I normally go to Bagel pub on 7th Ave and would get a dozen bagels. For the past couple of times I've been getting bagels that seem to be formed from scraps. Today was no exception, three plain bagels looked like end pieces and were flat and hard. I don't know why there is such an inconsistency the bagels. If they are scraps, why try and make a bagel and sell it to the customer? It's very unfortunate because I like their bagels. read more

Bagel Pub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Used to be great. Staff can be very rude, and it doesn't taste good anymore. Never coming back. There is a better place a few blocks away anyway! read more

Bagel Pub has one of the best bagels in Brooklyn. This is one of the bagel places that is certainly worth the hype, and I have found that the heavy traffic means that your bagels are always fresh, no matter what time of the morning you place your order. The pumpernickel everything is a Bagel Pub exclusive, and is one of the most interesting bagels I've ever had -- it is well coated with the everything bagel seasoning, but has the rich nuttiness of the rye flour, which is a perfect pairing for an egg sandwich or the perfect vehicle for just about any savory cream cheese. They also offer a whole wheat everything and a whole wheat sesame, both of which can be hard to find. Their bagel selection truly sets them apart. The ordering process during COVID has been very impressive -- you can place an order online, and can avoid the long lines/the crowded inside. The online pickups are on a table right behind the counter, so you can see if your order is ready just by peering through the window. I have found that their estimated pick-up times are very accurate, even during the busiest mornings, which is very impressive. I have yet to find a bagel experience that is as thoroughly pleasant as the one offered by Bagel Pub -- this location is more than a mile from me, and I still go out of my way to order here rather than places that are much closer/have shorter wait times. read more

This pub produces very good bagels! The aroma of the bagels can be smelled from blocks away, that's how good the bagels are. They make bagels in-house. They open early because we understand the pain and suffering of the bagel lovers who need bagels early AM haha, like us! However, the first time we came here around midday after our workout at Prospect Park. We had a few things to go. I don't usually eat bagels for lunch but I broke this rule just for one day. There are two doors. To order, please use the side door. The front door is mainly to exit the pub. There are a few tables outside in case you want to eat here. We decided to sit in for breakfast the second time around. This time I had a pastrami lox on a plain bagel with coffee. I recommend both! I would ask for less cream cheese. Other items that we have tried are whitefish and tuna salad and everything bagels. I found both whitefish and tuna salad have a lot of mayo in them. I liked the taste but too much mayonnaise. We liked this new bagel spot! Everyone works hard here. Good job! read more

See all

While the wait at the Bagel Pub might be long, their egg sandwiches are definitely worth it! Theirs is a classic done right: perfectly cooked eggs on a fresh, toasted bagel. You can customize it with your choice of cheese, veggies, and meats, but it's delicious even plain. read more

Five star establishment. I am writing this review w cream cheese all over my phone, bc I couldn't write this fast enough. The toasted egg everything w scallion lox CC is probably the best combo and bagel of my life. Was considering buying everything in the store it's that good! read more

Had a very bad experience at bagel pub. Cashiers lost our order and lied about it "being on the grill" for over 45 minutes. Rude staff. Not happy read more

If you're looking for variety, this is the place. So many options for cream cheese and bagels, lunch meats and salads!

Great bagels, but they should be more careful when someone asks for tofu cream cheese. Your mistake costs me a Saturday. Update: my weekend was messed up because of this. Allergies are a real thing and whoever prepared my bagel did not follow instructions. read more

I was just at this Pub after a long time. and the lady at the register was not to friendly and not patient as we were trying to decide on the drinks. I was trying to ask the lady at the register if they still sold the slush coffee that I bought a while ago. The lady rolled her eyes and with an attitude said "NO" . I was trying to explain to her but she didn't want to listen. Customer service is NO GOOD read more

We went on a 2pm Sunday afternoon. The servers behind the counter said they had no vegan cream cheeses even though we saw them on display, and we had to ask multiple times before someone finally confirmed there was vegan cream cheese. The line didn't seem very long but after placing our bagel order (pumpernickel w/ tofu cream cheese, lettuce onion and tomato), it took about 30-40 min for us to get our food, which seemed too slow for a bagel store. In addition to slow and poor service, the restrooms are poorly maintained and a very unpleasant experience. Hand soap was contained in a condiment bottle. The food itself was pretty good, coffee (oat latte) was decent but would not come again due to the slow and poor service and poorly maintained facility. read more

I moved to Brooklyn recently and found this place. The service is quick and so affordable! The breakfast bagels are so good! I love that I'm able to customize my bagel and I've never had any issue with my order even when I order for all of my coworkers! read more

These bagels are unbelievably good. And I'm very picky when it comes to great NY bagels. Can't beat them here. Gotta be a top 3 for me. Pumpernickel Everything yummm read more

Great place for hugh bagels, wide selection of cream cheese. Quick service My only complaint is they don't make DECAFE coffee.. read more

$10 for a bagel w/cream cheese and a small coffee. I was willing to give this place another chance but just can't do it. On top of the outrageous BS price, the coffee wasn't that great. I am done here! read more

They generally make a large tasty bagel with inconsistent shapes. The problem is tax is charged when the purchase is just an order of bagels. This is not prepared food like a sandwich. It should not be taxed. When yobject you are then told that you are being charged for the use of a debit card. The required signage for this isn't posted indicating that you receive a discount by paying with cash. read more

If it were possible to give zero stars I would. This was the worst experience ever. I can with my husband, toddler and one month old for a quick lunch. We waited over 30 min for two sandwiches and a side. After asking multiple times and finally demanding a refund while my toddler broke down and infant woke up they finally gave us our food which we had to take the few blocks home since it was now nap time. Both my bagel and my husband's sandwich were incorrect (added or missing things) and my son's side of chicken salad missing! My bagel was soggy. Lunch was a disaster and they did not even apologize for the delay! read more

