Cancel

Open app

Search

Bagel Toasterie

3.0 (42 reviews)
Open • 6:00 am - 3:00 pm

Order Bagel Toasterie Takeout or Delivery

Bagel Toasterie Photos

BAGEL TOASTERIE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like Bagel Toasterie

Recommended Reviews - Bagel Toasterie

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Goga P.

Nice clean place. I routinely come here for breakfast or lunch. It's always crowded. Many different options to choose from. They have halal bacon for BEC. Additionally all the chicken is halal. The brothers who own this are Turkish and are always kind.

Greek omelette and hash browns
Marvin S.

Always get my breakfast from them, great service. Make sure to try their fresh coffee

Everything bagel with barely any toppings and missing a few key toppings.

This is my second time personally visiting the location and the theme is the same. Slow customer service. It wasn't necessarily a busy time and there were only three customers in the store yet an everything bagel with bacon, egg and cheese took almost 15 minutes. Prices were reasonable but the everything bagel was more like a barely everything bagel. The sandwich was tasty but the bagel was very chewy and doughy. There was zero crisp to it and the top was the same pale color as the bottom. They had a slow but steady flow customers while I was in the shopping center but I likely won't return. This isn't a bad place but it was not worth going back to with so many other bagel locations around.

Robert R.

Fellow in my photo in orange t-shirt is spectacular. I've had him before. Used a sandwich coupon which was a great deal but took almost 15 minutes to get it and the small macaroni they included had a chemical taste to it suggesting it wasn't homemade. That always will knock stars off my reviews.

Tricia S.

Great service, super nice people! Such a nice place I will definitely be returning to. Excellent lunch. Seems so simple but some places just don't get it right. Great lunch deal - $8.99 sandwich, side salad, pickles and a drink. Highly recommend!

Halal beef bacon, 3 sunny side eggs with butter toast! Perfection

Food is always fresh and customer service is amazing! One of the only bagels stores to sell halal beef bacon and chicken!

Egg white sandwich. (They forgot to cut 1/4s, go figure!)
Jenna P.

Ordered online for pick-up and order wasn't ready when I arrived, even though confirmed via email that order was received. Gave therm the order # and they couldn't find anything. Maybe because I selected to pay in cash since they charge a $3 delivery fee on $15+ orders & 3% credit card processing fee. They didn't charge me due to the confusion (this the 2 instead of 1 stars) - but if I had ordered for my colleagues and had multiple items, that mishap could've been very inconvenient and time consuming. Based on my first experience & their prices and kinks they still haven't worked out, unsure that they're going to last. Very disappointed.

Fast / slow  We are here for you

"Get your morning toasty with the best bagels in town! Perfectly toasted and deliciously crispy - because life's too short for cold bagels! Stop by, and let's make your breakfast un-bagel-ievable! #BagelGoals #ToastyGoodness #BreakfastDoneRight"

Turkey wrap

Smallest stingiest wrap I've ever had. Child size for $12.93! And they charged me for apple and forgot to put it in!

a man in sunglasses eating a bagel
Michael L.

Hey Greenly. Rainbow bagel cream cheese! Bagel Toasterie puts just the right amount of cream on their bagels, not to little not too much!

Price of wrap

See all

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Bagel Toasterie

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bagels 3,122 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Bagel Chalet - Bagels

Bagel Chalet

3.5(281 reviews)
0.9 mi
•$$

Bagel Chalet is hands-down one of the best spots in Commack!…read moreI've been coming here for a while, and their quality and service are amazingly consistent. The bagels are phenomenal, but don't sleep on their lunch menu--the Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap is unbelievable. It comes with a side salad, and their cucumber salad is always fresh and delicious. The staff is consistently friendly, welcoming, and fast. I used to stop in years ago as a rep for Montauk Iced Tea, and while they don't carry that brand anymore, my love for this place hasn't changed a bit. If you're in the area, Bagel Chalet is absolutely worth checking out!

Here we go, So the hype was big about this Deli…read more I even passed by a couple of times while in the area and the line would be out the door. My BFF and I decided to check it out. We went after lunch crowd was over. It was about a few people sitting down in the dining area eating. Deli was very organized and clean. Customer service was OK. As we approached the counter of ordering I viewed the pastries which looked scrumptious. I decided to order the Apple Danish . My BFF ordered the chocolate muffin. Then we veiwed the sandwiches. I wasn't 100 percent sold on the sandwiches so I asked for my sandwich to be made fresh. However it wasnt . It was reheated. There is a big difference in taste from reheated to making it fresh. I just dealt with it. You would think after paying 46 dollars I would be satisfied, but to be honest with you I wasnt. After eating half of the sandwich I threw the other half away. Im thinking to myself ok maybe the Apple Danish would make up for it. No.. The Danish was very dry inside. Didn't really have any kind of kick to it. To be honest I was totally disappointed. Overall it was not the greatest but it wasnt the worst either. Im undecided if I would visit again. Happy Yelping.

Photos
Bagel Chalet - Dining area

Dining area

Bagel Chalet - Acai Bowl

Acai Bowl

Bagel Chalet - Exterior

See all

Exterior

Bagel Basket Cafe - Black hair in the middle of my wrap - Meat, 2 Eggs, Cheese

Bagel Basket Cafe

2.8(125 reviews)
2.5 mi
•$

When you walk through the doors, your welcomed by a cozy family oriented environment. Everything is…read morelove about the place. Then your nose is greeted by all the good eats from the kitchen. The options are ones you would desire! The display case was clean and shiny! The team in the back are CONSTANTLY wiping down the cutting boards and keeping a VERY neat workstation that handles food! Im more impressed by the amount of business they have and the ability to take all the orders and still wait a reasonable amount of time for your food. Whatever they are doing, its HIGHLY efficient and its working! Large crowd and the orders just kept coming out. No heavy delays on even the larger orders I seen. Obviously within reasonable timing. I highly recommend this place! I will be a returner for sure cause this experience was just too good. I live about 15 minutes away, and its worth the trip! Not to mention the food taste exactly how it smelled walking through the door. The bagels, safe to assume they are fresh cause every bite was nice and soft and not dry and hard. Also a very pleasant staff. There was a mistake on my behalf where I thought they called me for my order and without thinking I paid for it. I should have confirmed the order before paying. But the gentleman behind the register was super nice and the WHOLE staff seemed so apologetic! Honestly, I was okay with it cause they worked out the mistake. So no big deal, but the fact that the staff all noticed and where apologetic is what took it home for me! Dont worry team! You are all doing an amazing job! Keep up the outstanding energy!

Not great also very expensive it was a very basic bacon egg and cheese for the price I don't mind…read morepaying the extra money of the effort and food is better

Photos
Bagel Basket Cafe - Entrance

Entrance

Bagel Basket Cafe - Black ice in the Bagel Basket Parking Spots. Opened my door and took a really hard, really bad fall.

Black ice in the Bagel Basket Parking Spots. Opened my door and took a really hard, really bad fall.

Bagel Basket Cafe - Turkey, cheese, lettuce and mayo

See all

Turkey, cheese, lettuce and mayo

Bagel Toasterie - bagels - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...