphia. A sublime tasting bagel. read more

Had a BEC with salt pepper ketchup and hot sauce, one word: YUM! Also got a corn muffin and it was great.

Update - bagels have severely gone down hill. I no longer go to this bagel store. Last time we ordered the bagels were hard and stale. More and more bagel stores have opened in the recent years and instead of rising to meet the competition, bagel works has dropped the ball. read more

Only bagel shop in Huntington, and pretty darn good at that. I've been coming here for about 15 years now, and they have rarely disappointed. Best tuna fish I've ever tasted. The bagels and muffins are named fresh and there is always a huge selection - go with banana yogurt muffin and sesame seed sunflower bagel. They also make delicious egg sandwiches, though the bulkie rolls could use some improvement. Chicken salad is average. Reasonable prices too, even though they essentially have a monopoly on bagels in the Village. Lastly, the owner is very sweet and down to earth, which is a big plus in my book. read more

Nice stuff with quality. Amazing staff. Bagels are very nice and soft. I really recommend the store for food.

One of the better whole wheat everything bagels in Huntington... and they deliver on Seamless! Not much more I'm looking for in a bagel place. read more

I've been here twice, and will never go back again. The manager was extremely rude to the employees; barking orders, creating discomfort for the customers. The second time I went it was close to closing, and this time the rudeness was towards the customers. Turning the lights off in the shop while waiting to be served, and it my business seemed unwanted. Rude, and disrespectful. And the bagel... nothing to rave about. Boo! Huntington needs a good bagel place, this is last on my list. read more

I was reading some reviews and I agree that the bagels are good, maybe not the BEST! But for all those people complaining about them messing up your orders...I have stood there listening to the orders some of you people come up with, "egg whites, no salt, half with lite scallion cream cheese, toasted but not too much, coffee half regular/half decaf..." please just stay home. It's people like you that are the reason I have to wait to get a simple order. And then on top of it you complain on yelp, go get a job bc you clearly have too much free time between yoga and tanning. :) read more

I remember going here years ago, and being treated very poorly by one of the cashiers as I paid for my food. I sat down with my tray, and posted a negative review here on Yelp about the experience. I kid you not- five minutes later, the dad of the rude cashier marches up to my table and barks at me, "Did you just post a bad review about my daughter?!" He was inches away from my table with an angry expression on his face. He made me SO uncomfortable that I walked straight out, leaving the tray with my food sitting on the table. He couldn't handle a truthful review about his obnoxious daughter so he intimidated me. I called and spoke with the owner, who apologized, but I never went back again; that man's behavior was a deal breaker. read more

Found a hair in my bacon egg and cheese, the wax paper they use sticks to food, I generally don't care about the packaging but it's annnoying to take off. The hair is just nasty, telling me whoever made my sandwich didn't care enough. When i call to order food so i can pick it up, i do it to save time, but somehow i always get stuck there for about 15-20 minutes. My order has been wrong everytime i call - so i refuse to even call anymore, very frustrating. read more

Way over priced bagels! The bagels are dry and tasteless. If you want real bagels try oasis bagels off the lie. A cheese and tomato sandwich shouldn't cost over 7$ where all the other bagel stores charge $4 read more

Once again gave this place another try.. horrible horrible horrible... kid was using his bare hands texting, in between making my sandwich. Soooo gross, and literally holding the cold cut meat with his hands as he slices it, no gloves!!!!!! Absolutely grossssssss omg. Then doesn't even wrap it up once he puts it back in, this is how sickness is spread with bacteria on the pieces. This sandwich was for my husband.. mind you he messed it up twice... such an attitude also, I'm sorry but ugh noooo place is not quality anymore. I'm also pregnant so I barely ate my bagel after seeing all of this happen. I think maybe it could of been the guy I got? Seemed like the others were a lot better and more accommodating/ listened better ! read more

Decent breakfast sandwiches. I've had equally good at other bagel stores, so while this place has good food, it's not one-of-a-kind. Yesterday, a friend and I went in. We were trying to read the menu, which is scattered all over the back wall behind the register. A lady working there who looked like she was late 40s or early 50s.....she asked us if we were ready to order. We told her we still needed a few moments to decide. She immediately looked annoyed & had an attitude. Me & my friend exchanged looks asking each other what just happened. Another gal entered the store. So this same lady behind the counter stalled taking this other gal's order. She told this other customer that she can't take her order yet because we're "taking long to decide". What?? Did I miss something? So my friend & I said, "don't worry you can go ahead in front of us". So the lady working in the bagel store had such an attitude saying "I'm still waiting for them". (Meaning us) We re-emphasized that it's ok to skip us while we're looking over the menu. But the lady working at the store looked even more annoyed. She said to us.... "You're still not ready?" My friend & I were boggled. This experience was unexpected & distracting so we still did not make up our minds as quickly as the worker wanted us to....but we weren't holding up the line.... Instead we stepped aside, right away, when we just walked in. My friend decided on an egg sandwich. So the woman looks at me and says, "are you having one too?" so I said "uhm, I'm not sure yet, but you can continue taking care of her". So with an attitude she said "are you having one or not?" If you're having an egg sandwich I can make them at the same time ya' know." Me & my friend felt uneasy & were contemplating walking out....but we were so hungry we decided to just bite the bullet. We were actually quite humble & quiet. We were not expecting an issue. I noticed that the older workers here seem rude & easily annoyed when a customer doesn't immediately know what they want. This was our second time here. We noticed both times that the workers here seem rushed to get your order. Some if the workers here seem impatient if a customer is still deciding or doesn't immediately give their order. This is not ideal customer service I feel disappointed. Customers don't deserve to be rushed or spoken to like they're an inconvenience if they have questions or don't immediately have their order outlined. I just read other reviews about how rude some of the staff here is. They need to fine tune their customer service skills. read more

On the positive side, the bagels are good; at least as good as any on Long Island, and as we know, Long Island bagels are quite superior. The baked goods, spreads, and so on, are all of high quality. On the negative side, the place is usually messy if not downright dirty. The folks behind the counter are generally quite blase, don't engage you in any banter or conversation, and seem not to have been trained to clean up the eating areas when the shop is (relatively) quiet. We used to go there all the time; now we avoid Bagel Works, although we can walk there from home, preferring to take a short car ride to go to a competitor whose shop's ambiance is upscale, and more importantly - clean and neat. read more

I have to agree with Carrie C. the service is atrocious. I was asking how many bagels you get when ordering a dozen (usually at least 13). The girl said something in broken English, so I said I'm sorry I didn't understand what you said. So she said shouted the same thing at me. As if I had a hearing problem, it was embarrassing. Well you only get 12. The bagels were typical, a little shy of topping (seeds). I will not go back, there are so many bagel shops in the area, no need to be treated poorly when you're the customer. read more

I've been here for breakfast and lunch. The breakfast sandwiches are over priced and have barely anything on them. When I ordered my sandwich I saw on the board I could get it on a roll or a hero, I asked for a hero and she forced me to get a roll. The sandwich was supposed to have melted Swiss, it was ice cold. It's also supposed to come with a side salad, which it didn't and I had to ask for. This place is too pricey for the terrible service and quality. How dare they have a tip jar out, for what?! for awful service and bad quality of food? Thanks but no thanks, never returning. read more

$3 for a bagel with cream cheese and 1 person behind the counter at 7am? No thanks.