These guys turn it OUT in the middle of a pandemic! Friendly, fast, and plenty of signage put up that they take no bull. No mask no service, social distance spots on the floor, etc. bagels are some of the best in the hood. I love their tofu cream cheese, a totally foolproof dup for the real thing. They LOAD it on, but that's easy to fix if you prefer a little less. The black iced coffee happened to taste very weird today, but that's the least of my worries, and nothing a little sugar and a spot of milk can't fix. They made a lot of outdoor space-love a side of dog watching with my bagel treat! read more

Surprised this place doesn't have a better rating, although it looks like most of the bad ratings spawn from being crowded and I went right when it opened. Judging solely on bagel quality this place is a MUST GO. Also want to try their other locations. For a full bagel review check out the video below: https://youtu.be/yy0Bd8jpdto read more

Good bagels. On bigger side. Interesting options for everything rye and egg bagels in addition to whole wheat and a regular everything. Can be long waits there. read more

My favorite bagel shop! Everything is super fresh. You can see the bagels in the making. All the spreads are delicious read more

Terrible service from the cashiers lady's. Very bad attitude. Small location with a couple seating and always very busy. Food was good tho

Pretty good bagel! I got the onion bagel with the tofu spread, and the flavors mixed well together. A nice take-out option for a picnic in the nearby park. read more

DELICIOUS! I love this place. Great prices and a great staff. I got the classic everything bagel with plain cream cheese and a latte. I'll definitely be a regular here. read more

Bagel Pub - Everything Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Absolute favorite place for breakfast and lunch! Best bagels we have tried in the neighborhood, I always get the Fresh Lox #1 toasted (Fresh Nova lox, cucumber dill cream cheese, capers, tomatoes and red onions) The coffee and baked goods are very good, everything is great from the cookies and muffins to the fresh juice, the salads and bagels Highly recommend ! read more

Pretty good neighborhood bagel spot. I'm no NY bagel expert since I just moved here but these bagels are big, soft on the inside with a crunchy chew on the outside, just how I like them! I would recommend visiting on a weekday, as I think the weekend rush might cause some slip ups or rushed preparation? The last one I got (on a Saturday morning!) was a little undercooked, but that hasn't happened before, and everyone has an off day, so I'm not that mad about it. They are also GENEROUS with the cream cheese. I'm a "I'll have a bagel with that cream cheese" type, and on my last order I actually had to scrape some off. I'm not complaining though because there are few things I hate more than a bagel place that's stingy with the cream cheese. Overall probably not the worlds best bagel place but very solid and good and leaves me happy every time. read more

Plain bagel, scallion cream cheese, lox.... HELL. YEAH. The restaurant is beautiful and inviting. Nice service and EXCELLENT food. I recommend read more

God bless the Bagel Pub. I decided to make this my last breakfast in Brooklyn, and I got a classic bagel with lox, but then decided I wanted to get pastrami lox instead of the regular lox so I ended up eating two bagels. They were both delicious. Yummm read more

DO NOT GO HERE. END OF STORY. Go anywhere else. Not worth spending your hard earned money here at all. I really wish I would put no stars.

Excellent bagel! They toast nicely and don't skip on the cream cheese. They make a pretty killer hash brown as well.

Delicious bagels for a reasonable price! Highly recommend ordering online because the lines get long especially at peak hours. Their bagel sandwiches are my favorite - definitely recommend trying one if you can! I usually eat one half and save the other for later. read more

First time at this new-ish Park Slope location. Better bagels than I can get in my immediate neighborhood. Everything Pumpernickel is my favorite, and they got it They're consistently I'm iincluding other PB locations) correct with orders and really solid staff. read more

A refreshing street corner pub that feels classic, new - great menu (LOTS TO CHOOSE FROM). Looking forward to trying the smoothies.

wonderful place to start your day. Excellent bagels and lox

I got Henry st panini. It came with a side of fries or salad. I picked the fries. Everything was freshly cooked and tasted delicious! Would definitely come back to try other things as well read more

Bagel Pub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Only reason they're getting 4 stars is because they close so early. But besides that everything is amazing!!!! My go to is chicken cutlet, tomato, Mayo and white American on their fresh baked roll yummmmmmmm read more

I ordered online for pick up and my order was ready to go once I got there; they made it super convenient by placing done orders next to the counter on a little table by the exit door. The bagel itself is pretty good. There is a nice texture, not too thin and not too big. The flavor is also very good. The only downsize to the bagel is the spread. I had ordered the sundried tomato spread, which is good, but I felt that it was too buttery. I could not fully enjoy my bagel as much as I wanted. I felt the butter in the spread overpowered the taste of the bagel as a whole. I will give this place another shot to try other spreads and the other items on their menu. read more

Excellent bagels and service. I was so excited when this location opened and have been frequenting a few times a week ever since. Would love if you could start carrying veggie sausage as an option for sandwiches. read more

My best friend treats the Crown Heights location like an institution so I'm happy this new Park Slope location is closer to me! This is officially my new favorite bagel spot. Everything pumpernickel bagel (why isn't this a thing everywhere)...lox chipotle cream cheese?! Yes, please. I visited early morning and the spot was clean and they definitely were following the social distanced guidelines establishment need to follow. Can't wait to go back. :) read more

Absolutely the best bagels in the Slope. Love this new location - it's spacious and clean and they have a great system for social distancing while managing multiple orders and pick-ups. My fave is the everything pumpernickel as the foundation for one of the special lox sandwiches (they offer several interesting combos with avocado, cucumber, etc.). The tops and bottoms of their bagels are the same texture and equally seasoned - there is no "bad" side! I need to branch out and try other things. The menu is huge. read more